3. Pathogenesis and Virulence Factors
During the infectious process, streptococci face a diversity of changing environments and hence need to adapt to varying conditions for successful infection. As a consequence, they express a number of virulence factors that allow survival and replication in different host tissues during pathogenesis, e.g., by conferring adhesion and invasion to host cells or avoidance of immune recognition and subsequent degradation. The virulence factors of S. uberis, S. dysgalactiae, and S. agalactiae are summarized in Figure 2.
Figure 2. Schematic representation of the bovine-associated streptococcal virulence factors. (A) S. uberis harbors the capacity for preventing opsonization via the synthesis of the protein HasC, capable of masking the antigens present on the surface of S. uberis. Synthesis of Sua and Vru proteins allow binding of the antimicrobial lactoferrin and thus creating a less hostile environment for the pathogen. Lysis of casein through a so far unknown process provides extra nutrients and thereby favors biofilm formation. PauA and SkC proteins confer plasminogen-activating capabilities to S. uberis. The activation of plasminogen to plasmin leads to the degradation of the extracellular matrix, which in turn facilitates bovine mammary epithelial cell invasion. (B) S. dysgalactiae is equally capable of avoiding opsonization via the binding of fibrinogen with the M-like protein DemA, the binding of IgG and the binding of the alpha 2 macroglobulin-trypsin complex via the synthesis of the MAG protein. (C) S. agalactiae possesses virulence factors implicated in invasion of host cells, namely Bca for integrin binding and Lmb for laminin binding. Immune evasion is facilitated via the synthesis of proteins such as FbsA and FbsB implicated in fibrinogen binding. This leads to a decreased risk of opsonization by phagocytic cells. Synthesis of the serine protease CspA allows S. agalactiae to cleave certain chemokines, which are responsible for neutrophil recruitment, further increasing immune evasion potential.
Amongst all the listed virulence factors, a study of 78
S. uberis strains showed that the three most prevalent are the
hasC gene (hyaluronic acid production) present in 89.7% of the studied strains, followed by the
sua gene (lactoferrin binding) at 83.3% and
gapC (plasmin binding as well as immunomodulation) at 79.4%. The
has operon is a conserved gene region present in all strains of group A streptococci and encapsulated group C streptococci. It enables production of a hyaluronic acid capsule that protects e.g.,
S. uberis from opsonization and phagocytosis and mediates resistance to bacterial clearance within neutrophil extracellular traps
[21]. In terms of capsulation, the most well-characterized virulence factors are the capsular polysaccharides coded by the
cps and
neu genes, which are at the basis of determining different Group-B-Streptococci (GBS) serotypes discussed later. The capsular types are labeled as Ia, Ib, II-IX and are critical for grouping the different pathogenic types of GBS. These proteins confer immune evasion by masking pro-inflammatory cell wall components and by mimicry of host-cell surface glycoconjugates. SodA and rhamnopolyene also contribute to immune evasion by detoxifying superoxide responsible for the formation of reactive oxygen species implicated in oxidative stress. The C5a peptidase coded by
scpB is another virulence factor that contributes to immune evasion. C5a is a component of the human complement system, its degradation leads to an inhibited opsonophagocytic killing pathway. In addition to this, the peptidase has been shown to bind to fibronectin, thus contributing to the bacteria’s adhesion and invasion in epithelial cells
[22].
Internalization of
S. uberis into mammary epithelial cells is an important early event in the establishment of mastitis in dairy cows. Possession of the
S. uberis Adhesion Molecule (SUAM), which was suspected to have an affinity to the host protein lactoferrin, seems to facilitate pathogenesis in this context. Lactoferrin is a protein present in human and bovine milk as well as many other mammalian body fluids. The protein has antimicrobial properties as it binds iron, which is essential for bacterial and viral replication
[23]. Since iron demand of streptococcal species is rather low, lactoferrin was demonstrated to have a bacteriostatic effect on different streptococci
[24]. Clinical trials attempted on seven Holstein Friesian cows showed that 67% of the mammary quarters infected with
S. uberis wild-type showed clinical manifestations of mastitis (clots in produced milk, firm and moderate swelling of the mammary glands with red coloration). In contrast, experiments conducted with a SUAM-deficient mutant only manifested mastitis in 28.6% of the infected quarters. Colony counts in milk samples as well as somatic cell counts displayed decreased
S. uberis abundance in the absence of SUAM compared to the wild-type, indicating that the
sua gene could be an important virulence factor. Moreover, SUAM facilitated efficient epithelial cell adhesion and subsequent internalization
[25]. However, other studies have shown that certain factors have overlapping functions with
