The epithelial cells and the submucosal glands, which form an integral part of the innate immune system, secrete many host-defense proteins, including lysozymes, lactoferrin, lipocalin-2, defensins, cathelicidin, surfactant proteins, acute-phase proteins, psoriasin (S100A7) proteins, and palate, lung, and nasal epithelium clone (PLUNC) proteins
[14]. The lung epithelial cells act as immune sentinels, and this sets up an innate immune response owing to an ample repertoire of cytosolic, membrane-bound, and endosomal pattern-recognition receptors (PRRs) to identify various pathogens
[15].
1.4. Physiological Barrier in Airway
The airway defense responses that guard the lungs and the rest of the body against inhaled irritants like cigarette smoke and aerosols include bronchoconstriction, which is a crucial and effective reflex mechanism
[16]. However, the chemical irritants stimulate the sensory nerves present in the respiratory tract, and the generated action potential is conducted by the vagus nerves (to the brain stem). This instantly causes bronchoconstriction via the cholinergic efferent pathway accompanied by the hypersecretion of mucus, coughing, and dyspneic sensations
[17]. Thereof, the conjecture that bronchoconstriction is a physiological protective mechanism, becomes a clinical symptom as this also confines the entry of the air and, thus, difficulty in breathing occurs subsequent to the bronchoconstriction.
1.5. Special Cellular Machinery in Airway Epithelial Barrier
Surprisingly, airway epithelial layers also have special machinery, like pulmonary neuroendocrine cells (PNECs), that produce an array of neuropeptides, neurotransmitters, and amines to sense the environmental air and catabolize the irritants/toxicants of the air to neutralize them
[18][19]. Therefore, these cells are considered intrapulmonary sensors that also sense hypoxia by chemoreception
[20]. Indeed, like the traditional chemoreceptors present in the nose, the PNEC clusters that are part of the epithelial layer have been shown to have olfactory receptors so that they can sense the toxicants in the inspired air and react to prevent the further entry of such toxicants through induction of bronchoconstriction
[21].
1.6. Barrier Function of Airway Epithelium against Air Pollutants and Pathogens
Air pollutants are typically categorized as ultrafine, fine, and coarse, depending on their size, source, and nature (gases or particles). The main sources of indoor air pollution include stoves, biological substances (including mold), microplastics, and household dust, whereas automobile, industrial (urban), and agricultural (rural) activity are the major reason for outdoor pollution
[22]. Airborne particulate matter (PM) is a heterogeneous mixture of solids and aerosols, which can include heavy metals, airborne dust, and nanoparticles discharged from chemical factories, wildfire smoke, vehicle exhaust, and volcanic eruptions. Urban homes have PM
2.5- and PM
10-rich indoor pollutants along with higher NO
2 levels
[23]. Since fine PM penetrates the narrow airways more deeply than coarse PM, it is particularly dangerous to breathe it in. Inhalation of fine particulates has been linked to the development of asthma and COPD. A correlation has been put forward between increased levels of outdoor pollution, particularly NO
2, PM
2.5, and black carbon, and the onset and development of childhood asthma along with lowered lung function
[24].
In addition to pollutants and allergens, pathogens also have a major role in disrupting the epithelial barrier. Adivitiya et al. have shown the impact Sars Cov2 has on mucociliary clearance through protein network analysis. The spike (S) protein of the virus utilizes ACE2 (angiotensin-converting enzyme 2) and TMPRSS2 protease, which are present in the ciliated and secretory cells, to enter the host. The receptor-binding domain of S also interacts with CD209, a lectin protein found in the epithelial cell, to facilitate virus entry.
2. The Victim Role of Airway Epithelium in Asthma Pathogenesis
2.1. Role of Th2 Cytokines in Airway Epithelial Barrier Dysfunction
It is generally believed that T helper 2 lymphocytes play a crucial role in asthma development after the initial sensitization phase (with allergen exposure). Upon repeated secondary exposures to the same allergen, Th2 cells accumulate in the lungs, and the features of allergic asthma develop. This is popularly referred to as type2/Th2 asthma, whereby such Th2 cells release various cytokines, like IL-4, IL-5, and IL-13, in response to allergens
[25].
