3. Sequestration and Compartmentalization: Plants’ Way to Alleviate the HM Toxicity
During their growth and development, plants absorb essential elements such as carbon (C), nitrogen (N), potassium (K), zinc (Zn) as well as non-essential elements such as Cd, Hg, and Pb, among several others
[26]. Although trace quantities of non-essential elements are beneficial for plant growth, excessive accumulation of these elements adversely affects various physiological and metabolic processes and deteriorates plant growth and development
[26]. Metal accumulation in plants is majorly governed by the two processes including their uptake inside the plant cells and their translocation from roots to other parts
[27]. In most of the cases, the major percentage of the HMs in plants is transported from root to stem and thus the concentration of HMs in the aboveground parts is higher than the roots; however, the most toxic HMs are commonly not transported in non-hyperaccumulating plants and the highest concentration is usually found in the roots
[28]. For instance, in tomato plants, the highest concentrations for Cu, Ni, Cr, Mn, and Pb were reported in order of root > leaf > stem > fruit
[29].
HM stress-tolerant and hyperaccumulator plants get rid of the unused and extra amount of metal ions by effluxing and/or compartmentalization majorly in the vacuole with the help of two vacuolar proton pumps, including an ATPase and a Ppas (
Figure 2)
[30][31][32]. For instance, sequestration of Zn in the hyperaccumulator plants has been majorly observed in the vacuoles of epidermal cells and trichomes of mesophyll cells, as shown in
Thlaspi caerulescens [33] and in
Arabidopsis helleri respectively
[34][35]. In addition, Zn can also be accumulated, although to a lesser extent, in the cell wall and cytosol in leaves of another hyperaccumulator plant
P. griffithii [36]. Apart from the Zn, Ni was also found to be accumulated in the vacuoles of a Ni hyperaccumulator plant
Alyssum serpytllifolium [37]. Similar findings were also reported in the case of tolerant plants such as
B. juncea, Silene vulgaris [38][39][40], and
Brassica napus [35][41] where an accumulation of Cd has been reported majorly in the epidermal and mesophyll cells.
Apart from sequestration, plants minimize the HM toxicity by limiting the absorption of HMs from the soil through secretion of chelating compounds in the root hairs
[42]. Plants synthesize cystine-rich metal-binding peptides known as PCs and MTs to chelate the HMs. Among different HMs, Cd has been identified as the most potent inducer of PC synthesis in plants
[28][43][44][45]. These PCs bind to the HMs and sequester them into the vacuoles; however, PCs accumulation does not always have a beneficial effect on plants. For instance, rice plants expressing
TaPCS1 from
Triticum aestivum were found to be Cd sensitive and showed enhanced Cd accumulation in shoots
[46]. Similar to the PCs, MTs also act as biochelators and can directly bind to various HMs such as Zn, Cu, Cd, and Ni, among others. These MTs are localized in the membrane of the Golgi apparatus and growing evidence also indicates their role in maintenance of ROS homeostasis during HM toxicity. For instance, ectopic expression of different MT genes including type 1, type 2, and type 3 genes from a variety of plants such as rice,
B. juncea, and
Elsholtzia haichowensis has been shown to enhance the tolerance to Cu and/or Cd stress in transgenic plants
[47][48][49]. This MT-induced enhanced HM-toxicity tolerance was because of the increased SOD
[50] and POD
[51] activities and decreased production of hydrogen peroxide (H
2O
2) that protected the transgenic plants from the HM-toxicity-induced oxidative stress. Similar to the MTs, some of the beneficial elements such as silicon (Si) and selenium (Se) also participate in the HM-stress tolerance by limiting the uptake of HMs and enhancing the activities of antioxidant enzymes
[52]. There are now ample reports which have shown that the exogenous application of either of these two metals enhances plants’ tolerance to HM toxicity
[53]. For instance, exogenous treatment of Si has been shown to decrease the uptake, transport, and accumulation of Cd in various plants such as peanut,
Cucumis sativus, cotton, and
Brassica chinensis and mitigate the toxic effects of Cd toxicity by reducing the electrolyte leakage, MDA and H
2O
2 contents and improving the activities of antioxidant enzymes such as CAT, SOD, and POD
[54][55][56][57].
