1000/1000
Hot
Most Recent
Eating disorders are a group of psychiatric conditions that involve pathological relationships between patients and food. The most prolific of these disorders are anorexia nervosa, bulimia nervosa, and binge eating disorder.
Disorder | First Author, Year | Country of Study | Sample Size | TMS Pattern | Number of Sessions | TMS Target | Duration of ED | Initial BMI | BMI Outcome | Disease Severity Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AN with comorbid MDD | Kamolz, 2008 [23] | Germany | 1 | 100 cycles of 10 Hz for 2 s on/10 s off | 3 series for 26 total sessions | dlPFC | 4 years | 12.4 kg/m2 | Increased to 16 kg/m2 | Initial HAMD value of 28 decreased to 11. |
AN (restricting and binge–purge type) | Van den Eynde, 2013 [24] | UK | 10 | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 1 session | Left dlPFC | 10 (3–30) years | 15.7 kg/m2 (13.8–17.8 kg/m2) | N/A | Sensations of “feeling fat” and “feeling full” decreased along with “urge to exercise.” Reduced feelings of anxiety. |
AN (restrictive with comorbid MDD; binge–purge) | McClelland, 2013 [25] | UK | 2 | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 20 sessions; 19 sessions | Left dlPFC | 12 years; 35 years | 15.7 kg/m2, 16.4 kg/m2 | BMI decreased at 1 month follow-up in both patients (average decrease of ~0.7 kg/m2) | EDE and DASS scores decreased in both patients. Patient 1 reported increase in purging frequency. Patient 2 reported decreased purging and laxative use. |
AN (binge–purge subtype) or BN | Dunlop, 2015 [26] | Canada | 28 (16 responders) | 60 cycles of 10 Hz, 5 s on/10 s off | 20 sessions; 30 for responders with residual symptoms | Bilateral dmPFC | 14.75 years | 19.03 kg/m2 | N/A | No significant difference at baseline between responders and non-responders. Among responders, binge and purge frequency decreased. No change in non-responders. |
AN | McClelland, 2016 [27] | UK | 60 (49 completed study) | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 1 session | Left dlPFC | 9.05 years for TMS group, 11.27 years for sham | 16.73 kg/m2 for TMS group, 16.38 kg/m2 for sham | N/A | Single session of TMS resulted in lower core AN symptoms of feeling full, urge to restrict, and feeling fat. |
AN | Choudhary, 2017 [28] | India | 1 | 1000 pulses of 10 Hz stimulation | 21 sessions | Left dlPFC | 9 years | 10.94 kg/m2 | 17.98 kg/m2 at end of 3-week treatment, 18.55 kg/m2 at 8-week follow-up | Laxative and diuretic abuse decreased significantly. |
AN (comorbid depression and anxiety) | Jaššová, 2018 [29] | Czech Republic | 1 | 10 Hz, 15 trains/day, 100 pulses/train, intertrain interval of 107 s | 10 sessions | Left dlPFC | 1.5 years | 12.21 kg/m2 | 13.15 kg/m2 at discharge, 22.9 kg/m2 at 2-year follow-up | No change in Zung self-rating scale (score = 70). |
AN | Dalton, 2018 [30] | UK | 34 | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 20 sessions | Left dlPFC | Average 14.07 years | Average 16.00 kg/m2 | Small but non-significant increases in BMI at end of stimulation and 4-month follow-up | Significant decreases in DASS global score, favoring TMS. |
AN | Dalton, 2020 (18-month follow-up from Dalton, 2018) [31] | UK | 30 | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 20 sessions | Left dlPFC | Average 14.07 years | Average 16.00 kg/m2 | Non-significant increase in BMI at 18-month follow-up | Higher rate of weight recovery in TMS group (46% vs. 9%). Non-significant improvements in EDE-Q global in both groups and improvements in DASS-21 were maintained in both groups. |
