Dissolution, chemical or electrochemical reactions, can change the morphology of crystal surfaces. If some points dissolve or react preferentially on the exposed surfaces, etch pits will form.
As dislocations have been revealed by etch pits, the control of the dislocation density becomes feasible, and this is very important for the modern electronic industry. Hence, examples are shown here to demonstrate the improvements of the application of etch pit technology. By limiting the growth of dislocations revealed by etch pits, the dislocation density of a newly grown crystal can be reduced effectively. Meanwhile, new tiny crystals can grow in etch pits. Utilizing dislocations below etch pits as a channel, some kinds of atoms in the substrate can be transported into corresponding etch pits preferentially and form new crystals. By presenting the new and skillful utilization of etch pits, it is our hope that more ingenious methods can be found to promote the application of etch pit technology as well as related modern fabrication industries.
2. Influencing Factors for the Formation of Etch Pits
The morphology, size, and density of etch pits can be affected by various factors, including the chemical composition of the etchant, etching time, etching temperature, status of the matrix, and so on. It is important to investigate the effect of different factors on etch pits to obtain well-defined etch pits that can be utilized to reveal defects in crystals precisely.
2.1. The Etchant
The selection of proper etchants is critical to obtain well-defined etch pits on crystals. The dissolution rate of surface atoms on crystals is closely related to the type of etchants. The morphology and density of etch pits can also be affected significantly by the etchant.
2.1.1. Effect on the Morphology of Etch Pits
The etchant could affect the size of the etch pits. The Sopori etchant and the Secco etchant were utilized to etch a multi-crystalline silicon sample. Etch pits obtained with 60 s Secco etching have a size of 0.5~1 μm, while etch pits produced by Sopori have a size of 2 μm after etching for only 5 s [
67].
The types of the as-revealed etch pits could vary with etchants. Some etchants are more suitable to reveal more kinds of etch pits. On a lateral epitaxial overgrowth GaN film, molten KOH revealed threading screw dislocations, while mixed HCl vapor revealed threading screw dislocations, mixed dislocations, and threading edge dislocations [
68].
The nucleation and growth process of etch pits are closely related to the composition of etchants. After etching with a saturated calcite solution containing 1 mM EDTA, symmetric rhombic etch pits were observed on calcite crystals. When the etchant was changed to a flowing saturated calcite solution, etch pit nucleation and growth halted immediately. When the etchant was changed to an undersaturated calcite solution, the growth of etch pits reinitiated, and the shape of etch pits gradually changed to an asymmetric rhombus [
69].
The morphology of etch pits can be affected by adding other chemicals into the etchant. After the addition of SO
42− and S
2O
32− ions in the 1 M NaCl solution, macro etch pits with rough walls appeared, and after the addition of HSO
4− ions in the 1 M NaCl solution, strip-like etch pits appeared on the Al substrate [
70]. Conventional KOH etchants are not applicable to SiC with high electron concentrations, while the addition of Na
2O
2 to the etchant is effective in revealing threading screw dislocations, threading edge dislocations, and basal plane dislocations [
71]. The addition of sulfate ions to HCl leads to the passivation of the existing etch pits and results in a more uniform etch pit structure on the aluminum foil after alternating current etching [
72].
The relative content of chemicals in an etchant can affect etch pits. On GaN, pure H
3PO
4 results in stripe-like etch pits; a mixture that contains H
3PO
4 and H
2SO
4 results in etch pits composed of two long {10
1¯0} facets, and pure H
2SO
4 results in rhombus-like etch pits [
73]. On the (100) surface of InAs, the etchant contains HCl, H
2SO
4, and H
2O with a volume ratio of 10:m:1 (0 ≤ m ≤ 20). When m = 0, elongated hexagonal etch pits with a long axis parallel to the [1
1¯0] direction were observed; as m increased from 1 to 10, the shape of the etch pits changed to a quasi-rectangle, and when m = 17, rectangular etch pits were observed [
74].
2.1.2. Effect on the Density of Etch Pits
The density of dislocations revealed by different etchants can be different. This is related to the fact that some etchants can reveal more kinds of dislocations than other etchants [
75,
76]. On a GaN film, etch pit densities revealed by molten KOH and a mixture of H
3PO
4 and H
2SO
4 were 4 × 10
7/cm
2 and 5 × 10
8/cm
2, respectively [
77].
2.1.3. Effect on the Etching Rate
The etching rate could be affected by the composition of etchants [
78]. The etching rate of Ga-polar on GaN crystals was 30 nm/min with H
3PO
4 as the etchant, while the etch rate dropped to 8 nm/min when KOH was used as the etchant [
79].
