The cornea is an ideal tissue for gene therapy, as the ocular surface can be an excellent platform for the topical application of various viral/non-viral gene delivery vectors. The overexpression of specific genes in corneal epithelial or stromal cells that block the TGF-β signaling cascade can prevent scar formation.
3.4. MicroRNA Therapies in Regenerating Cornea without Scars
MicroRNAs are 21-nucleotide-long, non-coding RNAs that can post-transcriptionally silence the expression of their target genes. These microRNAs form an RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC) with Argonaute proteins. These proteins guide them towards the target mRNA, where they pair with the target mRNA and silence its expression
[57].
MicroRNAs in the cornea affect various cellular processes, such as cell migration, differentiation, proliferation, and metabolism. Any dysregulation in miRNA levels during corneal injury can lead to corneal neovascularization and scar formation. An J et al.
[58] observed a sharp decrease in the expression of miR-204 in a murine corneal wound model. MicroRNA-204 is abundant in the cornea. It inhibits corneal cell proliferation by G1 phase arrest. Therefore, low miR-204 levels during corneal wounds account for the excessive proliferation of transformed epithelial cells, myofibroblasts, ECM remodeling, and fibrosis during quick wound healing. Wang Y et al.
[59] compared lens epithelial cells from healthy donors and patients with posterior capsular opacification (PCO). They showed increased α-SMA and vimentin and decreased E-cadherin in the diseased cells, indicating opacification. An in vitro PCO model was developed and transfected with miR-204. The lens epithelium cells showed increased E-cadherin and decreased α-SMA compared to non-transfected controls and miR-204-5p-inhibitor-transfected cells. MicroRNA-204 prevents TGF-β-mediated EMT and fibrosis by targeting SMAD4, disrupting the SMAD2/3-SMAD4 complex. It also decreases the expression of the Hey/HMGA transcription factors, which induce EMT through CDH1 repression and SNAIL activation
[60][61]. A subconjunctival injection of a recombinant adeno-associated vector (rAAV-miR-204) prevented neovascularization in murine alkali-burned corneas, indicating the anti-angiogenic role of miR-204
[62].
The downregulation of miR-145 and the upregulation of miR-204 and miR-133b can prevent TGF-β-mediated corneal fibrosis. MicroRNA-based gene targeting is a promising therapeutic approach to prevent and heal corneal scarring (Figure 4).
Figure 4. MicroRNA therapy for corneal scarring. Upregulation of miR-204 and miR-133b and downregulation of miR-145 help in healing a scarred cornea via modulating Krüppel-like factor 4 (KLF4), Smad2/3, and CTGF.
3.5. Bioactive Molecules as HDAC Inhibitors in the Regeneration of Scarless Cornea
The wound-healing process of an injured cornea involves three overlapping phases: the inflammatory phase, the proliferative or fibrotic phase, and the final remodeling phase
[63]. These events change the native morphology of the corneal stromal ECM, rendering it opaque. During the initial inflammatory phase of the healing process, corneal cells exhibit high levels of proinflammatory cytokines. During the initial phase of wound healing, the infiltrated neutrophils, monocytes, or activated macrophages secrete TGF-β, increasing its local concentration around the wounded area. TGF-β guides the transition of the wound from the inflammatory phase to the fibrotic phase by decreasing the local proinflammatory cytokine level. The timely termination of the initial inflammatory phase is required for the cells to enter the cell proliferation and ECM synthesis phase, healing the wound
[64]. A lesser-known pathway that TGF-β uses for this transition is by modulating histone acetylation. TGF-β recruits histone deacetylases (HDACs), removing the acetyl group from the lysine residues of histones H3 and H4 of anti-inflammatory genes. Histone acetylation is associated with anti-inflammatory gene activation; therefore, HDAC is recruited in the presence of TGF-β, deactivating various anti-inflammatory genes and enabling the transition to the fibrotic phase
[65][66][67][68][69]. Trichostatin A (TSA), a deacetylase inhibitor, prevents the deacetylation of histone H3 or H4 of anti-inflammatory genes. TSA prevented the TGF-β-mediated transformation of corneal fibroblasts to myofibroblasts in vitro and also reduced the corneal opacity in a rabbit model of corneal haze
[70][71].
A possible mechanism of action for HDAC inhibitors is increasing the local concentration of TGF-β during wounding, leading to HDAC recruitment, SMAD7 deacetylation, SMAD7 ubiquitinylation, and proteasomal degradation. This paves the way for TGF-β-mediated corneal scarring. Similarly, suberoylanilide hydroxamic acid (SAHA), an HDAC inhibitor, reduced α-SMA and MMP9 expression in equine corneal fibroblasts treated with TGF-β. This shows that SAHA can prevent TGF-β-mediated corneal fibrosis
[72]. Epigenetic modulators, such as TSA and SAHA, might be useful bioactive molecules for treating corneal scars.
