Different types of male pregnancy in various
Syngnathidae fishes exemplify evolutionary gradation and progress in paternal involvement, from the simple attachment of eggs to the body surface to a fully developed internal pregnancy within the uterus/placenta-like pouch. In the subfamily
Nerophinae, eggs are just attached to the skin surface without any protection. In
Oosthethus,
Doryrhamphus, and some
Solegnathiinae, the attached eggs are protected by the special flaps of the skin. Finally,
Syngnathus and
Hippocampus have a completely closed brood pouch where developing embryos are integrated in paternal tissue and fully supplied through the vascularized placenta-like structure (
Figure 1 and
Figure 2)
[4][6][7][8][9][10][11]. Harada et al.
[7] studied in detail the brood pouch morphology and histology in five species of the
Syngnathidae family and described five types of brood pouches. The alligator pipefish has a completely open pouch without skinfolds (type I), the messmate pipefish has an open pouch with skinfolds (type II), the seaweed pipefish has a closed pouch with skinfolds (type III), the pot-bellied seahorse has a closed pouch on the tail (type IV), and the Japanese pygmy seahorse has a closed pouch within a body cavity (type V)
[7]. Interestingly, the type V pouch is positioned in the seahorse body cavity, and the embryos are located between the kidney and intestine
[7]. The juvenile seahorse does not have a brood pouch. It develops during the post-juvenile stage
[9]. While the female seahorse is laying eggs in a male brood pouch, the male fertilizes them at the pouch entry. Developing embryos are gradually enclosed within individual compartments of the placenta-like tissue of the pouch. This pseudo-placenta is vascularized and allows for the exchange of gases, nutrients, and waste removal through the epithelium that lines the pouch lumen
[9]. The luminal epithelium of the pouch derives from the surface epithelium covering the seahorse’s body. Thus, at some point in pouch development, there must be a change in the epithelium properties. Kawaguchi et al.
[9] studied successive stages of pouch development in the pot-bellied seahorse
Hippocampus abdominalis as well as the molecules involved in the transition of the surface epithelium of the dermis into the luminal epithelium of the pouch. Pouch development lasts several months and starts from the long projections of the dermis (epithelium with underlying collagenous fibers) on both ventral sides of the body, which eventually fuse in the ventral midline, forming the pouch. During this stage, the pouch consists of only two layers of the dermis (epithelial layers with underlying collagenous fibers) and still lacks placenta-like features. The final step involves the formation of the pseudo-placenta. The smooth muscles and blood vessels form, and the properties of the epithelium change. The epithelium of the dermis and developing pouch express two types of C-lectins, haCTL I and haCTL II. In contrast, the luminal epithelium of a fully developed pouch with a pseudo-placenta specifically expresses haCTL IV lectin, which is never expressed in skin epithelium (
Figure 2)
[9]. By analogy to the muscle contraction during mammalian birth, the smooth muscles of the brood pouch were thought to be needed for pouch contraction during the expulsion of neonates. However, recent micro-computed tomography studies of the seahorse brood pouch showed that the muscles of the brood pouch are limited to the scattered small bundles, which cannot produce enough contraction during labor. Instead, male seahorses, in contrast to females, have large muscle bundles attached to the anal fin bones at the opening of the brood pouch, and contraction of those fin muscles, together with the body movements, opens the pouch and expels neonates
[6].
Like in most vertebrates, reproduction stages and cycles in fishes are regulated by the hypothalamic–pituitary–gonadal (HPG) axis. In females and males, the gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) produced by the hypothalamus induces the pituitary gland to release the gonadotropins, follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH) and luteinizing hormone (LH), into the bloodstream
[12], while the gonadotropin-inhibitory hormone (GnIH) inhibits gonadotropin secretion
[13]. In females, gonadotropins stimulate steroid (testosterone and estradiol) production by the ovary, which, in turn, promotes secondary sexual features and sex-dependent behavior, follicle development, and vitellogenin production. Oocyte maturation is stimulated by the LH-induced production of gamete maturation-inducing steroids (MISs). Ovulation in fish is stimulated by an increase in LH followed by the release of ovarian prostaglandins, which regulate spawning behavior
[14][15][16]. In males, FSH induces spermatogenesis, and LH stimulates sperm maturation, and both these gonadotropins stimulate the male gonad to produce androgens, such as testosterone and 11-ketotestosterone, in fishes, which, in turn, regulate sexual dimorphism
[16][17]. Gonadotropins also induce testes to produce MISs, which regulate spermiogenesis and the final maturation of spermatozoa
[16][18].
