Extraction Method
|
Advantages
|
Disadvantages
|
Hot water/alkali extraction
|
Optimal rheological properties and purity of the extracted hydrocolloids
|
Involves high temperatures and very long extraction time
|
Long extraction time and high temperature may affect extracted compounds’ functionalities
|
Use of hazardous chemical solvents
|
|
|
High cost of chemical solvents
|
Microwave-assisted extraction (MAE)
|
Use of water instead of chemical solvents
|
High temperature can deteriorate thermolabile compounds
|
It provides locally heat raw materials, enhanced biomass digestion, reduced process time, solvent consumption, and costs
|
Extracted compounds possess good quality
|
It utilizes directly on fresh biomass from seaweed
|
Ultrasound-assisted extraction (UAE)
|
Ability to achieve larger yield of extracts utilizing water
|
High noise levels involved (safety issues)
|
Ultrasound might bring to depolymerization of compounds
|
It increases extraction yield with lower extraction time
|
Due to the high cost of energy and equipment, UAE needs a large amount of capital to get started on an industrial scale
|
Efficient, environmentally friendly, and low extraction processes. Low equipment expenses and maintenance, possibility to scale-up to industrial production, reduced number of process steps
|
UEA applications are still limited
|
Extraction techniques used in food industry
|
|
Ability to obtain larger yield of extracts utilizing aqueous-based solvent
|
High-pressure involved (safety issue)
|
Pressurized solvent extraction (PSE)
|
High-pressure power can bring depolymerization of compounds
|
It has high extraction performance, less solvent usage, quick extraction time, and does not imply the use of hazardous solvents
|
These processes might degrade labile compounds due to high temperature and pressure
|
Scarcity of application on seaweed extractions
|
Enzyme-assisted extraction (EAE)
|
Ability to achieve larger yield of compounds utilizing water
|
Scarcity of application on seaweed extractions
|
It is inexpensive, highly efficient, possibility to scale up, avoid the use of any harmful chemicals or organic solvents and it has shorter extraction time
|
It preserves the structural integrity of the target compounds extracted that exert important bioactivities suitable for cosmetic, nutraceutical and pharmaceutical industries
|
4. Potential Use of Seaweed for Nutraceutical Applications
The most ancient information regarding the use of seaweed as food for therapeutical purposes goes back to ancient times in Japan. Even though many of the transcripts have been destroyed or lost, the properties of
Sargassum sp. were investigated and compiled in Chinese medical literature “
Compendium of Materia Medica”, written by Shizhen Li in 1578. While the
Compendium also states that
Sargassum sp. can soften hard lumps, dispel nodes, eliminate phlegm, induce urination in humans
[42], treat fever, infections, laryngitis, and other diseases
[43], the most ancient information on
Sargassum focuses on its ability to treat thyroid-related diseases, such as goitre, and iodine deficiency disorders
[44]. Vietnamese medicine frequently employs species from the
Eucheuma and
Kappaphycus (Rhodophyta) genera to reduce the incidence of tumors, ulcers, and headaches.
Although recent researchers see
Sargassum sp. as a suitable immunomodulator, due to its bioactive metabolites, which may improve immune function and inhibit thyroid growth caused by excessive iodine absorption, important information related to the treatment of thyroid-related conditions, such as goiter, as claimed for
Sargassum sp. in traditional Chinese medicine, has not yet received enough research
[45]. Asian cultures still consume seaweed for therapeutical applications, and this practice is widely spreading across the world as the beneficial properties of seaweed have been abundantly confirmed by scientists.
Currently, preclinical and clinical tests have demonstrated the efficacy of several biological activities of seaweed bioactive compounds.
Meinita et al.
[46] collected case studies conducted on seaweed and the treatment of chronic disease
[47]. The research records a higher percentage of experiments conducted with brown seaweed (68%), followed by red seaweed (18%), and green seaweed (14%). The most extensively investigated species of brown seaweed were
Ecklonia,
Sargassum, and
Fucus (they represent 21.3%, 20.2%, and 9%, of the total of the studies collected, respectively). The two species of red seaweed that have been examined the most for potential application in the treatment of chronic illnesses are
Gracilaria, (20.8%) and
Gelidium (16.7%). While,
Ulva (47.4%),
Codium (26.3%), and
Caulerpa (47.4%, 26.3%, and 15.8%, respectively) the three species of green seaweed explored the most. Brown seaweeds have been the most researched in relation to cancer, diabetes, arthritis, neurodegenerative illnesses, obesity, osteoporosis, liver disease, and cardiovascular disease. Not many clinical trials have been performed, however, one was carried out to evaluate a seaweed extract formulation from
Fucus vesiculosis,
Macrocystis pyrifera, and
Laminaria japonica, on osteoarthritis patients. According to the study, the formulation would ameliorate osteoarthritis symptoms in a dose-dependent way
[48].
