3. Connexin Participation in the Structural and Functional Integration of Malignant, Stromal, and Immune Cells within the Tumor
The coordinated actions of TME elements is one of the putative factors which determine tumor progression.
3.1. Connexins Integrate Tumor Cells
Connexin channels are direct bridges between neighboring cells, thus the presence of functional gap junctional plaques allows us to consider a network of such cells as a functional “syncytium”, somewhat similar to cardiac tissue
[34]. The formation of such a structure provides metabolic cooperation and a platform for rapid signaling, both applicable to the cancer microenvironment to adapt to limitations. For example, such cooperation can rapidly regulate cell sizes in the actively proliferating tumor. Cells deep in the tumor experience great solid stress, thus their size is limited so water can be transported to cells of the outer layers accompanied by ion transport which proceeds through gap junctions. This causes swelling of the outer layer cells leading to increased cell proliferation
[35]. Cx43-mediated glucose transfer reduces the size of the necrotic core in spheroids of colon cancer cells and elevates oxygenation and higher level of oxidative phosphorylation
[36]. Cx43 located on the tips of TNTs possess integrative properties due to their capability to unite separate cells, as was indicated in vitro, such physical integration is relevant for the formation of metastatic foci and participates in angiogenesis due to the integration of endotheliocytes and pericytes.
3.2. Connexins Integrate into the Bone Metastaic Niche
Connexins coordinate the bone metastatic niche and lead to successful metastasis establishment due to the interaction of malignant cells with the osteoclast syncytium. In the osteoblast-conditioned microenvironment, membrane-localized Cx43 mediates tumor cell chemotaxis via its non-channel functions. At the leading edge of migrating cells, Cx43’s C-tail interacts with Rac1 and contractin, thus sustaining cell migration towards the osteogenic metastatic niche
[37]. The direct interaction of cancer cells with osteoblasts through Cx43-based gap junctions provides a Ca
2+ influx to the cancer cells enhancing their malignant potential
[38]. By interacting with the osteoclast syncytium, cancer cells promote bone resorption during which a massive release of calcium and transforming growth factor-beta (TGFβ) takes place. TGFβ up-regulates Cx43, thus elevating the intracellular concentrations of calcium and enhancing GJ intercellular communications; in turn, Cx43 accelerates metastasis in the framework of this vicious cycle
[39]. Taken together, the participation of connexin in bone metastasis may be considered a two-stage process with the connexin C-tail-mediated attraction of cancer cells and channel-related progression. At the same time it should be noted that in the bone microenvironment osteocytes perform purinergic signaling and can create an oxidative microenvironment by Cx43 hemichannel activity, thus combating tumor invasion
[40][41]. Presumably, the overall role of connexins in bone as the potential soil for metastasis might depend on the ratio of the microenvironment participants.
3.3. Connexins in the Brain Niche
In the brain microenvironment, connexins appear to be the instrument that cancer cells use to turn astrocytes to allies. The connexin C-tail-mediated inhibition of Src kinase down-regulates β-catenin, triggering the preferential differentiation of neural progenitor cells towards astrocytes (against neurons). While the establishment of connexin GJs between normal neural cells and tumor cells can attenuate cell proliferation due to miR-124-3p transfer
[42], astrocytes are reported to possess pro-tumorigenic activities in the glioma microenvironment
[43][44][45]. One of the possible reasons for this is the transfer of miRNA derived from glioma cells to astrocytes, which promotes pro-invasive behavior, as was shown for miR-5096
[46] and miR-19b
[47]. In the case of miR-19b, invasiveness might be associated with the disruption of cell–matrix adhesion. The resulting shift in the microenvironment drives tissue malignization
[48].
Connexins heavily contribute to successful brain metastasis. Cx43 GJ communication mediates the extravasation of cancer cells to the brain parenchyma via a transcellular way. This process is initiated by the interaction of cancer cells with endothelium. The extravasated tumor cells engage Cx43 contacts with astrocytes in favor of the formation of metastasis and then form Cx43 contacts with each other, thus establishing a metastatic node
[49]. The preferential interaction of tumor cells with astrocytes has been shown to be promoted by c-MYC (cellular myelocytomatosis, a proto-oncogene)
[50]. Thus, in the brain niche connexins may have anti-tumor properties in the case of early tumors, while in the case of metastasis from tumors of other organs, connexins of the brain microenvironment mostly provide the means for tumor cells to pass through the blood–brain barrier and accommodate in the brain parenchyma.
