Over the last two decades, amino acids and peptides have been harnessed to control the solubility, optical properties and/or self-assembly of PDI derivatives by taking advantage of highly directional hydrogen-bonding interactions as well as other non-covalent interactions such as ionic and π−π interactions [
39]. In addition, polypeptides are known for their biocompatibility, biodegradability and molecular specificity [
40], ultimately supporting the use of peptide-based PDI assemblies for different biomedical applications. Chemically, peptides can be considered as linear polymers/oligomers assembled from the condensation of amino acid building blocks [
41]. The 20 natural amino acids, as well as countless unnatural amino acids, allow virtually infinite combinations of sequences and offer an unlimited diversity of physicochemical and structural properties of the resulting polypeptide chains [
42]. Herein, we present relevant examples of the use of amino acids and short peptide sequences to modulate the self-assembly of PDI derivatives into tailored nanostructures. The self-assembly of PDI–peptide conjugates and the resulting supramolecular morphologies are modulated by a fine balance of complex intermolecular interactions, such as PDI’s π–π stacking interactions and numerous non-covalent interactions involving side chains and the polyamide backbone, as well as by the conditions of the microenvironment, including solvent polarity, solution ionic strength, pH, and temperature [
9,
11,
39].
3.2. Sequence-Dependent Self-Assembly
Specific variations within peptide sequences have been used to control the self-assembly process of PDI conjugates and to modulate the morphology of the resulting nanostructures through a delicate balance of non-covalent interactions (hydrogen bonding, hydrophobicity, ionic bonding) involving specific residue side chains. Short dipeptides GX (where X = D or Y) were used to enhance the solubility and to modulate the self-assembly properties of PDI in polar organic solvents and aqueous solution [
47]. It was observed that, by varying the X residue of the PDI–[GX]
2 bola-amphiphile conjugates from hydrophobic Tyr to hydrophilic Asp, the balance between hydrogen bonding and π–π stacking interactions were altered, ultimately affecting the morphology of the assemblies and their optical properties. For instance, in aqueous sodium bicarbonate buffer (pH 10.8), dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), dimethylformamide (DMF), tetrahydrofuran (THF), or acetone, the symmetric PDI–[GY]
2 formed chiral nanofibers, whereas PDI–[GD]
2 assembled into achiral spherical aggregates in buffer and DMSO. In addition, PDI–[GY]
2 formed a gel in DMF, while organogels were observed for the PDI–[GD]
2 derivative in this polar aprotic solvent. An exhaustive study of structure-assembly relationships revealed how peptide’s physicochemical properties and length, asymmetric substitution at the
imide positions, and stereocenter inversion can affect the thermodynamics of the self-assembly of peptide–PDI hybrid molecules [
39]. A set of peptide–PDI conjugates were synthetized, all encompassing three units: (i) a glycine residue at the
N-terminal position used as a low-steric hindrance linker; (ii) a central variable region composed of three L or D amino acids to evaluate the impact of increasing the peptide hydrophobicity and the role of stereocenters; and (iii) a
C-terminal charged region composed of one to three Glu residues to enhance the hydrosolubility and examine the effect of the charge density on the assembly process (
Figure 2) [
39]. Moreover, to induce a strong amphiphilic character, one of the peptide sequences was replaced by a hydrophobic hexyl chain. It was observed that peptide hydrophobicity and an asymmetrical hexyl substitution induce significant changes on the aggregation thermodynamics of the bioconjugates (
Figure 2a,b). In contrast, varying the peptide length, the
C-terminal charged region length or the stereocenter inversion induced a significantly lower impact on the aggregation thermodynamics, while having an effect on the peptide-driven self-assembly of PDI nanofibers [
39]. Overall, these studies revealed that the physicochemical properties of the residue side chains, the configuration of stereocenters, and the symmetric/asymmetric conjugation can be exploited to dictate the non-covalent interactions that drive the self-assembly of peptide-conjugated PDIs and the final morphology of the assemblies.
Figure 2. Structure of the peptide–PDI conjugates and impact of structural modulation on the aggregation thermodynamics. The histogram shows (
a) the deviation between the lowest and the highest values for each parameter, and (
b) the standard deviation as a more collective measure of variability [
39]. Copyright © 2014 American Chemical Society.