3.6. Guided Wound Healing to Prevent Scarring
Corneal wound healing is accompanied by the secretion of various growth factors. During wound healing, these growth factors interact with their cognate receptors present on the surface of the cell to regulate the synthesis of collagen, proteoglycan, and other ECM components’ deposition. Various growth factors, such as IGF-1, platelet-derived growth factor (PDGF), TGF-β, and fibroblast growth factor 1 (FGF-1), either reach the wound site from the tear film or are secreted by the surrounding wounded or apoptotic epithelial cells. Etheredge et al.
[73] reported that FGF-1 stimulates keratocyte proliferation; however, it inhibits the synthesis of type 1 procollagen and keratan sulfate. Type 1 procollagen is an essential component of the stromal ECM, and keratan sulfate directs collagen assembly to maintain corneal transparency. FGF-1 induces the formation of hypercellular keratocytes with densely packed cells in the sparse matrix. IGF-1 turns these hypercellular keratocytes into collagenous keratocytes that secrete ECM components, similar to native keratocytes. Therefore, the IGF-1/IGF-receptor signaling pathway prevents the transformation of keratocytes into myofibroblasts and ECM remodeling (
Figure 5). However, this is not a predominant signaling pathway during wound healing because the local concentration of TGF-β in the wound microenvironment is high. Therefore, the TGF-β/TGF-βRI pathway takes charge, and TGF-β binds to its receptor on keratocytes to synthesize biglycan, fibronectin containing extra domain A, and hyaluronan. This proteoglycan disrupts the spacing between collagen fibrils, reducing the corneal transparency. It also guides the differentiation of keratocytes into myofibroblasts, characterized by the neo-expression of α-SMA. α-SMA incorporates actin into collagen fibrils and exerts a contractile force on the ECM, disrupting the normal corneal architecture.
Figure 5. Role of growth factors in scar prevention. Various growth factors, such as fibroblast growth factor (FGF) or insulin-like growth factor (IGF-1), are secreted from the tear film. These growth factors cross the disrupted Bowman’s membrane to reach the corneal stromal layer. FGF converts keratocytes to hypercellular keratocytes. IGF-1 converts hypercellular keratocytes to collagenous keratocytes, which secrete ECM components similarly to the native cornea. Meanwhile, in the epithelial layer, after wounding, epithelial cells undergo apoptosis, and the apoptotic epithelial cells release TGF-β. Neutrophils, macrophages, and monocytes, which migrate from the epithelial layer to the stromal layer, secrete TGF-β, thereby increasing its local concentration. Keratocytes in the presence of TGF-β are converted to myofibroblasts, which disrupt the highly organized fibrillar arrangement of the corneal ECM.
TGF-β heals corneal wounds and is a hallmark of the process of scarring. In contrast, IGF-1 guides the process of wound healing and circumvents scarring. So far, IGF-1 has been studied as an external growth factor, either alone or together with a bioactive compound, such as SAHA or substance P. Bioengineering keratocytes to overexpress IGF-1 can increase its local concentration and allow it to control the process of wound healing.
3.7. Clinical Therapy for Scar Prevention
A gold-standard technique to prevent corneal scarring is still under research. Various biomolecules, such as decorin, TPCA-1, glucosamine, acetylcholine, and chitosan, have the potential to heal a scarred cornea via their respective biological pathways. Chen et al.
[74] reported the significance of glucosamine in corneal scar treatment. This amino sugar finds clinical application in osteoarthritis management
[75]. However, it significantly enhances intraocular pressure
[76]. Park et al.
[77] noted that glucosamine attenuated renal fibrosis by downregulating SMAD2 phosphorylation; therefore, a study of glucosamine’s effects on corneal fibrosis can provide new insights into its clinical applications. Chen’s group observed an increase in the expression, stability, and nuclear localization of KLF4 and a decrease in fibrotic gene expression in HCFs treated with glucosamine and TGF-β. The mechanism underlying the glucosamine-mediated increase in KLF4 expression is still under research. However, a study by Wang DF et al.
[78] reported that glucosamine increases the expression of the phosphorylated form of PTEN (a phosphatase), leading to an increase in the phosphorylated form of KLF4. This increases the P300 histone acetylase activity, mediating H3 histone acetylation
[79][80].
Glucosamine can form O-linked N-acetylglucosamine via glucosamine transferase activity and the post-translational modification of the proteasome complex to prevent KLF4 degradation
[81]. Moreover, KLF4 interacts with TGF-β control elements and prevents a proinflammatory environment
[82]. Therefore, glucosamine might find clinical applications in healing corneal scarring (
Figure 6).