3.4. Connexins Mediate Interactions of Cancer Cells and Cells of the Immune System
An important aspect of the integrative functions of connexins in the TME is their contribution to the communication of tumor cells and cells of the immune system. Connexins participate in immunological synapses
[51] and execute both pro- and anti-tumor activities
[52]. The anti-tumor activity of connexins mostly consists of their involvement in antigen presentation. Cx43 has been shown to accumulate at the interfaces between dendritic cells (DC) and cytotoxic immune cells, such as natural killers and cytotoxic T-lymphocytes, and between cytotoxic immune cells and target cells. These interactions are key to the activation and execution of the cytotoxic functions towards tumor cells
[53][54][55][56]. Of note, the connexin-mediated cytotoxic effect can also be directed towards normal cells. The transfer of peptides across the gap junctions between melanoma cells and endothelial cells, for example, may provoke the destruction of endotheliocytes by cytotoxic T cells, thus hindering tumor neovascularization and lowering the supply of oxygen and nutrients to growing tumors
[57].
Immune cells can also participate in the microenvironmental adaptation of the tumor. It has been suggested that tumor-associated macrophages (TAMs) may begin to act as intermediaries of nutrients between the tumor and vessels, creating an extensive cellular network integrated by Cx43 channels. The resulting rise in tumor metabolism not only increases its adaptability, but also leads to higher aggressiveness
[58].
The connexin-mediated cooperation of stromal cells with immune cells can contribute to tumor progression and manifests as a failed regeneration process. In the case of the giant-cell tumor of bone, Cx43 participates in the fusion of osteoclasts and monocytes. This abnormal cellular cooperation is most likely associated with an attempt by monocytes to regenerate the cancer-associated damage to bone tissues, which instead leads to an increase in the size of the tumor
[59].
3.5. Connexins in the Interactions between Tumor Cells and Other Types of Stromal Cells
Connexin contacts are established between various stromal cells, characteristic of certain metastatic niches or immune cells. Fibroblasts are a vital tissue component which substantially participates in the TME. The participation of connexins in integrating fibroblasts into the TME is tumor suppressive in the case of the early tumor and pro-tumorigenic in the advanced stage. Normal fibroblasts of the skin inhibit keratinocyte colony formation by the establishment of Cx43 GJ intercellular communications. When normal fibroblasts are exposed to sublethal doses of hydrogen peroxide (e.g., in aging) they lose Cx43 expression and thus GJ intercellular communications, which leads to the activation of keratinocyte colony formation. When the transformed fibroblasts start to prevail in the tissue microenvironment this is the turning point towards tissue malignization
[60]. Interestingly, during the development of melanoma, where Cx43 is lost in malignant cells, Cx43, Cx26 and Cx30 expression was reported to be enhanced in the surrounding normal epidermis and correlated with the grade of the tumor, while this was not observed in benign nevi, as shown by measuring the mRNA content
[61] and the evaluation of the protein localized at the membrane
[62]. Such an up-regulation of Cx26 and Cx30 occurs during wound healing and triggers keratinocyte proliferation
[61]. It should also be noted that high levels of Cx43 is characteristic for basal keratinocytes, while during maturation the level of Cx43 decreases and Cxs 26, 30 and 31 start to increase, yet their levels are still relatively low
[63].
Cells of squamous cell carcinoma down-regulate homologous GJ intercellular communications mediated by Cx43 between fibroblasts in vitro in a paracrine fashion with the involvement of calcium signaling
[64]. In the same type of cancer in vivo, Cx43 expression was observed in cancer-associated fibroblasts (CAF) located in the perlecan-rich stroma which is characteristic of invasion. Interestingly, these fibroblasts were localized in areas deficient in vasculature, i.e., areas of limited oxygen and nutrient supply
[65]. Tumor cells can also use fibroblasts as energy donors, triggering the process of cytoplasmic and organelle sharing between fibroblasts and melanoma cells by TNT formation
[66].
Initial connexin contacts between tumor cells and non-fibroblast cells can induce profibrotic properties in them, the most prominent of which is the enhanced expression of type I collagen. This was indicated for stellate cells in hepatocellular
[67] and pancreatic
[68] carcinomas.
