2. AMPK and Ca2+—Dependent Signaling Transients
2.1. Dynamics of AMPK and CaMKII Activity during Exercise
During the onset of exercises, AMPK isoforms demonstrate different activities. In general, changes in AMPK isoform activity depend on exercise intensity and duration. A muscle biopsy is used to determine AMPK activity in vivo. Typically, a biopsy is taken at a limited number of time points due to the complexity of this invasive procedure. For example, samples were taken six times per participant (before and during training)
[4], but usually there are even fewer samples. Since the minimum time required for a biopsy procedure is about 15–30 s, this also imposes limitations on the exercise regimens that can be studied (including interval exercises). After the biopsy, a complex multistage procedure
[5] is performed to measure the activity of the obtained AMPK and its isoforms using various substrates.
While α2 AMPK, especially α2β2γ3 isoform activity, commonly rises after exercise at intensities above 50% VO
2peak and higher
[4][6][7][8], the α1 AMPK activity changes are controversial. The controversies in the data from different studies may be partly due to the different training statuses of participants and different exercise intensities. In untrained subjects, α1 AMPK activity increases or tends to increase
[9][10][11], while the activity of α1 AMPK during exercise does not change or tends to decrease in trained subjects
[4][6][7][8][12][13][14][15]. One study even showed a decrease of α1 AMPK activity after high-intensity all-out sprint exercise
[8].
Among the cited works
[6][7][10][11][12] used the SAMS peptide, while
[4][8][14][15] used the AMARA peptide. In various studies, the amount of lysate used in measurements varied from 50 to 300 μg.
If the time points at which AMPK activity was measured were far apart (10 min or more) then a progressive increase in the activity was observed as a rule.
If the biopsy was taken more often, then signs of transient processes would be observed. At the beginning of the exercise, a downward trend in the activity of α1β2γ1 and α2β2γ1 isoforms of AMPK was observed
[4], as well as a slow rise in α2β2γ3 activity. Then, the AMPK activity increased during the progression of exercise.
Therefore, the decrease in AMPK activity after high-intensity exercise observed in a number of studies, including
[8], may not be a fundamental dependence, but represent only part of a transient process.
An opposite transition but fairly similar trend was observed for CaMKII phosphorylation and autonomous activity during exercise on a bicycle ergometer at intensity corresponding to 67 ± 2% of VO
2peak for 90 min
[16]. In this study, biopsies were taken from the
vastus lateralis muscle before and after 1, 10, 30, 60, and 90 min of exercise. At the 1 min time point, there was a significant increase in CaMKII phosphorylation and autonomous activity, which decreased significantly at the time point of 10 min and beyond. The trained subjects (VO
2peak 55 mL/kg/min) participated in this study
[16], just like in the
[4] study (VO
2peak 55 mL/kg/min).
The transients in CaMKII autonomous activity may be related to differences in Ca
2+ uptake and release kinetics and thus Ca
2+–CaM binding, or changes in the activity of protein phosphatases dephosphorylating CaMKII over time
[16].
It should be noted that assumptions about transient processes were made using the data obtained in mixed fiber muscle extracts (homogenate and lysate). Individual muscle fibers of various types and motor units may have significant differences in the concentration of metabolic enzymes, kinases, and phosphatases. During exercise of different intensities, the concentrations of metabolites in different muscle fibers can vary greatly, both due to uneven recruitment and differences in fiber types.
Taken together, the data suggests that some transient processes occur in a short period of time (1–10 min from exercise onset), the underlying causes of which are not yet clear. Unfortunately, most of the studies discussed above were performed using continuous exercises with constant loads of different intensities. There is no data on what transients exist during variable intensity training and competitions. For example, during various interval training exercises or when moving along a course with uphills, downhills, and flat terrains.
2.2. Possible Effects of Repeated Exercise
It is known that during repeated bouts of physical exercise, different kinetics of oxygen consumption
[17][18][19][20] as well as different rates of activation of a number of metabolic enzymes
[21][22][23] and, respectively, different kinetics of metabolic processes (ON-kinetics)
[17][24][25][26] are observed.
Unfortunately, the kinetics of the activity of metabolic enzymes and kinases in the pause between exercise bouts or after exercise cessation (OFF kinetics) have not been comprehensively studied. To researchers' knowledge, there are no in vivo investigations with data on OFF-kinetics with sufficient time resolution, although the data are very important since they can additionally characterize and support a hypothesis on the mechanism of transient processes. Such processes can play an essential role in actual training practice, determine the effectiveness of various training programs and exercise regimens, and provide insight into how to optimize training regimens.
2.3. Simulations Based on the Current Model and Their Limitations
The current model by
[3] simulates a non-linear increase in AMPK phosphorylation as a surrogate for its activity (ON-kinetics) during moderate-intensity exercise, which is similar to the increase in AMPK activity that was proposed by
[27] based on experimental data.
The simulated AMPK activity during recovery shows an almost exponential decline in the model
[3]. At the same time, there is a study demonstrating that the decrease in AMPK activity occurs with some delay
[28]. The decrease of AMPK activity in vitro takes a sigmoid-like shape after the addition of protein phosphatase with about a 10-minute delay. The reasons for such a delay are unexplained, though. A rather similar pattern of AMPK activity in vitro is shown by
[29], but the sigmoid-like shape is almost indiscernible, probably due to different experimental conditions and a much higher rate of dephosphorylation.
The current set of model equations
[3] cannot simulate changes in AMPK activity different from exponential-based rise and drop dynamics and particularly transient processes. To adequately simulate the transient processes, it is necessary to find out the underlying causes and incorporate them into the model.
One of the directions was the interrogation for data on the kinetics of protein phosphatase activity during exercise (ON and OFF phases). Since it is necessary to clarify the shape of the decrease in the activity of AMPK and other kinases after exercise and in pauses of 1–10 min during interval training.