1. Introduction
Increased interest regarding the health benefits of
L. frutescens has encouraged researchers to look into the phytochemical composition of the plant. To date, a variety of compounds has been isolated from mainly the aerial part of the plant and are reported to provide the basis for the plant’s multipurpose medicinal benefits
[1]. So far, the phytochemicals isolated include, but not limited to amino acids, flavonoids (including flavonol glycosides), pinitol and triterpenoids (including triterpenoids glycosides)
[1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9].
2. Amino Acids
Apart from being the building blocks of proteins, amino acids play a key role in the growth, development and well-being of humans
[10]. The molecules consist of two broad categories, essential and non-essential. The term non-essential amino acids does not mean the amino acids are not crucial, but it refers to amino acids that are mainly synthesized by body cells, which then need to be provided for through diet. Meanwhile, the essential amino acids are not synthesized by body cells and should be compensated for through diet
[10]. The study conducted by Mncwangi and Viljoen
[11] on wild and cultivated populations of
L. frutescens from various locations revealed that amino acid content ranged from 10 to 15%, and 60% of the total amino acids, comprising asparagine, alanine and proline. In this study, about 100 mg of dried homogenized leaves was extracted with 50% acetonitrile and 0.1% formic acid mixture prior to analysis. The findings identified asparagine, alanine, and proline as major amino acid constituents of
L. frutescens. Although not part of the major amino acids of
L. frutescens, canavanine and gamma aminobutyric acid (GABA) enjoy scientists’ attention, due to their notable health benefits
[12][13][14].
A comparison of the concentration of amino acids in natural populations of
L. frutescens is depicted in
Table 1. The two studies by Mncwangi and Viljoen
[11] and Moshe
[15] were conducted 14 years apart. The results highlight a significant depreciation in overall amino acid concentrations over the years. The authors are cognizant that the evaluation should be considered with caution, since the samples were not collected from the same location. Although both authors used leaves for analysis, Mncwangi and Viljoen
[11] used an acetonitrile: formic acid mixture, while Moshe
[15] used ethanol to prepare extracts. In another study, Shaik and colleagues
[7] reported GABA and canavanine content to be 3.48 and 0.08 mg/g, respectively, in the methanolic extracts of leaf samples, confirming the depreciation of amino acid content as noted above. These results were consistent with the 3 mg/g GABA and 0.4 mg/g canavanine content, wherein methanolic extracts of pulverized leaves were used for an analysis
[3].
Table 1. Amino acid concentration in
L. frutescens. Data from Moshe
[15] and Mncwangi and Viljoen
[11].
2.1. Alanine
Alanine (
Figure 1a), commonly known as L-alanine, is a non-essential amino acid
[16] with benefits for humans. According to Araujo and colleagues
[17], alanine is instrumental in regulating pancreatic β-cell physiology to minimize lifestyle-induced obesity. For example, it is used in the regulation of healthy blood sugar levels through gluconeogenesis. Gluconeogenesis is the process of producing glucose molecules in the liver
[18]. Thus, avid exercisers benefit greatly from the involvement of alanine in gluconeogenesis. Mncwangi and Viljoen
[11] reported alanine concentrations in
L. frutescens ranging from 0.37 to 1.67 mg/g, while Moshe
[15] observed concentrations of up to 10.7 mg/g. A significant depreciation in the phytochemical is evident in the results.
Figure 1. Amino acids found in Lessertia frutescens: (a) alanine, (b) asparagine, (c) proline, (d) canavanine and (e) gamma aminobutyric acid.
