1.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
L. stoechas (
Figure 1A) has a circum-Mediterranean distribution, and it is widely known for its applications in cosmetic, food, perfumery, and pharmaceutical industries
[1]. This lavender is traditionally used as a carminative, antispasmodic, expectorant, anticonvulsant, analgesic, sedative, and diuretic
[2]. It is also widely referred in ethnobotanical literature for the treatment of skin injuries and burns, either as antiseptic or healing/vulnerary of wounds
[2][3].
Figure 1. Lamiaceae species with scientific evidence for their wound healing use in the Iberian Peninsula. Images of the plants (
A)—
Lavandula stoechas L., (
B)—
Marrubium vulgare L., (
C)—
Origanum vulgare L., (
D)—
Prunella vulgaris L., (
E)—
Salvia officinalis L., (
F)—
Salvia rosmarinus Schleid (Syn:
Rosmarinus officinalis L.), (
G)—
Salvia verbenaca L. and (
H)—
Thymus vulgaris L. were obtained from the website Plants of the World Online (
http://www.plantsoftheworldonline.org/ accessed on 4th February 2023).
1.2. Phytochemical Background
Flavonoids, tannins, sterols, coumarins, mucilages, and triterpenoids such as oleanolic and ursolic acids, have been identified as major classes of compounds in its hydroethanolic extract
[4]. Recently, Baali et al.
[2] reported that the prominent compound found in
L. stoechas’ methanolic extract is rosmarinic acid, besides luteolin-7-
O-glucoside, luteolin-7-
O-glucuronide, salvianolic acid B, and quercetin-3-
O-galactoside (
Figure 2)
[2]. On the other hand, and similarly to other aromatic plants of the Lamiaceae family,
L. stoechas’ essential oils may present certain chemical variability. Even though the essential oils from several locations around the Mediterranean basin are mainly characterized by the presence of monoterpene ketones, such as fenchone and camphor, or by the oxygenated monoterpene 1,8-cineole, besides other volatiles such as linalool, linalyl acetate, terpineol, terpinen-4-ol, α-pinene, viridiflorol, camphene, among others
[4][5].
1.3. Pharmacological Evidence
A clinical trial by Vakilian et al.
[6] evaluated the efficacy of
L. stoechas’ essential oil as a wound healing agent in episiotomy, a common perineal incision in obstetric and midwifery. This study included 120 randomized primiparous women divided in two main groups: patients treated with a sitz bath containing five to seven drops of the essential oil, and a control group of patients treated with povidone-iodine
®. On the 10th day postpartum, the incision wounds were evaluated, and 25 patients treated with the sitz bath did not manifest any pain (
p = 0.06), similarly to those treated only with povidone-iodine
®, suggesting the efficacy of
L. stoechas essential oil in pain relief. Furthermore, it reduced redness in the episiotomy area when compared to the control group (
p < 0.001). Following this investigation, subsequent studies have been made to evaluate the utility of other lavender species essential oils on episiotomy healing
[7][8][9].
Regarding the treatment of burn wounds, another clinical trial was performed for 14 days with 111 randomized patients with second-degree burns. This trial suggested that the incorporation of the essential oils of
L. stoechas and
Pelargonium roseum Ehrh. In a cream containing
Aloe vera L. significantly reduced pain in patients with superficial second-degree skin burns, from day 0 to the 7th (
p = 0.014) and the 14th (
p = 0.05), when compared to the control group comprising patients treated with the standard drug silver sulfadiazine
® (SSD) 1% cream
[10].
The wound healing effects of
L. stoechas using
in vivo excision wound models have also been evaluated
[2][5]. From this perspective, using Wistar albino rats, the methanolic extracts of
L. stoechas and
Mentha pulegium L. were incorporated in ointments at two distinct concentrations (5 and 10%)
[2]. During 18 consecutive days the extract-containing ointments were topically applied (0.5 g per rat) once a day until the complete re-epithelization of the excision wounds. A wound contraction of 93.1 ± 2.88% and 97.19 ± 1.06% was observed on the 18th day in rats treated with ointments containing the
L. stoechas extract at 5 and 10%, respectively. Besides that, wound contraction with the lavender-containing ointment (10%) group was statistically higher (
p < 0.001) in comparison with the positive control group, an allantoin-based pharmaceutical formulation. The herbal ointment containing
L. stoechas extract was promising for re-epithelization and cell migration, a critical step in the wound healing proliferative phase. Furthermore, appreciable granulation tissue and higher collagen quantity, without inflammatory signs such as oedema or erythema, were other observed characteristics. The authors further hypothesize that phytochemical compounds such as hydroxycinnamic acids, flavanols, flavones, and flavonols may explain the wound healing activity observed
[2]. In another recent study, a cream prepared with the essential oil of
L. stoechas at 0.5% showed the highest effect on excision wound models compared to the reference Madecassol
®, a registered therapeutic cream. On the 4th, 11th, and 16th day, wound contractions were, respectively, 26.4%, 78%, and 96.3% for the group of rats treated with this herbal formulation, compared to 8.5%, 64.1%, and 86.1% for the control group. The authors concluded that the
L. stoechas cream induced a significant decrease in the epithelization period, wound area and scar thickness, along with a significant increase in wound contraction. Moreover, this treatment also resulted in decreased inflammatory parameters and a great rate of tissue perfusion and proliferation, as well as remodeling and re-epithelization
[5].
The capacity of
L. stoechas to induce fibroblast proliferation and consequent
in vitro wound healing was also explored in another study using an aqueous extract. This revealed that the growth and migration of fibroblasts was promoted at 24, 48, and 72 h transducing in a wound closure of 21.3%, 27.4%, and 29.2%, respectively
[11].
Before the scientific evidence around
L. stoechas, new drug delivery systems have been designed. Therefore, Mahmoudi et al.
[12] synthesized silver nanoparticles (AgNPs) with a reductant methanolic extract of
L. stoechas [12]. AgNPs presented antioxidant properties and antibacterial potential against
S. aureus and
P. aeruginosa which are common wound infecting bacteria. As these nanoparticles exhibited biocompatibility at an effective and non-toxic concentration (62.5 μg/mL), authors suggest their application for wound healing
[12]. It is worth mentioning that other investigations have been carried out to develop innovative strategies for drug delivery of essential oils from other
Lavandula species
[13].
2. Marrubium vulgare L.
2.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
In traditional medicine,
M. vulgare (
Figure 1B) is mostly used to treat gastrointestinal and respiratory diseases
[14], and also for several skin conditions, either in the Iberian Peninsula
[15] or in other countries of the Mediterranean region
[16][17]. Interestingly, the scientific-based wound healing activity of this Lamiaceae has received some attention in the Mediterranean basin
[16][18][19].
2.2. Phytochemical Background
M. vulgare is a poor essential oil-bearing plant with low extraction yields ranging between 0.03% and 0.06%. However, several monoterpenes have been identified in its essential oil, such as camphene,
p-cymol, fenchone, limonene, α-pinene, sabinene, and α-terpinolene (
Figure 2)
[14]. Considering terpenoids,
M. vulgare is enriched in several diterpenes such as the labdane-type diterpene marrubin. This is responsible for the plant’s bitter characteristic and it is also a chemotaxonomic marker for the genus
Marrubium [14][18]. The triterpenoids lupeol and oleanolic acid, as well as phytosterols such as β-sitosterol, have been reported for this Lamiaceae species
[14]. On the other hand, the flavonoid family in
M. vulgare is mainly represented by flavones such as luteolin, ladanein, and apigenin, flavone derivatives such as apigenin-7-
O-glucoside and luteolin-7-
O-glucoside, and the flavonol derivatives quercetin-3-
O-galactoside and rutin. For a long time, and since this plant is part of the Lamioideae subfamily, rosmarinic acid was thought to be absent. However, a few reports have shown its presence in M. vulgare extracts and caffeic, ferulic, and chlorogenic acids
[14].
2.3. Pharmacological Evidence
Recently, Mssilou et al.
[16] assessed the activity of the hydroethanolic extract of
M. vulgare to heal skin burns induced on the dorsal part of rats during a period of 21 days. The hydroethanolic extract of
Dittrichia viscosa (L.) Greuter and the ointment-based combination with
M. vulgare extract was equally investigated. According to the observations, the topical application of the ointment with
M. vulgare extract, also in combination with
D. viscosa, recorded remarkable and progressive wound closure at the 21st day, when compared to the controls that were unable to induce complete wound healing in the same period of time. Moreover, equal promising results were observed for inflammation and pain, other key parameters of the wound healing process
[16]. Indeed, de Souza et al.
[20] demonstrated the analgesic properties of an hydroalcoholic extract of
M. vulgare regarding different models of pain in mice. In another study, Yahiaoui et al.
[19] showed that the acetonic extract of
M. vulgare improved the quality of the scar tissue and wound contraction by around 93.79% after 14 days, compared to control rats treated with Madecassol
® with a wound closure of around 96.55%.
Amri et al.
[18] conducted an
in vitro cell-based investigation with a methanolic extract. Authors found that in a non-toxic concentration (5 μg/mL), the extract showed to promote migration and proliferation of dermal fibroblasts (NHDF cell line), reaching complete confluence after 48 h of extract application. Besides that, the aqueous extract of
M. vulgare demonstrated not only antioxidant potential, but also interesting hemostatic activity. The latter is suggested to arise from the presence of condensed tannins, which are well-known for their astringency activity. In fact, tannins are important hemostatic agents working positively in wound and burn healing. Moreover, they observed that wound healing is independent from the presence of the diterpene marrubiin
[21].
3. Origanum vulgare L.
3.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
O. vulgare (
Figure 1C), commonly known as oregano, is a widespread herbaceous Lamiaceae found in Europe, North Africa, America, and Asia. A wide range of activities have been scientifically evidenced such as antimicrobial, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, antitumor, antihyperglycemic, and anti-Alzheimer activities and in skin disorders
[22]. Its ethnopharmacological uses are mainly related to respiratory conditions, such as cold symptoms, including cough, as well as digestive disorders and dermatological affections
[1][22][23]. In the Catalonian region of Ripollès district, Spain, there are reports of using
O. vulgare’s flowers in embrocation for their vulnerary properties
[24].
3.2. Phytochemical Background
O. vulgare is a rich essential oil-bearing plant and for this reason, the most relevant family of phytochemicals are the volatiles found in its essential oil. According to the analysis of several oregano essential oils, they are chemically polymorphic, existing with several chemotypes based on major compounds. Monoterpene phenolics such as carvacrol and thymol are prominent in oregano essential oils, along with linalool, γ-terpinene,
p-cymene, and the sesquiterpenes β-caryophyllene and germacrene D. Besides essential oils,
O. vulgare is also a rich source of flavonoids, tannins, and phenolic glycosides. From this point of view, luteolin-
O-glucuronide and luteolin-7-
O-glucoside have been pointed out as main flavonoid derivatives found in hydroalcoholic extracts, decoctions, and infusions. Smaller molecules such as caffeic, protocatechuic, vanillic, and
o-coumaric acids have been equally identified, with rosmarinic acid as the major phenolic acid (
Figure 2)
[22].
Figure 2. Chemical structures of the most relevant phytochemicals found among Iberian Lamiaceae species with wound healing scientific validation. Chemical structures were designed using ChemDraw software.
3.3. Pharmacological Evidence
In a randomized pilot petrolatum-controlled clinical trial, an ointment containing an
O. vulgare aqueous extract was tested by topical application, twice a day, on patients with excision wounds. The group treated with
O. vulgare ointment presented a significant improvement in comparison to the petrolatum-treated group regarding skin pigmentation, vascularization, thickness, relief, and pliability. It is worth mentioning that the ointment proved to be a good antimicrobial product on post-surgical excision injuries, namely against
S. aureus [25].
The design of innovative drug delivery systems has been pursued by some authors
[26][27][28]. In this sense, considering
in vivo excision wound models, a study on synthesized titanium dioxide nanoparticles (TiO
2.NPs) loaded with an oregano aqueous extract was made. Rats treated with TiO
2.NPs presented a wound closure of 94% on the 12th day of evaluation while the control group remained at 86%. In addition, animals under this treatment showed an increased collagen content and degree of re-epithelization, as well better fibroblasts and macrophages aggregation
[27]. Recently, a biocompatible pharmaceutical formulation with potential wound dressing was designed to overcome the instability and skin irritancy that may arise from the direct application of essential oils. In this study, the essential oil of
O. vulgare was encapsulated in a poly (L-lactide-co-caprolactone) (PLCL)/silk fibroin (SF) nanofiber membrane through electrospinning. Results from the
in vivo assays showed that the designed therapeutic system improved re-epithelialization and the formation of granulation tissue, and it also stimulated angiogenesis and collagen accumulation
[26]. Afterwards,
in vivo diabetic wound models were studied by the same team where the co-delivery nanofibrous membranes loaded with two bioactives, the essential oil of
O. vulgare and zinc oxide, were tested. The bioactive multifunctional nanofibrous wound dressing system was revealed to promote tissue regeneration, re-epithelialization and collagen accumulation. Besides that, and according to the observed expression of VEGF, the angiogenic response was highly stimulated as well. The observations highlighted that the typical inflammatory process in diabetic wounds was also inhibited
[28].
On the other hand, according to an
in vitro scratch-based assay, the application of
O. vulgare essential oil (25 μg/mL) promoted cell migration after 72 h
[29]. Additionally, investigators stimulated keratinocytes with IFN-γ and histamine to induce ROS generation. They found that ROS levels were significantly reduced, along with the levels of inflammation and of the matrix metalloproteinase biomarkers
[29]. Similarly, in another work, pre-inflamed human dermal fibroblasts were treated with
O. vulgare essential oil, showing to inhibit both inflammatory and tissue remodeling biomarkers. In the end, authors suggested that the tested carvacrol-rich essential oil is a potential ingredient for skin-related products with anti-inflammatory activity
[30]. Interestingly, carvacrol and thymol, phenolic monoterpenes abundant in the essential oils of plants from
Origanum sp. and
Thymus sp. genera, have demonstrated beneficial wound healing properties. According to Costa et al.
[31], these monoterpenes act in the three distinct phases of the wound healing process: reducing inflammation, excessive ROS production, and infection, followed by the enhancement of angiogenesis, re-epithelialization, and tissue remodeling with final collagen synthesis along with the proliferation of dermal fibroblasts and epidermal keratinocytes.
4. Prunella vulgaris L.
4.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
According to its ethnopharmacological uses,
P. vulgaris (
Figure 1D) is used around the world to treat several skin conditions
[32]. In the Iberian Peninsula, its traditional topical application is mostly associated with its antiseptic activity, with flowers used in infusions or decoctions for washes and baths
[24][33][34]. Vulnerary and healing properties are equally attributed to this plant species, being topically applied as a cataplasm or in baths for wounds healing
[24][35].
4.2. Phytochemical Background
Triterpenoids is the major and most important phytochemical group in
P. vulgaris. They are skeletons of 30 atoms of carbon divided in three main types, oleanane, ursane, and lupane, and they may be present in the free, ester, or glycosylated form. In
P. vulgaris, oleanolic acid and ursolic acid are pointed as the main triterpenoids (
Figure 2)
[36][37]. Steroids are also present and are mainly represented by phytosterols and their derived saponins, such as sitosterol and stigmasterol
[37]. Other sterols have also been identified, such as daucosterol and α-spinasterol
[36]. Besides triterpenes and sterols, a wide range of flavonoids have been equally identified, such as homoorientin, wogonin, quercetin-3-
O-β-D-rhamnoside, kaempferol-3-
O-β-D-glucoside, hesperidin, and acacetin-7-
O-β-D-glucopyranoside
[36]. Considering phenolic-derived compounds,
P. vulgaris is rich in coumarins such as umbelliferone, scopoletin, and esculetin, and in phenolic acids such as rosmarinic, caffeic, and ellagic acids, the most important given the several associated pharmacological activities
[36][37][38].
4.3. Pharmacological Evidence
Recently, the wound healing activity of the
P. vulgaris was assessed in an
in vivo bioactivity-guided fractionation assay from its methanolic extract. Extracts at 1% were incorporated in ointment formulations and topically applied on wound models (incision and circular excision). Findings showed that, in the incisional wound, the ethyl acetate extract increased 39.3% of the tensile strength of the wound, while in the excisional wound a wound contraction of around 86.3% was observed after 12 days. Six bioactive compounds (ethyl rosmarinate, methyl arjunolate, ursolic acid, chlorogenic acid, rosmarinic acid, and methyl-3-epimaslinate) were identified in the ethyl acetate sub-extract proving to be the most effective for wound healing. Furthermore, ursolic, chlorogenic, and rosmarinic acids were shown to positively influence the anti-inflammatory and wound healing effects of
P. vulgaris [32].
The thermal-induced wound healing properties of
P. vulgaris were investigated in aqueous extracts. The
in vivo study was performed for 14 days, and the plant-derived extract (10%) was incorporated in a cream, showing a better healing capacity for burn wounds when compared to the standard SSD
® cream. According to these findings, the topical application of
P. vulgaris stimulated collagen production and antioxidant efficiency by lipid peroxidation suppression, a decrease in inflammation, along with an increase in the proliferation of keratinocytes, leading ultimately to wound contraction and re-epithelialization by the 14th day
[38].
5. Salvia officinalis L.
5.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
S. officinalis (
Figure 1E), known as common sage or garden sage, is widely used as a seasoning and flavoring condiment in culinary arts. In traditional medicine, it is used for different ailments
[39]. This species has, in fact, been the focus of careful scientific validation. Hence, numerous pharmacological activities have been reported such as anticancer, anti-inflammatory, antinociceptive, antioxidant, antimicrobial, antimutagenic, antidementia, hypoglycemic, and hypolipidemic
[40]. The aerial parts have been used for wounds in the Iberian Peninsula, specifically through infusion used for baths and washes, to clean and enhance wound healing
[41][42][43].
5.2. Phytochemical Background
More than 120 different compounds have been identified in sage’s essential oils. Furthermore, this plant species presents chemical variations according to the parts used for extraction. Linalool is the main compound in stems, α-pinene and 1,8-cineole are predominant in the flowers, while bornyl acetate, camphene, camphor, humulene, limonene, and thujone are predominant in essential oils extracted from leaves (
Figure 2). Besides, alcoholic and aqueous extracts have mainly flavonoids, such as luteolin-7-glucoside, while methanolic extracts present appreciable amounts of phenolic acids, such as caffeic and 3-caffeoylquinic acids. On the other hand, the infusion of
S. officinalis has rosmarinic and ellagic acids as major bioactive compounds
[44].
5.3. Pharmacological Evidence
Karimbazeh et al.
[45] evaluated the potential of the hydroethanolic leaf extract of
S. officinalis. Firstly, a circular excision full-thickness wound was inflicted on the anterior-dorsal side of each rat to study the wound contraction ratio, period of re-epithelization, and histopathological change. Then, an incision wound was made through the skin and cutaneous muscle in the right side of depilated back. Ointments consisting of Eucerin
® (25%) and Vaseline
® (75%) with hydroethanolic extract of
S. officinalis at 1, 3, and 5% were prepared and then topically applied once a day for 9 days. On the 10th day there was no sign of acute skin irritation in all tested animals. The highest tested concentration (5%) allowed an increase of the wound contraction and breaking strength ratio, and it also reduced the period of re-epithelialization. An increase in hydroxyproline content in dead space wounds was observed when compared to the control group, as it also promoted the formation of granulation tissue. Furthermore,
S. officinalis proved to up-regulate macrophage and fibroblast distribution, increasing collagen deposition and promoting the proliferative stage of wound healing.
On the other hand, a study by Farahpour et al.
[46] assessed the effect of
S. officinalis’ essential oil on infected wounds. After inoculation with
P. aeruginosa and
S. aureus and the infliction of circular full-thickness wounds, ointments containing 2 and 4% of
S. officinalis’ essential oil were applied once a day for 14 days. It showed a shortening of the inflammatory phase of the healing process once pro-inflammatory cytokines expression was reduced. Furthermore, cellular proliferation was stimulated via the upregulation of cyclin-D1 and Bcl-2 expression. By regulating FGF-2 and VEGF expressions,
S. officinalis promotes neovascularization and tissue antioxidant status. In another study, Eshani et al.
[47] used
S. officinalis aqueous extract to synthesize ZnO/magnetite-based nanocomposites (ZnO/Mgt-NCs) that were further tested in both
in vitro and
in vivo experiments using infected wound models. Firstly, the
in vitro assay demonstrated strong antibacterial properties when tested against
Streptococcus pyogenes and
P. aeruginosa. As for the
in vivo assay, it revealed an improvement of the histological parameters and a decrease of the bacterial population growth on wounds treated with ZnO/Mgt-NCs. Additionally, granulation tissue, collagen density, and epithelization were improved. In turn, the development of a novel polyvinyl alcohol-based (PVA) nanofiber mat loaded with bioactive compounds from
Hypericum perforatum L.,
S. officinalis, and
T. vulgaris also revealed interesting antioxidant and antimicrobial activities, proving the potential of the innovative formulation
[48].
6. Salvia rosmarinus Schleid. (Syn: Rosmarinus officinalis L.)
6.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
According to the most recent phylogenetic criteria, the former scientific name
Rosmarinus officinalis L. is considered a synonym of the currently accepted
Salvia rosmarinus Schleid. (
Figure 1F), since the genus
Rosmarinus was merged into the genus
Salvia [49]. Several ethnobotanical surveys report the healing effect of rosemary, either for wounds or burns, in the Portuguese traditional medicine
[34][42][50][51]. Likewise, in Spain, Benítez et al.
[3] reports the application of its essential oil to heal skin injuries, and Aceituno
[52] states the vulnerary effect of a cataplasm made with leaves, while in Navarra this plant is traditionally used for the treatment of wounds, boils, and furuncles
[41].
6.2. Phytochemical Background
Since several chemotypes have been reported, most of the volatile compounds found in rosemary essential oil are monoterpenes, the most common ones being α-pinene, 1,8-cineole, borneol, limonene, and the ketones camphor and verbenone. Similarly, the sesquiterpene β-caryophyllene has been also identified
[49][53][54]. Diterpenes such as rosmarol, carnosol, and carnosic acid, as well triterpenes such as ursolic and oleanolic acids have been found in appreciable amounts (
Figure 2). The anti-inflammatory activity of rosemary is actually related to their synergic activity
[49]. Phenolic acids such as rosmarinic and caffeic acids, and the flavonoids class (eriocitrin, luteolin 3′-
O-β-D-glucuronide, hesperidin, diosmin, isoscutellarein 7-
O-glucoside, hispidulin 7-
O-glucoside, and genkwanin), comprise other important bioactive compounds found in the extracts of
S. rosmarinus [49][54].
6.3. Pharmacological Evidence
Once it is one of the topmost validated Lamiaceae species, a monograph about this medicinal plant can be found in the European Medicines Agency
[55] and two other monographs are comprised in the European Pharmacopoeia
[56].
S. rosmarinus finds important applications, namely in the food industry as a food additive and preservative
[53], or as an active ingredient in cosmetic formulations
[49].
Regarding the upcoming scientific evidence on the wound healing effect of
S. rosmarinus, a recent clinical trial was conducted with 80 primiparous women to evaluate the healing effect of a rosemary cream on episiotomy. Results of this study indicated that on the 10th day postpartum, the group of women treated twice a day with rosemary cream had a statistically higher (
p < 0.001) rate of episiotomy healing when compared to the placebo group
[57].
The effects of S.
rosmarinus on treating diabetic wounds have also been investigated. Abu-Al-Basal
[58] studied its effect in alloxan-induced diabetic mice. After the infliction of full-thickness excision wounds, a group of mice was treated with
S. rosmarinus essential oil (25 μL) twice a day for 3 days, while another group was submitted to an intraperitoneal injection of aqueous rosemary extract (10%) (0.2 mL), following an evaluation for 15 days. Statistically significant positive differences (
p < 0.01) were found between rosemary-derived treatments and control groups. Furthermore, the essential oil treatment was more effective than the aqueous extract exhibiting an evident amelioration of several parameters related to the wound healing process. Similarly, Umasankar et al.
[59] also confirmed the positive role of the essential oil of
S. rosmarinus for wound closure of both streptozotocin-induced diabetic rats and non-diabetic rats. It is worth mentioning that a rosemary extract (5%) was also tested on full-thickness wounds inflicted on rabbits and the effect compared with povidone-iodine
® and isotonic saline solution
[60].
In another interesting study, the wound healing effect of the essential oil of
S. rosmarinus and
Melaleuca alternifolia Cheel, in combination or separated, in chitosan-loaded formulations, were evaluated
in vivo on excision wounds inflicted on rats. It was observed that the most successful chitosan-derived formulation was the one loaded with the combination of both essential oils, presenting a full re-epithelization with activated hair follicles, comparable to the positive control
[61]. For instance, Khezri et al.
[62] focused on encapsulated essential oil into nanostructured lipid carriers (EO-NLCs). Accordingly, gels with EO-NLCs and with only essential oil were prepared and applied to heal full-thickness wounds infected with
S. aureus and
P. aeruginosa. Results showed that EO-NLCs had antibacterial activity while promoting
in vivo wound closure, angiogenesis, fibroblast infiltration, re-epithelialization, and collagen production. Moreover, an increase in key wound healing cytokines reduced inflammation and edema, while an increase in serum levels of VEGF may explain the observed positive angiogenic response
[62]. Recently, Gavan et al.
[63] aimed to develop carbomer-based hydrogel wound dressings containing ethanolic extracts of
S. rosmarinus and two other plants (
Achillea millefolium L. and
Calendula officinalis L.). The
S. rosmarinus loaded hydrogel was a promising formulation for wound healing therapy, similar to the hydrogel loaded with the mixture of the three studied extracts
[63].
The healing effect of rosemary on burn wounds has also been tested by other authors
[64][65][66][67]. Regarding the
in vivo thermal-induced wounds, the activity of two different ointments prepared with
S. rosmarinus and
Populus alba L. essential oils was studied. Results at the end of 25 days of study showed
S. rosmarinus’ ointment to have a bigger wound contraction of 4.44 ± 0.07 cm
2 compared to only 1.06 ± 0.44 cm
2 for the Madecassol
® control group. Rosemary essential oil did not show acute toxicity and this report also suggests a significant healing activity during the proliferative phase of the wound healing process
[65]. Recently, Khalil et al.