2.3. Retinoic Acid
Another molecule involved in seahorse male pregnancy regulation is retinoic acid (RA), a metabolite of vitamin A1 (all-trans-retinol). Among various retinoic acid isomers, such as 13-cis- and 9-cis-retinoic acid, the all-trans-retinoic acid (retinoic acid) is most abundant and required for growth, embryonic development, differentiation, cancer, and immunity
[19][20][21][22][23][24]. During early development, RA signaling through the homeobox (Hox) and POU genes establishes the anterior–posterior axis and patterning of the embryo
[22][23]. Comparative transcriptomic and metabolomic analyses of the lined seahorse
Hippocampus erectus in different stages of brood pouch formation (unformed, newly formed, and pregnant pouch) identified 141 genes and 73 metabolites related to pouch formation and 2533 and 121 metabolites related to pregnancy. Additionally, integrative omics showed that retinoic acid (RA) synthesis and signaling were involved in brood pouch formation and seahorse pregnancy and in regulating antioxidant defenses
[25]. These studies also showed that in
H. erectus and
H. abdominalis, RA functions upstream of testosterone and progesterone, directly regulating pouch formation via G protein-coupled receptor FSHR and cholesterol 7alpha-hydroxylase CYP7A1, a member of the cytochrome P450 superfamily of enzymes involved in the synthesis of cholesterol, steroids, and other lipids
[25][26][27].
3. Adaptations of the Immune System to Male Pregnancy
The biggest challenge in pregnancy is how not to reject an allogeneic (nonself) embryo
[28]. In mammalian pregnancy, immune tolerance toward the semi-allogenic embryo occurs through the downregulation of the major histocompatibility genes MHC I and MHC II. Paradoxically, pregnancy starts from the inflammation of the endometrium necessary for the implantation of the embryo. Chavan et al.
[29] and Griffith et al.
[30] called this “the inflammation paradox”. They believe that, early in evolution, acute endometrial inflammation (still occurring in some marsupials) was a natural maternal immune reaction toward the attaching embryo. Subsequently, during evolution, by suppressing the most damaging parts of the inflammatory response, the acute inflammation was transformed into the embryo-friendly process of implantation and placental pregnancy
[29][30]. In mammals, several mechanisms based on the extensive crosstalk between the embryonic trophoblast layer and maternal uterine immune cells prevent the rejection of the allogeneic embryo by the maternal immune system. First, trophoblast does not express MHC II, which otherwise would present embryonic antigens to maternal T-helper cells (Th) and initiate an immune response
[31][32]. Additionally, the MHC I genes, which present antigens to maternal cytotoxic T cells, are downregulated in the trophoblast
[32][33]. Additionally, regulatory T cells (Tregs) recognize fetal antigens via maternal antigen-presenting cells (APCs) and induce tolerance toward the embryo
[34].
Thus, the fascinating question is how, during evolution, did the immune system adjust to tolerating the nonself embryo. Because most mammals, except for egg-laying monotremata, such as echidna and platypus, have internal pregnancies, they are useless for reconstructing evolutionary progress in parental immunotolerance. In contrast, male seahorses, with their gradation of pregnancy, from a simple attachment of eggs to the skin, through a different degree of coverage by the skin flaps, to internal gestation within the brood pouch, are perfect for reconstructing evolutionary progress in the development of immune tolerance toward the nonself embryo (
Figure 3). Recently, using this approach, Roth et al.
[4] studied the immune gene repertoire across male pregnancy gradients in 12 species of seahorses and pipefishes. These detailed studies showed that the evolution of pregnancy coincided with either a complete loss or rearrangement of MHC II pathway genes and correlated with the expansion of the MHC I gene repertoire. MHC II molecules are found on professional antigen-presenting cells such as dendritic cells, mononuclear phagocytes, some endothelial cells, thymic epithelial cells, and B cells, which are crucial for initiating immune response. The antigens presented by the MHC II genes derive from extracellular proteins, while antigens presented by the MHC I genes mainly derive from cytosolic proteins. MHC II binds peptides, which are derived from the proteolysis of self and non-self proteins, and presents them to antigen-specific CD4+ T cells. On the same theme, studies from another laboratory compared transcriptome-wide gene expression in four syngnathid species with different degrees of paternal involvement at four pregnancy stages (nonpregnant, early, late, and at birth)
[35]. They found that the loss or downregulation of MHC pathway gene expression occurs only in species with a brood pouch pregnancy, and that a decrease in MHC pathway gene expression is limited to the early and middle stages of pregnancy. In late pregnancy and at birth, the expression of immune genes was elevated, suggesting that the late embryos, in contrast to the early embryos, are no longer in direct contact with the paternal immune system
[35][36].
