Latent infections can establish one of four programs of gene expression: type 0, type I, type II, or type III (summarized in
Figure 1). The proteins expressed play important roles in maintaining latency. A number of factors determining which latency program is ultimately expressed have been identified. For example, expression from the C promoter (cP) is essential in establishing type III latency. In type I latency, the cP is silent while the Q promoter (Qp) becomes active. An analysis of the three-dimensional structure of chromatin showed that the latent origin of replication (oriP), a section of the EBV chromosome important in replication and plasmid maintenance
[67], is found near cP during type III latency, but near Qp during type I latency. CCCTC-binding factor (CTCF), which is a zinc finger protein important in creating DNA loops
[68], has been implicated in modulating the association between oriP and either cP or Qp
[69]. Furthermore, poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase I (PARP1) stabilizes CTCF binding and ensures that chromatin remains open during type III latency
[70]. Histone H3 and H4 acetylation provide an additional layer of control over cP and Qp activation
[71]. Establishment of type II latency occurs in the presence of IL-10, which can stimulate LMP1 production without concomitant stimulation of EBNA-2. This indicates that it may play a role in the establishment of type II latency
[72]. EBV-infected cells expressing other types of latency can be converted to type II latency by IL-21, which stimulates latent membrane protein (LMP) 1 but not Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen (EBNA)-2 in type I latency. It inhibits cP and LMP2A mRNA while upregulating LMP1 mRNA in type III latency
[73]. Type 0 latency is seen in B cells that are not undergoing active division
[35].
Figure 1. EBV Latency Types. EBV has four gene expression profiles during latent infection: type 0, type I, type II, and type III. In type 0 latency EBV, few, if any, proteins are expressed. Epstein-Barr nuclear antigen (EBNA)-1 is the only protein expressed during type I latency. Latent membrane protein (LMP) 1, LMP2, and EBNA-1 are all expressed during type II latency. All genes associated with latency are expressed in type III latency, including EBNA-1, EBNA-2, EBNA-3A, EBNA-3B, EBNA-3C, EBNA-LP (leader protein), LMP1, and LMP2. These proteins play important roles in maintaining latency. Notably, non-canonical latency expression profiles have also been documented. For example, infected cells expressing a type I latency profile may also express LMP1 or LMP2A, and infected cells expressing a type III latency profile may not express EBNA-2.
Few, if any, proteins are expressed during type 0 latency. EBNA-1 is the primary viral gene expressed in type I latency, although other latency-associated proteins are occasionally expressed as well. Infected cells exhibiting a type II latency pattern express LMP1 and 2 in addition to EBNA-1. Infected cells with a type III expression profile express all latency associated genes, including EBNA-1, EBNA-2, EBNA-3A, EBNA-3B, EBNA-3C, EBNA-LP (leader protein), LMP1, and LMP2
[35][74][75]. Of note, non-canonical patterns of EBV expression exist. For example, cells exhibiting a type I latency program may also express LMP1 or LMP2A
[76], and cells with a type III latency expression profile may not express EBNA-2
[77].
EBNA-1 is expressed in every lytic expression program except type 0. It contributes to the stability of the latent EBV episome
[78], which is the EBV genome conformation most commonly assumed during latency
[79], by playing roles in episomal replication and mitotic segregation. EBNA-1 activates other latent genes that lead to B cell immortalization
[78] and tethers the viral episome to the host genome
[80]. EBNA-2 is a transcription factor that interacts with DNA through the adaptor proteins, C-promoter binding factor (CBF) 1 and PU.1. It stimulates the C promoter as well as the promoters for LMP1, LMP2A, and LMP2B
[81]. Of note, the C promoter is important in EBNA gene expression
[82]. EBNA-2 is also essential for B cell immortalization
[83]. The best characterized function of EBNA-LP is as a coactivator of EBNA-2
[81][84], but it has also been implicated in modulating other cellular and viral functions, such as apoptosis and cell survival
[85][86]. It has been shown to help recruit transcription factors to the viral genome
[86]. The EBNA-3 proteins are transcription regulators, with EBNA-3A and EBNA-3C acting as oncogenes and EBNA-3B acting as a tumor suppressor
[87]. While EBNA-3B is nonessential for B cell immortalization
[88], EBNA-3A and EBNA-3C are essential
[89]. LMP1 is best known for its role in B cell immortalization, but it is also involved in a myriad of other viral functions, such as cell contact/migration, immunomodulation, changes in gene and miRNA expression, and stimulation of tumor invasion
[90]. LMP2 has two isoforms, LMP2A and LMP2B. Together, these proteins are involved in transformation, proliferation, migration, and latency
[91]. The two isoforms have conflicting roles in B cell receptor signaling, with LMP2A inhibiting B cell receptor signal transduction when expressed alone. Co-expression with LMP2B restored normal signal transduction
[92]. LMP2A is also essential in generating surrogate cell survival signals
[76][93].