AN | Woodside, 2021 [11] | Canada | 19 | 10 Hz | 22.6 average (20–30) sessions | Bilateral dmPFC | N/A | 16.4 kg/m2 (14.5–18.5 kg/m2) | Average BMI declined to 16.3 kg/m2 at end of treatments | Significant improvements in shape concerns and weight concerns in EDE. Additionally, improvement in BAI and BDI. |
BN with comorbid MDD | Hausmann, 2004 [32] | Austria | 1 | 10 trains of 10 s 20 Hz pulses with a train interval of 60 s | 10 sessions, twice daily for 5 days | Left dlPFC | 9 years | 18 kg/m2 | N/A | Absence of binge–purge behavior following stimulation treatment. HAMD decreased 50%. |
BN | Walpoth, 2008 [33] | Austria | 14 | 10 trains of 10 s 20 Hz pulses with a train interval of 60 s | 15 sessions | Left dlPFC | Average 8.4 years for TMS group, average 8.0 years for sham group. | Average 19.6 kg/m2 in TMS group, average 19.7 kg/m2 in sham group. | N/A | Significant improvement in BDI, frequency of binging, and YBOCS at end of treatment, but no significant change between groups. |
BN | Van den Eynde, 2010 [12] | UK | 38 | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 1 session | Left dlPFC | Median 5–10 years in TMS group, median 0–5 years in sham group. | Average 25.8 kg/m2 in TMS group, average 25.0 kg/m2 in sham group. | N/A | Significant decrease in urge-to-eat VAS in the TMS group. No significant changes in hunger, urge to binge, mood, tension, or FCQ-S between groups. |
BN | Van den Eynde, 2012 [34] | UK | 7 | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 1 session | Left dlPFC | Median 0–5 years in the left-handed group, median 5–10 years in the right-handed group. | Average 22.9 kg/m2 in left-handed group, average 28.5 kg/m2 in right-handed group. | N/A | No significant differences in urge to eat, mood, tension, hunger, urge to binge eat, and FCQ-S between left- and right-handed groups. Mood differed significantly between groups, with the left-handed group experiencing a worsening in mood and the right-handed group experiencing an improvement in mood. |
BN with comorbid MDD | Downar, 2012 [35] | Canada | 1 | 60 trains of 10 Hz for 5 s on/10 s off | 20 sessions | Bilateral dmPFC | 28 years | 20.3 kg/m2 | N/A | Initial HAMD of 26 and 28 on the BDI; decreased to 0 at the end of treatment and 7 after 11 sessions, respectively. Binge–purge behavior disappeared completely after session 11 (originally twice-daily 5 h binges with subsequent purging). Single binge–purge episodes on days 65, 70, and 71 post-treatment. |
BN | Gay, 2016 [36] | France | 47 | 20 cycles of 10 Hz for 5 s on/55 s off | 10 sessions | Left dlPFC | Average 8.0 years in TMS group, average 10.5 years in sham group. | N/A | N/A | No significant changes in binging, purging, craving, MADRS, or duration of binging. |
BED with comorbid bipolar II disorder | Sciortino, 2021 [13] | Italy | 2 | 30 Hz bursts at 5 Hz intervals; 2 s on/12.3 s off; 600 pulses per session | 18 sessions across 3 weeks | Left dlPFC | 32 years, 10 years | N/A | Weight reduction of 4 kg and 2 kg at 12-week follow-up. | HAMD and MADRS improved marginally in both patients. YMRS remained at 0 throughout for both. Complete remission of binging episodes at the end of 2 weeks of treatment. |
Disorder | First Author, Year | Country of Study | Sample Size | tDCS Parameters | Number of Sessions | Intervention Target | Duration of ED | Initial BMI | BMI Outcome | Disease Severity Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
AN | Khedr, 2014 [37] | Egypt | 7 | Anodal 2 mA for 25 min with 15 s ramp in and ramp out | 10 sessions | Left dlPFC along parasagittal line | Mean of 3.4 years | Mean 14.85 kg/m2 (12–17 kg/m2) | N/A | Significant decreases in body dissatisfaction, interpersonal distrust, interoceptive awareness, and ineffectiveness scores of the EDI. Significant improvement in BDI from 22.4 to 13.3. |
