1000/1000
Hot
Most Recent
Weeds, pathogens, and animal pests are among the pests that pose a threat to the productivity of crops meant for human consumption. Bird-caused crop losses pose a serious and costly challenge for farmers.
Author |
Year |
Bird Species |
Area |
Deterrent Technique |
Success Rate |
Negative Aspects |
Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[4] |
1990 |
Phalacrocoracidae |
Aquaculture |
Scarecrows/Sirens |
Effective |
N/A |
The more realistic the facial and body shape, the more effective scarecrows are likely to be. They can be more detectable if they are painted in bright colors. |
1995, 1997 |
N/A |
N/A |
Scarecrows/ Lights/Sound |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
1976, 1979, 1983, 1985, 1980, 1982 |
N/A |
N/A |
Scarecrows |
Ineffective |
Birds get used to it easily. |
Short time application, needs to be used with other techniques. |
|
1990, 1983, 1987 |
N/A |
N/A |
Scarecrows |
Ineffective |
Birds get used to it easily. |
Relocate every 2–3 days. |
|
[16] |
1997 |
Streptopelia orientalis |
Flight Cage |
Scarecrows |
Effective |
N/A |
Better than stuffed crows or kites. |
[17] |
1989 |
Turdus merula, Anas platyrhynchos, Anser anser |
4–6 acres sunflower fields |
Scarecrows/ Propane cannon |
Effective |
N/A |
Ducks and geese spook more easily than blackbirds. |
[18] |
1974 |
Charadriiformes |
Fishponds |
Scarecrows |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Birds get used to it after two hours. |
[19] |
1986 |
N/A |
Various crops |
Reflective Tape |
Effective |
May interfere with walking on the terrain. |
Tape 0.025 mm thick and 11 mm wide. High winds may increase efficiency. |
[20] |
1986 |
Turdus merula |
Crops |
Reflective Tape |
Effective |
May interfere with walking on the terrain. If the tape gets twisted, it can be less effective. |
Tape 3 m apart from each other at 0.5 to 1 m from the ground. |
[21] |
1990 |
Anser anser |
20.2 hectares of winter wheat |
Reflective Tape |
Effective |
May interfere with walking on the terrain if the tape gets twisted; it can be less effective. |
20 mm thick red fluorescent tape. The lines were tied at 40 to 60 m between rows of wheat. |
[22] |
1998 |
N/A |
Vineyards |
Hawk Kites and Balloons |
Ineffective |
Birds get used to it easily. |
Short-term utilization. |
[23] |
1983 |
N/A |
Agricultural |
Dead Bird Models |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
1983, 1976, 1980 |
N/A |
Airports |
Dead Bird Models |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
1985, 1986, 1987, 1990 |
Larus delawarensis |
City |
Dead Bird Models/Pyrotechnics/Falconry |
Effective |
N/A |
The use of this method is recommended, but the positive results are partly due to the use of pyrotechnic material. |
|
[22] |
1984 |
N/A |
Agriculture |
Aircraft |
N/A |
Dangerous to the tripulants. |
Not recommended |
1983, 1967, 1990 |
N/A |
Farms/Airports |
RC Aircraft |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
1975, 1981 |
Sturnidae, Charadriinae, Anser anser, Anas platyrhynchos |
Airport, City |
RC Aircraft |
Very effective |
Requires a highly skilled operator. |
Birds may habituate slowly to a model aircraft that actively hazes them, especially if it has a falcon shape. |
|
[34] |
1987 |
Sturnidae |
Roost |
Lights/Predator Model |
Effective |
N/A |
N/A |
[24] |
1976 |
Anas platyrhynchos |
Grain Fields |
Searchlights |
Effective |
May attract birds if it is nighttime or if the weather is cloudy or foggy. |
It is recommended in certain weather conditions. |
[35] |
1975 |
Vanellinae, Larinae |
Airport |
Lights |
Effective |
N/A |
N/A |
[36] |
1982 |
N/A |
Airport |
Lights |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Whether the plane had its lights on or not, the results were the same. |
[37] |
1986 |
Corvus Corax, Pica, Cyanocitta cristata |
Airport |
Lights |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Birds were more frightened by the plane than by the lights. |
[38] |
1992 |
Falco sparverius, Leucophaeus atricilla |
N/A |
Lights |
May be effective |
N/A |
Lights that flash faster increase the birds’ heart rate more in the short term, but lights that flash more slowly manage to keep the average heart rate higher. |
[39] |
1976 |
N/A |