2.2. The Etching Time
As the etching time increases, the size, depth, and shape of etch pits can be changed. Meanwhile, the density of etch pits can also be affected.
2.2.1. Effect on the Morphology of Etch Pits
Generally, etch pits will enlarge and deepen with increasing etching time due to the continuous dissolution of atoms on the exposed surface of the substrate, and neighboring etching pits will merge into a larger one after a period of etching [
80,
81]. On an organic single crystal of 2-amino 4,6-dimethyl pyrimidine 4-nitrophenol, the size of the etch pits enlarged with increasing etching time, and then the etch pits overlapped [
82]. On single crystals of stearic acid, small flat-bottomed etch pits at an etching time of 5 s became large flat-bottomed etch pits at 13 s, while pyramidal etch pits became deeper and larger, and the distance between the pyramidal etch pits varied because of the inclination of dislocations [
19].
The shape of the etch pits also varies with the etching time [
83,
84]. On the (111) face of a diamond etched with molten NaNO
3, after 40 min of etching, the conical steep-sided etch pits became flat-bottomed [
85]. On the (100) face of Al under an anodic pulse current in a mixture of HCl and H
2SO
4, only circular etch pits were observed before reaching the steady-state potential, while after dissolution at the steady-state potential, circular etch pits transformed into square etch pits [
86].
Molten potassium was chosen to etch a diamond at 600 °C, and the exposed surface was determined to be {100} [
87]. The etch pit size gradually increased with increasing etching time. Initially, shallow, square etch pits were observed. When the etching time reached 1 h, the corners of some etch pits were blunted. When the etching time reached 1.5 h, octagon-shaped etch pits were observed, as shown in
Figure 4.
Figure 4. Morphology of the diamond {100} face after etching at 600 °C for different times: (
a) 30 min; (
b) 1 h; and (
c) 1.5 h [
87]. Reproduced with permission from Elsevier.
2.2.2. Effect on the Density of Etch Pits
The density of etch pits can increase with increasing etching time. On 4H-SiC crystals etched with KOH, as the etching time increased, etch pits increased in number, and the original etch pits increased in size, while the increased number of etch pits could be related to the fact that more dislocations were revealed gradually as some buried dislocations emerged at the continuously lowering surface [
88]. On the CR-39 surface etched with a NaOH solution, etch pits could hardly be observed when the etching time was shorter than 45 min, and the etch pit density increased slightly and then saturated with the etching time; a longer etching time resulted in over-etched pits [
89].
2.3. The Etching Temperature
The size, depth, shape, and density of etch pits can be affected by the etching temperature as well [
90]. Hence, the etching temperature should be confined in a reasonable region to obtain well-defined etch pits.
The morphology of the etch pits formed on crystals can be affected by the etching temperature. On ScN crystals etched with a eutectic mixture of KOH and NaOH and then rinsed in HCl solution for 5 min, it was observed that after etching at 220 °C for 10 min, hexagonal and distorted square etch pits were observed; after etching at 230~240 °C for 10 min, octagon-shaped etch pits were observed; after etching at 330 °C for 5 min, square-shaped etch pits were apparent [
91]. On ZnO, well-defined hexagonal etch pits were observed on the oxygen terminated face after etching at 1050 °C for 4 h in air; when the etching temperature increased to 1100 °C, gutter-shaped hollows were observed; after etching at 1150 °C, a distortion of atomic terraces emerged [
92].
The etching temperature should be maintained in a reasonable region in the etching process, as under an etching temperature that is too low or too high, no etch pits could be observed. On the C-face (0001) 4H-SiC etched with chlorine trifluoride, at 573 K, no etch pit were observed, while at 623 K, 973 K, and 1073 K, etch pits were observed [
93]. On the (001) face of GaAs etched with H
2 plasma, when the etching temperature was 640 K, distinct etch pits with 20~50 nm diameters and 5~10 nm depths were observed; when the temperature reached 800 K, individual etch pits could hardly be seen [
94]. On the {100} face of a diamond etched with molten potassium for 15 min, when the etching temperature was 600 °C, only some small and shallow etch pits were observed; when the etching temperature increased to 700 °C, large and deep etch pits with <100>-oriented edges were observed; when the etching temperature reached 800 °C, the outline of the diamond crystal was dissolved due to the high etching rate [
87].