sua in terms of pathogenesis of
S. uberis. Similarly to
sua,
vru gene deletion has been shown to decrease the pathogenicity of
S. uberis, probably due to its capability of binding the antimicrobial lactoferrin
[26]. This is an indicator that the
sua gene should not be considered the only virulence factor of
S. uberis and that other genes should be taken into account for further research.
Lactoferrin plays a role in pathogenesis of other streptococci as well. After 8 h of exposure to lactoferrin, a dose-dependent growth inhibition of
S. dysgalactiae was observed in a previous study due to the antimicrobial properties of the protein. In addition, assays conducted with HC-11 murine epithelial cells revealed lactoferrin-dependent decrease of bacterial adhesion
[24]. Lactoferrin may serve as a bridging molecule for
S. uberis, consequently promoting adherence and internalization into mammary epithelial cells, thereby surviving host defense mechanisms by immune evasion
[27]. Although
S. dysgalactiae also expresses lactoferrin-binding proteins, allowing interaction
[28] similar to
S. uberis, the effect of lactoferrin on
S. dysgalactiae pathogenesis is quite opposite. The mechanisms of internalization and host cell interaction after lactoferrin binding of
S. dysgalactiae are poorly defined and require further classification to explain these contrary phenotypes.
Besides lactoferrin-binding proteins, adherence and invasion are also extensively studied for
S. agalactiae. Exposure of bovine mammary epithelial cells to
S. agalactiae significantly decreased host cell viability starting 2 h post infection. Electron microscopy showed that adherence of the bacteria was achieved 6 h post-infection with cell membrane breakage visible after 8 h
[29]. Furthermore, host-cell adherence and invasion are facilitated by extracellular matrix protein binding. The main virulence factors for this are the fibrinogen binding proteins FbsA and FbsB, which promote entry into the host cell and by the laminin binding protein Lmb. Serine-rich repeat proteins allow for
S. agalactiae to adhere to human keratin and epithelial cells. The alpha C protein coded by
bca is also shown to participate in cell adherence to epithelial cells
[22].
S. dysgalactiae was found to be capable of binding extracellular matrix proteins such as fibronectin, a main component of connective tissues. This could encourage bacterial adherence and internalization, e.g., to the mammary tissue as can be observed in bovine mastitis
[30]. Furthermore, binding of
S. dysgalactiae to vitronectin was implicated in phagocytosis. Exposure of
S. dysgalactiae to vitronectin before phagocytic assays increased phagocytosis by bovine polymorphonuclear neutrophils
[31].
Binding to extracellular matrix proteins is also a key aspect of biofilm formation, which comprises one of the main pathogenic factors of many bacteria and streptococci are no exception. It was previously demonstrated that the addition of milk to liquid THY (Todd–Hewitt broth with 1%,
w/
v yeast extract) culture led to an encouragement of biofilm formation by up to 800%. A more detailed look revealed that alpha and beta casein were at least partially responsible for the phenomenon that was decreased by the addition of protease inhibitors. It was speculated that the casein proteins were most likely degraded by proteases, thereby allowing
S. uberis to utilize the resulting amino acids as nutrient sources
[32]. Further studies on
S. uberis biofilm formation showed that certain genes associated with biofilm formation were more prevalent than others.
luxS and
comEA (corresponding to quorum sensing and bacterial competence, respectively) were found at rates of 42.8% and 21.4% of the
S. uberis isolates which were used for the study. Given the pathogenic capabilities of biofilms, it would be interesting to unravel underlying mechanisms in order to diminish invasive capabilities of
S. uberis [33]. Furthermore, biofilm formation is suspected to play an important role in
S. dysgalactiae pathogenesis in cases of bovine mastitis as well. An article by Alves-Barroco and colleagues in 2019 showed that certain strains of
S. dysgalactiae were capable of forming biofilms on hydrophilic surfaces and that treatment of these biofilms with the protein fisetin induced a decrease in biofilm formation. Fisetin is a flavonol that exhibits various effects, including neurotrophic, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, and anti-angiogenic effects
[34]. Furthermore, a
brpA-like gene might contribute to the initial steps of biofilm formation. A recent study postulates that this brpA-like protein is inhibited by fisetin, thus rendering the gene a potential target to eliminate
S. dysgalactiae biofilm formation
[35].