2.2. Asparagine
Asparagine (
Figure 1b) is an amide of amino succinic acid which is partially soluble in water. Asparagine comprises a standard nitrogen: carbon ratio of 2:4. This special trait makes the molecule a suitable candidate for the storage and transportation of N
2 in living organisms
[19]. In a very recent study, it was suggested that asparagine reduces viral replication in human cells. This discovery makes the phytochemical a potential agent for antiviral development
[20]. Soluble asparagine accumulates in almost all parts of plants. It has also been noted that the accumulation of this compound may occur as a result of abiotic stress
[19]. However, Dell’Aversana and co-workers
[21] reported contrasting observations. They observed a significant decrease in the asparagine content of
Hordeum vulgare, which was subjected to salt stress. So far, the influence of abiotic stress on the accumulation of asparagine has not been explored in the case of
L. frutescens. The available literature suggests that the asparagine concentration in
L. frutescens ranges between 3.00 and 61.0 mg/g
[11][15]. The contradicting reports on the content of asparagine in plants subjected to abiotic stress highlights the importance of seeking to study specific plants before making conclusions, in order to avoid inaccurate claims.
2.3. Canavanine
Canavanine (
Figure 1c) is a non-protein amino acid commonly present in leguminous plants. The metabolite exhibits antagonistic characteristics against arginine and may inadvertently substitute arginine molecules during protein synthesis
[22]. This phenomenon leads to abnormal three-dimensional protein molecules, also called canavanyl proteins
[22][23]. The substitution of arginine by canavanine is not a favorable biosynthesis pathway as it may interrupt enzyme activities and subsequently obliterate the conformation of proteins
[22]. Relatively high concentrations of canavanine are detected in the seeds of leguminous plants, while moderate levels are found in their aerial parts
[22][23]. For example, canavanine constitutes a major proportion of the amino acids in alfalfa seeds.
Canavanine is known for its superior antitumor properties
[24]. Research into this claim began decades ago, with the in vivo experiments on mammals taking place in the early 1980s. The study by Green et al.
[25] assessed the anticancer properties of canavanine in leukemic mice infected with L1210. Their findings indicated that high doses of canavanine injections to the mice deactivate cancerous cell proliferation. In addition, the treatment increased the life span of the mice by 44%. The anticancer activity and mechanism of the phytochemical was reviewed by Bence and Crooks
[26]. In addition to the antitumor properties, canavanine is reported to provide protection for plants against pathogens and predators
[22][24].
Canavanine is among the most-studied amino acids in
L. frutescens. Of interest is that Mncwangi and Viljoen
[11] observed a huge variation in the concentration of some amino acids, including canavanine, in propagated
L. frutescens plants. To date, the concentration of canavanine in the aerial part of
L. frutescens ranges from 1.00 to 18.0 mg/g
[3][7][11][15]. Such discrepancies in the phytochemical composition of medicinal plants are unfavorable, lest they result in challenges for formulation of standardization protocols. Therefore, practical and sustainable interventions on the cultivation level to optimize phytochemical compounds in the plant are necessary.
2.4. Gamma Aminobutyric Acid
Gamma aminobutyric acid (
Figure 1d) is a four carbon non-protein amino acid essential biochemical, commonly found in microorganisms and plants
[27][28][29] Various types of foodstuffs contain low levels of GABA, with fermentation causing an escalation in its concentration
[30]. It is suspected that lactic acid is a precursor for the phytochemical
[31]. Gamma aminobutyric acid was initially regarded as just a phytochemical. However, decades after its discovery, speculations that the compound could be a signaling molecule surfaced. Extensive research to investigate the suggestion commenced and still continues
[29][32]. Unlike proline, GABA is a flexible compound and can assume various structural conformations, including a cyclic shape. Gamma aminobutyric acid induces anti-abiotic stress defenses in plants by preventing reactive oxygen species (ROS) formation, redox imbalance and cell death
[23].
Of all the amino acids reviewed here, GABA is the second-most beneficial to humans, after canavanine. It is highly esteemed for its inhibitory neurotransmitter properties in the central nervous system
[31]. Furthermore, Inoue et al.
[33] reported that blood pressure reduction was witnessed in humans who consumed GABA. In addition to these benefits, GABA can induce relaxation and reduce anxiety. These benefits may be the reasons why GABA is used as a fortifier for various foodstuffs in Japan
[31].
