The most popular method for processing sugar solutions at the moment is bacterial fermentation; this method produces high yields and, depending on the bacteria used, permits the production of either a specific stereoisomer or a racemic mixture. According to estimates, this method yields around 90% of global LA today. The following LA purification procedure, which is costly and affects process profitability, is the crucial stage in this system. Reactive distillation, membrane separation, ion exchange, and liquid extraction are frequently used.
Step growth polymerization or ring-opening polymerization (ROP) are viable methods for creating PLA polymers. The reactivity of the two LA functional groups is exploited in step growth polymerization; in fact, the polycondensation of the hydroxyl and carboxyl moieties results in the production of the ester linkages that make up the polymer backbone. This method of synthesis has several drawbacks, including the need for prolonged residence times for longer chains (which can cause undesirable side reactions, such as transesterification), difficult reaction parameters with temperatures reaching 250 °C, and a vacuum pressure of ~100 mbar), along with the continuous exclusion of water (a polycondensation byproduct). It is theoretically possible to use chain extenders (such as isocyanates or epoxides), but doing so inevitably affects the quality and purity of the material.
It is also important to note the advantages of PLA as a polymer: its eco-friendliness, biocompatibility, ease of processing, and less energy consumption (25–55% less energy) during production compared to petroleum-based polymers. Though several advantages have been stated, PLA has its disadvantages, which are poor toughness (highly brittle: <10 elongation at break), slow crystallization and degradation rate, relatively high hydrophobicity (contact angle of 80°), and a lack of reactive side chains or surface functional groups making it very difficult to almost impossible to modify PLA.
There is no one method for determining flame retardancy because the FR chemistry of composites is typically overly complex. For this reason, scientists frequently select FRs based on models for the chemistry of heat degradation of polymers and fire hazards. In addition, various commercial specifications, including those relating to the way a product is processed, its cost, environmental stability, color, and, more recently, its sustainability and recyclable nature, are imposed on commercial goods.
2. 2D Flame Retarding NPs as FRs in PLA Composite Systems
Several layered NPs (2D nanomaterials), such as expandable graphite (EG)
[35], MXenes
[36], MMT
[37], LDH
[38], MoS
2 [33], and others, have so far demonstrated outstanding flame-retarding properties in PLA-based polymer composite systems.
It has been suggested that the geometry of NPs, such as zero-dimensional (0D), one-dimensional (1D), 2D, and/or three-dimensional 3D, greatly affects the FR properties of polymeric matrices and their ultimate NCP(s)
[39]. It has been demonstrated that fire performance increases with the order of rod-like, spherical, and plate-like geometries that qualitatively match the effective surface area of NPs in the PLA-based NCP(s). This phenomenon was claimed to be dependent on the intercalation/exfoliation (nanodispersion) of the clay (MMT), which resulted in a significant increase in the surface area that aided in the rapid migration and accumulation of platelets on the exposed sample surface before the formation of intumescent char. A thicker aluminum phosphate/MMT NCP char formed as a result, acting as a potent transport barrier and preventing intumescence
[39]. Additionally, investigations into the microstructural development of the leftovers revealed remarkably uniform, hollow-fibrillar formations after PLA/aluminum diethylphosphinate (AlPi) combustion.
2.1. Nanoclays (NCs)
The most widely used and significant class of two-dimensional NPs are often NCs (amongst which a notable exception of increasing importance is one-dimensional (1D) sepiolite). Most of them are phyllosilicate minerals that are found in nature. Although boehmite (an aluminosilicate) and other clays have also been utilized in polymeric (nano)composites, MMT is by far the least expensive and most frequently employed
[40]. Even compared to other nanomaterials, they compare favorably in cost-benefit ratio
[41].
