The Tubulin Code in Mitosis: History
Please note this is an old version of this entry, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Subjects: Cell Biology
Contributor: ,

Mitosis relies on the critical contribution of microtubules, as well as several microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) and motors, to regulate several key mechanisms underlying the faithful segregation of the genetic material during cell division. The mitotic spindle is an anisotropic and highly heterogeneous structure, with dynamic astral microtubules essentially tyrosinated, in contrast with more stable microtubule subpopulations, such as kinetochore and a fraction of interpolar microtubules, which accumulate detyrosinated, Δ2, acetylated and polyglutamylated tubulin.

  • microtubule
  • mitosis
  • tubulin code
  • detyrosination
  • kinetochore
  • mitotic spindle
  • centrosome
  • molecular motors
  • MAPs

1. A Navigation System Guides Chromosomes to the Spindle Equator

Although tubulin diversity in the mitotic spindle has been recognized for several decades, the respective functional relevance for mitosis remained unclear until recently. One crucial implication of the tubulin code hypothesis is the regulation of MAPs and motors by specific tubulin isotypes and PTMs [4]. Original work in neurons revealed that classic kinesin motors, such as Kinesin-1, are able to recognize and have a preference for microtubules with particular tubulin PTMs, namely detyrosination and acetylation [60,61]. Subsequently, α-tubulin detyrosination was shown to regulate mitotic chromosome congression to the metaphase plate by guiding the microtubule plus-end-directed motor CENP-E/kinesin-7 at kinetochores in human cells [36]. In contrast, the microtubule minus-end-directed motor dynein/dynactin that is also localized at unattached kinetochores [50,51] preferentially associates with tyrosinated microtubules [40,62,63,64], which favor the initiation of motion but are dispensable for subsequent dynein/dynactin processivity [63,64]. Thus, detyrosinated/tyrosinated α-tubulin regulates the activity of opposing kinetochore motors, establishing a navigation system for chromosomes that assists their congression to the spindle equator [65] (Figure 2). Accordingly, during the initial capture of chromosomes, dynein/dynactin counteracts the action of chromokinesins on chromosome arms to move peripheral chromosomes along tyrosinated astral microtubules towards the vicinity of the poles [66]. By transporting peripheral chromosomes to the poles where the microtubule destabilizing activity of Aurora A kinase is higher [67,68], dynein/dynactin prevents the formation of stable end-on kinetochore–microtubule attachments that would otherwise cause the random ejection of polar chromosomes by chromokinesins [65,66]. Once at the poles, Aurora A-mediated phosphorylation activates CENP-E at kinetochores of polar chromosomes [69], thus allowing their transport specifically along detyrosinated spindle microtubules towards the equator. In agreement, recent super-resolution coherent-hybrid stimulated emission depletion microscopy [70] of CENP-E-GFP revealed its exclusive association with stable kinetochore and interpolar microtubule bundles but not with tyrosinated astral microtubules [71]. Curiously, α-tubulin acetylation on K40, which is also enriched on stable spindle microtubules [41], does not interfere with polar chromosome congression [36]. While the potential contribution of other tubulin PTMs to chromosome congression remains unknown, these findings support a robust working model in which tyrosinated/detyrosinated microtubules guide peripheral chromosomes towards the spindle equator.
Figure 2. Summary of the established roles of the tubulin code in mitosis. The initial capture of peripheral chromosomes is mediated by dynein/dynactin at kinetochores, upon which, the chromosome is brought to the vicinity of the centrosome by lateral transport along tyrosinated astral microtubules. This prevents the random ejection of the chromosome by the action of Chromokinesins on chromosome arms. Once at the pole, high Aurora A activity prevents the stabilization of end-on kinetochore-microtubule attachments, which otherwise would favor the action of Chromokinesins on chromosome arms. In parallel, Aurora A-mediated phosphorylation activates CENP-E at kinetochores. This initiates transport towards the spindle equator (congression) along stable detyrosinated microtubules. Mitotic centromere-associated kinesin (MCAK) and Kif2b (not depicted) at centromeres and kinetochores are also inhibited by tubulin detyrosination on kinetochore microtubules, allowing the correction of syntelic and merotelic attachments, while preserving correct amphitelic attachments on bi-oriented chromosomes. MCAK at the microtubule plus ends also regulates astral microtubule length to allow interaction with dynein/dynactin at the cortex or cytoplasmic organelles (not depicted), which exerts pulling forces necessary for spindle orientation and positioning.

