A number of preconditioning and engineering strategies have been developed in recent years with the goal of maintaining cell viability, improving cell survival, enhancing cell maturation and differentiation, and promoting angiogenesis. Some of the most prominent are dealt with in more detail below.
4.1. Biomimetic Microenvironmental Approaches
It is desirable for any urethral engineering application that the biopsy samples are best possible protected en route from the donor. With this in mind, researchers have recently demonstrated that the transport of oral tissue samples using thermoreversible gelation polymers provides an optimal environment for preserving the viability of oral epithelial cells intended for tissue-engineered grafts
[21]. Scaffolds that mimic the natural physical environment of cells are also critical to support cell survival, attachment and synthesis of ECM, prevent apoptosis, and facilitate cell migration. In this context, nanofibrous scaffolds fabricated by electrospinning of biopolymers provide an architecture that mimics the ECM and enables the incorporation of relevant biomolecules during the fabrication process
[22][23]. Wang and coworkers have demonstrated the successful reconstruction of the urethra in a rabbit model using poly-L-lactic acid (PLLA) scaffolds seeded with ASCs
[24]. Electrospun silk fibroin scaffolds have also shown excellent results in urethral reconstruction
[25]. Interestingly, three-layer electrospun scaffolds that mimic the architecture of the native urethra seeded with oral fibroblasts and keratinocytes not only supported better cell attachment and proliferation but also possessed the mechanical properties of natural tissue
[26].
Natural scaffolds obtained by the decellularization of tissues may also provide an inductive environment to support cell attachment and maturation prior to implantation. In a preclinical study, type I collagen cell carriers (CCC) with stratified multilayered autologous urethral epithelium were used to perform urethroplasty in minipigs
[27]. The implanted grafts successfully integrated into the host with concomitant development of junctional complexes and differentiation, suggesting that the collagen matrix may improve graft stability. Although the results of using scaffolds that mimic the native architecture of the urethra are promising, it must be emphasized that most preclinical studies have been performed in animal models with transient urethral defects. However, these animal models are very different from patients in whom the pathogenic condition for urethral stricture is scarring of the corpus spongiosum leading to fibrosis.
4.2. Surface Modification and Cell Seeding Technology
Despite the encouraging results obtained so far with unmodified synthetic and natural scaffolds in the field of urethral regeneration, new preconditioning strategies, such as the incorporation of bioactive molecules and the optimization of cell seeding technology are being considered. One such strategy is to functionalize the surface of synthetic scaffolds with naturally occurring ECM molecules or peptide sequences to enhance cell adhesion. Using this approach, Uchida and coworkers modified the surface of polycarbonate-urethane-urea scaffolds, known to have mechanical properties similar to those of bladder tissue, with fibronectin and gelatin, which improved the affinity of urothelial and bladder smooth muscle cells
[28]. The porosity of a scaffold is primarily responsible for the infiltration of stromal cells. However, even in scaffolds with high porosity, spontaneous infiltration takes a long time. Therefore, methods have been developed in which dynamic culture increases cell infiltration of scaffolds
[29]. Compared with static seeding techniques, agitation and centrifugation result in better infiltration as far as the stromal cells are concerned, however, when it comes to the other cell types relevant to urethral regeneration more work needs to be done
[30][31].
4.3. Scaffold-Free Approaches
Cell sheet engineering is a technique widely used in regenerative medicine, including urethral reconstruction. Cells are grown in culture surfaces containing a temperature-responsive polymer, the poly-N-isopropylacrylamide (PIPAAm). At 37 °C, the PIPAAm forms a dense membrane that supports cell attachment and proliferation
[32]. When the temperature drops below its critical temperature (32 °C), the polymer swells and becomes hydrophilic, leading to spontaneous detachment of the cell layer
[33]. This approach allows harvesting of the cells and deposited ECM without proteolytic treatment, maintaining cell adhesion molecules and important growth factors bound to the ECM. Zhou and coworkers used a dog model to demonstrate the utility of the cell layer technology in urethral reconstruction. They created tissue constructs from ASCs, oral mucosal epithelial cells, and fibroblasts that were successfully used for structural and functional regeneration of the urethra
[34]. Compared to conventional scaffold materials, cell sheets exhibit higher cell concentration, more uniform cell distribution, higher cell viability, and no immune system activation caused by scaffold materials. Cell sheets in clinical use today are derived from autologous cells, which reduces the risk of immune rejection, but the current cost required to produce patient-derived cell sheets severely limits their widespread use. Off-the-shelf allografts may be an option in the future; however, further research is needed to determine how to manage risks associated with immune rejection and/or transmission of infection.