2D Layered mineral silicate NPs called NCs have been developed for usage in various niches. Due to NC's potential advantages, including enhanced mechanical strength, lower gas permeability, and superior flame-resistance
[6], polymer-clay NCPs are a class of nanomaterials (NMTs) that researchers have widely explored. Based on their chemical makeup and NP form, NCs are classified into various classes, including MMT, halloysites, bentonite, kaolinite, and hectorite
[3][42][43]. The alluring class of hybrid organic-inorganic NPs known as “organoclays” can be used in polymer NCPs as FRs, gas absorbents, drug delivery vehicles, and rheological modifiers
[6]. Along with the well-known FR chemistries, it has been extensively reported that the application of NC enhances the qualities of PLA and its good FR capabilities
[1][6][21][42][43][44]. The addition of organo-modified NC improves the storage modulus of PLA in both the solid and molten stages and the polymer’s biodegradability and flexural strength
[6][42][43]. NCs also can reduce the cone calorimeter test’s pHRR
[6]. In a typical experiment, 3% organo-modified MMT (O-MMT) and sodium MMT (Na
+ MMT) loaded PLA/clay NCPs were created, and their FR properties, molecular and supramolecular characteristics were investigated using a thermogravimetric analyzer (TGA), differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), and light microscopy (LM)
[45]. It was determined that the filler changed the PLA matrix’s ordering at the molecular and supramolecular levels but that it encouraged char formation, decreased flammability, and increased thermal stability instead. A related study examined the melt stability and FR characteristics of O-MMT at 5 wt.% and intumescent FR (IFR) at 15 wt.%
[46]. The two systems produced outstanding flame retardancy, resulting in a UL-94 V-0 rating, an LOI of 27.5%, and improved melt dripping suppression. Similar results have been published
[22] for knitted fabrics finished with PLA/clay NCP in the presence of a plasticizer, in which a significant reduction in pHRR (38%) was reached. EG and O-MMT were used in synergy to create PLA-based NCPs, and their thermal and mechanical properties were assessed
[32].
The synergistic effect of SiO
2, Zinc Borate (ZnB), and O-MMT NPs in PLA aimed at retarding the flammability of PLA matrix containing 9,10-dihydro-9-oxa-10-phosphaphenanthrene-10-oxide (DOPO) has been investigated by Long et al.
[47]. These researchers adopted MCD and injection molding to prepare their NCPs. The virgin PLA displayed no retardancy against fire, though upon including 10 wt.% DOPO, an improvement in the LOI from 19.1% to 27.1% was observed, along with a UL-94 rating of V-0. Additionally, with the inclusion of the O-MMT, the UL-94 rating dropped from V-0 to V-1, and the system showed melt drops during the fire test. The same was true with the NCP containing DOP, O-MMT, and ZnB. However, upon the inclusion of SiO
2 in the composite system, the LOI value was 27% compared to the LOI value of 25.8% and 26.5% for the composite systems containing O-MMT and ZnB at 2 wt.%
[47].
There is an interesting report on the utilization of C30B in synergy with EG to fabricate a PLA NCP with not just flame retardancy but enhanced thermal stability, mechanical performance and also enhanced co-dispersion of 2D NPs with PLA
[32]. The improvement in the FR properties of the virgin polymer upon the inclusion of the NPs was attributed partly to accelerated PLA crystallization primarily governed by the added EG. Additionally, the enhanced thermal stability of the NCP system was attributed to the addition of organoclay. The presence of both 2D NPs was said to improve the mechanical performance and partially enhance thermal properties simultaneously. In this way, the authors prepared an NCP having either of the fillers and a ternary system having the synergized 2D NPs.
When C30B and EG are added to PLA, better property performance is achieved during combustion, resulting in significant reductions in sample BR compared to neat PLA. This phenomenon was postulated to be related to forming a carbonized surface layer rich in silicate or graphite, which can shield the bulk of the PLA from the heat source. These researchers also noted that PLA-EG NCPs are entirely shattered by burning and dripping, in contrast to PLA-C30B NCPs, which retain the original shape of specimens with only partial fragmentation (
Figure 4a,b)
[32].
Figure 4. (a) Images of neat PLA and PLA specimens containing CLO, previous and after UL94V test and (b) Images of PLA-9EG specimen before UL94V testing and residue obtained by burning. Similar observations were obtained for PLA-3EG and PLA-6EG NCP.
Another experimental investigation conducted by Solarski and his group aimed at preparing PLA-clay NCPs for creating FR textile fibers has been explored
[22]. Melt mixing was adopted in their work to process PLA and 1–10 wt.% of a particular organomodified bentonite clay (Bentone1 104-B104) in order to investigate the impact of processing variables, such as residence time, temperature, and shear on the morphology of PLA/clay NCPs. It was revealed that the dispersion of B104 occurred under various conditions without difficulty due to strong compatibility with the PLA matrix, and a comparable morphology was formed
[22]. Their outcomes demonstrated that the extent of intercalation and delamination at low mixing temperatures is significantly influenced by the shear stress applied to the polymer. By adding 4 wt.% B104 to the PLA matrix during melt blending, upscale tests were carried out under improved circumstances to create NCP for the spinning process. It was then shown that, surprisingly, it is not necessary to utilize a plasticizer to spin a mixture with 4 wt.% B104 by melt spinning to obtain NCP-based multifilament yarns
[22]. The yarns’ thermal, mechanical, and shrinkage properties and clay dispersion were all investigated. Even at high draw ratios, B104 may be added to PLA in amounts up to 4 wt.% without negatively affecting the tensile strength of melt-spun filaments. Interestingly, the flammability of the NCP-based multifilaments was investigated using a cone calorimeter at 35 kW/m
2. The HRR experienced a significant decline of up to 46%
[22].