Lessertia frutescens natural populations contain GABA content, which is relatively close to the minimum range. For instance, Moshe
[15] and Tai and partners
[3] reported GABA concentrations of 0.045 and 0.029 μmol·g
−1, respectively. According to
[29] the concentration of GABA in plants shoots up under extreme environmental conditions. Therefore, under extreme environmental conditions, the increase in GABA may be accompanied by a reduction in the concentration of L-glutamate, because it is a precursor molecule for GABA. Again, this claim needs to be ascertained in the case of
L. frutescens. As a result, GABA is often used to circumvent adverse effects of extreme environmental conditions. Priya and co-authors
[30] demonstrated how GABA application can benefit the crop industry through alleviation of heat in mung beans. The authors observed a decline in endogenous GABA contents of the plants subjected to heat stress. However, the application of exogenous GABA to the plants resulted in improved plant parameters when compared with just the heat-stressed mung beans. Meanwhile, Yang et al.
[34] soaked peach fruits in GABA solution to develop resistance to chilling injury due to the activation of antioxidant enzymes and the maintenance of higher energy level status in the fruits. In the most recent study, GABA was used as a drought stress suppressant in two variants of black pepper plants
[35]. Physiological parameters of pretreated pepper plants were better than untreated plants, when both were subjected to drought stress.
2.5. Proline
Proline (
Figure 1e) is a unique proteogenic amino acid with its γ-amino acid group positioned as a secondary amine. The compound is characterized by a rigid, cyclic structure, which restricts conformational flexibility
[36][37]. The fact that proline is considered a non-essential amino acid in humans unless they are injured has almost disguised its indispensable value in neonates
[38]. Interesting discoveries were made in studies that involved pig neonates, which could be extrapolated to human neonates, since similarities in the two were validated
[38]. In one study, a remarkable demand for proline, used in protein synthesis, was noted during pre- and postnatal periods
[39]. Meanwhile, Brunton et al.
[40] indicated a huge dependability of protein synthesis in neonates, on parenteral proline supply.
Proline plays a vital role in plant primary metabolism
[41]. Its compatible solute characteristics are remarkable in dehydrated seeds and pollen, where it combats cellular structure degradation
[36]. It has also been reported that the metabolite plays a critical role in plant pathogen interactions, programmed death and development
[37]. Proline accumulation in plants is attributed to their exposure to stressful environmental conditions such as salt, drought, ultraviolet (UV) radiation, extreme temperatures, and toxic metals
[41]. This accumulation is apparently at a pace that is relatively faster than any other amino acids. Hence, other researchers proposed its exploitation as a tool to develop irrigation protocols for plants and select drought resistant species. However, in the case of
L. frutescens there is no data available to support or refute whether the metabolite accumulates under extreme environmental conditions. The concentration of proline in
L. frutescens natural population aerial parts ranged between 0.32 and 36.8 mg/g
[11][15]. High concentrations of proline are purportedly found in the reproductive organs of plants when compared to other plant parts. The variability extends to plant leaves, where young ones contain relatively high concentrations when compared to the mature counterparts
[36].
3. Pinitol
Pinitol (
Figure 2) is a cyclitol which was first isolated from
Pinus monticola, from which the name was derived. It occurs naturally in plants, especially of the Leguminosae family
[42]. The concentration of pinitol in plants may vary in response to abiotic stress. Considering that pinitol is among the phytochemicals that are responsible for
L. frutescens’ medicinal properties, it does not come as a surprise that several studies
[7][11][15] have documented its valuable health benefits in humans. These include antidiabetic
[43][44], antioxidant
[45] and anticancer
[46][47] capabilities. A significant improvement in the condition of a liver was noted in the patients of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease, when pinitol was administered. Pinitol induced the reduction of oxidative stress and accumulation of fatty acids, in order to effect the improvement
[45]. Meanwhile, it induced cytotoxicity in human leukemia cells, MOLT-4. In this case, the dose-dependent cell apoptosis was achieved through the generation of reactive oxygen species
[46]. Thus, a reduction in the level of this phytochemical in plants may lead to compromised efficacy.