N/A |
Lights |
N/A |
N/A |
Frequencies should not exceed 100 Hz. |
1976, 1976 |
Larinae, Sturnidae, Columba livia |
N/A |
Lights |
Effective |
No repellant effect was observed when the strobe light flashed at higher frequencies to 60 Hz. |
Gulls delayed approaching a feeding point by 30 to 45 min. |
|
[42] |
1993 |
Falco sparverius, Leucophaeus atricilla |
Laboratory |
Lights |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Birds did become attentive to the lights, but it did not necessarily mean that it frightened them away. |
1983, 1977 |
Anseriformes, Charadriiformes, Passer, Larinae, Turdus merula, Sturnidae |
Oil Spill |
Lights |
Limited effectiveness |
Ineffective to gulls (Larinae), blackbirds (Turdus merula), and starlings (Sturnidae). |
50–60% success rate. |
|
[11] |
1980 |
Anseriformes |
Oil Spill |
Lights |
Ineffective |
N/A |
N/A |
Author |
Year |
Bird Species |
Area |
Deterrent Technique |
Success Rate |
Negative Aspects |
Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1939, 1968, 1986, 1989 |
N/A |
Fisheries operations |
Shotguns and Rifles |
Ineffective |
Sometimes the birds die. |
N/A |
|
[17] |
1989 |
N/A |
Agricultural fields |
Shotguns and Rifles |
Ineffective |
Sometimes the birds die. |
N/A |
1983, 1988 |
N/A |
Airports |
Shotguns and Rifles |
Ineffective |
Sometimes the birds die. |
N/A |
|
1988, 1991 |
Phalacrocoracidae, Ardeidae |
Fish farms |
Shotguns and Rifles |
Ineffective |
Sometimes the birds die. |
Killing some birds only had temporary effects. |
|
[22] |
1998 |
N/A |
Airport |
Pyrotechnics |
Effective |
Birds get used to it easily. |
Only used in an initial approach. |
[24] |
1976 |
N/A |
N/A |
Flares |
May be effective |
Fire hazard |
In conjunction with other techniques, it can help to disperse the birds in a certain direction. |
1980, 1981, 1986 |
N/A |
Landfill sites |
Pistols |
Effective |
N/A |
Small area and short-term usage. |
|
[54] |
1991 |
Branta canadensis |
Urban parks |
Screamer shells |
Very Effective |
N/A |
Long-term effects, the concentration of geese in the area was reduced by 88%. |
[24] |
1976 |
N/A |
N/A |
Mortars |
May be effective |
Highly skilled operator. Safety hazard; there have been several accidents related to the use of mortars. |
If they produce a loud bang, they are more effective at daytime and in a larger area than other pyrotechnic devices. |
1974, 1990 |
N/A |
N/A |
Gas cannon |
N/A |
N/A |
The noise of the explosion resembles or is louder than that of a 12-gauge shotgun. |
|
1981, 1986 |
N/A |
Areas up to 4 ha |
Gas cannon |
Effective |
N/A |
Proven to be effective deterrents for areas up to 4 ha in the cases of nongame species. |
|
1984, 1990, 1990 |
Laridae |
Landfill |
Gas cannon and others |
Effective |
N/A |
Gas cannons, in combination with other dispersal methods such as pyrotechnics, have been found to reduce numbers of gulls. |
|
1983, 1976 |
N/A |
Various Crops |
Av-alarm |
Effective |
N/A |
AV-alarms appear to have been used successfully to reduce numbers of small birds. |
|
[60] |
1985 |
Sturnus vulgaris, Passer melanurus, Ploceus velatus |
Grape culture |
Av-alarm |
Effective |
N/A |
Can be effective in reducing the damage to grapes. |
[61] |
1970 |
Sturnidae |
Blueberry crops |
Av-alarm and others |
Effective |
N/A |
It worked better in conjunction with shotguns or propane cannons. |
[62] |
1978 |
Telluraves |
Cornfields |
Av-alarm and gas cannon |
Effective |
N/A |
Better results were obtained by combining both methods. |
[63] |
1983 |
N/A |
N/A |
Av-alarm |
Ineffective |
N/A |
AV-alarm was not as effective as distress calls in repelling birds. |
1990, 1990 |
N/A |
N/A |
Av-alarm |
Ineffective |
Birds accustomate to this sound. |
Birds accustomate to this sound. |
|
[66] |
1979 |
Sturnidae |
N/A |
Av-alarm |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Starlings only increased slightly the heart rate when they were exposed to AV-alarm. |
1973, No date |
Aequornithes |
Aquatic terrain |
Av-alarm |
May be effective |
N/A |
Insufficient details to assess changes in bird numbers. |
|
1973, 1968 |
Laridae |
Airport |
Predator Sounds |
Effective |
N/A |
The playback of a Peregrine Falcon call was effective at dispersing gulls. |
|
[71] |
1957 |
Anas platyrhynchos |