Apparently in the TME as long as connexins are predominantly used by non-tumor cells to successfully retrain tumor cells rather than by tumor cells to subjugate normal cells, they thus act as tumor suppressors. When normal stromal communication is lost, tumor cells multiply and start to prevail in the microenvironment and thus connexins become a means of tumor progression.
4. Involvement of Connexins in Cancer Initiation
Early studies in connexin-deficient mice revealed their increased susceptibility to carcinogens
[69][70][71][72]. This phenomenological coincidence strongly indicated that connexins are involved in cancer initiation. Indeed, Cx43-knockout mice tended to be statistically more predisposed to developing lung cancer induced by urethane or DMBA (7,12-dimethylbenz[a]anthracene) than the wild-type mice
[69][70]. Cx32-deficient mice had an increased incidence of liver tumors after exposure to chemical carcinogens (DEN, diethylnitrosamine) and radiation (X-rays), with a higher number and sizes of tumor nodes compared to wild-type mice
[71][72].
Shifts in overall connexin abundance, but predominantly its loss, is associated with tissue malignization under the action of various transforming factors, such as metabolic disorders, inflammation, bacterial infection, etc. Thus, non-alcoholic hepatosteatosis can be accompanied by the down-regulated expression of Cx32 which eventually causes liver fibrosis and is followed by hepatocellular carcinoma
[73]. In the inflammatory microenvironment, for example, in the presence of pro-inflammatory cytokines (TNF-α, IL-1β and IL-6) during aging
[74] or prostaglandin E2
[75], the level of Cx43 decreases. Pre-tumorigenic cells which have lost Cx43 are susceptible to the inflammatory microenvironment and they acquire a motile phenotype
[76]. Improper diet and related metabolic stresses are shown to induce malignant transformation of the intestinal epithelium.
The improper membrane localization of connexins can also become a tumor-initiating event. Infection with human papillomavirus 16 causes mutation in the human homolog of Drosophila discs large (hDlg)-binding motif of the Cx43 C-tail, which results in the disruption of proper Cx43 and hDlg trafficking to the membrane so Cx43 remains in the cytoplasm
[77].
Another mechanism is the initiation of endometrial cancer in obese patients which can be due to the disruption of Cx43 GJ intercellular communications by hypermethylation of the Cx43 promoter in normal endometrial epithelium mediated by the microenvironment conditioned by adipose stromal cells which massively release plasminogen activator inhibitor 1
[78].
Considering not only the levels of individual connexins, but also taking into account their interplay with each other, relative changes in their levels are also important. For example, the turning point for the transformation of bile duct epithelium by
Clonorchis sinensis metabolites and eventual cancer development is accompanied by the simultaneous decrease in the expression of Cx32 and up-regulation of Cx43 and Cx26. Cx43 in this case acts as a tumor promoter as its inhibition leads to a proliferation decrease
[79]. Similarly, the altered expression and functionality of Cx43 and Cx32 in liver oval cells have been demonstrated to cause hepatocellular and cholangiocellular neoplasms due to the disruption of adequate cell differentiation
[80]. This evidence may be supported by the fact that differentiation towards normal liver tissues in early development requires the sustained expression of Cx32 and down-regulation of Cx43
[81][82].
Another way to alter intercellular communication and hence the tissue context is the stable expression of connexins which are normally only transiently expressed in a tissue when necessary for precise functional needs. For example, in normal breast development Cx32 is expressed only during lactation precisely at the interfaces of luminal cells
[83] but this is characteristic of metastatic breast cancer lesions in lymph nodes. Overexpression of Cx32 in the normal breast epithelium cell line MCF10A turned the cell morphology towards a mesenchymal phenotype and increased the migratory activity of these cells by triggering the expression of EMT markers
[84].
Hypoxia is a biological condition characterized by insufficient oxygenation of tissues which, in the case of malignant tumors, is caused by rapid cell proliferation
[85][86]. The oxygenation levels in tumors are lower compared to normal tissues. For example, it was demonstrated with the polarography method, that the oxygenation levels in well-oxygenated tissues, such as muscle, lie in the range of 20 to 70 mmHg, while in breast tumors it ranges between 3 and 30 mmHg, which indicates hypoxia
[87].