Plasminogen activation is yet another virulence mechanism prevalent in the streptococcal genus. Secreted polypeptides, such as streptokinase of
S. dysgalactiae, can degrade fibrin and connective tissue, thereby allowing deeper tissue infiltration. After exposure to streptokinase, plasminogen is thereby activated to plasmin, in turn allowing the hydrolysis of connective tissue proteins and subsequent tissue penetration
[36]. Besides plasminogen degradation, e.g., by streptokinase,
S. dysgalactiae produces a hyaluronidase, which degrades hyaluronic acid. Hyaluron is a polysaccharide present in connective tissues and its degradation is thought to contribute to the tissue invasive properties of streptococci. The
hly gene found in
S. agalactiae is a virulence factor that codes for hyaluronate lyase. The protein is capable of cleaving hyaluronan, allowing for an easier invasion and spread of GBS, similar to the action of streptokinase in
S. dysgalactiae [37][38].
pauA is notable since it was the first described plasminogen activator affecting bovine plasminogen. Furthermore, it encourages the hydrolysis of casein to peptides allowing the bacteria to profit from the resulting amino acids
[33].
skC is another gene which codes for a plasminogen activator. A study by Loures in Brazil has shown that this gene, along with
pauA, is highly conserved between different strains of
S. uberis [39].
S. dysgalactiae has a vast array of potential virulence factors, e.g., facilitating binding to diverse host structures that could push towards potential vaccine agents. For instance,
S. dysgalactiae is capable of binding IgG, therefore interfering with immune responses such as opsonization and toxin neutralization
[40]. In addition to IgG binding, a protein named MAG for alpha2-Macroglobulin/Albumin/IgG-binding can additionally connect to alpha2-macroglobulin and is suspected to contribute to the inhibition of opsonization as described previously
[41]. It was shown that when alpha2M was associated with trypsin to form alpha2M-T,
S. dysgalactiae can attach to the complex, thus creating a dose-dependent inhibition of phagocytosis, thereby significantly contributing to pathogenesis
[42].
Another notable virulence factor for immune evasion is the serine protease coded by
cspA. This protease cleaves fibrinogen and chemokines, but also impairs neutrophil recruitment and phagocytic killing. Serotype III of GBS has been shown to be capable of producing a protein called Rib coded by the
rib gene. Rib is suspected to be one of the reasons for
S. agalactiae host-immune evasion thanks to a structure that confers domain atrophy (a phenomenon where protein domains lose a significant number of core structural elements)
[43]. One final important virulence factor in terms of immune evasion is a superantigen named
S. dysgalactiae-derived mitogen. Superantigens are a class of antigens capable of inciting an excessive activation of the immune system, thereby inducing potentially life-threatening symptoms such as shock
[36].
A versatile variety of other virulence factors facilitate additional essential steps in streptococcal pathogenesis. In terms of bovine mastitis, survival in milk is clearly an important step besides invasion of mammary epithelial cells. The pathogenicity of
S. agalactiae varies and certain strains are more adapted to bovine hosts in that they are more capable of growing in cow milk than their human or fish-associated counterparts. An article by Maoda Pang and others observed that bovine strains achieved a CFU/mL count of around 5 × 10
9 as opposed to the 10
8 CFU/mL of the human and fish strains investigated in this study after 12 h of growth in milk. Furthermore, biofilm formation was more important in bovine-associated strains, showing ODs that doubled or even tripled the ones evaluated in the other strains
[44]. SCC indicates the total number of cells per milliliter in milk, which is increased during infection due to the resulting inflammation. According to the 2013 Bulletin of the International Dairy Federation, milk is considered abnormal when SCCs are higher than 200,000 cells/mL
[45]. SCCs, determined with an automated, fluorescent, microscopic somatic cell counter, were increased when milk samples contained
S. dysgalactiae. Indirect fluorescence labeling targeting neutrophils showed that there was a particular increase in neutrophil recruitment
[46]. In addition, a notable increase in
Il-1beta and
TNF-alpha expression, both being potent inducers of the acute immune response, has been observed via real-time PCR. Further understanding these phenomena could push towards a deeper comprehension of
S. dysgalactiae pathogenesis
[47]. Different virulence traits, however, enable survival of streptococci besides inflammatory responses of the host. For instance, extracellular deoxyribonucleases are shown to aid in bacterial proliferation thanks to the neutrophil-mediated resistance it confers. The enzyme is capable of degrading the antimicrobial system induced by the neutrophils. It was shown in a study by Florindo that all of the
S. agalactiae strains associated with subclinical or clinical mastitis in 121 clinical samples were capable of synthesizing DNAses
[48]. This could imply that DNAse synthesis could be important for the development of bovine mastitis. Further research is required.