In addition to the above proteins, EBV generates a host of RNAs during latency, including BamHI fragment A rightward transcripts (BARTs) and Epstein-Barr virus-encoded small RNAs (EBER). These RNAs play many essential roles in latently infected cells, including but not limited to contributions to cell survival, immunoevasion, cell proliferation, immunomodulation, malignant transformation, and maintaining viral latency
[94][95][96][97][98]. Interestingly, EBER deletions have been shown to have no effect on establishing transformed lymphoblastoid cell lines
[99], and it has been proposed that they act as a backup for LMP1
[100]. By contrast, BARTs have been shown to play a role in latency
[101][102].
Establishment and Maintenance of Latency in EBV Infection
B cell immortalization is strongly associated with latency
[103]. EBV has been shown to stimulate reactive oxygen species (ROS) production in cells
[104][105]. This oxidative stress is required to immortalize B-cells. In fact, Chen, Kamranvar, and Masucci showed that the addition of ROS scavengers, such as N-acetylcysteine amide (NACA) and reduced glutathione, to infected B cells significantly inhibited their proliferation. No such adverse effect on cell growth was noted when ROS scavengers were added to mitogen-stimulated B cells. The authors further found that ROS production was necessary for normal expression of LMP1 and that ROS scavengers decreased signal transducer and activator of transcription 3 (STAT3) phosphorylation
[106]. B cells derived from patients with a STAT3 negative mutation have previously been shown to resist EBV-induced immortalization, indicating the importance of STAT3 phosphorylation and activation in B cell transformation
[107].
The early lytic cycle gene BHLF1 was recently shown to play a role in establishing latent infection and in B cell immortalization. Importantly, BHLF1 protein expression required the presence of the post-transcriptional regulator protein SM, which is only expressed during the lytic cycle. This requirement indicates that the latency-associated functions of BHLF1 are mediated by long noncoding RNA (lncRNA) rather than by the protein itself. While BL2 cells infected with both wild-type EBV and EBV carrying deletions of the BHLF1 open reading frame (ORF) and 5′ promoter region both established type III latency, cells infected with the mutant strain transitioned to a type I latency program by two months post infection. Cells infected by wild-type virus continued to express type III latency genes. This trend was also observed with deletions targeting the BHLF1 ORF alone, although the cells infected with this strain remained in type III latency for slightly longer than those infected with EBV containing deletions to both the BHLF1 ORF and 5′ promoter region. In addition, B cells from three out of four donors infected with either deletion demonstrated impaired B cell immortalization when compared to wild-type EBV. Cells from one donor were transformed equally effectively regardless of which of the three viruses were used to infect the cells, although the authors noted that these B cells appeared to be more sensitive to transformation than B cells from other donors
[108]. Notably, the above experiments on B cell transformation were performed in vitro. There may be additional factors involved in in vivo transformation.