(a) IL-4 and IL-13: Both IL4 and IL-13 are crucial Th2 cytokines responsible for immunoglobulin class switching to enhance IgE production
[26], leading to the degranulation of mast cells and basophils. The released proinflammatory meditators not only caused bronchoconstriction, but also cause airway epithelial injury. Treatment with both IL-4 and IL-13 cytokines showed reduced expression in the apical junctional complex proteins that encompass both the tight junction and adherent junction
[27]. Treatment with IL-4 in HBEC (human bronchial epithelial cells) increases permeability in epithelial cells. There is reduced transepithelial electrical resistance that, in turn, leads to increased allergen sensitization and allergen uptake. IL-4 and IL-13 also cause a reduction in the ciliary beating of the ciliated epithelial cells and, in turn, in mucociliary clearance
[28]. IL-13 also plays a major role in the secretion of periostin (POSTN), which is an essential biomarker in asthma. Periostin is an extracellular protein present in the matrix. It is a downstream product of the IL-13 pathway, signifying type 2 immunity. POSTN release is then coupled with epithelial mesenchyme transition, which is also shown in vitro in Beas2B cell lines. Thus, POSTN plays a major role in airway remodeling
[29]. Overall, these cytokines are responsible for injuries to the airway epithelium. In addition to causing airway epithelial injury through oxidative stress, both IL-4 and IL-13 have been shown to cause perturbation in airway epithelial integrity with barrier dysfunction
[27][30].
(b) IL-5: IL-5 plays a crucial role in differentiation, activation, maturation, and the recruitment of eosinophil that releases major basic cationic proteins, like major basic protein-1 (MBP-1), eosinophil cationic protein (ECP), eosinophil derived neurotoxin (EDN), and eosinophil peroxidase (EPO-1), that induce oxidative stress, causing an injury to the airway epithelium
[31].
2.2. Mitochondrial Dysfunction in Asthmatic Airway Epithelium
The earlier clinical study found the presence of an increased number of mitochondria with altered structures in asthmatic children [32]. Later, a lab demonstrated the involvement of mitochondrial dysfunction in asthma pathogenesis [33]. The lab also demonstrated a reduction in the cytochrome c oxidase (COX), which is the primary enzyme of the electron transport chain (ETC) residing in mitochondria’s inner mitochondrial membrane (IMM), which transfers electrons from the cytochrome c to oxygen in the lungs of mice with allergic airway inflammation.
While it is known that both IL-4 and IL-13 promote IgE class switching through STAT-6, they also induce an enzyme: 12/15-lipoxygenase (12/15-LOX, also called 15-lipooxygenase in humans) [34]. Even though the role of 5-lipoxygenase (5-LOX) is well established in asthma pathogenesis, the detailed role of 12/15-lipoxygenase was demonstrated. 12/15-LOX is one of the enzymes responsible for cellular suicide via the programmed disappearance of mitochondria and other cellular organelles from the reticulocytes and for immature fibroblasts converting into red blood cells and mature fibroblasts, respectively [35][36][37]. This is essential for the uninterrupted functions of red blood cells and mature fibroblasts, as the presence of organelles in these cells disturbs their functions, such as effective gas exchange and clear vision, respectively. Though it was known earlier that 12/15-LOX was increased in asthmatic lungs [38][39], its role in mitochondrial dysfunction was not known. The mere overexpression of 12/15-LOX in naïve mice causes mitochondrial dysfunction, along with the development of asthma-like features, indicating the pathogenetic role of 12/15-LOX [40].
3. Governing/Immune Role of Airway Epithelium in Allergic Airway Inflammation
3.1. Less Dominant Role of Inflammation in Causing Epithelial Barrier Dysfunction
The Th2 immune response has been demonstrated as the causative factor for inciting the loss of epithelial layer integrity. However, numerous pieces of literature also suggest the possibility of inflammation-independent epithelial cell dysfunction. Numerous asthma susceptibility genes, for instance, IL33, IL1RL1, MUC5AC, TSLP, CDHR3, and KIF3A, are expressed in the airway epithelium. This highlights the significance of the airway epithelium in the development of asthma
[41]. Anomalies in the epithelial barrier due to disruptions in the tight and adherens junctions have been proclaimed to be involved in allergen sensitization and asthma advancement
[42]. All these indicate that asthmatic people might have a compromised and dysfunctional epithelial barrier. Genome-wide association studies in asthmatics have shown the association of various genes with asthma susceptibility and how these genes are also expressed in the airway epithelium
[43].
In addition to the inherent barrier defects seen in asthma patients, allergens directly affect the lung epithelial barrier, the first layer of defense in them. Allergens, such as house dust mites (HDMs), pollens, cockroach extracts, and fungi, produces or contain proteases and hence disturb the epithelial barrier, causing increased sensitization
[44]. Inhaled allergens or proteases can cause epithelial cells to recognize and react by activating a variety of PRRs, including TLR and PAR. NF-κB activation is stirred up by these activated receptor signals. This, in turn, causes transcriptional activation of myriads’ pro-inflammatory genes, including cytokines and chemokines. As the role of NOD-like receptors in allergic inflammation is complex and context-dependent
[45], the role of innate immune receptors in allergic inflammation is complex.