Another study examined how O-MMT, an IFR, affected PLA’s melt stability and flame retardancy. A twin-screw extruder and a two-roll mill created the FR PLA. Then, adopting LOI, vertical burning test, TGA, scanning electronmicroscopy (SEM), melt flow index (MFI), and parallel plate rheological studies, the impact of IFR and MMT on flame retardancy and melt stability was carefully examined. The testing findings demonstrate that the IFR system, in conjunction with MMT, has good fire retardancy, as evidenced by the sample’s ability to receive a UL94 V-0 rating and an increase in the LOI value from 20.1 for unaltered PLA to 27.5 for the flame-retarded PLA. O-MMT greatly improves melt stability and reduces melt leaking, according to MFI and rheological measurements
[46].
In another instance, clay particles were added to polylactide (PLA) together with a plasticizer, inorganic additives, plus O-MMT or unmodified O-MMT NPs (ethylene glycol)
[45] to fabricate FR PLA NCP. Melt blending PLA with other components produced the PLA-based systems. While adding microparticles produced a microcomposite, combining PLA with O-MMT particles produced an NCP with an intercalated nanostructure. In both systems, the proportion of O-MMT was kept at 3 wt.%. The same blending conditions were also used to create unfilled PLA, plasticized PLA, and plasticized NCP. Poly(ethylene glycol) in the amount of 10% was utilized for plasticization. The melt filling of PLA with organomodified NPs results in an NCP with an intercalated nanostructure, as was demonstrated. In plasticized NCPs, the intercalated nanostructure was also generated. PEG molecules take part in or promote the intercalation process. Unaltered clay particles create a traditional microcomposite with a PLA matrix.
Contrary to neat PLA, it was discovered that thermo-mechanical processing of PLA improves its capacity to crystallize by heating up from the glassy amorphous form
[45]. Because of the intercalated nanostructure in NCPs, including inorganic clay particles, it has a stronger inhibitory effect on PLA crystallization from the glassy amorphous state. Plasticized PLA and polymer matrices crystallize more easily in NCPs thanks to plasticizers. Independent of the sample composition, the heating technique used to induce crystallization from the glassy amorphous stage resulted in the same crystalline alteration of the PLA matrix. The sample composition impacted the spherulites’ sizes and perfection as they formed along with the crystallization. Spherulites are typically generated with smaller filler inclusions and with worse order. The plasticizer’s presence, particularly, is reported as a factor in developing delicate spherulitic morphology. In this case, the amorphous phase’s organization is said to change little with age; it is more plasticized in PLA, more constrained in NCPs, and stabilized by intercalated nanostructures
[45]. It was demonstrated that intercalation is not destroyed by crystallization in NCP materials or plasticized NCP materials. Additionally, depending on the overall morphology and responsiveness to the sample mix were mechanical properties.
Among the most popular organic biodegradable polymers, PLA is utilized extensively. Its FR properties, however, are poor, as earlier stated: In order to overcome this drawback, a group of authors performed melt-blending of PLA with IFRs (melamine phosphate and pentaerythritol) in the presence of organically modified MMT (O-MMT)
[6]. The authors carefully analyzed these produced nano-biocomposites with excellent intumescent char formation and improved FR properties. The MMTs utilized in this work were modified with tributyl hexadecyl phosphonium (O-MMT-2) and triphenyl benzyl phosphonium (O-MMT-1). According to a thermogravimetric investigation and Fourier Transform Infrared spectroscopy, these NCPs emit fewer hazardous gases during thermal decomposition than unmodified PLA. Concluding statements based on cone calorimeter data and char structure of different nanobiocomposites were supported by melt-rheological behaviors.
Additionally, the surfactant characteristics utilized to modify MMT were very important in regulating the fire properties of the composites. Compared to unmodified PLA, the fire characteristics of the NCP containing 5 wt.% O-MMT-1 were dramatically enhanced, with peak heat and total heat release rates (THRR) declining by 47% and 68%, respectively. In conclusion, developing high-performance PLA-based sustainable materials may benefit from the melt-blending of PLA, IFR, and O-MMT
[6].