CRISPR screening recently identified MYC, an important cellular protein with many functions (reviewed in
[109]), as a key regulator of EBV latency. Induction of lytic infection in Burkitt lymphoma cells was correlated with decreased MYC expression. MYC depletion resulted in increased expression of BZLF1 and BMRF1 in Akata and P3HR-1 cells, while eliminating MYC caused an increase in the expression of the late protein gp350 in Burkitt lymphoma cells. RNA sequencing analysis demonstrated that MYC depletion resulted in the upregulation of 77 genes associated with the EBV lytic replication cycle. There was a corresponding increase in the EBV genome copy number. MYC knockdown in lymphoblastoid B cells, which have a type III latent gene expression profile, also induced BZLF1 and BMRF1 expression. BMRF1 was not as strongly stimulated in lymphoblastoid cells, which the authors postulated may have been due to tet methylcytosine dioxygenase 2 (TET2) demethylase-mediated inhibition of BZLF’s ability to stimulate early gene expression. gp350 expression was abrogated in BZLF1 knockout cells, indicating that MYC acts on BZLF1 to promote latency. Subsequent experiments indicated that MYC acts on the BZLF1 promoter and interacts with EBV DNA near both oriLyts (origin of lytic replication). Chromatin conformation capture (3C) assay showed interactions between the BZLF1 promoter and the oriLyt T6 R primer as well as interactions between BZLF1 and the T10 primer of the TR region. These interactions did not occur in the presence of MYC overexpression. The authors proposed that loss of MYC results in oriLyt and TR-DNA looping to the BZLF1 promoter to trigger lytic replication
[110].
The same set of experiments demonstrated that factors associated with MYC influence EBV latency. For example, depleting the cohesin structural maintenance of chromosomes 1A (SMC1A) also stimulated 77 EBV genes associated with the lytic cycle and increased the EBV genome copy number. Consistent with these results, MYC mRNA expression was significantly decreased. Likewise, the facilitated chromatin transcription (FACT) complex, which previously was shown to interact with MYC
[111], impacts MYC expression. CRISPR targeting of SUPT16H, a FACT subunit, reduced MYC expression by 65% and stimulated 67 lytic genes. Additionally, SUPT16H and SSRP1, another FACT subunit, are both upregulated by EBV during initial infection. Other proteins in which the CRISPR knockout induced lytic gene expression included STAGA, GCN5 histone acetyltransferase/lysine acetyltransferase 2B (PCAF), and Mediator, which is recruited by STAGA and MYC
[110].
EBV is capable of manipulating C-X-C motif chemokine receptor 4 (CXCR4) expression to maintain latency in EBV-related gastric carcinoma. EBV was shown to increase CXCR4 expression by activating the AKT/PI3K pathway. Notably, LMP2A was found to increase CXCR4 expression, and BZLF1 expression increased in AGS cells treated with siRNA targeting CXCR4. CXCR4 decreased the viral copy number and stimulated LMP2A and EBNA-1. These results indicate that CXCR4 is necessary for EBV latency
[112].
Small ubiquitin-related modifier (SUMO) modification is a reversible physiologic process involved in regulating transcription, remodeling chromatin, and responding to hypoxic stress
[113][114]. Like so many other cellular processes, it has been subverted for use by EBV