Figure 6. Mechanism of action of TPCA1 in attenuating corneal fibrosis.
Chitosan is an effective therapeutic tool for wound healing because of its antifibrotic and anti-angiogenic properties and its ability to promote rapid re-epithelization for wound closure
[83][84]. Fischak et al.
[85] formulated a topical eye drop for corneal epithelial wound dressing by functionalizing chitosan with N-acetylcysteine to improve its mucoadhesive properties. They observed faster wound closure in a rabbit corneal wound model. Similarly, thiolated chitosan nanoparticles (TCS-NPs) prevented myofibroblast formation in IL-6-treated HCFs
[86]. The TCS-NPs reduced fibronectin or collagen I expression and VEGF expression by 99.9%. Chitosan downregulated TGF-β expression by promoting a more stable interaction between miRNA-29b and the CDS region of TGF-β, attenuating TGF-β signaling
[87]. However, the expression of miRNA-29b was not upregulated after TCS-NP treatment. The cellular pathway underlying the chitosan-mediated attenuation of TGF-β expression remains unclear; however, functionalized chitosan can be a novel therapeutic approach to prevent corneal scarring.
Lycium barbarum polysaccharide (LBP), derived from the ancient herb
Lycium Barbarum, is a bioactive molecule clinically used in kidney, eye, and liver fibrosis
[88]. Du et al.
[89] observed that LBP prevented UV-B-induced apoptosis of corneal epithelial cells (CECs) by preventing the phosphorylation and activation of the JNK pathway. In a proof-of-concept experiment to test LBP’s efficacy in attenuating corneal fibrosis, TGF-β stimulated HCF cells subjected to varying concentrations of LBP showed a dose-dependent decrease in α-SMA expression and a reduction in profibrotic collagen
[90].
Fibrosis is generally accompanied by the production of reactive oxygen or nitrogen species (ROS/RNS)
[91]. ROS are produced because of the TGF-β-mediated activation of NADPH-oxidase 4 via the SMAD3 signaling pathway
[92]. ROS directly contribute to fibrosis by inducing TGF-β expression
[93]. They also indirectly contribute to fibrosis by activating various growth factors, chemokines, cytokines, and other inflammatory molecules
[94]. Increased ROS levels have been observed in skin specimens of patients with systemic sclerosis or skin fibrosis
[95]. This increase is associated with EMT and myofibroblast accumulation
[96]. Therefore, attenuating ROS production might prevent scarring events. Nuclear factor erythroid 2–related factor 2 (Nrf2), a leucine zipper transcription factor, decreases ROS production by increasing the expression of antioxidant genes, such as superoxide dismutase and NADPH quinone oxidoreductase, by binding to the antioxidant response element. Nrf2 is subjected to proteasomal degradation in the presence of kelch-like ECH-associated protein 1 (keap1), which is activated by BRD4 expression triggered by TGF-β. JQ1, an inhibitor of BRD4, reduces the expression of α-SMA and collagen I. It increased Nrf2 nuclear localization in HCF cells stimulated with TGF-β in vitro. It also increased corneal scarring in an injured mouse model by reducing fibrotic marker expression, supporting the antifibrotic role of JQ1
[97]. A similar antifibrotic effect was observed when immortalized HCFs pretreated with TGF-β were transfected with siRNA targeting BRD4, indicating that BRD4 inhibition prevents TGF-β-mediated corneal fibrosis.
IL-β, a proinflammatory cytokine, crosses the disrupted Bowman’s membrane and binds to receptors on keratocytes upon injury, promoting apoptosis or angiogenesis in the cornea
[98]. IL-1β activates the NF-κβ pathway, which causes inflammation and fibrosis. The NF-κβ pathway is activated by the phosphorylation of either the IKKα or IKKβ subunit of its key modulator, IKK. TPCA1 inhibits the phosphorylation of the IKKβ subunit and deactivates the NF-κβ pathway. Zhang et al.
[99] showed that TPCA1 preserved the keratocyte phenotype in HCFs pretreated with IL-β via nuclear accumulation of phosphorylated NF-κβ. Corneal keratocytes stimulated with IL-1β showed the reduced expression of keratocyte markers such as KERA, LUM, and ALDH3A1 and elevated levels of phosphorylated NF-κβ
[100]. IL-1β treatment elevated MMP2, MMP3, and MMP9 expression in corneal fibroblasts. This was reversed by TPCA-1 application to IL-1β-stimulated fibroblasts
[101]. MMPs have multiple roles in wound healing, such as ECM remodeling, TGF-β cleavage, and the activation of EMT
[102]. TPCA-1 can prevent corneal scarring by inhibiting IKK and MMP (
Figure 6).