Apart from these proteins and metals, various secondary metabolites also act as metal chelators and are involved in the sequestration of HMs to vacuole to provide HM-stress tolerance (
Figure 2). Su et al. (2020) investigated the role of lignin in HM-stress tolerance and found that two lignin-defective mutants (
ldm1 and
ldm2) of rice showed dwarf shoots and roots due to higher levels of Cu accumulation in the roots and leaf sheaths tissues, suggesting that the promotion of lignin synthesis in plants may be an adaptive strategy for Cu adaptation
[58]. Interestingly, a higher accumulation of phenolics and amino acids was found to be associated with Co and Cu stress tolerance. It was observed that exposure of Co and/or Cu significantly reduced chlorophyll content and photosynthetic and transpiration rates of the two barley genotypes. In the comparison of a single treatment of Co or Cu, their co-application significantly attributed the higher accumulation of phenolics, including cinnamic acid and benzoic acid derivatives, together with free amino acids in tolerant genotypes (Yan66) than in susceptible genotype (Ea52). Moreover, phenolic compounds also participated in the vacuolar sequestration of Cd which enhanced Cd tolerance in
Thlaspi caerulescens [59]. In
Jatropha curcas, phenylalanine ammonia-lyase (
JcPAL) genes were identified in the metal detoxification mechanism along with the metallothioneins (
JcMT2a). Interestingly, the transcript levels of
JcPAL-R and
JcPAL-L were upregulated with increasing Pb dose in a dose-dependent manner. Overall, their results suggested that along with the steadiness of growth traits, upregulation of metal transporter, and antioxidant defense system and higher accumulation of antioxidants including flavonoids and phenolics also participate in alleviating the HM-toxicity
[60]. Similarly, the phenylalanine ammonium lyase-related gene (
HvPAL) was found to be highly upregulated along with the genes (
HvMDH and
HvCSY), involved in the biosynthesis of malate and citrate, under the combined treatment of Co and Cu in barley. Some organic acids such as citrate and malate are known to participate in HM tolerance directly or indirectly
[61]. The increase of these organic acids might be responsible for energy production under the combined treatment to fulfill the higher energy demand by metal transporters to improve Co and Cu tolerance
[62]. These metal transporters, including ABC type transporters, are a group of organic solute transporters that help in vacuolar sequestration of “PC-metal complexes” and play an important role in metal ion homeostasis and tolerance
[63][64]. For instance, it was shown that “PC-metal complexes” of metal ions such as Zn
2+, Cu
2+, and Mn
2+ can be transported into the vacuole through the putative ABC transporter(s)
[65]. A recent study has highlighted that H
2S functions by regulating the expression levels of genes of the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) superfamily to provide HM-stress tolerance
[66][67]. In rice, H
2S was found to alleviate the Al
3+ toxicity by enhancing the expression levels of ABC transporters, including
OsSTAR1 and
OsSTAR2 genes which prevent entering of Al into the cytoplasm
[68]. Besides, some other studies have also highlighted the pivotal roles of ABC and other transporters in HM-stress tolerance. For instance, upregulation of wheat ABCC transporters including
TaABCC3, TaABCC4, TaABCC11, and
TaABCC14 was observed under Cd toxicity
[69]. In
Brassica napus, ABCC transporters
BnaABCC3 and
BnaABCC4 were upregulated under Cd stress and enhanced Cd tolerance by limiting the entry of Cd inside the cells and their phytochelatin-mediated detoxification
[70]. Similar observations have been observed in Arabidopsis where ABCC transporters
AtABCC3 and
AtABCC6 were found to be involved in phytochelatin-mediated Cd tolerance during seedling development
[71][72]. In addition to these expression studies, overexpression studies have further supported the role of ABC transporters in HM-stress tolerance. For instance, overexpression of
FvABCC11 gene increased Cd tolerance in strawberry
[73] and
AtABCC1 and
AtABCC2 conferred tolerance to Cd and Hg in Arabidopsis through the vacuolar sequestration of these HMs
[74]. It was determined that
OsABCC1 regulated As-stress tolerance by sequestering As in vacuoles of the phloem companion cells of the nodes in rice grains
[65]. Similarly, a heavy metal transporter gene
AtPDR8 (an ABC transporter) was identified as a cadmium-extrusion pump in Arabidopsis to mediate resistance against Cd and Pb toxicity
[75].