[113]. EBV has three separate potential SUMO interaction motifs (SIMs) called SIM1, SIM2, and SIM3, of which SIM2 and SIM3 were shown to be important in EBNA-1’s ability to bind to His-tagged SUMO1 and SUMO2 proteins. SIM2 deletion inhibited EBNA-1 dimerization, while SIM3 deletion inhibited poly-SUMO2 modification of EBNA-1. Chromatin immunoprecipitation (ChIP) assays demonstrated that mutations in both SIM2 and SIM3 impaired the binding of EBNA-1 to oriP chromosomal DNA. Cells infected with EBV containing SIM3 or K477R (a SUMOylation site) mutations as well as SIM2, SIM3, and EBNA-1 with glycine/alanine deletions demonstrated impaired oriP mini genome maintenance. Furthermore, SIM3 deletion and K477R mutation stimulated the transcription of BZLF1, an immediate early protein important in lytic gene expression
[115], while deletions in SIM2 or SIM3 caused increased transcriptional activity of the BZLF1 promoter. Immunoblot analysis demonstrated that SUMO1-modified proteins increased in frequency in the presence of EBNA-1, while SUMO2-modified proteins decreased in frequency. Notably, SUMO2-associated proteins targeted by EBNA-1 were primarily associated with the proteasome regulatory complex and the ubiquitin-dependent Cullin-RING E3 ligase. This indicates that EBNA-1 may target proteins with SUMO2 modifications for degradation. Pathways affected include those involved in the viral life cycle, gene transcription, gene expression, and mRNA metabolic processes. Those affecting DNA and RNA binding were particularly prominent in affected mRNA metabolic process pathways. In addition, proteins associated with EBNA-1 SIM sites were mainly associated with DNA and RNA binding, gene transcription and expression, and other proteins involved in proteasome-mediated degradation. Lastly, the authors showed that hypoxia-induced EBV reactivation stimulated an increase in SUMO1-modified STIP1 homology and U-box containing protein 1 (STUB1) and tripartite motif containing 28 (KAP1), while the SUMO2 modified forms decreased. Hypoxia stimulated the preferential association of EBNA-1 with SUMO2 over SUMO1. It also downregulated the association between EBNA-1 and SUMO2-modified KAP1, which, along with ubiquitin specific peptidase 7 (USP7), make up a SUMO2-modified complex. STUB1 inhibition decreased the EBV genome copy number, while USP7 knockdown had the opposite effect. KAP1, USP7, and STUB1 knockdown cells exposed to hypoxic conditions had higher BZLF1 levels than the control
[116].
Paired box (PAX) 5 is a cellular oncogene involved in activating genes that promote differentiation into B cells and in inhibiting genes that promote differentiation into other cell types
[117]. More recently, it has been shown to physically interact with EBNA-1. Expression of a short hairpin RNA targeting the 3′ untranslated region of PAX5 nearly eliminated the activity of the oriP-Luc reporter plasmid, which is an oriP-SV40-Luciferase expression vector dependent on EBNA-1 expression
[118]. This defect was corrected in the presence of plasmid-generated Flag epitope-tagged PAX5 (FPAX5). PAX5 depletion resulted in a 70%–95% decrease in EBNA-1 enrichment at oriP and a 50%–95% decrease in nucleolin (NCL, an EBNA-1 associated protein) enrichment at TR-DNA, as measured by ChIP assays. This is consistent with a model in which PAX5 is necessary for EBNA-1 to localize to EBV oriP or TR-DNA. It was also shown that PAX5 associates with the transcription enhancers p300 and histone 3 lysine 4 trimethyl (H3K4me3). PAX5 knockdown resulted in the dissociation of p300 from oriP DNA as well as the dissociation of both p300 and H3K4me3 from TR-DNA. EBNA-1 dissociated from both oriP DNA and TR-DNA. Lastly, the authors showed that PAX5 knockdown reduced the EBV genome copy number, a finding that was reversed in the presence of transfected FPAX5
[119].
