Figure 2. Side and top views of Spike trimer with site-specific glycosylation shown (moss surface) from molecular dynamics simulations
[23]. The glycans are shown in ball-and-stick representation in green, dark yellow, orange and pink. The protein surface is colored according to antibody accessibility from black (least) to red (most accessible). One RBD is shown in the open conformation (circled in blue). Images are from
[23] and are used under Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License:
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/, accessed on 1 March 2022.
Since the original identification of SARS-CoV2, a number of variant forms have evolved and spread. Each of the variants show mutations in the Spike protein that have been linked to altered virulence and/or transmissibility. The Alpha (B.1.1.7), Beta (B.1.351) and Gamma (P.1) variants all carry an N501Y mutation within the RBM that has been demonstrated to increase the binding affinity to ACE2 by 3- to 7-fold, depending on the presence of additional mutations
[27][28][29]. The recent emergence of the highly contagious Delta (B.1.1.617.2) and Omicron (B.1.1.529) variants reveal a number of additional important mutations in Spike
[30]. The Delta variant has two mutations in its RBM, L452R and T478K, and in some instances has additional mutations K417N and E484K. The Omicron variant Spike protein, in contrast, carries as many as 30 point mutations, three deletions and one insertion. Strikingly, it has 15 mutations within its RBD with 10 tightly clustered within the RBM, namely N440K, G446S, S477N, T478K, E484A, Q493K, G496S, Q498R, N501Y and Y505H (
Figure 3). It is interesting to note that these 10 mutations result in a significant change in the charged nature of the RBM with the substitution of four non-charged residues (N, T, and 2Qs) with positively charged residues (R and 3Ks), the loss or one negatively charged residue (E) and the addition of one histidine which can carry a positive charge depending on its local environment. A systematic analysis of each single Omicron mutation on ACE2 binding revealed that nine of the RBD mutations would be expected to decrease binding affinity while the other six should increase affinity
[31]. Indeed, a comparative analysis of WT, Delta and Omicron revealed that the Delta Spike binds with higher affinity compared to WT and Omicron. Interestingly, the Omicron Spike does not show increased affinity for ACE2 compared to WT Spike
[31]. Hence, it appears that the binding affinity for ACE2 is not the sole determinant of the effectiveness of Spike protein that dictates the enhanced transmission of SARS-CoV2 variants.
3. Heparan Sulfate Proteoglycans (HSPGs) and Spike Interactions
HSPGs are a class of macromolecules expressed on cell surfaces and within the extracellular matrix of nearly all mammalian cells and tissues
[32][33][34]. HSPGs are characterized by a core protein with covalently attached heparan sulfate (HS) chains. HS is a class of negatively charged linear polysaccharides characterized by repeating disaccharide units of alternating
N-substituted glucosamine and hexuronic acid residues subject to selective modification including sulfation of the
N-position as well as the
C-6 and
C-3 O-positions of the glucosamine and the
C-2 O-position of the uronic acid. Thus, the 32 (or more) potential unique disaccharide units and their grouping into structural motifs make this class of compounds one of the most information-dense in biology, providing a wide-array of protein-binding sites
[35][36][37]. As such, HSPGs have been shown to serve as co-receptors to assist growth factor binding to its tyrosine kinase receptors
[38][39][40], and have also been demonstrated to provide attachment and entry sites for a number of viruses
[41][42]. The high density of HSPG expression on cell surfaces combined with the large flexible HS chains are features that make this class of molecule ideal as initial attachment sites. Consequently, proteins and viruses can use HSPG to scan large regions of the cell surface to increase the probability of encountering lower density specific receptors. Moreover, as has been well characterized for heparin-binding growth factors, the presence of distinct HS and receptor binding sites on proteins allow HS to contribute to the formation of high-affinity ternary complexes that enhance ligand-receptor binding and signaling
[39][40].
Additionally, the SARS-CoV2 Spike protein has been shown to bind HS and heparin (a highly sulfated form of HS expressed by mast cells), which is thought to be reflective of Spike-HS interactions on the cell surface that promote virus entry
[43][44][45][46][47]. Indeed, removal of cell surface HS with heparinase has been shown to reduce SARS-CoV2 infection in cell culture models
[43][45]. Spike has also been shown to bind to ACE2 and heparin independently in vitro such that a ternary complex can be generated involving all three molecules
[44]. Computational docking and molecular dynamics simulations have identified a putative heparin/HS binding domain on Spike, a long positively charged patch that overlaps the S1/S2 junction and extends throughout the RBD
[44][48]. Electron microscopic analysis indicates that heparin enhances the open conformation of the RBD suggesting a model whereby Spike binding to HS facilitates Spike-ACE2 interactions through a variety of mechanisms
[44]. These findings, combined with the clinical observations that COVID-19 patients treated with heparin show improved outcomes
[49][50], have led to a number of studies aimed at targeting Spike-HS interactions as a means of blocking SARS-CoV2 infection
[51]. Most of these approaches are based on a model whereby soluble and/or extracellular heparin will bind to Spike protein and competitively inhibit binding to HS on the cell surface
[47]. As such, there are more than 100 active clinical trials in the US exploring the use of heparin to treat COVID-19, including trials that are evaluating the delivery of heparin via nasal sprays or nebulizers to protect susceptible tissues against SARS-CoV2 infection (see:
https://www.clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/results?cond=COVID-19&term=heparin&cntry=&state=&city=&dist=, accessed on 1 March 2022).