An innovative IFR PLA system has reportedly been used to study the effects of various organically modified MMTs (labeled DK1, DK2, and DK4)
[4]. Lignin and microencapsulated ammonium polyphosphate made up of the IFR system were adopted, while appropriate characterization techniques were used to study the morphology of PLA/O-MMT NCPs. The composites FR and their thermal properties were assessed using the UL-94, LOI, and the cone calorimeter (CC). According to the findings, the sample containing DK2 had superior flame retardance supported by its lower pHRR and more excellent LOI value
[4]. Sample PLA8 (including DK2) demonstrates a more outstanding increase in the flame retardancy of IFR-PLA when compared to DK1 and DK4, having the best LOI value of 35.3 and UL-94 V-0 at the loading of 2 wt.% of DK2. According to the cone calorimeter’s findings, the addition of IFR greatly reduces the HRR and THR of the IFR-PLA, and the addition of DK2 to IFR-PLA can further reduce the corresponding values of IFR-PLA above; however, the addition of DK2 and DK4 cannot have the same impact. According to the TGA data, the sample containing DK2, which has a higher char yield at high temperatures, has superior thermal stability than the samples containing DK1 and DK4. The TG-FTIR data demonstrate that all O-MMTs stimulated the breakdown of PLA and that the sample containing DK2 released fewer combustible gas products than the samples containing DK1 and DK4. The integration of DK2 could enhance the char quality and result in a considerably more compact and continuous morphology, as the study of the char residues demonstrates
[4].
As per considered literature, it is well established that the phenomenon responsible for impacting flame retardancy to PLA-CL systems may be related to the formation of a carbonized surface layer rich in silicate, which can shield the bulk of the PLA from the heat source and the barricading of the volatiles within the composite thereby retarding degradation caused by oxidation. Additionally, considering the inexpensive nature of CLs NPs, their commercialization is achievable.
2.2. MXene
Through an etching process of titanium aluminum carbon (Ti
3AlC
2) followed by liquid exfoliation, a novel 2D nanomaterial known as titanium carbide (Ti
3C
2T
x) was identified for the first time in 2011
[48][49][50]. Ti
3C
2T
x nanosheets have a wide range of potential uses in the fields of sensors, water treatment, catalysis, energy storage, electromagnetic interference shielding, and so on because of their inherently high metal conductivity, adjustable surface active sites, and notable mechanical stability
[50]. Additionally, because of its low thermal conductivity and exceptional lamella thermal stability, Ti
3C
2Tx can have a lamella barrier effect during the pyrolysis and combustion of polymeric materials
[48]. As a result, Ti
3C
2T
x has been considered a viable polymer FR additive for polymer matrices, such as PLA
[48].
As a potential nontoxic functional ingredient for creating FR polymer composites, a novel 2D transition metal carbide called MXene (Ti
3C
2) has recently received much attention
[36]. Mxene limits the emission of flammable volatiles while preventing further burning of the underlying polymer composite thanks to its layered flake shape, which creates a physical barrier effect. The Ti component of Mxene has been discovered to exert a catalytic attenuation effect on most polymers, unlike most traditional FRs and other 2D nanomaterials, leading to a considerable decrease in composites’ heat and smoke release
[36].
Zhou et al.
[36] reportedly synthesized a PLA/DOPO-Ti
3C
2 NCP system having excellent property performance as a FR material. The fabricated FR presented a pHRR reduction of 33.7%, a V-0 UL-94 rating owing to the DOPO- Ti 3 C 2 ability to interplay the catalytic, barrier, and condensed effects within the PLA system.
Cone calorimetry, the UL-94 test, and the LOI were used to demonstrate their findings on PLA composites’ thermal and burning capabilities. The authors also looked at the tensile and UV-shielding capabilities. According to the findings in the UL-94 test, PLA/ Ti 3 C 2 /DOPO (3 wt.%) demonstrated a V-0 rating. The large decrease in pHRR (33.7%), total heat release (47%) and peak CO output (58.8%), as well as the improvement in fire safety, were all indicators of this (41.7%). The interaction of catalytic, barrier, and condensed effects of the Ti
3C
2/DOPO nanosheets in the PLA matrix, as seen in
Figure 5, was the cause of the composites’ increased fire-safety performance
[36].
Figure 5. Proposed mechanism of FR.