AN | Costanzo, 2018 [15] | Italy | 23 | 1 mA anodal stimulation | 18 sessions | Anode over left dlPFC and cathode over right dlPFC | N/A | Mean 14.7 kg/m2 for tDCS group, 15.5 kg/m2 for sham group. | tDCS with “treatment as usual” resulted in significant improvements in BMI. No significant change in family-based therapy with “treatment as usual” group. | Significant improvement in multiple eating disorder subscales, but not significant between groups. |
AN | Phillipou, 2019 [38] | Australia | 20 | Anodal stimulation for 20 min at 2 mA | 10 sessions | Anode over left inferior parietal lobe | Currently underway | |||
AN | Mares, 2020 [39] | Czechia | 1 | 30 min of 2 mA anodal stimulation | 7 sessions | Left dlPFC anode with cathode over the right orbitofrontal region | 11 years | 17.4 kg/m2 | N/A | During tDCS, the patient developed hyperglycemia and, subsequently, diabetes mellitus. |
AN | Ursumando, 2023 [40] | Italy | 80 | 20 min of 1 mA stimulation | 1 session | F3 (anode) and F4 (cathode) of dlPFC | Currently underway | |||
BN | Kekic, 2017 [16] | UK | 39 | 20 min of 2 mA with 10 s ramp on/off | 3 sessions | F4 (anode) and F3 (cathode) of dlPFC in one group; F3 (anode) and F4 (cathode) of dlPFC in the other group | Mean 9.25 years | Mean of 21.65 kg/m2 | N/A | Both stimulatory groups exhibited decreased self-reported urge to binge eat and increased self-regulatory control. Anode right/cathode left stimulation reduced global MEDCQ-R compared to the other groups. |
BED | Burgess, 2016 [41] | USA | 30 | 20 min of 2 mA | 1 session | Anode on right dlPFC, cathode on left dlPFC | N/A | Mean of 36.1 kg/m2 | N/A | Significant fewer total calories consumed by the tDCS group. Additionally, mean decrease in consumption of preferred foods by 70.28 kcals. tDCS decreased cravings for desserts more than sham. No effect on binge frequency. |
BED | Gordon, 2019 [42] | UK | 66 | 2 mA with 10 s fade-out and fade-in | 6 sessions over 3 weeks | Anode on right dlPFC, cathode on left dlPFC | Currently underway | |||
BED | Max, 2021 [43] | Germany | 31 | 20 min of 1 mA (n = 15) or 2 mA (n = 16) | 1 session | Anode over F4, cathode over left deltoid muscle | N/A | Mean 32.1 kg/m2 in 1 mA group, mean 33.8 kg/m2 in 2 mA group | N/A | 2 mA group showed significantly fewer binge episodes with 1 mA group showing no changes. 2 mA group demonstrated improved food inhibition in UPPS. |
BED | Giel, 2023 [44] | Germany | 41 | 15 min of 2 mA | 6 sessions | Anode over F4, cathode over left deltoid muscle | N/A | Mean 31.9 kg/m2 for tDCS + FRIC group, 36.0 kg/m2 for sham + FRIC group. | Both groups experienced significant reduction in BMI | Both groups experienced significant improvement in EDE and QoL scales. Greater reduction in binge eating frequency in the tDCS + FRIC group vs. sham + FRIC group. |
BED | Flynn, 2023 [45] | UK | 80 | 2 mA | 10 sessions over 2–3 weeks | Bilateral dlPFC | Currently underway |
First Author, Year | Country of Study | Sample Size | Intervention Target | Stimulation Parameters | Disorder | Inclusion Criteria | BMI Criteria | BMI Outcome | Disease Severity Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Israël, 2010 [72] | Canada | 1 | Bilateral SCC | Unilateral stimulation on right side at 130 Hz, 5 mA for 2 min on, 1 min off | Restrictive AN | N/A. Patient has a disease duration of 35 years | N/A | Stable BMI at 2 years (19.1) | EAT-26 was 1.04 and 1 at 2 and 3 years. Low EDE score at 3 years “comparable to normal population”. No QoL score. |