3.2. Less Dominant Role of Inflammation in Causing Mitochondrial Dysfunction in Airway Epithelia
Similar to epithelial barrier dysfunction, mitochondrial dysfunction in asthmatic airway epithelia can additionally be unaided by inflammation. Investigations and research have already determined the possibility of inflammation and oxidative stress-induced mitochondrial dysfunction in asthmatic airway epithelia. When there was a forced reduction in the expression of certain ETC enzymes in airway epithelium, allergic airway inflammation features got developed
[46]. This indicates the possibility of inflammation-independent mitochondrial dysfunction in asthma pathogenesis.
3.3. Airway Epithelium Induces ILC2-Mediated Type 2 Immune Response through Alarmins
So far, the conventional rationale about the airway epithelium is of a ‘victim’ that often comes under recurrent stress from the inflammatory system in asthma. Albeit, over the last decade, mounting evidence has shifted the paradigm for the role of airway epithelium towards a more upstream modulator in airway inflammation. Several PRRs, including TLR2, TLR4, NOD1
[47][48], and PAR1-4, are expressed by airway epithelial cells
[49][50]. Upon stimulation, they activate various signaling pathways that lead to the enlistment of immune cells and also the Th2 immune response
[51]. One major group of cytokines which is recognized as important in this epithelium-driven immune response is called ‘alarmins’
[52]. ‘Alarmins’, specifically thymic stromal lymphopoietin (TSLP), interleukin-33, and interleukin-25, are released by airway epithelium upon cellular stress or damage caused by an allergen, pathogen, or pollutant exposure ultimately skews the immune response toward type 2
[53][54]. The concept of alarmins was introduced by Joost J Oppenheim. He used this umbrella term to describe a group of host proteins that are released upon cell damage or pathogen challenge, which recruit and activate both innate and adaptive immunity and galvanize the whole immune response through ‘early signals’
[52]. Although airway epithelium is considered the major source of alarmins but innate, adaptive, and other structural cells can also secrete alarmins
[55] (
Figure 2).
Figure 2. Airway epithelia regulating epi-immune response upon allergen/pathogen exposure. Pathogens or allergens disrupt the airway epithelia. Disrupted epithelia releases alarmins (IL-25, IL-33, and TSLP). Alarmins activate dendritic cells for Th2 polarization of the immune response. On the other hand, alarmins can directly activate ILC2 cells to secret IL-4, IL-5, and IL-13 cytokines. The dysregulation of this pathway leads to asthma pathogenicity.
64. Conclusions
When the treatment or control of asthma was insufficient, there was a need to modify the existing concept of asthma pathogenesis. Thus, the concept of asthma pathogenesis changed periodically from a neuropsychological disease to airway inflammation. Parallel to this conceptual change, the treatment strategy also changed from “calming mind” to anti-inflammatory drugs. For a long time, it has been believed that the Th2 immune response is the main driver of the entire pathophysiological features of asthma. When asthma was considered a Th2-dominant inflammatory disease, it was believed that almost everything was solved in asthma pathogenesis. However, this Th2-dominant hypothesis could not explain the poor correlation between airway inflammation and airway remodeling, severe asthma endotypes [Th2-high (eosinophilic) and Th2-low (non-eosinophilic)], therapy resistance in a certain percentage of asthmatics, etc. This indicated a need to change the concept used in asthma pathogenesis. In this context, it was always believed that the airway epithelium was a helpless victim of the immune cells. Although this was demonstrated to be partially true, it seems this is not the entire story. In this context, the literature in the last decade has emphasized the importance of airway epithelium in asthma pathogenesis. The airway epithelium has dual roles in healthy lung homeostasis and asthmatic lungs. The airway epithelium maintains lung homeostasis against environmental irritants, with its armamentaria, including anatomical barriers, chemical barriers, chemosensory apparatus, like pulmonary neuroendocrine cells, a detoxification system for inhaled xenobiotics, etc. However, if the external allergens load is severe and beyond the capacity of the airway epithelium, with or without the inherent epithelial barrier dysfunction in asthmatics, the airway epithelium starts secreting special biomolecules called alarmins that induce the ILC2-mediated type 2 immune response. This role is pathogenetic, as these alarmins tend to amplify the inflammatory response in contrast to the earlier homeostatic role. However, the exact role of these alarmins in asthma pathogenesis is yet to be investigated. The inflammatory mediators released from Th2 cells induce oxidative stress and also epithelial cell death. If the external irritants are severe, as is the case with cigarette smoke, the airway epithelium also releases IL-17A and IL-8, which are crucial in neutrophilic asthma. Current asthma pathogenesis knowledge is mostly based on the concept of “inflammation-induced epithelial injury”. So, it is obvious that therapeutic strategies have not focused on improving epithelial functioning in asthmatics, holding the belief that airway inflammation is the upstream event when an epithelial injury is caused.