2. A Mitotic Error Code

The regulation of kinetochore microtubule dynamics is essential for error correction and the maintenance of genome stability, since it allows the establishment of amphitelic kinetochore-MT attachments that lead to chromosome biorientation relative to the spindle poles. Kinesin-13s, such as Kinesin superfamily 2b (Kif2b) and mitotic centromere-associated kinesin (MCAK), promote kinetochore microtubule dynamics, thus playing a key role in the correction of mal-oriented chromosomes with erroneous kinetochore-microtubule attachments (e.g., syntelic, in which both sister kinetochores are oriented towards a single spindle pole, and merotelic, where a single kinetochore is attached with microtubules oriented to both poles) and, ultimately, in the prevention of chromosome mis-segregation [55,72] (Figure 2). In agreement, stimulation of kinetochore microtubule dynamics in otherwise chromosomally unstable cancer cells by increasing kinesin-13 depolymerase activity reestablished chromosomal stability [55,73]. Building on the previous finding that MCAK’s microtubule depolymerizing activity is reduced four-fold in the presence of detyrosinated microtubules in vitro [74,75], it was recently shown that the mitotic error correction activity of MCAK and Kif2b is regulated by α-tubulin detyrosination [37]. Accordingly, the experimental depletion of TTL or overexpression of VASH1-SVBP, which caused a constitutive increase of α-tubulin detyrosination in the vicinity of the kinetochores, compromised error correction, leading to chromosome segregation errors. Importantly, α-tubulin detyrosination specifically impaired the MCAK-based error correction machinery located on centromeres/kinetochores, and it did so without affecting global kinetochore microtubule dynamics, suggesting that mitotic error correction is exquisitely sensitive to the detyrosinated state of α-tubulin that likely occurs at the individual microtubule level. These data support the existence of a “mitotic error code” in which α-tubulin detyrosination/tyrosination signals and regulates MCAK activity at centromeres/kinetochores to discriminate between correct and incorrect kinetochore-MT attachments during mitosis (Figure 2).
Complete centrosome separation before nuclear envelope breakdown prevents subsequent segregation errors and ensures mitotic fidelity [76]. This relies on several elements, including the microtubule motors kinesin-5, required for centrosome separation, and dynein/dynactin, which promote both centrosome separation and positioning [77,78]. Similar to dynein/dynactin, kinesin-5 appears to have increased affinity to tyrosinated dendritic microtubules in neurons [79], but direct evidence from in vitro reconstitution assays is still lacking. Nonetheless, recent work in which centrosome positioning in human mitotic cells was tracked in 3D indicated that centrosome separation at nuclear envelope breakdown is insensitive to the tyrosinated state of α-tubulin [37]. This reinforces the idea that the observed increase in mitotic errors associated with excessive α-tubulin detyrosination is due to the incapacity to correct, rather than an increased propensity to make errors.

3. Role in Mitotic Spindle Orientation and Positioning

Mitotic spindle orientation and positioning in the cell center is essential for accurate cell division and relies on the action of pulling forces on astral microtubules [80]. In particular, dynein/dynactin anchored to cortical proteins or cytoplasmic organelles was shown to play a significant role in spindle orientation/positioning [81,82,83], possibly through its increased affinity to tyrosinated astral microtubules. Indeed, modulation of the α-tubulin tyrosination state, either through TTL knockout [40] or CRISPR/Cas9-mediated editing of the C-terminal tyrosine [83], caused spindle orientation defects. In contrast, an experimental decrease of α-tubulin detyrosination after VASH1/2 silencing increased the depolymerase activity of MCAK, resulting in disoriented spindles, with shorter astral microtubules [19]. Taken together, these observations indicate that the mechanisms behind spindle orientation/positioning rely on the intrinsic nature (i.e., nonmodified) of tyrosinated α-tubulin to allow astral microtubules to establish a correct cell division plane (Figure 2).

4. Roles in Centrosome Structure and Cytokinesis

Tubulin polyglutamylation is highly enriched on centriole microtubules [42,84] and has been proposed to contribute to normal mitosis by maintaining centrosome structure [84,85]. Indeed, recent super-resolution imaging of the centriole structure revealed the specific distribution of polyglutamylation on centriole MTs and suggested a key role for this PTM in ultrastructural organization of specific centriolar proteins [86]. Furthermore, tubulin polyglutamylation promotes the activity of the microtubule-severing enzymes spastin and katanin [87,88,89,90], which are also implicated in cell division. Indeed, their activities regulate several cellular processes that likely impact chromosome segregation fidelity, such as microtubule poleward flux, spindle orientation and length [91,92,93]. Spastin and katanin are also required for the abscission step and completion of cytokinesis [94,95,96]. Like spastin [94] and katanin [96], polyglutamylated tubulin is enriched at the midbody [87], and a tubulin mutation that compromises polyglutamylation (and, possibly, also polyglycylation) in cilia was shown to cause cytokinesis defects [97]. These results suggest that the completion of cytokinesis relies on the regulation of spastin and katanin activities by tubulin polyglutamylation.

This entry is adapted from the peer-reviewed paper 10.3390/cells9112356

This entry is offline, you can click here to edit this entry!
Video Production Service