M-proteins are the most important virulence factors in streptococcal pathogenesis. It is extensively described in
S. pyogenes pathogenesis although it is a virulence factor present in a wide variety of streptococcal species. Its best-known property is the capacity to inhibit phagocytosis in non-immune humans. However, it has been associated with a variety of functions and was shown to interact with an extensive amount of host proteins, such as fibrinogen, albumin, plasminogen, and immunoglobulins. The N-terminal part of the protein is hyper-variable, leading to antigenic diversity, consequently allowing efficient serotyping of
S. pyogenes. The N-terminal region is also known to induce protective antibody production, turning it into a promising vaccine candidate. In contrast, the C-terminal region is highly conserved among M proteins and can bind to a wide array of host molecules
[49]. An M-like protein was discovered in
S. dysgalactiae and
S. canis, termed DemA and SCM (
S. canis M-protein), respectively. It displays plasma protein binding properties and sequence similarities with the M-protein of
S. pyogenes. Given the importance of the protein in Group A
Streptococcus, it would be interesting to further study the effect of DemA in
S. dysgalactiae pathogenesis
[50].
Group B Streptococcus has a huge set of virulence factors that are quite prevalent in most strains isolated from humans. They have been shown to have a wide variety of functions, such as pore-formation via toxins, immune evasion, resistance to antimicrobial peptides, host-cell adherence and invasion. Pore formation via toxins is another main virulence mechanism of S. agalactiae. Beta-hemolysin or cytolysins are significant virulence factors, which promote invasion of host cells, but also impair cardiac and liver functions whilst inducing inflammatory responses and apoptosis. The CAMP factor is a pore-forming toxin, which attacks the host-cell membrane and binds to GPI anchored proteins. Resistance to antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) is an interesting virulence mechanism for S. agalactiae. Alanylation of lipotechoic acid decreases cell surface charge, thus repelling AMPs. In addition, S. agalactiae has been shown to bind penicillin via a protein labeled PBP1a through a so far unknown mechanism. The expression of pili also contributes to AMP resistance, although not much is known about this process either.
Bovine strains possess much of the same virulence factors as the human strains, yet to varying degrees. In an article by Mohammad Emaneini in 2016, it was shown that 89% of the 48 bovine strains expressed the
rib gene, a value significantly higher than that observed in human isolates, indicating that this gene could be an important virulence factor for bovine-specific cases. However, all of the other virulence factors typically associated with human infections were not detected in bovine isolates. This is in direct contrast with a study by Duarte in 2005, where he showed that the majority of his 38 bovine isolates expressed
scpB and
bca. Even the findings concerning the
rib gene by Emaneini are in direct contrast with a study by Jain in 2012. Jain showed that only 26% of bovine isolates possessed the gene, an incredibly low number, compared to the 89% observed by Emaneini. Overall, determining bovine streptococci mastitis specific virulence factors by comparing those found in human isolates seems to have variable results. The bacteria most likely have bovine-specific virulence factors that are fairly different from those found in human isolates
[10][37][51].
Virulence factors for
S. canis and
S. equinus are rarely described. For
S. lutetiensis known virulence factors are: hemolysin (Hly), α C protein (Bca), superantigen proteins, and C5a peptidase (ScpB)
[52].