1000/1000
Hot
Most Recent
Hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) is a chronic, inflammatory skin disease usually occurring after puberty with painful, deep-seated, inflammatory lesions in the apocrine gland-bearing areas of the body. Paradoxical reactions during biologic treatments may be defined as the appearance or exacerbation of a pathological condition that usually responds to this class of drug while treating a patient for another condition.
TNF-α is a proinflammatory cytokine produced by innate and adaptive immune cells, has been shown to play a central role in HS [2][3][4]. These findings result in the approval of targeted therapy (anti-TNF) for the management of most severe forms of HS [3].
Typical examples of paradoxical adverse effect are: psoriasis (such as palmoplantar pustular), psoriasiform reactions, and HS. These reactions have been mainly reported in patients during biologic treatment for rheumatoid arthritis or inflammatory bowel disease [23]. However, the exact underlying physiopathologal mechanism behind these paradoxical reactions is unknown, although it has been showed that multiple immunological pathways may be involved. Particularly, one of the most important factors behind paradoxical reactions could be cytokine imbalance, which could play a key role in the development of these paradoxical reactions [6].
Although the pathogenesis of paradoxical HS induced by biologics is still unproven, it has been observed that, in genetically predisposed individuals, the introduction of biologics may induce a modulation of the innate immune system, leading to an alteration of the cytokine balance, and an increase in pro-inflammatory cytokines [37]. Nowadays, adalimumab represents the most commonly used biologic treatment involved in the onset of paradoxical HS. Particularly, a recently published multicenter retrospective study reported paradoxical HS under biological agents, with adalimumab being responsible for 48% of new HS onset cases [6]. TNF α inhibitors may cause modification of the local cytokine balance and activate alternate pathways, namely type 1 interferon and the IL 1-related family of inflammation mediators, in selected patients. The production of IL 1b is increased up to 54-fold in conventional HS skin, compared with healthy control skin, and IL 1 receptor antagonists have shown efficacy in HS. Individual susceptibility is required if further up-regulation of the IL 1 pathway is involved in TNF α inhibition, because adalimumab reduces IL 1b levels in conventional HS. It is also important to consider that, due to the larger use of this class in the management of HS, the paradoxical reactions after their use (particularly with adalimumab) are reported most frequently, without implying that there is a higher individual risk of causing paradoxical HS. As consequence, a challenging issue is whether or not to continue anti-TNF treatment after the onset of paradoxical HS. Indeed, a management algorithm for paradoxical HS has recently been proposed which suggested to continue anti-TNF treatment in mild paradoxical HS forms, suggesting a suspension in the case of a progressive worsening, or at the beginning in more severe forms [6].
In order to clarify the role of adalimumab and other anti-TNF involved in HS paradoxical reactions, including infliximab and etanercept, an imbalance has been supposed, induced by TNF blockage in the cytokine pool and a consequent activation of type I interferon or IL 1 beta, together with the possible role of occult infections [51][52]. Although adalimumab still represents the only FDA-approved biologic therapy in HS management, it has also been recently proposed that a key role is played by the IL 17 pathway in HS pathogenesis. Indeed, increased serum levels of IL 17 have been found in patients with HS, as well as a significantly increased quantities of IL 17-producing cells in both lesional and perilesional HS skin, compared with healthy subjects [2][3]. Indeed, anti-IL 17s, particularly secukinumab and ixekizumab, have been proposed as treatment options for moderate to severe HS, being also reported as possible effective therapies in some case reports [4][5][6][7]. Furthermore, secukinumab is being investigated in a phase III trial for HS treatment. Although only a few cases have been reported, anti-IL 17 has been linked to the development of paradoxical HS [5][10][11][34][36][35][37]. Indeed, HS and inflammatory bowel diseases, such as CD, share genetic susceptibility, common clinical manifestations at the gut and skin, and some immunologic features. Some genes, for example SULT1B1 (OMIM 608436) and SULT1E1 (OMIM 600043), have been associated with HS and inflammatory bowel disease. Emerging studies have shown that HS and inflammatory bowel disease are both diseases characterized by immune dysregulation. Cytokine abnormalities, such as the elevation of IL 1, IL 6, IL 17, IL 23 and the tumor necrosis factor, are involved in HS and inflammatory bowel disease. Alteration of the microbiota, resulting in immune dysregulation, also appears to play an important role in both diseases [53]. However, the exact mechanism linking paradoxical HS manifestation and CD is still unclear.