2. Can Polyamines Ameliorate the Damaging Effect of Stress?
Similar to other plant cells, the ability of pollen to withstand stressful conditions is related to its intrinsic biochemical, physiological, and cytological characteristics, for example the production of HSPs or osmoprotectants
[32], as well as the fine-tuning of ROS and Ca
2+ levels and the ability to build a cell wall suitable for new conditions
[33]. PAs have often been associated with the environmental stress response as they interface with various intracellular signaling processes
[11][34], such as phosphorylation
[35] and cation transport
[8].
When plants are subjected to abiotic stress, one possible adaptive response is the increase in PA levels. The literature comprehensively describes changes in PA content in response to altered environmental conditions. For example, during heat and cold stress, PA levels change, and in some cases, PAs might also be redirected to the synthesis of uncommon PAs, the latter being more involved in thermotolerance
[36]. Under cold stress, PA rebalance may increase the synthesis of ABA and/or reduce lipid peroxidation indirectly by inhibiting the synthesis of ROS
[37]. Tolerance to salt stress is also mediated by PAs, which regulate Na
+ and K
+ fluxes
[38][39]. Likewise, under salt stress, Pas might counteract drought stress by controlling Ca
2+ and K
+ flux, thereby causing stomata to close
[40]. Exogenous putrescine can mitigate drought by reducing oxidative stress and increasing the synthesis of endogenous PAs
[41]. In the osmotic stress response, PAs likely facilitate and enhance the synthesis of osmoprotectants
[42]. PAs are also involved in the response to nutrient deficiencies, such as potassium
[43], and in counteracting hypoxic conditions
[44]. The protective effect of PAs against abiotic stresses appears therefore evident, but most likely, the effect is not strictly direct or dose dependent; moreover, the protective effect might be limited to specific cells and distinct time frames
[45].
The association between susceptibility/tolerance to environmental stress and PA levels is also supported by expression changes of genes encoding for enzymes in the PA synthesis pathway in transgenic plants
[46][47][48][49]. Downregulation of the spermidine synthase gene (SPDS) by RNA interference in
Nicotiana tabacum showed that drought and salt stress can be counteracted by changes in PA content
[50]; the mutation enhances tolerance to salinity and drought conditions due to a constant intracellular pool of putrescine (spermidine precursor) and spermine (spermidine product), thus highlighting a different action of the three PAs
[51]. This is confirmed by the Arabidopsis mutant defective in spermine synthesis and consequently hypersensitive to drought and salt stress, whose effects can be mitigated by pretreatment with spermine
[52]. Overexpression of the SAMDC gene in tobacco led to an accumulation of spermidine and to a concurrent increase in polyamine oxidase activity, which in turn increased the antioxidant response
[53]. Similar results were obtained following overexpression of the SAMDC gene in rice
[48].
The effect of PAs on pollen tubes is only partially known, and many details are missing. However, the acquired information may help to understand the role of PAs during stress conditions. When applied to pollen tubes, PAs affect several cytological parameters, such as Ca
2+ and H
+ flux, ROS accumulation and tube shape
[54][55]. Thus, a balanced content and localization of ROS, Ca
2+ and H
+ is likely to normalize pollen tube growth. The action of PAs and ROS is interconnected; PAs may play a role in tip growth as precursors of ROS. In
Arabidopsis thaliana, ROS accumulation at the tip correlates with pollen tube growth. In detail, the ABC transporter AtABCG28, which regulates ROS levels, is localized in secretory vesicles that fuse with the plasma membrane at the pollen tube tip. Deletion of AtABCG28 results in defective pollen tube growth, failure to localize PAs and ROS at the tip of growing pollen tube, and complete male infertility
[56]. Spermidine-treated pollen tubes are initially characterized by progressive changes in shape until growth resumes, despite a larger diameter, concomitantly with extensive rearrangements of actin filaments and pH gradient
[57].
PAs, either produced internally or imported from outside, or directly targeting the surface of pollen tubes, can regulate several molecular processes during pollen tube growth, such as the proper balance of Ca
2+, protons, and ROS. The mechanism is not known in detail, but currently, available data suggest possible pathways, depicted schematically in
Figure 1. In the pollen tube, the exact correlation between Ca
2+ and H
+ fluxes and ROS synthesis is not known, although data suggest that Ca
2+ and ROS may interact. The correlation between Ca
2+ and H
+ fluxes is also unknown, although data suggest that increasing Ca
2+ precedes high growing rates in the pollen tube, whereas H
+ flux follows fast growth
[21]. It is assumed that both Ca
2+ and H
+ enter the apical region and are expelled at the subapical region; almost certainly, H
+ is expelled at the level of the alkaline band, while Ca
2+ can be actively pumped into organelles. As suggested for other biological systems, if PAs trigger active Ca
2+ pumping, this will result in dissipation of the cytosolic Ca
2+ gradient
[58]. If Ca
2+ levels control H
+ content (either by activating H
+ influx or inhibiting active H
+ pumping) and if PAs promote dissipation of the Ca
2+ gradient, this implies that PAs promote more H
+ efflux, resulting in dissipation of the H
+ gradient. The catabolism of PAs produces ROS, which in turn modulates Ca
2+ [8]. Therefore, PAs could first dissipate the Ca
2+ gradient, but the subsequent ROS production due to PA catabolism could trigger a new increase in Ca
2+ levels. Conversely, that PAs can alter ROS levels is well-known and PA metabolism leads to ROS production because of the activity of enzymes such as diamine oxidase (DAO) and PA oxidase (PAO)
[59]. Finally, the accumulation of Ca
2+ levels is also regulated by plasma membrane phospholipases, i.e., phospholipases C (PLC) and phospholipases D (PLD) through distinct pathways. These enzymes modulate cytoskeleton organization
[60], are involved in autophagy-mediated cytoplasmic deletion that is necessary for pollen tube emergence
[61] and that affect the Ca
2+ level
[62].