Ponds |
High-intensity Sounds |
Effective |
Can cause hearing damage and other human health effects. |
Some birds vacate the pond after two or three days. |
[72] |
1986 |
Laridae |
N/A |
Ultrasounds |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Found no evidence that gulls either heard or reacted to ultrasounds. |
[73] |
1992 |
N/A |
N/A |
Ultrasounds |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Bird population did not decrease in more than 5%. |
[74] |
1996 |
N/A |
N/A |
Infrasounds |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Birds do not associate these sounds with danger. |
Author |
Year |
Bird Species |
Area |
Deterrent Technique |
Success Rate |
Negative Aspects |
Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1988, 1990 |
N/A |
Residential area |
Chemical |
N/A |
N/A |
Birds tend to not get used to it. |
|
1976, 1984, 1988 |
N/A |
Cities, agriculture, and airports |
Chemical |
N/A |
N/A |
Birds tend to not get used to it. |
|
[80] |
1997 |
Sturnidae |
Laboratory |
Tactile repellents |
May be effective |
N/A |
It may be possible to develop non-lethal, plant-based dermal repellent. |
[22] |
1998 |
N/A |
N/A |
Tactile repellents |
May be effective |
N/A |
Plant compounds that have been tested caused agitation and hyperactivity in the birds. |
[22] |
1998 |
N/A |
N/A |
Behavioral Repellents |
N/A |
Can cause disorientation and erratic behavior. |
N/A |
1983, 1983, 1990 |
N/A |
N/A |
Behavioral Repellents |
Effective |
If the dose is too high, it can lead to the bird’s death. |
Unaffected birds from the flock eventually escape due to the warning signal from the flock mate. |
|
1983, 1983, 1990, 1970, 1973, 1970 |
Sturnidae, Turdus merula, Passeriformes, Laridae, Corvus Corax |
Air bases |
Behavioral Repellents |
Effective |
N/A |
N/A |
|
[22] |
1998 |
Branta Canadensis, Laridae, Sturnidae |
Laboratory, sanitary landfill, airports |
ReJeX-iT |
Effective |
N/A |
ReJeX-iT can be effective at deterring birds in certain situations, but the doses used in some studies were not effective. |
[86] |
1992 |
Anas platyrhynchos, Branta Canadensis |
Laboratory |
Dimethyl and Methyl anthranilate |
Very Effective |
N/A |
When subjected only treated grain, both ducks and geese reduced their food intake. |
[87] |
1995 |
Larus delawarensis, Larus argentatos, Anas platyrhynchos |
Pools of water in fields |
Methyl anthranilate |
Effective |
N/A |
N/A |
[88] |
1996 |
Branta Canadensis |
N/A |
Methyl anthranilate |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Product concentration used in [87] did not repelled this species. |
[89] |
1993 |
N/A |
Ponds at airports |
ReJeX-iT |
Effective |
N/A |
Bird numbers decreased in treated ponds. |
Author |
Year |
Bird Species |
Area |
Deterrent Technique |
Success Rate |
Negative Aspects |
Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1978, 1981, 1981 |
N/A |
N/A |
Exclusion |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
[93] |
1936 |
Aequornithes |
Aquaculture ponds |
Overhead Wires and Lines |
Effective |
N/A |
Recommended as a method of deterring waterbirds from fishponds. |
[52] |
1981 |
N/A |
Fish-rearing facilities |
Overhead Wires and Lines |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
[94] |
1990 |
Aequornithes |
N/A |
Overhead Wires and Lines |
Effective |
N/A |
The effectiveness of overhead wires or lines varies widely among species and circumstances. |
[22] |
1998 |
N/A |
Fruit trees |
Overhead Wires and Lines |
Effective |
High costs and difficult application in large areas. |
It solves the problem of the presence of birds in a permanent way. |
[22] |
1998 |
N/A |
Sanitary landfill |
Foam |
May be effective |
Its effectiveness would be reduced in rainy or windy weather. |
It could be used to cover small areas that are particularly attractive to birds. |
[22] |
1998 |
N/A |
Lakes, ponds… |
Bird Balls |
May be effective |
N/A |
Are very easy to install and require significantly less maintenance. |
Author |
Year |
Bird Species |
Area |
Deterrent Technique |
Success Rate |
Negative Aspects |
Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[95] |
1968 |
N/A |
N/A |
Tall Grass |
N/A |
Long grass can attract rodents and birds of prey. |
Prevents some birds from accessing food. |