Along with the ABC transporters, involvement of other transporters including multidrug and toxic compound extrusion (MATE) family proteins
[76][77], zinc-iron permease (
ZIP), iron-regulated transporters (
IRT1)
[77], natural resistance-associated macrophage proteins (NRAMP), copper transporters (Ctr/COPT), and heavy metal ATPase (HMA) transporters
[78] has also been highlighted in tolerance to HM toxicity. These metal transporters are involved in mediating metal intake and translocation in plants
[79]. For instance, IRT1 (a Fe transporter gene) that belongs to the ZIP family has been identified in Arabidopsis that leads to high-affinity Fe uptake under Fe-deficient conditions
[80] along with uptake of other heavy metals such as Cd and Zn
[81]. Other ZIP metal transporters such as
ZIP1 and
ZIP2 were identified as Zn and Mn transporters in roots that mediate remobilization of Zn and/or Mn from the vacuole to root stele
[82].
Metal transporters such as cation diffusion facilitator (CDF) transporters, ferroportins, VIT1/CCC1 also play a crucial role in the detoxification of HMs in plants and prominently remove transition metals out of the cytoplasm in the plant cell
[83]. ZAT transporters (a CDF transporter) in Arabidopsis such as
ZAT1 showed a significant role in Zn metal sequestration as transgenic lines with overexpression of
ZAT1 exhibited increased Zn resistance
[84]. It was hypothesized that ZAT is involved in vesicular or vacuolar sequestration of HMs such as Zn and thus is involved in enhancing Zn tolerance in plants
[84]. The expression of
ZTP1 (a ZAT gene) in the Zn hyperaccumulators such as
Thlaspi caerulescens in response to calamine (source of Zn, Pb, and Cd) and serpentine (rich in Ni) suggests the alleviatory role of
ZTP1 in plants during HM toxicity
[84][85].
ShMTP1, a CDF transporter, confers Mn tolerance in Arabidopsis by sequestering metal to internal organelles and may function as an antiporter of Mn to enhance tolerance
[86]. Several P
1B-ATPases in Arabidopsis have been identified that majorly alleviate metal accumulation. For instance, ectopic overexpression of
AtHMA4 in Arabidopsis mediated plant growth and development by enhancing the root growth and root-to-shoot metal translocation in the presence of toxic heavy metals (Zn, Co, and Cd)
[87]. The expression of P-type ATPase transporters enhanced under Pb stress in
Brassica juncea plants
[88] and tomato seedlings
[89]. The metal transporters including ABC, ZIP, NRAMP, Ctr/COPT, and HMA maintain metal homeostasis via activating different signaling components such as MAPK signaling and hormone and calcium signaling
[90]. Metal tolerance proteins (MTP) are also considered to be the potential efflux transporters that extrude mainly Zn out of cytoplasm along with other metals (Mn, Fe, Cd, Co, and Ni)
[91].
MTP1 confers to Zn hypertolerance in plants during high Zn concentration
[92]. Identification of undiscovered transporter genes, their functional characterization, and their manipulation can further aid in the production of hyperaccumulators as well as plants with enhanced phytoremedial potential. The HM-stress detoxifying transporters can be employed in growing applications of molecular-genetic technologies for a better understanding of heavy metal accumulation and tolerance in plants. These transporters either limit the entry of HMs into the cells or are involved in the vacuole sequestration of these HMs to improve HM-stress tolerance.