Inspired by the β-continuous interface of the bovine peroxiredoxin-3 protein, a short heptapeptide (IKHLSVN) was conjugated to PDI in order to control self-assembly into organic semiconductor nanostructures [
48]. The designed self-assembling peptide encompassed three different regions: (i) a glycine or ethylamino linker attached to an
imide position of the PDI to reduce steric hindrance between the PDI core and the peptide sequence, (ii) a β-sheet-forming peptide, and (iii) a terminal unit composed of glutamic acid residues to assist solubility and to trigger the assembly of peptide–PDI conjugates by pH jump. Two groups of peptide–PDI derivatives were prepared. The first group results from the symmetrical substitution of PDI with peptide sequences, whereas for the second group the PDI core was replaced with perylene
imide bis-ester to generate asymmetrical derivatives. Furthermore, for one derivative of each group, the peptide core was attached to the PDI via the amino terminus using a glycine linker, while for the other derivative the peptide core was attached via the carboxyl terminus using an ethylamino linker. The symmetrically substituted PDI showed spectral profiles characteristic of monomers in DMSO. However, UV-visible spectral profiles of bis-ester-functionalized PDI displayed some aggregation, with predominantly monomeric species. In aqueous media, these peptide–PDI conjugates self-assembled into H-aggregate suprastuctures. Particularly, all peptide–PDI derivatives self-assembled into extensive fibril networks in aqueous solution, except for the bis-ester-functionalized PDI for which the peptide was attached via the
C-terminal position. This compound formed amorphous, plate-like accretions. Furthermore, reversing the peptide sequence, i.e.,
N- to
C-, for the symmetric derivatives led to the formation of short fibrils and thread-like assemblies instead of ribbon-like structures. This observation highlights the importance of the attachment mode of peptide to the PDI core towards self-assembly and final morphology of the assemblies.
Similarly, the
N-(tetra (
L-alanine) glycine)-
N′-(1-undecyldodecyl) functionalized perylene-3,4,9,10-tetracarboxyl diimide was designed as an asymmetric amphiphilic derivative in order to elucidate how molecular-scale interactions govern the overall self-assembly process [
49]. The oligopeptide block on one of the
imide nodes of the PDI core provided aggregation directionality through hydrogen bonding and π−π stacking interactions. In chloroform, which was chosen to strengthen inter-peptide hydrogen bonds, this asymmetric amphiphilic PDI derivative adopted a right-handed helical arrangement due to the delicate balance between π–π stacking involving PDI cores and the network of hydrogen bonds between β-sheet-forming peptides. Interestingly, the addition of trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) to the self-assembling media, which was used as a hydrogen-bonding breaking agent, induced the transition of the nanofibers into small aggregates. These aggregates could be brought back into nanofibers by the addition of triethylamine (TEA), which was used to neutralize TFA, favoring the formation of H-bonding between the peptide blocks [
49].
Computational simulation and experimental studies have been combined to understand the relationships between the sequence and the self-assembly process of π-conjugated peptides to ultimately predict the resulting supramolecular organisations and photophysical properties from the peptide sequence. For instance, it was shown that increasing the hydrophobicity of the closest residue attached to the PDI core can modulate the photophysical responses in aqueous solution via the conversion of J aggregates, or liquid-crystalline-type materials, to H-type aggregates [
50]. In addition, the relationships between the resulting morphologies and the molecular structure of a small library of peptide–PDI derivatives bearing a variable number of
L-alanine units as well as methylene, ethylene, and propylene spacers were investigated [
51]. It was revealed that the number of
L-alanine units in the β-strand peptide segments and the length of the spacer affected the morphology of the resulting suprastructures. In addition, it was shown, through molecular dynamic simulations, that there is a complex interplay between the translation of molecular chirality into supramolecular helicity and the inherent propensity for well-defined one-dimensional aggregation into β-sheet-like superstructures in the presence of a central chromophore [
51]. Finally, a symmetric PDI–tripeptide conjugate, which was obtained by introducing a KPA tripeptide block at the 1 and 7
bay positions of PDI via a 2-(2-aminoethoxy)-ethoxyl linker, self-assembled into β-sheet nanohelices directed by hydrogen-bonding [
52].These resulting supramolecular structures were particularly sensitive to thermal and ultrasound stimuli. For instance, upon heating/cooling and sonication of the peptide–PDI sample, an interconversion of the supramolecular chirality between left- and right-handed nanostructures was observed [
52].