4.4. Bioprinting
Bioprinting is a relatively new technology, but it already has shown great potential for producing complex cell-laden constructs that can be tailored to specific needs
[35]. A unique advantage is that it can be used to create different cellular structures to mimic the complexity of natural tissues, which is not possible with conventional scaffold-based technology
[36]. Using 3D printing technologies, Zhang and coworkers fabricated a structure mimicking the structural and mechanical properties of the rabbit urethra
[37]. A 3D-printed spiral tubular scaffold served as a support for two cell-loaded hydrogel layers in the outer and inner surfaces, containing SMCs and UCs, respectively. Although the maturation of the cells was not investigated, this entry provided the first proof of concept that bioprinting is a promising approach to assembling the different layers of the urethra in predefined spatial patterns. In another study, Pi and coworkers developed a multichannel coaxial extrusion technique for printing tubular structures with multiple circumferential layers. With this technology, and using a sodium alginate and gelatin methacrylate (GelMA) blend bioink loaded with human UCs and SMCs, they printed tubular structures that mimicked urethral tissue
[38]. Their results show that bioprinting not only allows for high structural fidelity but also that the cells retain the ability to proliferate and differentiate. These results support the use of bioprinting in urethral tissue engineering, but issues, such as biomaterial selection, fine-tuning of printing parameters, crosslinking time, and mechanical properties need to be addressed to optimize the functional performance of the constructs.
4.5. Bioreactors
Bioreactors are systems that provide a more physiologically relevant environment for cultures compared to traditional static conditions and allow for organ modeling in vitro. By regulating pH, temperature, oxygen partial pressure, cell perfusion, and external mechanical stimuli, these systems support tissue development by providing the biochemical and physical regulatory signals required for cell proliferation, differentiation, and ECM production
[39]. Simultaneous application of biophysical and biochemical stimulation signals in the bioreactors results in synergistic responses that are expected to significantly improve the functional properties of the cells
[40]. Wang and coworkers investigated the feasibility of dynamic mechanical stimulation to promote smooth myogenic differentiation of ASCs seeded on polyglycolic acid (PGA)
[41]. After one week of static culture, tubular cell-PGA constructs were induced by 5-azacytidine (5-aza) and stimulated in a pulsatile flow bioreactor for five weeks. Histological examination revealed that the urethral-shaped constructs contained smooth muscle-like cells and well-oriented collagen fibers. Similarly, Yang and colleagues were able to employ the pulsed-flow conditions to achieve the formation of a fully developed multilayer UC epithelial layer within the tubular collagen scaffold
[42]. In line with this entry, Versteegden and coworkers developed a system to mimic the urine flow stress on the human urethra, demonstrating that mechanical stimulation is critical for maintaining a tight epithelial layer
[43]. While significant progress has been made in the design, construction, and application of bioreactors for urethral tissue engineering, most bioreactors are currently dedicated devices with low-volume output. The optimal culture conditions for different cell types on different scaffolds need to be further optimized.
4.6. Addition of Bioactive Factors
Recent studies have shown that growth factors can be incorporated into the tissue-engineered constructs to meet cell growth and maturation requirements, and also to support the development of a functional vasculature that is critical for graft survival
[34][44][45]. For example, Loai and coworkers, when experimenting with a bladder acellular matrix scaffold coated with VEGF, achieved the formation of new blood vessels as well as urothelial and smooth muscle layers in the constructs engrafted in rats and pigs
[46]. In an attempt to provide for a more sustained signaling, a recombinant VEGF protein containing the collagen-binding domain (CBD-VEGF) was devised, and indeed it was documented as superior to simple VEGF in terms of neovascularization in a dog model
[47].
Before urethral regeneration can become embraced as a reliable option, there is the critical issue of stricture recurrence due to tissue fibrosis, which needs to be resolved. The TGF-β1 is believed to be the culprit, thus targeting its receptor and/or signaling pathways appears of key importance, as exemplified by targeting the canonical Wnt regulatory pathway
[48][49]. In this context, Zhang and coworkers introduced the Wnt pathway inhibitor ICG-001 into electrospun scaffolds
[50]. Urethrography results showed patent urethra in all rabbits of the ICG-001 group, in contrast to the control group where the urethral strictures and fistulas were frequent. Li and coworkers produced a tissue-engineered urethral graft using oral keratinocytes and fibroblasts transfected with TGF-β1 siRNA
[51]. The result was a decrease in collagen deposition, effectively inhibiting fibrosis. Overall, the results of these studies indicate that targeted delivery or inhibition of growth factors in the tissue-engineered grafts is a valid approach that may translate into improved in vivo performance.