Lessertia consists of several subspecies that are very similar, and that may be difficult for laymen to distinguish
[12]. Moshe
[15] determined the concentration of pinitol in
Lessertia frutescens in subspecies
microphylla only, and found it to be 14.4 mg/g. Meanwhile, Shaik, Singh and Nicholas
[7] found pinitol to be the most abundant in the field-grown leaves of
L. frutescens at a concentration of 18.17 mg/g, while Mncwangi and Viljoen (2012) reported concentrations ranging between 0.02 and 1.32 mg/g. The field leaves that Shaik and colleagues
[7] used in their study were sourced commercially, rendering it difficult to find more details about their origin. Knowledge of the exact source or location of the samples would provide insight into how the environment may affect pinitol content and allow informed deliberations on the variation of pinitol that is evident. Previously, it was reported that variable geographical locations may result in different metabolite profiles
[48]. These results also demonstrate that the concentration of pinitol fluctuates vastly due to factors such as storage, cultivating and harvesting season and abiotic stress
[7].
4. Triterpenoids
Triterpenes are naturally occurring C30-terpene compounds characterized by isoprene subunits and diverse structures. Terpene compounds are classified into monoterpenes (C10), sesquiterpenes (C15), diterpenes (C20), sesterpenes (C25), triterpenes (C30), and tetraterpenes (C40), depending on the number of carbons in their structure
[49][50][51]. Although often interchanged with triterpenes, triterpenoids are slightly different from triterpenes. Triterpenoids are a collective name for all triterpenes, including natural degradation products, natural and synthetic derivatives, and hydrogenation products
[49][50][52]. There are more than 20,000 identified triterpenoids and the number continues to grow due to the heightened interests in the compounds because of their bioactive capability
[49][51]. Moreover, there are two main groups of triterpenoids, tetracyclic and pentacyclic triterpenoids, with the latter group being the largest, while monocyclic, bicyclic, tricyclic, hexacyclic and acyclic triterpenoids also exist
[51][52]. The structural diversity of triterpenoid compounds is attributed to the enzyme oxidosqualene cyclase process which facilitates the rearrangement of triterpenoids scaffolds to form distinct structures
[51].
Triterpenoid Glycosides
Triterpenoid glycoside is a general term for a natural product, a triterpenoid in this case, attached to glycone compounds
[53]. Researchers continue to isolate and identify novel triterpenoid glycosides from plant extracts
[54][55]. Triterpenoid glycosides act as self-defense agents for plants. For example, Kubanek et al.
[56] established that triterpenoid glycosides served as deterrents for predators of marine sponges. The compounds also exhibit anti-proliferative properties on cancer cells
[57]. Fu and co-workers
[58] isolated and identified four novel triterpenoid/cycloartane glycosides, Sutherlandiosides A–D, from
L. frutescens extracts. The group also established that Sutherlandioside B was the major compound of the four. Furthermore, Fu and co-workers
[58] proposed for Sutherlandioside B to be used as a biomarker for
L. frutescens, a proposal which was refuted by Albrecht and partners
[4] on the basis that the compound is not detectable in all populations and it has not been certified as the main active ingredient. In addition, Brownstein and co-workers
[9] proposed that Sutherlandioside B may have caused a reduction of corticosterone in rats that had chronic immobilization stress, validating it as a potential anti-stress agent in humans.
To date, there has not been a conclusive investigation on the biological activities of the individual phytochemicals of Sutherlandiosides A–D, partly due to complications associated with attaining their pure compounds. Should pure isolates of these compounds be accessible, accurate speculations into their individual biological activities would be achieved. A successful attempt was however made to isolate and purify Sutherlandioside B
[9]. When an antiviral activity assay was conducted for the isolated Sutherlandioside B against Epstein–Barr virus (EBV), very little activity was evident. However, the detected antiviral activity was lower than that of the positive control employed in the study. Moreover, unpublished data from Fu
[59] indicated no antimicrobial activity on the four triterpenoid glycosides, despite increasing their concentration up to 20 µg/mL. The results for the little to no antiviral activity of Sutherlandiosides found in
L. frutescens should however not deter the interests in their health benefits. Rather, it should spur researchers to look into other biological activities of the compounds, because their presence in
L. frutescens is associated with superior anticancer activities
[60].