2.4. The Matrix
Etch pits preferentially initiate at sites with unevenly distributed atoms or stress. If the crystal is doped with other elements or the atom arrangement or stress distribution in the crystal is affected by factors, such as pretreatments and/or heat treatments, the morphology, distribution, or density of etch pits would be affected accordingly.
The size and shape of the etch pits and the etching rate can be affected by doping in crystals [
95]. On the {111} faces of synthetic diamond crystals, the etching rate increased as the N impurity concentration increased from 1 ppm to 200 ppm, and then the etching rate subsequently decreased. Meanwhile, the etch pits with a low N content have a convex triangle shape, while etch pits on nitrogen-doped crystals were found to be regular triangular [
96].
Some etching processes contain multiple steps, including a pretreatment process. The effect of chemical pretreatment of the Al substrate on the electrochemically etched surface of Al was investigated [
97]. The results show that a two-step pretreatment with H
3PO
4 and H
2SiF
6 led to a high density of pre-etch pits on the Al surface. During the subsequent electrochemical etching, a high density of etch pits was observed.
Etch pits can be affected by the heat treatments of the matrix. As it is well known that heat treatment can affect dislocations in the matrix, the variation in the etch pits before and after heat treatment can be related to the variation in dislocations in the matrix. The etch pit variation before and after a heat treatment of a HgCdTe matrix was investigated [
98]. After annealing for 4 cycles at 494 °C, there was a nonuniform reduction in the dislocation density identified by etch pit observation; meanwhile, the fish-shaped etch pits were completely absent.
2.5. Electrochemical Parameters
Etch pits can also be obtained by electrochemical etching; hence, electrochemical parameters also affect the etch pits on crystals. Anodic etching was carried out to obtain etch pits on GaN films [
99]. When the electrolysis voltage was 50 V and 30 V, the surface was over-etched; when the voltage was 20 V, the etch pits were observed; when the voltage was 10 V, the etch pits could also be observed, but the density was lower. An Al substrate was etched in a HCl-H
2SO
4 solution with different current profiles including the direct current, anodic pulse, and square wave, only square waves produced cubic etch pits [
100].
2.6. The Atmosphere
As the formation of etch pits is determined by the dissolution or chemical reactions of the surface atoms of crystals and the dissolution and chemical reactions can be affected by the chemical environment; hence, etch pits can also be affected by the chemical environment, including the atmosphere. Many gases are effective etchants to obtain etch pits on crystals.
Atomic hydrogen was utilized to etch epitaxial diamond (111) films [
101]. After exposure to atomic hydrogen for 12 min at 500 °C, square pits with (111)-oriented facets were observed. After exposure to oxygen at 1 × 10
−3 Torr for 1 min at room temperature and then exposure to atomic hydrogen at 500 °C for 5 min again, new etch pits were formed, and these new pits were inferred to be related to oxidation.
After exposure to ambient humidity, etch pits formed on potassium dihydrogen phosphate crystals with porous coatings [
102]. The shapes of the etch pits were regular. At 10% RH, the etch pits were 0.5~1 μm in length; at 55% RH, the average length of the etch pits was 3.5 ± 0.5 μm; at 75% RH, the etch pits grew to 20 μm. When the RH increased from 10% to 75%, the etch pit density decreased by two orders of magnitude.
2.7. Other Factors
There are other factors that can affect the formation of etch pits on crystals, such as catalysts [
103], magnetic fields [
104], and illumination [
105]. Catalysts can affect chemical reactions on the surface of crystals. The magnetic field can act on the ions in the liquid in the etch pit and affect the transport of reactants and products of chemical reactions. In the n-type material, light could not only speed up the reaction rate but also reveal the defects as crystallographic defects are effective sites for the recombination of photogenerated carriers [
105].
A highly {110}-oriented diamond coating was etched with hydrogen gas with Fe, Co, Ni and Pt nanoparticles as catalysts [
103]. The metal atoms were vacuum-evaporated onto the diamond coating and formed nanoparticles by themselves at an elevated temperature. The samples were kept in a flowing gas mixed with H
2 (10%) and N
2 (90%) between 700 °C and 1000 °C for a specific duration. Co was preferred by the etching process carried out at 800 °C for 2 h, as dense etch pits were observed. When Pt was utilized as the catalyst, it was difficult to identify the etch pits after etching at 900 °C.