In this interesting example where Mxene was adopted as reinforcing 2D NPs in the PLA system, the tensile strength of PLA/Ti
3C
2-DOPO increased by about 9%, and it scored “Excellent” (UPF 50+) for UV protection
[36]. This study presents a novel chemical modification technique for 2D Mxene flakes to create multifunctional PLA composites, which show promise as candidates for the next wave of sustainable and protective plastic products
[36].
There is an existing instance where Shi and his group
[48] pointed out that Mxene (Ti
3C
2T
x) can be effectively used as FR in its pristine state, and it modified form Ti
3C
2T
x (benzyldimethylhexadecylammonium chloride (HDBAC)-Ti
3C
2T
x. They prepared Mxene (Ti
3C
2T
x) via the etching of Ti
3AlC
2 using LiF/HCl at a temperature of 35 °C for 48 h, followed by washing with deionized H
2O to neutral via centrifugation. The prepared Mxene was then dried and ready for modification with HDBAC through a facile solution mixing under a nitrogen environment for 2h, washed and dried for inclusion in the PLA matrix, as depicted in
Figure 6a.
Figure 6. Schematic diagrams for HDBAC-Ti3C2Tx (a) and PLA/HD-TC/SiAPP composites (b).
According to
Figure 6b, melt blending was used to process PLA composites. The formulations for the PLA/HDBAC-Ti
3C
2T
x(HD-TC)/SiAPP composites were made by adding 0.2, 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 wt.% of HDBAC-Ti
3C
2T
x and 15.0, 14.8, 14.5, 14.0, and 13.0 wt.% of SiAPP, respectively. Raw PLA was first vacuum-dried at 80 °C for 12 h before processing. The samples were then created using an internal mixer at 180 °C with a 50 r/min rotation speed. First, pure PLA was poured into the internal mixer. The modified Ti3C2Tx and SiAPP were introduced into the mixer for 20 min to obtain an excellent visible dispersion after melting the PLA. The sample was heated under 10 Mpa at 180 °C for additional analysis
[48]. Their prepared composite/hybrid system presented the best results for their formulation: PLA/2.0HD-TC/13.0SiAPP, which contained 2 wt.% Mxene and 13 wt.% SiPPA: the LOI was enhanced from 24.4% to 33.3% with a UL-94 rating of V-0, a pHRR reduction of 49.8% along with T
5%(°C) of 327 (residual wt.% of 10.33 at 700 °C)
[48]. They investigated the residual char from the NCP in order to ascertain the FR mechanism of the PLA/Mxene/SiAPP: the formation of dense continuous intumescent C-layer was said to separate the thermal decomposition zone and hinder the transfer of heat into the underlying NCP. Additionally, the addition of HDBAC-Ti
3C
2T
x enhanced the char formation, thereby hindering the spread of the fire, as depicted in
Figure 7 [48].
Figure 7. Schematic illustration for the proposed flame-retardant mechanism.
In their study, Huang et al.
[51] prepared PLA/IFR composites with Ti
3C
2 Mxene nanosheets using melt blending, and they looked at the synergistic impacts of Mxene on the fire performance of PLA/IFR systems by replacing some of the IFR with Mxene. The incorporation of a small amount of Mxene might significantly improve the flame retardancy of PLA/IFR composites, according to their LOI, UL-94, and CCT results. The addition of 1.0 wt.% Mxene and 11.0 wt.% IFR resulted in a V-0 UL-94 rating, an apparent rise in LOI (160.4%), and a clear decrease in pHRR (64.6%). Intumescent char formation capability of PLA/IFR systems could be effectively improved by the presence of nano TiO
2 catalyst and 2D nanosheet barrier effect of Mxene (as per
Figure 8), thereby preventing the further flame spread and the spread of fire hazard, according to CCTs analysis, SEM, photographs, laser Raman spectroscopy (LRS), XRD, and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) of carbon residues of PLA/IFR/Mxene composites. It was claimed that the use of 2D Mxene in this research was successful as FR additive-based nanomaterials with self-charring and self-catalyzing functions as a high-performance synergist for various kinds of IFR polymeric matrix
[51].
Figure 8. Schematic illustration for the synergistic flame retarded mechanism of PLA/IFR/Mxene NCPs.
In summary, the 2D nanosheet barrier effect of Mxene is hypothesized to significantly increase the ability of PLA/IFR systems to create intumescent char, hence halting further flame development and the spread of fire hazards. Mxene’s layered flake form, which produces a physical barrier effect, controls the emission of combustible volatiles while inhibiting additional burning of the underlying polymer mixture.