Figure 3. Seahorse immune adaptations in male pregnancy. Three main mechanisms are responsible for the development of seahorse immune tolerance against allogeneic embryos. (A) Seahorses are asplenic (spleen loss). Asplenia is caused by the amino acid substitution in the transcription factor TLX1, which, through the retinoic acid pathway, regulates spleen development. Asplenia affects the white blood cell repertoire (causes partial loss of red blood cells, platelets, various subsets of T and B cells, dendritic cells (DCs), and macrophages) and decreases immune response. (B) There is a downregulation of the MHC II pathway, either through a loss or rearrangement of MHC II genes. This, in turn, decreases self- and non-self-antigen presentation to the effector immune cells, such as CD4+ T cells, and lowers the immune response against allogenic embryos. (C) Despite the weakened immune responses of the parent against embryos, gestating embryos are protected against pathogens abundant in a nonsterile seawater-filled pouch by the increase in antibacterial peptides and immune factors, such as hepcidin (Hehamp II), lysozymes (HeLyzC, HeLyzG1, and HeLyzG2), monocytes and leukocytes, interleukin 2 (IL-2), and interferon alfa (IFN-α) in the pouch. Red X symbol depicts inhibition of disruption of the process, and red star depicts changes in molecule composition or structure.
4. Effects of Male Pregnancy on the Microbiome
One of the most fascinating changes occurring during
Syngnathidae male pregnancy is a profound change in their microbiome. Although there is not much information on this subject in seahorses, there are recent, very detailed studies on pipefish pregnancy
[37]. In animals with maternal pregnancy, some microorganisms are transferred to the offspring from the mother, and some colonize newborns (through the mouth) from the environment. In maternal pregnancy, it is very hard to establish if there is any input of microorganisms from the father. Thus, animals with male pregnancy, such as pipefishes or seahorses, are very well suited to study this phenomenon and answer the question of how pregnancy influences the parental microbiome. Recent studies on pipefish
Syngnathus typhle sequenced microbial 16S rRNA from maternal gonads and the brood pouches of non-pregnant and pregnant males
[37]. These studies also assessed the effect of the parental immune system on the complexity of the microbiome. These analyses showed that maternal gonads and male brood pouches contain different microbial species (listed in the entry) and contain different species in early and late pregnancy brood pouches
[37]. The most abundant bacteria in the maternal gonads and in the paternal brood pouch were
Marinomonas (28.0%),
Halomonas (10.3%),
Aeribacillus (6.3%),
Ruegeria (5.8%),
Bacteroidetes (4.5%), and
Nesterenkonia (3.8%). Additionally, the paternal immune system changes the bacterial composition to a higher abundance of
Kiloniella,
Aquimarina,
Ulvibacter, and
Marinomonas. These are commensal bacteria that help fight pathogenic bacteria and possibly boost the immune response in the offspring
[37].
5. Effects of Environmental Changes and Pollutants on Seahorses
Many species of seahorses are endangered by overfishing, degradation of their habitats, and pollution. Even under the best circumstances, seahorse numbers are low because of the demanding and restrictive lifestyle. Seahorses sparsely inhabit an intricately structured niche, and their survival depends on the elaborate camouflage specific to a particular surrounding. Because seahorses are poor swimmers, nonmigratory, monogamous, and form a lifelong pair bond, finding a new partner when one dies is very difficult. Seahorse reproductive rate, even under optimal conditions, is low because of the small brood size and lengthy parental care. Consequently, seahorses are on the local, international, and IUCN Red List of Threatened Species
[38], becoming a bioindicator of crude oil exposure
[39]. Studies of the effects of ocean warming and acidification on the physiology and behavior of the long-snouted seahorse
Hippocampus guttulatus, which has been recently added to list of threatened and/or declining species by the Oslo and Paris (OSPAR) commission, showed that although the adults are quite resistant to ocean warming, the combination of warming and acidification (caused by CO
2 uptake from the atmosphere) causes lethargy and reduction in feeding and gill ventilation rates
[40]. In contrast, the seahorse newborns are much more sensitive to warming, which causes heat-induced hypometabolism
[41].
Besides factors related to climate warming, seahorses, like other aquatic animals, are constantly exposed to various types of pollutants. For example, studies of seahorse species inhabiting coastal waters of the Black Sea and China showed a high accumulation of heavy metals (including Cu, Pb, Cd, Cr, and Hg), benzo(a)pyrene (B[a]P), organochlorine pesticides, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), and microplastics
[42][43][44][45][46].