Acetylcholine is a neurotransmitter that is released by cholinergic receptors. CECs show a very high expression of acetylcholine
[103]. Acetylcholine interacts with its nicotine receptor, causing the influx of Na
+ or Ca
2+ ions and the efflux of K
+ ions. This modulates various signaling pathways through protein kinases and phosphatases
[104]. Acetylcholine can also act via a murine receptor (mAchR) to activate multiple downstream signaling pathways by activating protein kinase C. mAchR (M1, M3) and nAchR are present in CECs, and acetylcholine can promote re-epithelization in an injured rat cornea
[105]. In contrast, keratocytes produce a meager amount of acetylcholine. Acetylcholine promotes keratocyte proliferation by activating the mAchR present on keratocytes. Sloniecka et al.
[106] showed reduced fibrotic gene expression in primary human keratocytes cultured in the presence of acetylcholine with concentrations of 10
−7 M and 10
−8 M. The low dose of acetylcholine had a pronounced antifibrotic effect, indicating that it can be developed as topical eye drops for safe and antifibrotic wound healing.
Decorin, a prime proteoglycan of the corneal ECM, can interact with all three isoforms of TGF-β. It can directly sequester the active form of the growth factor and attenuate its function
[107]. The overexpression of decorin using a mammalian expression vector prevents myofibroblast transformation in TGF-β-stimulated HCFs
[108]. Decorin binds to its cognate receptor and increases the intracellular calcium level. This increase in calcium activates calmodulin, which phosphorylates CAM Kinase II and inhibits the TGF-β-mediated activation of fibrotic genes via SMAD 2 phosphorylation
[109]. The administration of decorin, using fluid gel with a better drug retention capacity, promoted rapid re-epithelization in ex vivo injured rat corneas
[110]. Therefore, the ocular administration of decorin using a delivery vehicle with increased retention time exerts a better therapeutic response in regaining a scarless cornea
[111].
3.8. Nanomedicine in Corneal Scarring Treatment
Nanomedicine is an emerging field in medical science with the potential to revolutionize corneal fibrosis therapy (
Figure 7). Nanomedicine utilizes materials with nanometer dimensions to target living cells at the genetic and molecular levels. It ensures efficient and sustained drug release, increasing the bioavailability of drugs. This is especially good for topical eye drops, which have a bioavailability of only 5%
[112].
Figure 7. Nanotechnology as a therapeutic tool for reviving scarred corneas. Keratocytes transform into fibroblasts and then into myofibroblasts in the presence of TGF-β. This disrupts the highly organized fibrillar arrangement of the corneal stromal ECM. Nanoparticles loaded with the gene of interest or specific drugs, nanofiber scaffolds loaded with drugs, dendrimers, nanomicelles, and nanopolymers are a few nanomedical approaches for treating a scarred cornea.
A polymeric acid nanofiber scaffold covalently attached to antisense oligonucleotides targeting diabetes-linked genes was conjugated to a monoclonal antibody for cell targeting. A trileucine repeat for endosomal rupture (caused by low pH) and an Alexa Fluor for cell tracking showed the release of the antisense oligonucleotides in the cytoplasm of the target cell. The oligonucleotides were released because of covalent bond cleavage by cellular glutathione, resulting in the binding and suppression of diabetes-linked genes
[113]. Ma et al.
[114] prepared a poly-lactic co-glycolic acid (PLGA) scaffold that served as an ideal platform for corneal keratocyte growth and differentiation. This scaffold repaired corneal stromal defects. Polylactic acid nanofiber scaffolds can be loaded with drugs such as cyclosporine A to accelerate corneal stromal wound healing
[115].
Dendrimers are branched three-dimensional nanostructures. They can be coupled with polypropylene and crosslinked with collagen. They have high mechanical strength and can serve as an optimal tissue-engineering scaffold for corneal cells
[116]. Nanodevice soft lenses can be loaded with suitable drugs for sustained release over time and can be placed on the ocular surface. Pullulan and poly-caprolactone can be used to prepare nanospheres that can be loaded with antimicrobial drugs, such as ciprofloxacin. These nanospheres can be coated on the surface of the lens to prevent
Staphylococcus aureus and
Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections in the eye
[117]. Nanosponges are highly branched colloidal nanostructures that can be synthesized by crosslinking β-cyclodextrin and di-phenyl carbonate. When loaded with dexamethasone, these nanosponges increase the drugs’ permeability on the ocular surface
[118].
Although nanomedicine has proved to be an effective tool for corneal wound treatment, high production costs, tissue accumulation, and in vivo stability are the major limitations of their therapeutic application
[119]. Nanomedicine is a promising approach because of its drug release kinetics over conventional drug delivery methods. Therefore, it should be explored further for treating corneal scars.