Figure 1. Diagram illustrating some of the mechanisms regulated by PAs underlying Ca
2+ and proton balance in pollen tube growth. It is supposed that the accumulation of both proton and Ca
2+ ions, highlighted in the apex, depends on their influx through specific plasma membrane channels. Ion channels are under the control of other effectors; specifically, Ca
2+ channels are regulated by receptors and small GTPases that mediate external signals. Ca
2+ accumulation could hypothetically activate proton channels. Ca
2+ levels are also controlled through another signaling pathway; the GTPase-receptor complex can activate the plasma membrane-associated phospholipase C (PLC)
[62], which in turn generates IP3. The latter can stimulate the opening of Ca
2+ channels. The membrane receptor system most likely also activates the production of ROS through NAD(P)H oxidase; in turn, ROS can affect Ca
2+ flux. The action of PAs could be implemented in two distinct ways: PAs could activate the efflux of Ca
2+ in the subapical region, while PAs could contribute to ROS production through the PAO enzyme, thus causing an increase in Ca
2+ influx. The diagram also shows how the activation of PLC can lead to an increase in Ca
2+ as mediated by IP
3 production. Among the membrane phospholipases, phospholipase D (PLD)
[63] should also be recalled because it is responsible for the production of phosphatidic acid, a chemical mediator during stressful conditions.
The question now is: can PAs play a protective role in pollen against stress? Unfortunately, the current literature reports only a limited amount of useful information. PAs may exert a protective role possibly by regulating the levels of ROS, whose content varies significantly, such as under heat stress
[4]. As further evidence, the appropriate dosage of PAs was found to be important in heat-stressed tomato pollen during germination, again underscoring the protective effect of these molecules
[64]. Studies in
Prunus have shown that the protective effect of PAs against stress is dependent on the concentration and type of PAs
[65][66], indicating that the beneficial effect of PAs is calibrated on their concentration and that concentrations above a certain threshold have inhibitory effects on pollen tube growth (PAs often have a hormetic effect, and their action involves a dose/response relationship with a biphasic effect, i.e., opposite depending to the dose). Pollen deformities caused by cold stress can also be restored by the addition of spermidine, which allows for normal growth, possibly by recalibrating the pollen tube oscillatory growth. Although cold treatment strongly alters the pH gradient, simultaneous treatment with cold and spermidine causes no apparent damage, and the pollen tubes maintain their normal morphology. The same ameliorative effect is obtained on ROS levels and Ca
2+ [67]. Further evidence comes from the analysis of transgenic plants. Pollen viability under stress conditions is severely compromised when a key enzyme in PA metabolism (SAMDC) is downregulated
[68][69], suggesting that optimal PA levels are required for proper functioning and pollen tolerance capacity.
The action of PAs in counteracting abiotic stresses could also be carried out in concert with enzymatic activities that metabolize PAs; among these is the cross-linking enzyme TGases
[70][71], whose activity is enhanced by events that increase cytosolic Ca
2+, such as rehydration, light, developmental differentiation and stresses as injury, pathogens and induction of programmed cell death (PCD). In some cases, the action of PAs could be mediated by TGase, i.e., pollen cell modeling, ion fluxes regulation and cytoskeleton organization. For more information on the relationship between transglutaminase and pollen tube growth, readers are kindly referred to more specific reviews
[72].
One chemical form through which PAs could counteract abiotic stress is phenolamides (HCAAs); these are derived from the binding of PAs to phenylpropanoids, particularly hydrocinnamic acids (HCAs). These molecules have been known since the pioneering studies of Martin-Tanguy and coworkers
[73], which led to the identification of HCAAs in the male reproductive organs of maize. HCAs, such as ferulic acid, are bound to the primary and secondary amine groups of PAs (putrescine, spermidine, and/or spermine). HCAAs are pollen specific and synthesized exclusively in the tapetum of developing flowers through the activity of spermidine hydroxycinnamoyltransferase (SHT)
[74]. Based on the current data, the requirement of phenylpropanoids for eudicotyledon pollen fertility is unclear, although some evidence (as in the case of SHT-deficient Arabidopsis with an irregular pollen coat) suggests a structural role in the pollen cell wall
[74][75]. An interesting function of phenylpropanoids is protection against UV radiation
[76]; the binding of all four nitrogen atoms of spermine to HCAAs increases the UV absorbance of a single molecule by about 30% compared to spermidine (which contains only three nitrogen atoms). HCAAs, whether bound to spermidine or spermine, show absorption maxima of 315–330 nm, covering part of the UV-B and UV-A spectrum and thus helping plants cope with this abiotic stress. Finally, HCAAs also play a role as antioxidants and in plant–pollinator interactions. Tris-coumaroyl spermidine, in addition to lipids and flavonols from sunflower pollen, has been reported to stimulate insect feeding
[77]. PAs contain nitrogen atoms that could be taken up by insects for their metabolism. If plant–pollinator interactions are stimulated by a cocktail of metabolites that attract pollinators, this could be one reason for the evolutionary success of angiosperms starting with the pioneer
Amborella trichopoda.
Thus, the role of PAs in mitigating the detrimental effects of abiotic stresses on pollen and fertilization is exerted at several levels, including structural and biochemical. All of this underscores the substantial contribution that PAs can make to plant reproduction, but leaves several questions open, including whether the protective effect is exerted by a specific PA or by an appropriate mix of PAs, which is the optimal concentration of PAs and the best developmental stage for their action.