Hypoxic conditions are, on the one hand, a circumstance that is destructive to tumor cells, which cells must cope with, and on the other hand, a powerful selection factor for their collective adaptation with the subsequent development of progression mechanisms. Connexins participate in both of these aspects.
Overcoming hypoxia on a large scale is realized in tumors by promoting angiogenesis mainly by establishing the proliferative and migrative phenotype of endothelial cells. This can be realized via different types of cell–cell interactions, i.e., between tumor cells, tumor cells and endotheliocytes and between stromal cells, including vascular cells, and is mostly provided by functional GJ intercellular communications. For example, transcriptional suppression of Cx43 and Cx26 in MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cells led to the down-regulation of GJ intercellular communications between cancer cells and cancer cells-and-endotheliocytes, accompanied by reduced migrative and invasive properties, as shown by real-time cell analysis
[88]. These results suggest that GJ intercellular communications between tumor cells and endotheliocytes enhance their migration and proliferation. It has been shown that collectively migrating tumor cells that have formed Cx43 contacts with endothelial cells, i.e., pre-hypoxic micrometastases, trigger vascularization upon the onset of hypoxic conditions
[89]. On the other hand, GJ intercellular communications between endothelial cells is vital for initial vessel integrity. Loss of Cx43 expression and hence its patchy membrane localization leads to increased permeability of the existing vessels and promotes angiogenesis, as shown for high-grade serous ovarian cancer
[90]. Vascular permeability is reported to be the factor stimulating angiogenesis
[91]. Another mechanism of angiogenesis stimulation due to Cx43 loss relies on the massive production of pro-angiogenic factors due to the elevated levels of hypoxia-induced factor alpha 1 (HIF1a), as Cx43 is responsible for HIF1a ubiquitination and degradation indicated in melanoma
[92].
One of the characteristics of a severely hypoxic microenvironment that should be handled is acidosis, and functional GJ intercellular communications mediated by connexins allows its management. Thus, in spheroids of pancreatic cancer, it has been shown that connexin channels between hypoxic and normoxic cells allow the rapid distribution of bicarbonate ions to neutralize acidification in hypoxic areas
[93]. More than this, tumors can protect themselves from acidification by another mechanism, specifically, transmitting lactate through Cx43-based channels
[94]. It has been shown that acidosis management can be also carried out with the participation of the stroma. Hydrogen ions, produced by tumor cells, are captured from the extracellular space by the AE2 transporter on myofibroblasts and are then spread via Cx43 channels through the myofibroblast syncytium
[95]. The transfer of ions occurs passively, which is energetically beneficial for hypoxic cells, as they retain ATP; moreover, a spread of lactate can additionally act as an alternative nutrient shared between cancer cells, as lactate is indirectly involved in the tri-carbon acid cycle
[96]. Although as demonstrated in severe acidosis, when lactate concentrations are too high and high calcium concentrations are established, Cx43 channels close and uncouple, which leads to the interruption of the GJ intercellular communications in rat hepatocellular carcinoma and human glioblastoma A172
[97].
Thus, connexins participate in hypoxia resistance by providing a trans-cellular path for oxygen and nutrients in arranged cells which jut into the depths of the tissue from the perivascular space
[58] or by providing the spread of alternative nutrients (lactate) simultaneously protecting cells from acidification. The loss of GJ intercellular communications in vascular cells triggers angiogenesis; and the re-establishment of GJ intercellular communications in impaired vessels facilitates the migration of tumor cells through the vessel wall, enabling the formation of metastatic units already possessing resistance to hypoxia.
6. The Multifaceted Role of Connexins in Both Tumor Progression and Suppression Due to the Intracellular Transfer of miRNA
miRNAs are one of the most potent factors of the TME and they are transmitted between both malignant and stromal cells through connexin-based gap junctions or via extracellular vesicles (exosomes). Thus, Cx43-based channels have been reported to transmit miRNA-145 from microvascular endothelial cells to colon cancer cells leading to the inhibition of angiogenesis
[98]. A similar cancer-inhibiting effect was recently reported in glioma where the miR-152-3p transmitted from normal astrocytes to C6 glioma cells via Cx43-based channels attenuated their migration and invasion
[99]; and in hepatocellular carcinoma where miR-142 and miR-233 were transferred from macrophages to tumor cells
[100]. In glioma cells loaded with tumor-suppressive miR-124-3p, GJ intercellular communications enhanced the transfer and distribution of miRNA to neighboring cells which attenuated cell proliferation, as was shown in vitro and in vivo
[42].
A considerable amount of data has been gathered on the pro-tumorigenic role of miRNA transfer by connexin channels. The miR-5096 derived from glioma cells possesses a pro-invasive effect when transferred to astrocytes
[46], and a pro-angiogenic effect when transferred to microvascular endothelial cells along with the suppression of Cx43 expression
[101]. Hypoxia-induced miR-192-5p transferred through Cx43-channels from melanoma cells to cytotoxic T-lymphocytes triggers the immune surveillance escape
[102]. Bone marrow-derived miRNAs targeting CXCL12 were indicted to contribute to breast cancer quiescence
[103].
In the case of the exosome-mediated transmission, connexin channels have been reported to recruit miRNAs to exosomes as they possess RNA-binding motifs in their structure
[104]. The miRNA transmission mediated by exosomes containing connexins facilitates cancer progression in hypoxic conditions (Cx46-rich exosomes)
[105]. It is interesting to note that Cx43-based channels have a higher permeability for various miRNAs compared to channels formed by other connexins, such as Cx26, Cx30, and Cx31
[106], or Cx32 and Cx37
[107].
Summarizing these data, the trend towards tumor progression or suppression may be determined by the type of miRNA which is being transferred and the direction of transfer (from a tumor cell to a normal cell or vice versa, or between tumor cells with different malignant potential). This can probably be determined by the presence, quantity, affinity, and conformational availability of RNA-binding motifs in various connexins.
7. Connexins and Cancer Stemness
Cancer stemness is an important factor of cancer progression, which determines cancer self-renewal, dormancy, and resistance to treatment
[108]. Connexins are reported to participate in regulating cancer stemness in positive and negative ways, or utilized by cancer stem cells to perform their functions.
Connexins can reduce the stemness of cancer cells or provide assistance in cancer treatment aimed at resistant stem cells. Thus, ectopic expression of Cx43 in lung cancer cells reduces the abundance of cancer stem cells, as was shown by a reduction in tumor sphere formation and stemness markers in transfected cells
[109]. Stemness attenuation was also reported for Cx30 in glioma due to its ability to interfere with the insulin-like growth factor 1 receptor, which is involved in maintaining self-renewal
[110]. The assistance in coping with cancer stem cell drug resistance consists of the establishment of GJ communications, which was indicated in liver cancer, where simultaneous ectopic expression of Cx43 and SUMO1 resulted in a higher responsivity to treatment
[111].
Connexins can also support the stemness features of cancer cells. The most prominent stemness feature supported by them is self-renewal which was established in the case of intracellular localization of connexins. For example, it has been shown that Cx26, Cx32 and Cx46 can form alternative signaling with the pluripotency transcription factor NANOG, up-regulate CD133 or markers of stemness Oct4 and Sox2, which leads to an increased cancer abundance of stem cells and the acquisition of an invasive tumor phenotype
[112]. The functional GJ communications can also support stemness features, as was indicated for Cx46, which maintains self-renewal in glioblastoma
[113]; and for Cx43 which is crucial for maintaining pluripotency and proliferation in embryonic stem cells
[114] and maintaining dormancy in the bone marrow niche
[115].
Connexins can also be used by cancer stem cells as a means of the realization of their aggressiveness. Thus, Cx43 was reported to mediate breast cancer immune escape by establishing communications between cancer stem cells and mesenchymal stem cells which results in a preferential Treg response against T-helper 17 cells
[116]. Additionally, Cx43 facilitates lung cancer metastasis to the brain by establishing communications between cancer stem cells and astrocytes
[117].
The recent conceptual papers by J.E. Trosko discussed the hypothesis that connexins may act as key molecules which underlie cancer stem cell origin and determine the cancer stem cell type due to their tissue integration properties with the most crucial point, cell differentiation. Cancer cell stemness, in this case, is assumed to be maintained on the one hand by the sustained expression of the Oct4A oncogene which prevents the expression of connexin genes, thus making it impossible for cells to differentiate at all, or in the case of when Oct4A oncogene is absent the stemness is maintained by other oncogenes which prevent proper connexin localization and the execution of their differentiation functions
[118][119][120].