Barbier, 2011 [80] | Belgium | 1 | Bilateral ALIC, BNST | N/A | AN with comorbid OCD | N/A. Patient has a disease duration of 24 years | N/A | From an initial BMI of 13.1 kg/m2, BMI increased to 13.7 kg/m2 and 23.0 kg/m2 at 2-week and 3 month follow-up, respectively | The patient exhibited reduction in YBOCS, EDE, EDI, food phobia survey, MADRS, and an increase in global function scores. |
Lipsman, 2013 [74] | Canada | 6 | Bilateral SCC | Bilateral stimulation at 130 Hz and 5–7 volts with a pulse width of 90 μs |
Restricting or binge–purge AN | Inclusion criteria: >2 years if increasingly medically unstable >3 years if relentless unresponsive >10 years if stable Actual: 4–37 years duration |
≥13 kg/m2 | 50% (3 of 6) patients had higher BMI at 9 months than baseline | YBC-EDS (preoccupations) changed from 23.7 preoperation to 17.7 at 6 months. YBC-EDS (rituals) changed from 29.3 to 19.0. Decreases in HAMD, BDI, YBOCS, and BAI. QoL score increased in those who gained weight. |
Lipsman, 2017 [81] | Canada | 16 | Bilateral SCC | Bilateral stimulation at 130 Hz and 5–7 volts with a pulse width of 90 μs |
Restricting or binge–purge AN | Inclusion criteria: >2 years if increasingly medically unstable >3 years if relentless unresponsive >10 years if stable Actual: 4–37 years duration |
≥13 kg/m2 | BMI improved from 13.83 kg/m2 at baseline to 17.34 kg/m2 | Significant improvement in HAMD, BAI, and DERS at 12-month follow-up. No QoL measures reported. |
Wu, 2013 [76] | China | 4 | Bilateral Nacc | N/A | AN (subtype not specified) | >12 months duration of illness (range: 13–28 months) | None specified (range: 10–13.3) | Average 65% increase in BMI at 38-month follow-up | No AN-specific assessments reported. YBOCS and HAMA scores were reduced on average. No QoL measures were reported. |
Wang, 2013 [77] | China | 2 (6 more underwent RF ablation) | Bilateral Nacc | Bilateral stimulation at 135–185 Hz and 2.5 to 3.8 volts with a pulse width of 120–210 μs | AN | >2 years duration of illness | Not specified | Both DBS patients experienced increases in BMI from 13.1 kg/m2 to 18.0 kg/m2 and 12.9 kg/m2 to 20.8 kg/m2, respectively, at 1-year follow-up | No ED-specific scale. QoL: SF-36 improved in physical functioning, role-physical, bodily pain, social functioning, and role-emotional 1 year post-operation. General health, vitality, and mental health were improved at 6 months and 1 year post-operation. Social functioning: SDSS scores improved. |
Blomstedt, 2017 [82] | Sweden | 1 | Bilateral medial forebrain bundle, followed by bilateral bed nucleus of the stria terminalis | Bilateral medial forebrain bundle stimulation at 130 Hz and 2.8 to 3.0 volts with a pulse width of 60 μs Bilaterally bed nucleus stimulation at 130 Hz and 4.3 volts with a pulse width of 120 μs |
AN and comorbid MDD | N/A. Duration of disease not specified. Originated during childhood for this 60-year-old patient | N/A | BMI marginally increased at 12 months from 16.2 kg/m2 to 16.5 kg/m2 under medial forebrain bundle stimulation. BMI marginally decreased from 14.5 kg/m2 to 14.3 kg/m2 under bed nucleus stimulation | Medial forebrain bundle stimulation improved MADRS, HAMA, and GAF scales, but worsened HAMD. Bed nucleus stimulation resulted in improvement in HAMD and GAF, with marginal improvement in MADRS, and worsening of HAMA. |
Manuelli, 2019 [83] | Italy | 1 | Bilateral bed nucleus of the stria terminalis | Bilateral stimulation at 130 Hz and 4 volts with a pulse width of 60 μs | AN | N/A. Patient has a disease duration of 18 years | N/A | BMI steadily increased monthly from an initial 16.31 kg/m2 to 18.98 kg/m2 at 6 months | Consistent improvement in BUT subscores, except for “depersonalization”, which showed variable changes. BITE, EAT-26, and YBOCS scores also consistently improved. QoL: SF-36 showed consistent monthly improvement. |