[96] |
1996 |
N/A |
Airport |
“Poor grass” |
Effective |
N/A |
Bird numbers on poor grass were as low or lower than on long grass. |
[97] |
1996 |
N/A |
N/A |
Mowing at nighttime |
Not Tested |
N/A |
Mowing late in the day or overnight can reduce the attractiveness of this activities. |
[98] |
1997 |
N/A |
Airport |
Mowing at nighttime |
Effective |
N/A |
Mowing late in the day or overnight can reduce the attractiveness of this activities. |
[99] |
1988 |
Laridae |
Landfill |
Changing water/feeding zones |
Effective |
N/A |
By removing the water/food, the area is no longer attractive to birds. |
Author |
Year |
Bird Species |
Area |
Deterrent Technique |
Success Rate |
Negative Aspects |
Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[100] |
1968 |
Agelaius |
Corn fields |
Traps |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Due to the number of birds in the group, it is impossible to catch them all. |
1974, 1987, 1990 |
N/A |
N/A |
Traps |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
[90] |
1978 |
Butorides virescens |
Fish farm |
Traps |
Effective |
Transportation costs |
The birds were released 40 km from the point where they were trapped, and never came back. |
1976, 1970, 1986 |
Larinae |
Airport |
Live Ammunition |
Ineffective |
Birds habituate easily. |
It was seen that in the short term it was effective |
|
1968, 1970, 1976, 1991 |
N/A |
N/A |
Surfactants |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
[110] |
1997 |
Turdus merula, Sturnidae |
N/A |
Surfactants |
Effective |
38.2 million blackbirds and starlings were killed between 1974–1992. |
PA-14 did solve local roost problems. |
[104] |
1976 |
Laridae |
Airbase |
Falconry, Pyrotechnics |
Effective |
It was necessary to replace two falcons each year. |
Four goshawks were successfully used at an airbase in Holland to clear the runways from gulls. |
[111] |
1970 |
Laridae |
Airbase |
Falconry |
Effective |
N/A |
Gulls showed no signs of habituating to the goshawks during the two-year study. |
[112] |
1996 |
Laridae |
Military Airfield |
Falconry |
N/A |
N/A |
Not recommend as a routine method for bird control at civil airfields. |
[113] |
1978 |
Laridae |
Airfields |
Falconry, Pyrotechnics, Model Gulls |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
1985, 1986, 1987 |
Branta Canadensis |
Airfields |
Falconry |
Ineffective |
N/A |
N/A |
|
[114] |
1983 |
Columba palumbus |
Brassica fields |
Falconry |
Ineffective |
N/A |
After repeated attacks by the goshawk, the pigeons usually resettled and continued to feed. |
[115] |
1978 |
Laridae |
Landfill |
Falconry |
Very effective |
Some birds died |
The effectiveness seemed to derive from the cumulative effects of several bird control episodes. |
1998, 1965, 1980 |
Laridae |
N/A |
Falconry |
N/A |
Falcons cannot fly with bad weather. |
Dealing with gulls with bad weather is a problem. |
Author |
Year |
Bird Species |
Area |
Deterrent Technique |
Success Rate |
Negative Aspects |
Conclusions |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
[118] |
1976 |
Anseriformes |
Agriculture |
Lure Area |
N/A |
N/A |
Attracting and holding birds so that they will not go elsewhere. |
1975, 1974, 1978, 1981 |
N/A |
N/A |
Magnetic Field, Microwaves |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
[123] |
1997 |
Sturnus vulgaris |
N/A |
Magnetic Field |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Only been proven to disorient birds and not to disperse them. |
1971, 1973 |
N/A |
N/A |
Microwaves |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
|
[126] |
1985 |
N/A |
N/A |
Microwaves |
N/A |
N/A |
N/A |
1965, 1969 |
Laridae, Melopsittacus undulatus, Gallus gallus domesticus, Columbidae |
Laboratory |
Microwaves |
N/A |
The radiation levels are considerably higher than the levels that are safe for humans. |
N/A |
|
1996, 1946, 1949, 1954, 1971, 1972 |
N/A |
N/A |
Microwaves |
N/A |
N/A |
Few studies have reported that radars have caused behavioral changes in flying birds. |
|
1972, 1965 |
Sturnidae, Anas platyrhynchos, Laridae |
Laboratory |
Laser |
N/A |
Could cause hemorrhage in birds’ eyes. |
Not recommended |
|
[136] |
1980 |
Laridae |
Landfill |
Laser |
Ineffective |
N/A |
Not recommended |