Manufacturers and consumers have shown a growing interest in incorporating functional components into daily diets in recent years. Moreover, the antioxidant and antimicrobial activities exhibited by seaweed compounds will ensure safety and delete the spoilage of food. The presence of flavonoids in the green algae
Ulva reticulata and
Ulva sp. (Chlorophyta) showed potential free-radical-scavenging ability
[49][50]. Strong DPPH-radical scavenging activity has been measured in brown algae including
Eisenia bicyclis,
Ecklonia cava, and
Ecklonia kurome [51], as well as for red algae
Callophyllis japonica and
Gracilaria tenuistipitata ethanolic extracts
[52][53]. Seaweed polar lipids are now well recognized as essential phytochemicals that contribute and add usefulness and potential advantages for our health. Lopes et al.
[54] set out to reveal the lipid profile of
Palmaria palmata raised in an integrated multitrophic aquaculture (IMTA) to test its antioxidant properties. A total of 143 lipids were discovered, spanning numerous polar lipid groups such as phospholipids, glycolipids, and betaine lipids. It is important to note that eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) accounts for more than half of the lipid content. One of the primary determinants of the antioxidant effectiveness of
Palmaria palmata may be its level of EPA. Therefore, this finding suggests that this red macroalga could be used in the future as a source of EPA-rich lipids and antioxidant activity for functional foods
[54].
The inclusion of seaweed molecules in food can contribute to ameliorate the lifestyle of people with certain medical conditions, as they possess interesting biological properties that guarantee health benefits. Seaweed, as a nutritional source, inhibits the growth of cancer cells, most likely due to its antioxidant characteristics. Antioxidants are clearly important in the later phases of cancer formation, as evidenced by the mechanisms of carcinogenesis promoted by oxidation activity. As a result, antioxidants are regarded as a viable method for regressing premalignant lesions and preventing cancer development
[55]. Sulphated polysaccharide, derived from
Gracilaria lemaneiformis, showed exceptional anti-cancer and immunomodulatory activity against transplanted H22 hepatoma cells in mice. Tumor growth was significantly slowed, splenocyte proliferation was boosted, macrophage phagocytosis was increased, and the number of IL-2 and CD8+ T cells in the blood increased
[56]. The antiproliferative effect of κ-and λ-carrageenan extract from the red seaweed
Laurencia papillosa has been demonstrated in vitro with human breast cancer cell line MCF-7
[57]. κ-carrageenan from
Kappaphycus alvarezii, an edible seaweed, have been investigated for their antiproliferative activity. Results from the incubation of two LMWF of carrageenan with human colon cancer cells HCT116 revealed that these fractions may induce apoptosis via the ROS-mediated mitochondrial pathway by upregulating the latter, along with upregulating Bcl-2 and Bcl-xL, caspase3, and downregulating XIAP, an inhibitor of apoptosis. The investigated fractions could be incorporated in food to prevent colon carcinogenesis. Dietary behaviors influence the development of colorectal cancer; therefore, identifying dietary components that can help to prevent cancer could help people acquire healthier eating habits. LMWF soluble dietary fibers could be a potential additive in nutraceutical food, contributing to the efficacy of several health-promoting advantages as cancer treatment coadjutants. Exploring their health advantages would offer up new avenues for research in the nutraceutical field
[58].
Antimicrobial and antioxidant properties of
Kappaphycus alvarezii extracts were tested in both hot water and ethanolic extracts by Bhuyar et al.
[59].
Escherichia coli and
Bacillus cereus were used as pathogenic bacteria in the investigation of antibiotic activity. Both extracts’ antibacterial activity was more potent against
Bacillus cereus than against
Escherichia coli, suggesting that they might be able to maintain a healthy level of reactive oxygen species. Levoglucosenone, which has a highly functionalized chiral structure and can be used as a crucial intermediate in the development of biologically active compounds, and pyridinemethanol, a functional pyridine that is used as an intermediate in the pharmaceutical industry, were among the fatty acids found in both extracts; 1,2,5- Thiadiazole-3-carboxamide, which can be utilized as an antibacterial; and hexamethylcyclotrisiloxane, which is widely employed in medical, military aircraft, and other petrochemical sectors. Furthermore, GC-MS analysis revealed that considerable levels of levoglucosenone (48.9%) and 4-pyridinemethanol (28.21%) were found in hot water extract, suggesting that it may have antitumor potential
[59].
Among Asian seaweeds, the popular red edible seaweed
Gelidium amansii is frequently utilized in Korea, Taiwan, China, and Japan, as a cuisine ingredient. Particularly appreciated in Taiwan and Japan, agar jelly is prepared from hot-water extracts of
Gelidum amansii [60]. Galactose (23%) and glucose (20%) are particularly abundant in this red seaweed’s carbohydrate content
[61]. Due to its easy and low-cost cultivation,
Gelidium amansii is commonly involved in the manufacturing of agar
[62]. Moreover, extracts of this alga showed that diabetic rats’ liver and plasma lipid levels could be lowered by supplementing high-cholesterol and high-fat diets
[60]. Due to its numerous health benefits,
Gracilariopsis chorda (Rhodophyta) is another popular seaweed in Korea, and it is also used as a food component
[63]. In addition to Korea, France, Indonesia, Mexico, Morocco, Portugal, and Spain, also use
Gracilariopsis chorda as a raw material to extract agar
[64].