Liu, 2020 [75] | China | 28 | Bilateral Nacc | Bilateral stimulation at 160–180 Hz and 2.5–4.0 V with a pulse width of 120–150 μs | AN | >3 year duration of illness, resistance to medical treatment for at least 3 months | Not specified | BMI significantly improved from baseline of 13.01 kg/m2 to 15.29 kg/m2 and 17.73 kg/m2 at 6-month and 2-year follow-ups, respectively | No ED-specific scale. Significant decreases in YBOCS, HAMA, and HAMD at 6 months and 2 years. Significant increase in MMSE at 6 months and 2 years. Social functioning: SDSS improved from 11.14 to 8.64 at 6 months and 4.22 at 2 years after surgery. No QoL measures reported. |
Arroteia, 2020 [84] | Luxembourg | 1 | Bilateral Nacc | Bilateral stimulation at 204 Hz and 4.5 to 5.5 mA with a pulse width of 350 μs | Bulimic AN | Not specified | Not specified. Patient’s BMI 12.8 kg/m2 | 46.9% increase in weight at 12-month follow-up. At 14 months, binge eating and purging frequency increased, which persisted until 19 months. DBS explanted at 24 months due to infection | No ED-specific scale. No QoL or social functioning outcomes. Patient subjectively reported no change in behavior (anorexia/bulimia) but reported improvements in mood and energy. |
Villalba Martínez, 2020 [85] | Spain | 8 | Bilateral Nacc or SCC | Bilateral stimulation at 130 Hz with a pulse width of 90 µs Amplitude started at 3.5 mA and increased per patient tolerance |
AN | Age of 18–60 years, >10 years duration of illness, and refractory to treatment (no response to ≥3 voluntary intensive treatments or clinical deterioration and rejection of further treatment with ≥2 involuntary hospital for nutritional rehabilitation) | ≥13 kg/m2. One patient presented with a lower BMI and received preoperative admission for optimization of BMI | No change in mean BMI at 6 months. However, when adjusting for need for preoperative optimization, there was revealed to be a ≥10% increase in BMI in 5 patients | Mean increases in SF-36 scores (QoL measure). |
De Vloo, 2021 [86] | Canada | 15 | Bilateral SCC | Bilateral stimulation at 130 Hz and 5.0–7.0 V with a pulse width of 90 µs | Restricting or binge–purge AN | Inclusion criteria: >2 years if increasingly medically unstable >3 years if relentless unresponsive >10 years if stable Actual: 4–37 years duration |
≥13 kg/m2 | Mean BMI increased significantly from 14.kg/m2 to 17.5 kg/m2 and 16.3 kg/m2 at 1- and 3-year follow-ups, respectively | Significant improvements in YBOCS, YBC-EDS, HAMD, BDI, and BAI. No improvement in QoL. |
Scaife, 2022 [87] | UK | 7 | Bilateral Nacc | Bilateral stimulation at 130 Hz and 3.5 to 4.5 volts | AN | >7 years duration of illness. Mean of 21 years (range 12–40 years) | BMI 13–16 kg/m2 | No significant change in BMI (15.2 kg/m2 to 15.3 kg/m2) at 12 months. 3/7 patients responded (defined as >35% increase in EDE) |
At 12 months, mean EDE reduced from 4.2 to 3.4, (19.0% reduction), mean YBC-EDS reduced from 21.9 to 19.7 (10.0% reduction), and mean CIA reduced from 39.0 to 31.1 (20.3% reduction). HAMD and HAMA also decreased with an increase in SHAPS. QoL: WHO-QoL-Psych improved from 7.9 to 9.4 (18.9% increase). |
Shivacharan, 2022 [78] | USA | 2 | Bilateral Nacc | Responsive pulses delivered bilaterally at 125 Hz in two 5 s bursts; charge density of 0.5 μC cm−2 | BED and severe obesity | Failure of either 6 months of pharmacotherapy, 6 months of behavioral therapy, or gastric bypass therapy | BMI 45 to 60 | BMI loss of −2.2 kg/m2 (−4.5%) in Subject 1, −2.9 kg/m2 (−5.8%) in Subject 2 at 6-month follow-up | Reduced loss-of-control eating frequency (Subject 1: 80% decrease; Subject 2: 87% decrease). No QoL or social functioning scales reported. |