3. Applications of Etch Pit Technology
In the beginning of the 19th century, etch pit technology had already been utilized to investigate crystals [
106]. It is well known that the properties of a crystal and/or a multi-crystalline substrate are closely related to the intrinsic defects in the crystal and/or the multi-crystalline substrate. For example, the dislocation slip and the deformation twinning are the most common deformation mechanisms in coarse-grained materials. Dislocations can nucleate and slip under stress to accommodate the applied plastic deformation, while dislocation entanglement and accumulation will consequently lead to strain hardening [
107]. As defects can be revealed by etch pits, it is meaningful to utilize etch pits to evaluate and even improve some key properties of the matrix, as shown in
Figure 5.
Figure 5. Schematic diagram of the relationship of etch pits, defects, and properties.
3.1. Investigation of Dislocations
Due to the relationship between dislocations and etch pits, etch pit observation is frequently employed to characterize, evaluate, and count dislocations in crystals [
18,
31]. In the middle of the 20th century, researchers had already revealed dislocations with etch pits deliberately [
108].
The distribution of dislocations can be revealed by etch pits [
109,
110]. Polishing and etching could be carried out several times to trace the dislocation lines at different depths in an identical specimen [
111]. As a relatively larger area can be etched with etchants, the distribution of dislocations can be identified in a relatively macroscopic manner [
112] compared to those revealed by transmission electron microscope.
Etch pit observation can be utilized to investigate an individual dislocation or compare dislocations in different substrates. On the (111) face of CdZnTe, the orientations of dislocations related to the triangular etch pits were determined by measuring the depths of the etch pits, the orientations of the etch pit tips, and the side lengths of the triangular etch pits [
113]. The density of non-basal dislocations on the (001) face of anthracene was found to be larger in an annealed crystal than in an unannealed crystal [
114].
3.2. Reduction of Dislocations
As etch pits have already revealed many emergences of dislocations, in the following growth process of a new crystal upon a pre-etched crystal, it is important to confine the extension of the as-revealed dislocations, so that a low dislocation density crystal can be obtained.
Pits can be utilized to reduce the dislocation density in a newly formed crystal; as in the growing process of crystals on pits, dislocations tend to merge [
115]. A recess-patterned sapphire substrate and a protruding sapphire substrate were prepared utilizing a SiO
2 mask [
116], and the recess-patterned sapphire substrate was proven to be better since the density of dislocations was relatively smaller, as shown in
Figure 6.
Figure 6. Reduction in dislocations by pits (
a) and the combination of pits and an oxide mask (
b) [
116]. Reproduced with permission from Elsevier.
Then, as a typical kind of pit, etch pits were utilized directly to reduce dislocations [
117]. On a GaN substrate with several large and deep etch pits, a new bulk GaN with low dislocation density was obtained by hydride vapor phase epitaxy [
118]. A Ge film with a threading dislocation density of 2.6 × 10
8 cm
−2 was etched to produce etch pits, and then a 15 nm thick SiO
2 film was utilized to cover the etch pits. The subsequent growth resulted in a Ge epilayer with a threading dislocation density of 1.7 × 10
6 cm
−2 [
119].
3.3. Count of Precipitates
The areal defect densities caused by the precipitates on the surface of CdZnTe could be measured by etch pit observation [
120]. Etch pits caused by the Te-rich precipitate and Cd-rich precipitate were different. The former etch pits were crater-like, and the latter etch pits were always enwrapped by many other etch pits. The areal densities obtained by etch pit observation were consistent with those obtained by IR transmission microscopy, while the etch pit observation method saves time, and only one side of the specimen needs to be polished.
3.4. Polytype Identification
Polytypes of SiC could be identified by etch pit observation [
121]. SiC crystals with perfect hexagonal etch pits were 6H-SiC along the (0001) direction, and the SiC crystals with three long-edge and three short-edge hexagonal etch pits were 15R-SiC along the (0001) direction. This relationship was verified by the Raman spectra.
3.5. Polarity Detemination
The polarity of InN can be identified by etch pit observation [
122]. After etching with KOH, hexagonal pyramids surrounded by {10
1¯1¯} facets were observed on the N-polar surface, while hexagonal and dot-shaped etch pits were observed on the In-polar surface. Meanwhile, the dislocation density identified by the etch pit density on the In-polar surface almost corresponded to the threading dislocation density determined by transmission electron microscopy.
3.6. Detection of Leakage Current
The relationship between crystal defects and leakage current can be determined via etch pit observation. On β-Ga
2O
3 Schottky barrier diodes, dislocations and voids were revealed by etch pits after etching, and a comparison between the leakage current and the crystal defects indicated that dislocations along [010] acted as paths for the leakage current [
123]. In a GaN-based light-emitting device, the origin of the leakage current was also investigated by etch pit observation, and the leakage current was attributed to open core dislocations [
124].