The presence of HS generally presents protein-binding sites in the range of 10
6–10
7 per cell such that an initial collision of SARS-CoV2 with a cell might now be predicted to lead to hundreds to thousands of virus encounters with HS binding sites. Moreover, the binding of proteins to HS often show very fast kinetics such that proteins can bind, release, and rebind extensively, preventing their release from the cell surface
[52][53]. This rapid binding mechanism provides a means for a protein, or a bound virus particle, to scan a large area of the cell surface to increase the chance of encountering and binding to lower density receptors. Thus, a SARS-CoV2 collision with the cell surface might be expected to result in Spike-HS interactions that ultimately facilitate the formation of stable HS-Spike-ACE2 complexes (
Figure 4). Considering this HS co-receptor mechanism, the expression level and binding affinity of ACE2 on the cell surface might not be the key factors that limit SARS-CoV2 infection. Instead, the ability of Spike to interact with HS, or its susceptibility to proteolytic cleavage by TMPRSS2 might be the rate-determining factors.
Figure 4. HSPG-mediated Binding of Spike Leads to Increased Binding to ACE2. The initial collision of SARS-CoV2 with the cell surface is likely to result in encounters with high-density and large volume HS chains. Binding of Spike (S) to HS can result in binding, release and re-binding to adjacent HS chains allowing for viral particle movement from one HS chain to another until Spike engages ACE2 (A). Spike-ACE2 interactions are stabilized by the combined binding of HS within a ternary complex.
In addition to HS, there are several reports indicating that Spike binds to other potential co-receptors such as neuropilin 1 and extracellular matrix metalloproteinase inducer (EMMPRIN, also known as basigin and CD147)
[54][55][56]. Neuropilin 1 is a transmembrane glycoprotein that function as a co-receptor for semaphorins and vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) family members to regulate neurogenesis and angiogenesis
[57]. Furthermore, neuropilin 1 has been demonstrated to collaborate with HS to form high affinity multimeric complexes with VEGF and its receptors
[58]. Recently, neuropilin 1 was found to potentiate SARS-CoV2 infectivity using HEK-293T cells transiently expressing ACE2, TMPRSS2 and neuropilin 1. Furthermore, an analysis of human COVID-19 autopsies revealed that SARS-CoV2 infected neuropilin 1 positive cells in the nasal cavity
[59].
EMMPRIN is an integral plasma membrane glycoprotein that is enriched on the surface of tumor cells where it stimulates the production of several matrix metalloproteinases by adjacent stromal cells
[60][61]. EMMPRIN has also been implicated in oral cancers and inflammatory disorders, suggesting a connection to sites of SARS-CoV2 infection. Blocking EMMPRIN with antibodies or through knockdown in Vero E6 cells has been shown to inhibit SARS-CoV2 amplification while the expression of EMMPRIN in non-susceptible BHK-21 cells allows virus entry
[56]. In addition, transgenic mice expressing human EMMPRIN showed high viral loads in the lungs, while wild-type mice did not. However, there remains some debate over whether direct Spike interactions with EMMPRIN are responsible for the observed enhanced SARS-CoV2 cell entry
[62][63]. Nevertheless, the characterization of secondary Spike binding sites, in addition to ACE2, is revealing a broad range of mechanisms that Spike might employ to mediate SARS-CoV2 infection of cells.
The evidence that HS, neuropilin-1 and EMMPRIN are critical mediators of SARS-CoV2 infectivity via the ability to bind Spike and, in the case of HS, by stabilizing Spike-ACE2 interactions, necessitates that the models presented in Figure 1 and Figure 4 be expanded to capture the full nature of the viral-cell interaction process.
4. Conclusions
Mutations in the Spike protein of SARS-CoV2 have been attributed to the evolution of highly transmissible variants that have led to waves of increased COVID-19 cases, hospitalizations and deaths. Each additional infection provides opportunity for additional mutations in Spike and other viral proteins that may lead to new variants that could elude vaccine-induced or natural immunity. Herein has identified elements of Spike protein functions and additional relevant interactions that contribute to the ability of the virus to gain entry into target cells. The answer to the question of how much better (or worse in terms of causing human disease) Spike can become remains open, yet it is important to recognize that there is a limit. The concepts presented here may help guide studies to identify the aspects of viral infection that are subject to evolutionary improvement. Future viral pandemics are inevitable. Thus, it is critical that the scientific, public health and medical communities work together to foresee what evolution may have in store so that effective vaccines and therapies will be ready.