| Version | Summary | Created by | Modification | Content Size | Created at | Operation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Rita Puglisi | + 3429 word(s) | 3429 | 2022-02-18 04:04:09 | | | |
| 2 | Lindsay Dong | Meta information modification | 3429 | 2022-02-21 02:38:03 | | |
Frataxin, the protein implicated in Friedreich’s ataxia (FRDA), has a role in the Fe–S cluster biogenesis and possesses a well-defined structure. Several frataxin point mutations, identified in heterozygous FRDA patients, affect the protein structure and function and its binding with partners.




| Mutation | Location | Structural Effects | Other Effects | Tm (°C) | Affected Protein Interaction | Phenotype |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| L106S | α1 | Steric strain due to replacement of a apolar residue with a smaller polar one. | milder symptoms | |||
| D122Y | loop | Change of a conserved negatively charged residue. | Lower iron binding stoichiometry. | 50.4°C (Correia, 2008) | IscS | mild and atypical disease |
| G130V | turn β1–β2 | Steric strain due to replacement of a glycine that is in a conformation not allowed to other residues. | Higher degradation of frataxin in the cell. Lower iron affinity. | 43.2°C (Correia, 2008) | mild and atypical disease | |
| G137V | turn β1–β2 | Steric strain due to replacement of a glycine that is in a conformation not allowed to other residues and steric hindrance. | Lower efficiency of the folding process. | 46°C (Faggianelli, 2015) | milder symptoms | |
| N146K | β3 | Electrostatic strain. | 69.4°C (Castro, 2019) | IscU | classical | |
| I154F | β4 | Steric strain due to replacement of a hydrophobic residue by a larger one. | Maturation with increase of insoluble intermidiates. | 50.7°C (Correia, 2008) | Isd11 | classical |
| W155R | β4 | Replacement of a bulky highly conserved aromatic residue with a positively charged one. | 61.4°C (Correia, 2008) | Isd11/Nfs1 and IscU | classical | |
| L156P | β4 | Disruption in the β-sheet by introducing a proline. | IscU | classical | ||
| R165C | β5 | Replacement of a conserved positively charged residue with a cysteine that is hydrophobic and might form intermolecular disulfide bond. | IscU | mild and atypical disease | ||
| W173G | β6 | The introduction of a glycine affects the protein folding. | Poorly expressed. | classical | ||
| L182F | α2 | Steric strain due to replacement of a hydrophobic residue by a larger one. | Prone to degradation. | mild and atypical disease | ||
| L182H | α2 | Electrostatic strain due to replacement of a hydrophobic residue with a hydrophilic one. | Prone to degradation. | classical | ||
| H183R | α2 | Strain due to replacement of a residue with a bulkier one. | classical | |||
| L198R | C-terminal region (CTR) | Electrostatic strain and disruption of the interaction of CTR with α1 and α2. | Lower iron binding affinity. | 54.1°C (Faraj, 2014) | classical |
The mutations of the buried residues (L106, L182, H183 and L186) most likely disrupt the frataxin’s fold and cause FRDA disease.
This is the case for the replacement of a T with a C at position 317 in exon 3, which resulted in L106S missense. The patient carrying this mutation presented milder symptoms, such as the slow rate of disease progression, only lower limb weakness and no cardiac abnormalities or diabetes [73]. L106 belongs to the α1 helix and is conserved throughout the species. This is a nonconservative substitution of an apolar amino acid with a smaller polar residue with a lower tendency to form a helix [73]. The mutation from T to G was also reported. It causes the change from L106 to a stop codon (L106X) and leads to a truncated form of frataxin [74]. Patients carrying this mutation show a total deficiency of frataxin and typical FRDA with a severe course of the disease [75].
In other cases, individuals carry a C to T substitution altering the codon at position 182 and present a leucine replaced by the larger phenylalanine (L182F) in the α2 helix. They show atypical and mild symptoms, such as minimal dysarthria, little upper limb disfunction, absent ankle jerks, but reduced knee reflexes and progressively worsening lower limb ataxia [76]. Although L182 is supposed to be essential for the frataxin function, as it is a conserved residue, the L182F variant is still able to bind and activate the Fe–S machinery. On the other hand, the L182H mutation shows an alteration in the circular dichroism spectrum, suggesting a change in the secondary structure because of the substitution of a hydrophobic residue with a charged one.
H183 is a buried residue responsible for human frataxin stabilization, as it acts as a lock between the α1 and α2 helices, despite it is a non-conserved residue. Patients with H183R have been reported [77]. Although this is a conservative replacement, in which a positively charged amino acid is replaced by another one with similar characteristics, the steric difference between the two residues probably causes a strain disrupting the interaction.
Furthermore, the alteration in frataxin’s structure would arise from the mutation of β-sheet conserved residues with side chains directed towards the hydrophobic core, such as for L156 and W173.
L156 is highly conserved during evolution and a replacement by a proline (L156P) has been reported [77]. This is likely to profoundly affect the tridimensional structure, as proline has a high conformational rigidity and acts as a disruptor of the secondary structure. Consequently, the binding with IscU is affected [78]. W173 is also highly conserved and its replacement by a smaller residue, such as a glycine (W173G), may deeply affect protein folding [77] to the point that, when trying to produce it, the mutated protein is poorly expressed in the mature form [79].