Except for glycine, which is achiral, α-amino acids have an S configuration and are designated as
L using the Fischer configurational system [
42]. It has been reported that the presence of chiral proximal residues in close proximity to the achiral PDI, for symmetrical peptide–PDI derivatives, influences π–π stacking interactions and induces helical chirality to the PDI core. However, when chiral residues were located distant to the PDI core, or when an isolated stereocenter was introduced in proximal distance of PDI, no effect of chirality was observed during self-assembly [
53]. The designed peptide sequences with stereogenic positions and stereochemical configurations included three blocks: (i) an achiral glycine used as a spacer between PDI and the peptide, (ii) three variable residues forming the central block, and (iii) a terminal block of three ionizable glutamic acid residues to assist solubility and pH-triggered aggregation. It was observed that the self-assembly process is modulated by the β-sheet-forming potential of the peptide moieties and the π–π stacking interactions of PDI units. Interestingly, an inversion of the stereocenter within the proximal residues revealed chiral influence. In contrast, an asymmetrical peptide–PDI derivative obtained by the introduction of an alkyl chain at one of the amide nodes, generated an amphiphilic PDI conjugate and disrupted the chiral-mediated self-assembly [
53].
Besides, it was observed that the symmetrical conjugation of FF dipeptide to the PDI core leads to a helical assembly due to the chirality of amino acids as well as the co-facial π–π stacking of PDI units [
54]. Furthermore, it was shown that there is a close relationship between the translation of molecular chirality into supramolecular helicity and the one-dimensional assembly into well-defined β-sheet-like suprastructures [
51]. Overall, these structure–assembly relationship studies have indicated that the morphology of the resulting peptide-conjugated PDI nanostructures can be, to some extent, controlled by modulating the peptide sequence. Moreover, the stereocenters embedded in the peptide backbone can be exploited, under specific conditions, to induce a chiral morphology to the resulting assemblies.
3.3. Solvent-Dependent Self-Assembly
As described above, several substituted water-soluble PDIs have been obtained by functionalizing the PDI core at their
imide positions with amino acids and short peptides. Not only do the physicochemical properties of the conjugated moieties dictate the self-assembly behaviour of the PDI core as well as the morphology of the final aggregates, but the solvent also strongly influences the thermodynamics and kinetics of self-assembly [
54,
55,
56]. It is generally assumed that the aggregation constant of PDI derivatives decreases with increasing solvent polarity [
57]. The photophysical and aggregation propensities of PDI–[X]
2 symmetrical derivatives, where X is a residue with an aromatic group (Y, W or F), were evaluated in various organic solvents [
58]. This study revealed that all derivatives self-assemble into amorphous aggregates, excepted for PDI–[Y]
2 that forms
J-type aggregates in methanol. Although it is still unclear why this effect manifested only in methanol, the authors suggested that the formation of J-aggregates may be possible due to the network of hydrogen bonds involving the hydroxyl groups of tyrosine residues and the carbonyl groups of the PDI core. In pyridine and acetone, PDI–[F]
2 and PDI–[Y]
2 showed a higher propensity to aggregate than PDI–[W]
2, however, the origin of this tendency was unclear. Furthermore, the NMR data indicated a large degree of aggregation in DMSO for all three PDI–peptide derivatives, although the absorption and the fluorescence spectra were both characteristics of soluble and monomeric PDIs [
58]. In another study, it was reported that the relatively polar nature of chloroform, in contrast to THF and DMF, facilitates the formation of intermolecular H-bonding of PDI–[F]
2, which ultimately leads to
J-aggregates [
59]. In chloroform, PDI-[F]
2 assembled into vesicular suprastructures through the formation of right-handed helix, involving intermolecular H-bonding in lateral and π–π stacking in longitudinal growth directions. As shown in
Figure 3, the increase in solvent polarity correlated well with a decrease in the diameter of the vesicles assembled from the PDI–[F]
2.
Figure 3. Transmission electron microscopy images of PDI-[F]
2 assembled in (
a) CHCl
3, (
b) THF and (
c) DMF [
59]. Copyright © 2018 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim.