Crossover Effect in Cement-Based Materials
Cement-based materials (CBMs) such as pastes, mortars and concretes are the most frequently used building materials in the present construction industry. Cement hydration, along with the resulting compressive strength in these materials, is dependent on curing temperature, methods and duration. A concrete subjected to an initial higher curing temperature undergoes accelerated hydration by resulting in non-uniform scattering of the hydration products and consequently creating a great porosity at later ages. This phenomenon is called crossover effect (COE). The COE may occur even at early ages between seven to 10 days for Portland cements with various mineral compositions. Compressive strength and other mechanical properties are important for the long life of concrete structures, so any reduction in these properties is of great concern to engineers.
COE phenomenon was reported in the literature. However, based on the data reported in some papers, COE could be observed while the authors did not highlight and discuss this phenomenon in the publications. This study is a broad literature review on this phenomenon based on the existing published papers and try to identify this phenomenon in the other published papers those could not discover and discuss about it in the study. In addition, this paper tries to further explain about COE, reason and mechanisms and methods to overcome this drawback in concrete/mortar.
Cement-based materials (CBMs) such as mortars and concretes are the most frequently used building materials in the construction industry . Cement hydration is extremely exothermic in these materials . The hydration process of cement continues for many years at a reducing rate, depending on the water quantity in mixture and appropriate curing temperature conditions . For long-term durability and strength of concretes and mortars, their appropriate mixes should be placed and cured in a proper environment during early hardening by preventing water loss of evaporation from capillaries . In addition, internal water loss by self-desiccation should be replaced by water from external sources . The hydration process and resulting compressive strength of concrete depend on curing temperature, curing methods, curing duration and mix composition . The compressive strength of concrete, along with other mechanical properties, has essential role in the design and construction of all types of concrete structures .
Concretes exposed to accelerated curing temperatures at the early ages gain high compression and splitting tensile strengths at early ages but low compression and splitting tensile strengths at later ages compared with those exposed to moderate normal curing temperatures. The modulus of elasticity of concrete has the same tendency, but the variation in its value with accelerated curing temperatures is not as prominent as that of compressive strength . Fall et al.  stated that splitting tensile strength of the CBMs is more affected by the mechanism of crossover effect (COE) than compressive strength.
Researchers  described that increasing curing temperature of CBMs, such as cement pastes, mortars and concretes, increases rate of early-age strength gain but lowers the long-term strength (see Figure 1). Garcia and Sharp  also reported that concrete exposed to high curing temperatures exhibits accelerated hydration and non-uniform spreading of the hydration products. Such an exposure creates less porosity at early-ages and great porosity at later-ages. It results in increased compressive strength at early-ages and reduced compressive strength at later-ages .
Figure 1. Crossover effect (COE) with maturity and strength at low and high temperatures.
Ogirigbo and Black  described that concrete cured at elevated temperature of 38 °C had less porosity and more compressive strength at seven days than those cured at 20 °C. However, at 28-days, the porosity of elevated temperature cured concrete increased and compressive strength decreased than that of normally cured concrete. Luz and Hooton  studied the effect of elevated curing temperatures up to 50 °C on supersulfated cements incorporating low and high alumina slags. They observed lower porosity and higher compressive strength due to elevated temperatures (38 °C and 50 °C) than the samples cured at normal temperature (23 °C) at the age of seven days. Ezziane et al.  emphasised that under elevated temperatures, cement mortars and concretes have more porous and poorer physical structures than those developed at normal room temperature. They also stated that high temperatures increase strength gain at the early ages, whereas substantial amount of the formed hydrates have insufficient time for proper arrangement at the later ages. This process results in COE, a decrease in ultimate compressive strength of CBMs.
According to the research reports , COE may occur between seven and 10 days in Portland cements of various mineralogical compositions. Weerdt et al.  stated that the initial fast hydration of Portland cement can produce a lesser homogenous microstructure that causes the COE in cements and concretes. Castellano et al.  also reported that such a process of Portland cement can decrease hydration at later ages. This decrease is due to the postponing or ending of the hydration of anhydrous cement. Moreover, the hydration products at lesser temperatures have adequate time to precipitate and diffuse homogeneously in the whole cement matrix. According to Kim et al. , the COE of type V Portland cement concrete is not very clear compared with that of type I Portland cement concrete because of varying rates of hydration.
The COE in CBMs due to accelerated initial and prolonged curing is of great concern to researchers because of the utmost importance of concrete structures in the present construction industry. Some researchers  explained that the loss in compressive strengths of CBMs at later ages is because of different initial curing temperatures. Yang et al.  studied the strength development of concrete due to different initial curing temperatures with ageing (see Figure 2). They found a significant difference in compressive strengths of concretes at later ages because of various initial curing temperatures. At the later ages, compressive strength of materials cured at lower initial curing temperatures were greater than those cured at higher initial curing temperatures. They termed this phenomenon as COE.
Figure 2. COE during strength development of concrete due to different initial curing temperatures. Adapted with permission from , Hindawi, 2015.
According to Lothenbach et al. , the COE in compressive strength occurs in Portland cements, but its occurrence for blended cements having slag , natural pozzolan  and fly ash  is debated. The term COE has recently been used by researchers, but information is insufficient for a detailed discussion of this phenomenon in the CBMs. However, given the importance of mechanical properties and durability of concrete for long life of concrete structures, even any small reduction in the properties greatly concerns engineers.
2. Methods of Accelerating Strength Gain
The strength-gaining rate and hardening of CBMs such as mortars and concretes in the normal curing conditions are slow. Therefore, heat treatment is commonly used in the precast concrete industry to speed up the strength-gaining rate of these CBMs. The application of heat treatment depends on the acceleration of hydration reactions . Under heat treatment application, cement fineness, Portland cement composition, types and amounts of the additives used in blended cements are the main factors to determine behaviour of cements . The degree and speed of cement hydration, the consequent strength of CBMs and other mechanical properties are also directly influenced by the curing process .
3. COE and Mechanism
CBMs exposed to elevated curing temperatures at the early ages attain higher early-age compressive strength, but a loss of ultimate strength may occur at later ages because of the unsuitable arrangement of hydrates during fast hydration. This phenomenon is called COE . The scanning electron microscope (SEM) images of cement paste cured at room temperature and elevated temperature of 60 °C at the ages of three and 28 days were studied by Teixeira et al.  as shown in Figure 3 and Figure 4, respectively. From the images, they observed more uniformly distributed hydration products in the cement pastes cured at room temperature than in the cement pastes cured at 60 °C. The observed that cement paste cured at room temperature had porous microstructure with uniformly distributed capillary pores at early age of three days. This porous microstructure densified due to curing at elevated temperature and an increase in compressive strength of cement paste was observed. A dense rim of hydration product, generally composed of calcium silicate hydrate (C-S-H), was formed around cement particles cured at elevated temperature of 60 °C at the ages of three and 28 days. The concluded that increase in heterogeneous phases in microstructure of cement paste cured at elevated temperature might be the reason of compressive strength reduction at the age of 28 days.
Figure 3. SEM images of cement (ordinary Portland cement (OPC)) paste at the age of three days, (a) cured at room temperature, and (b) cured at 60 °C. Adapted with permission from , MDPI, 2016.
Figure 4. SEM images of cement (OPC) paste at the age of 28-days, (a) cured at room temperature, and (b) cured at 60 °C. Adapted with permission from , MDPI, 2016.
According to the research reports , the detection of COE depends on the range of temperature, duration of testing, type of cement used, proportions of the mineral additions and mineralogical composition of the cement used. Reports from the researchers  showed that an elevated temperature speeds up the binder hydration process and increases the quantity of formed hydration products (for example calcium-silicate-hydrate). Moreover, accelerated curing temperature increases strength gain at initial ages by faster precipitation of hydration products and refining pore structure of CBMs. According to several reports  COE is caused by harder and thicker formation of hydrated shells, low porosity hydration products round cement grains, slow diffusion of hydration products in secondary cement hydration reaction and non-uniform scattering of reaction products in pores of the hardening cement paste at elevated temperature. Kim et al.  reported that COE can appear even after seven days. Kjellsen et al. [ reported that the non-uniform distribution of hydration products results in porosity of bulk cement paste. Additionally, speedy temperature increase during early ages can increase inside stresses that surpass tensile strength of immature concrete, leading to increased porosity, cracking and decreased potential strength.
According to the reports , the rate of hydration and concrete strength increase rapidly by increasing early curing temperature, but porosity increases and micro cracks appear because of non-homogeneous distribution of hydration products and variance in coefficients of thermal expansion of the concrete's ingredients, which finally leads to reduced compressive strength at the later ages. Aldea et al.  stated that the hydration products do not have sufficient time for their uniform distribution within the pores of hardening CBMs at elevated temperature. Consequently, hydrated shells with low porosity are formed near the cement particles by ending further hydration. This non-uniform scattering of the hydration products causes large capillary pores by decreasing later-age compressive strength. Mindess and Young  also reported that steam curing makes the COE by causing great reduction in compressive strength because of less homogeneous scattering of hydration products in the paste due to fast initial hydration.
Researchers  reported that the major cause of the strength reduction at later ages is the shortage of the inner water present in samples to complete hydration. In a common water to cement ratio, internal water is present and sufficient for hydration for the duration of 1–28 days. However, after 28 days, this amount of water may be reduced and become insufficient for further hydration, which will result in strength loss at later ages. Reports by the authors  stated that the lesser hydration reaction of anhydrous cement is also due to delaying effect of the shell on distribution of hydrates in the secondary cement hydration reaction.
This work presents a detailed literature review about the COE phenomenon in CBMs due to accelerated initial curing. The basic concept and mechanism of COE, various methods of accelerating for strength gain at the early ages and reasons for strength decrease at the later ages of CBMs, effect of cementitious materials on COE and materials controlling COE have been discussed in detail. The following conclusions are drawn from this study.
(1) Pure and blended cement products subjected to accelerated curing temperatures show faster hydration and non-homogeneous scattering of hydration products that may result in the COE of their compressive strengths.
(2) The COE in compressive strengths of pure and blended cement products depends on the initial curing temperatures from lower to higher values and the amount of internal water present for hydration.
(3) The detection of the COE depends on the duration of testing, loss of water loss, temperature and techniques of curing, porosity, type of cement used, proportions of mineral additions, mineralogical characteristics of mineral additions and specific surface and composition of cement used.
(4) The COE in pure and blended cement products can appear even after 7 days onwards.
(5) The compressive strength loss at later ages in accelerated cured specimens ranges from 2.2% to 31% at 40–60 °C for accelerated prolong curing.
(6) The COE due to accelerated curing can occur at curing temperature as low as 40 °C.
(7) The COE can be controlled using slag blended cement with 80% replacement of GGBFS by OPC, 25–50% addition of slag powder in blended cement mortars, type V Portland cement concrete under an accelerated curing temperature of up to 50 °C as well as blended mortars with different percentages of natural pozzolan.
The entry is from 10.3390/app9142776
- Hosseini, P.; Booshehrian, A.; Delkash, M.; Ghavami, S.; Zanjani, M. Use of nano-SiO2 to improve microstructure and compressive strength of recycled aggregate concretes. Nanotechnol. Constr. 2009, 3, 215–221.
- Cervera, M.; Faria, R.; Oliver, J.; Prato, T. Numerical modelling of concrete curing, regarding hydration and temperature phenomena. Comput. Struct. 2002, 80, 1511–1521.
- Al-Gahtani, A. Effect of curing methods on the properties of plain and blended cement concretes. Constr. Build. Mater. 2010, 24, 308–314.
- Çakır, Ö.; Aköz, F. Effect of curing conditions on the mortars with and without GGBFS. Constr. Build. Mater. 2008, 22, 308–314.
- Neville, A.; Brooks, J. Concrete Technology Revised Edition—2001 Standards Update; Pearson Education Limited: Paris, France, 1990.
- Li, B.; Mao, J.; Lv, J.; Zhou, L.J.E.J.o.E.; Engineering, C. Effects of micropore structure on hydration degree and mechanical properties of concrete in later curing age. Eur. J. Environ. Civ. Eng. 2016, 20, 544–559.
- Silva, R.; De Brito, J.; Dhir, R.J.E.J.o.E.; Engineering, C. The influence of the use of recycled aggregates on the compressive strength of concrete: A review. Eur. J. Environ. Civ. Eng. 2015, 19, 825–849.
- Kim, J.-K.; Han, S.H.; Song, Y.C. Effect of temperature and aging on the mechanical properties of concrete: Part I. Experimental results. Cem. Concr. Res. 2002, 32, 1087–1094.
- Fall, M.; Célestin, J.; Pokharel, M.; Touré, M. A contribution to understanding the effects of curing temperature on the mechanical properties of mine cemented tailings backfill. Eng. Geol. 2010, 114, 397–413.
- Carino, N.J.; Malhotra, V. Handbook on Nondestructive Testing of Concrete, 2nd ed.; CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 2003.
- Escalante-Garcıa, J.; Sharp, J. The microstructure and mechanical properties of blended cements hydrated at various temperatures. Cem. Concr. Res. 2001, 31, 695–702.
- Ogirigbo, O.R.; Black, L. Influence of slag composition and temperature on the hydration and microstructure of slag blended cements. Constr. Build. Mater. 2016, 126, 496–507.
- Da Luz, C.A.; Hooton, R.D. Influence of curing temperature on the process of hydration of supersulfated cements at early age. Cem. Concr. Res. 2015, 77, 69–75.
- Ezziane, K.; Bougara, A.; Kadri, A.; Khelafi, H.; Kadri, E. Compressive strength of mortar containing natural pozzolan under various curing temperature. Cem. Concr. Compos. 2007, 29, 587–593.
- Castellano, C.C.; Bonavetti, V.L.; Donza, H.A.; Irassar, E.F. The effect of w/b and temperature on the hydration and strength of blastfurnace slag cements. Constr. Build. Mater. 2016, 111, 679–688.
- Escalante-García, J.I.; Sharp, J.H. Effect of temperature on the hydration of the main clinker phases in portland cements: Part i, neat cements. Cem. Concr. Res. 1998, 28, 1245–1257.
- De Weerdt, K.; Haha, M.B.; Le Saout, G.; Kjellsen, K.; Justnes, H.; Lothenbach, B. The effect of temperature on the hydration of composite cements containing limestone powder and fly ash. Mater. Struct. 2012, 45, 1101–1114.
- Castellano, C.; Bonavetti, V.; Irassar, E. Effect of curing temperature on hydration and strength of cement paste with granulated blast-furnace slag. Rev. Constr. 2007, 6, 4–15.
- Yang, K.-H.; Mun, J.-S.; Cho, M.-S. Effect of Curing Temperature Histories on the Compressive Strength Development of High-Strength Concrete. Adv. Mater. Sci. Eng. 2015, 2015, 12.
- Lothenbach, B.; Winnefeld, F.; Alder, C.; Wieland, E.; Lunk, P. Effect of temperature on the pore solution, microstructure and hydration products of Portland cement pastes. Cem. Concr. Res. 2007, 37, 483–491.
- Lee, H.-S.; Wang, X.-Y.; Zhang, L.-N.; Koh, K.-T.J.M. Analysis of the optimum usage of slag for the compressive strength of concrete. Materials 2015, 8, 1213–1229.
- Escalante-Garcia, J.-I.; Sharp, J. The chemical composition and microstructure of hydration products in blended cements. Cem. Concr. Compos. 2004, 26, 967–976.
- Paya, J.; Monzo, J.; Borrachero, M.; Peris-Mora, E. Mechanical treatment of fly ashes. Part I: Physico-chemical characterization of ground fly ashes. Cem. Concr. Res. 1995, 25, 1469–1479.