Subverting histone chaperone proteins is another mechanism by which EBV maintains latency. For example, the chromatin assembly factor (CAF) 1 complex supplies histone 3 and histone 4 dimers to replication forks. Depletion of any of CAF’s three subunits (CHAF1A, CHAF1B, and RBBP4) induced the expression of BZLF1 (an immediate early gene) and BMRF1 (an early gene) as well as numerous transcripts associated with lytic infection. These results were seen in multiple Burkitt’s lymphoma cell lines. In addition, it has been shown that inhibiting EBNA-2 resulted in downregulation of CAF1 subunit mRNA expression. Downregulating histone loader histone regulatory homologue A (HIRA), which loads H3.3 and H4 complexes onto DNA, had a similar result in that it increased BZLF1 and BMRF1 expression. Unlike CHAF1A and CHAF1B, there was no decrease in HIRA mRNA levels. Additionally, targeting alpha thalassemia/mental retardation syndrome X-linked chromatin remodeler (ATRX) and death domain-associated protein (DAXX), which load histone 3.3, with CRISPR stimulated BZLF1 and BMRF1 expression. This indicates that EBV subverts multiple histone loaders to maintain latent infection. Interestingly, reduction in CHAF1B levels decreased the concentration of histone 3.1 and histone 3.3 at the promoters for BZLF1 and BLLF1, and CHAF1B single guide RNA (sgCHAF1B) reduced histone 3.1 presence at oriLyt L and oriLyt R, which are important in initiating lytic gene expression. Levels of histone 3.1 and histone 3.3 were both increased by two days post infection, indicating that these histones are transferred to incoming EBV episomes. The same study showed that CHAF1B knockdown decreased histone 3 lysine 9 trimethyl (H3K9me3) at the promoters for BZLF1, BLLF1, oriLyt R, and oriLyt L, and that sgCHAF1B reduced histone 3 lysine 27 trimethyl (H3K27me3) occupancy at these sites in Akata cells
[120]. Both H3K9me3 and H3K27me3 are repressive histone modifications
[121].
Recent research has demonstrated the importance of miRNA in maintaining latency. Screening identified eight miRNAs (BHRF1-2, BART1, BART2, BART8, BART11, BART18, BART9, and BART17) whose expression diminished nuclear factor kappa B (NF-κB) expression, which was used as a proxy for B cell receptor activation. In addition, BHRF1-1, BHRF1-2, BART14, and BART18 expression significantly reduced AP-1 signaling. B cell receptor engagement leads to the activation of the transcription factor AP-1 via the GTPase Ral
[122]. Furthermore, many targets of EBV mRNAs are involved in B cell receptor signaling, such as growth factor receptor-bound protein 2 (GRB2), SOS Ras/Rac guanine nucleotide exchange factor 1 (SOS1), Ras-related C3 botulinum toxin substrate 1 (RAC1), and Ikk-B. shRNA targeting GRB2, SOS1, or RAC1 resulted in a sharp downregulation of NF-κB. Intriguingly, miR-BHRF1-2-5p targets all three of these proteins. Indeed, miR-BHRF1-2-5P inhibition stunted the growth of both lymphoblastoid and EBV-associated diffuse large B cell lymphoma cell lines
[123]. A summary of mechanisms involved in EBV latency can be found in
Table 1.
Table 1. Mechanisms Involved in EBV Latency.
Mechanism |
Effect |
References |
ROS Expression |
B cell immortalization |
[104][105][106] |
- |
Required for normal LMP1 expression |
[106] |
- |
STAT3 phosphorylation |
[106][107] |
BHLF1 |
Maintenance of type III latency |
[108] |
PAX5 |
EBNA-1 localization to oriP and TR-DNA |
[119] |
- |
Association of transcription enhancers from oriP and TR-DNA |
[119] |
CAF1 |
Inhibits lytic gene expression and increases histone presence at multiple points on the EBV genome. |
[120] |
HIRA |
Histone loader involved in maintaining latency |
[120] |
ATRX |
Histone loader involved in maintaining latency |
[120] |
DAXX |
Histone loader involved in maintaining latency |
[120] |
MYC |
Acts on BZLF1 promoter to prevent oriLyt and TR-DNA from looping |
[110] |
SMC1A |
Contributes to latency by promoting MYC expression |
[110] |
Facilitated Chromatic Transcription Complex |
Contributes to latency by promoting MYC expression |
[110] |
CXCR4 |
Maintenance of latency; stimulates LMP2A and EBNA-1 |
[112] |
SUMOylation/SIM-interacting motifs |
Facilitates oriP mini genome maintenance and the binding of EBNA-1 to His-tagged SUMO1 and SUMO2 proteins |
[116] |
- |
EBNA-1 targets proteins with SUMO2 modifications for degradation |
[116] |
- |
Inhibits BZLF1 expression |
[116] |
miRNAs |
Inhibition of B cell receptor activation by diminishing NF-κB and/or AP-1 signaling |
[123] |