Albrecht and partners
[4] discovered two types of
L. frutescens ecotypes in samples collected from the Cape, those that contain detectable amounts of Sutherlandiosides B (NC), and others without the compound (WC). The samples for this study were prepared by extracting the whole plant with an acetonitrile: formic acid mixture. The authors speculated that the two types of plants (with and without Sutherlandioside B) were
incana and
microphylla subspecies. However, they do discount the possibility of variation due to different origins and environmental conditions. According to Zonyane and partners
[48] Sutherlandiosides B and C were detected in the ethanolic extracts prepared from the leaves of
L. frutescens collected in the NC, while WC samples did not contain any of these phytochemicals. These findings corroborate what Albrecht and partners
[4] speculated, insinuating that plants from the two provinces are of different subspecies. Studies that explored the variation in the Sutherlandiosides A–D profile to see if they can be linked to specific subspecies concluded that subspecies
L. microphylla is characterized by the presence of Sutherlandiosides B and D
[61].
5. Flavonoids
Flavonoids are diverse polyphenolic class of compounds and secondary metabolites, occurring naturally in plants. These compounds consist of 15-carbon atoms fashioned in three rings as C
6-C
3-C
6 [8][62]. To date, the highest number of flavonoids isolated is 9000
[62], with other studies citing 6500
[63] and 4000
[64]. Thus, the numbers continue to grow due to increasing interest in the health benefits conferred by these compounds when present in human and animal diets. The biological activities possessed by the phenolic compounds include antioxidant activity, weight management, protection against cardiovascular diseases, anti-allergy properties, antibacterial activity, anti-inflammatory effects, anticancer properties and age-related neurodegenerative disease prevention
[62][65]. Flavonoids cannot be synthesized by animals. However, plants, particularly higher plants, synthesize them from phenylamine through the shikimic acid pathway
[65].
Flavonoids are reported to give plants their distinct color, flowers special aroma, and fruit characteristics that attract pollinators
[63]. They also play a vital role in seed germination, growth and development of seedlings
[63]. Pourcel et al.
[66] highlighted the ability of flavonoids to alleviate biotic and abiotic stress in plants. It is reported that the compounds act as UV-radiation filters, thereby minimizing the impact of abiotic stress
[66].
Flavonoids are categorized based on the substrate that attaches to the C
3 ring of the fundamental C
6-C
3-C
6 skeletal structure. Some of the classes of flavonoids include chalcone, flavones, flavonols, flavanones, anthocyanins, and isoflavonoids
[62][65]. Most of these groups have established significant commercial value in the market
[65]. They exist commonly in a glycosylated form
[62][63], and four of them were discovered by Fu and co-authors
[8] in
L. frutescens.
Flavonol Glycosides
Flavonol glycosides are flavonoids with a glycoside substrate attached to the C
3 ring of the flavonol compounds. To date, of the six novel flavonol glycosides in
L. frutescens discovered and discussed by Van Wyk and Albrecht
[12], only four were successfully isolated and identified. Fu and colleagues
[8] established the structures of the four compounds and named them Sutherlandins A, B, C and D. These compounds are quercetin and kaempferol derivatives
[4]. Although they are not major compounds of the medicinal plant, they may be used as its biomarker or to distinguish origins of
L. frutescens raw materials. The findings of Zonyane and co-workers
[48] provide a basis for their use to predict the origin of raw materials, since only samples from the WC province of SA contained Sutherlandin B, while samples from the EC and NC provinces contained both Sutherlandin A and D. Meanwhile, Acharya and colleagues
[61] used the presence of these glycosides to differentiate between subspecies. For example, Sutherlandin B’s presence was noted in
L. frutescens, while Sutherlandin A was found in
L. microphylla.
Although flavonol glycosides may exhibit some of the general health benefits of flavonoids, it is imperative to investigate compound-specific activities. This would only be possible if pure compounds of these glycosides were readily accessible. Thus, the work of Chen et al.
[67] could have an application, provided the yields are improved. Chen and co-workers (2017) reported a yield of 110.4 mg per 0.90 g plant extract, which the authors regard as low and wish to enhance.