- Erdoǧdu, S.a.; Kurbetci, S.i. Optimum heat treatment cycle for cements of different type and composition. Cem. Concr. Res. 1998, 28, 1595–1604.
- Türkel, S.; Alabas, V. The effect of excessive steam curing on Portland composite cement concrete. Cem. Concr. Res. 2005, 35, 405–411.
- Neville, A.M. Properties of Concrete; Longman: London, UK, 1995; Volume 4.
- Brooks, J.; Al-Kaisi, A. Early strength development of Portland and slag cement concretes cured at elevated temperatures. Mater. J. 1990, 87, 503–507.
- Ma, W.; Sample, D.; Martin, R.; Brown, P.W. Calorimetric study of cement blends containing fly ash, silica fume, and slag at elevated temperatures. Cem. Concr. Aggreg. 1994, 16, 93–99.
- Verbeck, G.J. Structures and physical properties of cement paste, Invited Paper. In Proceedings of the 5th International Symposium on the Chemistry of Cement, Tokyo, Japan, 7–11 October 1968; pp. 1–32.
- Pimenta Teixeira, K.; Perdigão Rocha, I.; De Sá Carneiro, L.; Flores, J.; Dauer, E.A.; Ghahremaninezhad, A. The Effect of Curing Temperature on the Properties of Cement Pastes Modified with TiO2 Nanoparticles. Materials 2016, 9, 952.
- Tank, R.C.; Carino, N.J. Rate constant functions for strength development of concrete. Mater. J. 1991, 88, 74–83.
- Alexander, K.M. Concrete strength, cement hydration and the maturity rule. Aust. J. Appl. Sci. 1962, 13, 277–284.
- Carino, N. Temperature Effects on the Strength–Maturity Relation of Mortar, Report No. NBSIR 81-2244; National Bureau of Standards: Washington, DC, USA, 1981.
- Carino, N.J.; Lew, H. Temperature effects on strength-maturity relations of mortar. J. Proc. 1983, 80, 177–182.
- Kjellsen, K.O.; Detwiler, R.J.; Gjørv, O.E. Pore structure of plain cement pastes hydrated at different temperatures. Cem. Concr. Res. 1990, 20, 927–933.
- Lee, C.; Lee, S.; Nguyen, N. Modeling of Compressive Strength Development of High-Early-Strength-Concrete at Different Curing Temperatures. Int. J. Concr. Struct. Mater. 2016, 10, 205–219.
- Yi, S.-T.; Moon, Y.-H.; Kim, J.-K. Long-term strength prediction of concrete with curing temperature. Cem. Concr. Res. 2005, 35, 1961–1969.
- Kim, J.-K.; Moon, Y.-H.; Eo, S.-H. Compressive strength development of concrete with different curing time and temperature. Cem. Concr. Res. 1998, 28, 1761–1773.
- Kjellsen, K.O.; Detwiler, R.J. Reaction kinetics of Portland cement mortars hydrated at different temperatures. Cem. Concr. Res. 1992, 22, 112–120.
- Aldea, C.-M.; Young, F.; Wang, K.; Shah, S.P. Effects of curing conditions on properties of concrete using slag replacement. Cem. Concr. Res. 2000, 30, 465–472.
- Mindess, S.; Young, J. Concrete; Prentice Hall: Upper Saddle River, NJ, USA, 1981.
- Mohamed, O.A.J.S. Effect of Mix Constituents and Curing Conditions on Compressive Strength of Sustainable Self-Consolidating Concrete. Sustainability 2019, 11, 2094.
- Sajedi, F.; Razak, H.A. Effects of curing regimes and cement fineness on the compressive strength of ordinary Portland cement mortars. Constr. Build. Mater. 2011, 25, 2036–2045.
- Kjellsen, K.; Detwiler, R. Later-age strength prediction by a modified maturity model. ACI Mater. J. 1993, 90, 220–227