[66] revealed the potential of an acetonic extract of
S. rosmarinus against multidrug resistant pathogens that frequently infect burn wounds.
An Eucerin
®-based cream containing rosemary’s essential oil at 2 and 4% was tested on excision wounds infected by
Candida albicans. The 4% preparation yielded the best results compared to the other groups with a remarkable decrease in the infection and inflammation parameters. It also improved fibroblast proliferation, leading to complete wound contraction on the 16th day of the experiment
[68]. The effect of Eucerin
®-based formulations with rosemary extracts at different concentrations (15, 10 and 5%) was also evaluated on excision wounds of rats
[69], as well as the effect of rosemary’s essential oil regarding the healing of skin lesions of mice
[70]. In turn, one study evaluated in Wistar albino rats after plastic surgery reported the potential of rosemary’s essential oil to increase skin flaps survival, encompassing the avoidance of necrosis
[71].
7. Salvia verbenaca L.
7.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
S. verbenaca (
Figure 1G) is a widespread
Salvia species occurring in the Mediterranean region but also around Europe and in Asia
[72]. This species exhibits various bioactive properties such as antibacterial, anticancer, antioxidant, antileishmanial, antidiabetic, immunomodulatory, and wound healing
[72].
In Morocco,
S. verbenaca is topically applied for burns healing and abscesses
[73]. Regarding the Iberian traditional medicine, in Sierra Norte de Madrid (Spain), the leaves of
S. verbenaca are macerated and prepared in olive oil as a vulnerary treatment for burns and wounds
[52]. Benítez et al.
[3] reported that in Western Granada (Spain), a decoction of the whole plant is used to treat skin injuries. Meanwhile, in the Ripollès district, Catalonia (Spain), the leaves are externally applied as an ointment to relieve pain and stimulate burns healing, thus functioning as an antipyrotic agent
[24].
7.2. Phytochemical Background
The chemical constitution of
S. verbenaca has been analyzed from several plant organs, in both wild and cultivated plants, revealing mainly flavonoids, terpenoids, phenolic acids, alkaloids
[72], and fatty acids
[73]. The terpenoids identified in
S. verbenaca’s essential oil are mostly α-pinene, β-pinene, sabinene, 1,8-cineole, β-phellandrene, linalool,
p-cymene, linalyl acetate, (E)-β-ocimene, (Z)-β-ocimene, tricyclene, camphor, among many others. For instance, the phenolic acids identified in methanolic extracts were
p-hydroxybenzoic acid, vanillic acid, rosmarinic acid,
p-coumaric acid, caffeic acid, and phenolic diterpenes. Similarly, carnosol, carnosic acid, and methyl carnosate have also been identified (
Figure 2)
[72]. As for the main unsaturated fatty acids, linolenic and linoleic acids were assigned
[73].
7.3. Pharmacological Evidence
Guaoguao et al.
[74] explored the effect of
S. verbenaca extracts for the healing of second-degree burn injuries, in an SSD
® controlled study. It revealed that on the 9th day of the experiment, the skin injury areas were 29.17% for the cream base treatment, 44.34%, 47.55%, and 49.16% for the hexane, ethyl acetate, and
n-butanol extracts, respectively, and 41.09% for the positive control SSD
®. Results showed that the healing process was accelerated in rats submitted to the application of extract loaded creams. Noteworthy, the
n-butanol extract was even more efficient than the standard SSD
® treatment. Following these experiments, Guaoguao et al.
[75] assessed the safety of a hydroalcoholic extract obtained from the aerial parts of
S. verbenaca that was successively fractionated with hexane, ethyl acetate, and
n-butanol. Crude residues were massaged in the shaved rat’s healthy skin. After 14 days, animals were healthy and had no skin injuries, thus proving the absence of dermal toxicity or inflammation after the topical application of the extract.
In another interesting study, Righi et al.
[76] evaluated the
in vivo antiphlogistic potential of an hydromethanolic extract obtained from the aerial parts of this same
Salvia species using a xylene-induced edema model. Mice treated with
S. verbenaca extract reduced the weight increase caused by xylene, especially at 600 mg/kg of body weight that afforded 50% of edema inhibition. This concentration was as effective as the reference anti-inflammatory agents, such as indomethacin and dexamethasone, non-steroidal and steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, respectively.
8. Thymus vulgaris L.
8.1. Ethnobotanical Uses and General Considerations
T. vulgaris (
Figure 1H), commonly known as thyme or garden thyme, is known for having an extensive array of pharmacological properties
[1], also with important applications in culinary, perfumery, and cosmetics fields
[77]. From this perspective, several pharmacological activities are reported, namely antibacterial, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, antiviral, and anti-cancerous
[77].