On the other hand, the mutations of conserved exposed residues on the β-sheet plane (I154, N146, W155 and R165) may alter the ability of frataxin to bind its partners and disrupt the function.
Patients with an I154F mutation were found in a restricted area of southern Italy, probably because of the founder effect, in which the mutation is passed down from an individual to other generations. These patients present the typical FRDA phenotype [10][77]. The missense mutation affects a conserved residue located in β4, a highly conserved region involved in the interaction with Isd11 [79]. The maturation of this pathological variant is affected and results in the presence of insoluble intermediates [80]. The I154F mutant presents reduced stability with a Tmof 50.7 °C [81] and precipitates in the presence of iron [81][82].
Among the conserved residues on the β-sheet plane, N146, W155 and R165 are significative as they are adjacent in the structure, and the mutation of one has a consequence on the other. Interestingly, the patients carrying the N146K mutation presented classical features of FRDA; despite this, the frataxin mutant showed a stabilized native conformation with a Tm of 69.4 °C [83]. It has been suggested that the proximity of W155 and the replacing lysine may imbalance the electrostatic properties of the frataxin surface and affect the binding capacity of frataxin for its protein partners [84]. The W155R mutation causes a classical FRDA phenotype as well. W155 belongs to β4 and is an exposed residue responsible for the interaction with ISD11 that is disrupted after the mutation [85], as are the interactions with IscU and Nfs1 [84]. This mutant retains a native fold and has a slightly reduced stability [86][82]with a Tm of 61.4 °C [81]. The destabilization is expected from the deletion of a π–cation interaction between W155 and contiguous R165, and the electrostatic repulsion resulting from the insertion of arginine. On the contrary, patients with a compound heterozygous for the R165C substitution have a milder disease course (no dysarthria, gait disturbance and ankle jerks) [87]. This mutation occurs in a conserved region of β5. It is a nonconservative replacement, altering a basic amino acid to a hydrophobic non-charged one, which might also form an intermolecular disulfide bond and perturb the interaction with IscU [78].
As a result of their unique properties of backbone conformations, glycines are often positioned in loops and their substitution necessarily leads to the destabilization of the fold.
The G130V mutation is relatively common in FRDA [87]. People presenting frataxin with the G130V mutation have an atypical mild disease with an early onset, spastic gait, absence of dysarthria, retained tendon reflexes, mild or no ataxia and the slow progression of symptoms [77][87][88]. This suggests that, although the residue is highly conserved, the mutation only partially influences the frataxin function. G130V results in a large change in the Tm value (43.2 °C) [81] and it seems to affect the maturation of the protein [89]. G130 belongs to a turn between strands β1 and β2, and its backbone carbonyl oxygen forms a hydrogen bond with the amide of K147, which is involved in binding the scaffold protein IscU [78] and belongs to a ubiquitination site. The mutation of G130 thus results in a higher degradation of frataxin in the cell [90] and in the disruption of the interaction with IscU. In addition, the G130V mutation affects the frataxin iron affinity [81][82].
An FRDA patient with a compound heterozygous with an G137V substitution was also reported. It described an onset at 25 years of age and phenotypes, such as gait and trunk ataxia, mild dysarthria, absent tendon reflexes in the upper and lower limbs and impaired position and vibratory sense in the lower limbs [91]. Frataxin carrying the G137V mutation presented no effects on the structure or activity of the protein, but had a reduced conformational stability with a melting temperature of 46 °C. This is supposed to affect the efficiency of the folding process causing reduced levels of the active protein [91]. G137 is not an evolutionary conserved residue and is located in the C-terminal globular domain at the end of the β2 strand. Its mutation to a valine is supposed to have an important influence on the turn and, additionally, to cause steric hindrance with other residues. Interestingly, D122 packs against G137, suggesting that the two mutations have the same effect [91]. Similar to the patients carrying the G137V mutation, those found with the D122Y mutation had a mild and atypical disease [77]. D122 belongs to the N-terminus and its mutation does not affect the folding. However, by changing the polarity of the anionic surface, it reduces the protein stability [6] with a Tm of 50.4 °C [81]. The D122Y variant has a lower iron binding stoichiometry [81] and a perturbed interaction with the desulfurase [78].
As it was already described above, the C-terminal tail plays a crucial role in the stabilization of the fold [92][93]. A compound heterozygous patient was reported to present a base substitution that converted leucine to arginine at amino acid position 198 (L198R), located in an apolar environment in the C-terminus. The patient showed a typical FRDA phenotype [94]. L198 is a conserved residue and the mutation causes an alteration in charge with a consequent destabilization of the protein, with a Tm of 54.1 °C [95], due to the disruption of the interaction of the C-terminus with the α1 and α2 helices. L198R also showed a lower iron binding capability [95]. To determine the relevance of the frataxin C-terminus, other mutations at this position were also investigated (L198A and L198C). They all presented protein destabilization [96] as well as the absence of the C-terminus (residues 196–210) [93][95]. On the other hand, the truncation of frataxin at residue 193 determines FRDA with a rapid disease progression [97].
Such a variety of examples prove that similar dramatic or milder phenotypes do not necessarily derive from the same cause and, actually, may have a different origin at a molecular level. Depending on their localization in the structure, specific mutations can impair the function by disrupting the interaction with essential partners and decrease the protein stability leading to the degradation or disruption of the folding.