4. Trends Related to Etch Pit Technology
4.1. Characterization of Etch Pits
Usually, etch pits are characterized by an optical microscope, a scanning electron microscope, or an atomic force microscope, and these etch pits are usually analyzed by manually interpreting the photographs of etch pits. To improve the efficiency of the interpretation process, new methods have been developed.
The etch pit density can be counted and/or analyzed utilizing a software [
125]. Kanik Palodhi et al. [
126] utilized an image processing technique based on convolution to analyze etch pits on nuclear track detectors, and this approach substantially sped up the task of track identification and analysis. M. Wzorek et al. [
127] proposed a method that implements a shape-from-shading method to estimate the depths of etch pits by analyzing the image brightness dependence on the slopes of etch pits, and the depth distribution revealed etch pits attributed to different kinds of dislocations in a GaN substrate. The ratio of different kinds of dislocations estimated by this method is comparable to that obtained by transmission electron microscopy.
Furthermore, a dissolution process can be measured by the phase shifting interferometry (PSI) approach. A.E.S. Van Driessche et al. utilized a white beam PSI [
128] to characterize the variation in the morphology of etch pits on a gypsum crystal [
129].
As the size, morphology, and density of etch pits vary with etching time, it is important to characterize the etch pits in-situ to further understand the growth process of the etch pits. Fuminobu Sato et al. [
130] recorded time-lapse images of etch pits formed on a nuclear track detector by an in-situ observation system, and then the pit evolution images were constructed by digital image processing of the time-lapse images.
4.2. Simulation of Disolution
As it is difficult to characterize the initiation and expansion of an etch pit in-situ on the atomic scale, it is critical to simulate these processes for a deeper understanding. Inna Kurganskaya et al. [
131] utilized a stochastic Kinetic Monte Carlo approach to describe the dissolution of phyllosilicates and predicted the surface evolution from the kinetics of elementary surface reactions and found that the dissolution of minerals proceeds via the formation of etch pits at opened screw dislocation cores through movement and coalescence of step waves. Konstanze Stübner et al. [
132] simulated the evolution of etch pits with an atomistic Monte Carlo simulation, and the results suggested that there are four stages in the evolution of etch pits on the (001) surface of an idealized regular lattice. During the first stage, an etch pit was an inverted pyramid. Then, the pyramid apex was truncated in the second stage. During the third stage, an etch pit consisted of a single concave up bottom plane. During the fourth stage, it was inferred that the etch pits would shrink until they disappeared altogether.
4.3. Etching on Macro Patterns
Usually, to statistically obtain the distribution of etch pits or other defects on an exposed surface, a sufficiently large surface area should be etched. It is also possible to etch partial areas or patterned areas of an exposed surface of a crystal for some purposes. Sachiko Ono et al. [
133] utilized a honeycomb Al
2O
3 mask to directly control the initial sites of etch pits; hence, the distribution, density, and homogeneity of the etch pits were adjusted. Dmitri A Brevnov et al. [
134] utilized Al
2O
3 as the etching mask and carried out electrochemical etching on Al (100) foils. Then, crystallographic cubic etch pits were observed at the unmasked area, and the Al substrate was preserved at the masked region.
4.4. Self-Assemble of Particles at Etch Pits
An etch pit could be a container for other materials. Because of the regular shape of etch pits, extrinsic substances could gather at positions preferentially in the etch pits. Hung-Ming Chen et al. [
135] investigated the effect of etch pits on the alignment of Ge dots grown on a pit-patterned Si (001) substrate. When the spacing between the etch pits was less than 100 nm and the depth of the etch pits was greater than 60 nm, the topology and the surface chemical distribution were favored by Ge dots to nucleate inside the pits and completely align with each other.
4.5. Crystal Growth at Etch Pits
A dislocation can be revealed by an etch pit, and the as-revealed dislocation is a shortcut for some kinds of atoms to transport. The aggregation of the transported atoms in the etch pits can result in a new crystal. Che-Ming Liu et al. [
136] pointed out that etch pits are preferred sites for crystal growth. One side of a sapphire crystal was etched with Na
2B
4O
7, and etch pits were obtained. Then, a Mg film was deposited on the unpolished surface. After heating and aging of the specimen, precipitation crystals were found at the etch pits of the sapphire as shown in
Figure 7. These newly formed crystals are Mg-Al spinel microcrystals.
Figure 7. Schematic diagram of the fabrication process (
a) and the as-fabricated spinels (
b) [
136]. Reproduced with permission from AIP Publishing.