From the Iberian ethnomedicinal perspective of this thyme species, several reports have mentioned its potential application for wound healing. Firstly, a decoction of the aerial parts is referred to be used in the region of High River Ter Valley, Catalonia
[78], as a vulnerary for the treatment of wounds. In Alt Empordà, Catalonia, Parada et al.
[33] also documented the topical application of the aerial part of this species for the treatment of wounds. For instance, Cavero et al.
[41] reported that in Navarra, the decoction of the aerial parts, is used to clean wounds and prepare ointments with wax, honey, and olive oil. The infusion of the aerial parts at the flowering stage is also reported to be used in the form of baths for wound healing
[24][41].
8.2. Phytochemical Background
In
T. vulgaris, different classes of compounds can be found such as phenolics, terpenoids, flavonoids, steroids, alkaloids, tannins, and saponins. Phenolic compounds are the ones with more pharmacological significance, and among them, rosmarinic, caffeic,
p-coumaric, geranic,
p-hydroxybenzoic, gentisic, syringic, and ferulic acids have been highlighted. Thyme’s essential oil is mostly rich in thymol and carvacrol, but it also has geraniol, linalool, α- and β-pinene,
p-cymene, and γ-terpinene (
Figure 2). Apigenin, luteolin, cirsimaritin, genkwanin, and xanthomicrol are some of the identified flavonoids
[77].
8.3. Pharmacological Evidence
Regarding Mekkaoui et al.
[64],
T. vulgaris honey was mixed separately with the essential oils of O. vulgare, S. rosmarinus, and T. vulgaris, each at 0.5%. Interestingly, the honey containing
T. vulgaris’ essential oil provided the best outcomes in this study with wound closure rates for thermal and chemical-inflected burns of 85.21% and 82.14%, respectively. Furthermore, this treatment provided the shortest healing period of 14 days with a great potential to treat burn wounds compared to Madecassol
® or honey-alone treated animals. Notwithstanding, in a previous
in vivo study, nitric oxide (NO), which was shown to be overproduced in thermal-induced wounds, progressively decreased during healing. However, in this investigation, thyme’s essential oil was shown to enhance the reduction of NO levels, presenting comparable results to conventional drugs used in burns management, such as SSD
®. Rats treated with thyme’s essential oil also showed better results regarding the formation of new tissue
[79].
In the Panah et al.
[80] study, circular wounds were inflected on rats and after 21 days, results showed that the animals treated with ointments bearing thyme’s essential oil had a statistically significant better distribution of fibroblasts and macrophages, besides promoting angiogenesis and collagen deposition, when compared to the control group treated with Eucerin
® (25%) and Vaseline
® (75%). Similarly, the daily application of an ointment containing an ethanolic extract of
T. vulgaris also afforded potent wound closure
[81].
Given the substantial evidence showing the beneficial effects of T. vulgaris as a promising wound healing natural product, numerous studies have focused on developing innovative wound dressing systems. As an example, thyme’s essential oil was encapsulated in sodium caseinate (Na CAS) nanomicelles resulting in a gelatin nanocomposite hydrogel formulation. Interestingly, this study proved that this delivering system not only promotes wound closure, but also reduces the inflammatory factor IL-6, while encompassing an increase of VEGF and transforming growth factor-β1. Furthermore, an appreciable antibacterial activity was equally found with this hydrogel disrupting bacterial membranes followed by alkaline phosphatase leakage
[82]. Another relevant study has led to the creation of an electrospun zein/thyme essential oil (TEO) nanofibrous membrane aiming to overcome some drawbacks of the conventional electrospun fibrous wound dressings, such as the lack of adjustment when topically applied on irregular wounds
[83].
Chitosan films loaded with
T. vulgaris’ essential oil at 1.2% also showed suitable antioxidant activity given the high amounts of carvacrol, and antimicrobial activity against some bacterial strains such as
E. coli,
Klebsiella pneumoniae, P. aeruginosa, and gram positive
S. aureus [84]. An antimicrobial wound dressing system of chitosan/Poly(ethylene oxide) nanofiber loaded with
T. vulgaris’ extract, synthetized through electrospinning, was equally afforded
[85]. Similarly, the extract of
T. vulgaris loaded into chitosan, eggshell membrane, and soluble eggshell membrane film were also attempted
[86], and Poly(vinyl alcohol)-based nanofiber mats were also loaded with
T. vulgaris hydroalcoholic extract
[48].
This entry is adapted from the peer-reviewed paper 10.3390/ph16030347