3. Novel Applications of Microspheres for Bone Tissue Engineering
3.1. 3D Culture of Seed Cells and Construction of Organoid
To ensure the efficient proliferation and differentiation of seed cells in vivo, it is necessary to provide a cell scaffold that acts as an artificial extracellular matrix. The scaffold materials used in bone tissue engineering must have good biocompatibility and surface activity, bone conductivity and bone induction ability, and appropriate pore size and porosity, as well as moderate mechanical strength and plasticity
[46]. At present, both biodegradable and non-biodegradable scaffold materials are widely used. However, due to the high levels of mechanical strength and strong biological inertia, non-biodegradable materials can cause secondary surgery problems. This has led to an increase in the study of biodegradable and bioactive materials in recent years
[47].
As a microcarrier structure, microspheres have a larger surface area and volume ratio than monolayer cells, so they can effectively promote the growth of cells
[48]. Microspheres are commonly used in 3D cell cultures in the process of stem cell growth and differentiation. This is because over the past decade, scientists have found that 3D cell culture technologies can provide cells with a culture environment more akin to the in vivo environment. Thus, the 3D cell culture must be able to simulate the main characteristics of the in vivo environment, including the interactions between cells and the extracellular matrix, between cells and organs, and between cells and other cells, in order to better realize the morphology and function of cells in vitro, understand their physiological function, and establish extensive cell-to-cell and cell-to-extracellular matrix (ECM) interactions
[49]. At present, studies have confirmed that a 3D culture of stem cells with microspheres can efficiently promote the growth of stem cells as well as osteogenic and chondrogenic differentiation
[50][51], and promote the paracrine ability of stem cells. This causes more anti-inflammatory factors and nutritional factors (such as VEGF, PDGF and FGF) to be expressed, thus allowing stem cells to play a more effective therapeutic role in bone regeneration
[52]. Compared with traditional 2D cultures, the MSCs sphere conditioned medium was more effective in promoting the phenotypic transformation of macrophages from mainly pro-inflammatory M1 to anti-inflammatory M2, thereby playing an active anti-inflammatory role
[53]. In 3D cultures, human pluripotent stem cells can be cultured to produce a trophoblast-like tissue model, which is helpful in analyzing the potential mechanisms of early human placental development
[54]. Additionally, the 3D culture of stem cells includes self-assembly aggregation and encapsulation by hydrogel microspheres. Passanha et al. found that cells encapsulated by alginate hydrogel exhibited better viability on the 14th day, probably because the alginate gel could provide more room for cells and allow for the diffusion of more nutrients and oxygen
[55].
The cytoskeleton of the internal structure of the cell provides the basis for the cell’s ability to sense external mechanical rigidity, thus mediating the interactions between the cell and the extracellular environment
[56]. Some studies have even suggested that the hypoxic microenvironment may be the leading factor in the enhancement of the therapeutic potential of MSCs in 3D environments
[57]. Chen et al. believed that a 3D environment’s conduciveness to the therapeutic effect of stem cells cannot be attributed only to the hypoxic microenvironment. Notably, the slight metabolic conversion of 3D cultured stem cells may have a significant impact on their paracrine potential. Upon further exploration, researchers found that 3D MSCs spheres made by 40,000 cells have the best paracrine and immune regulation ability
[58]. Therefore, researchers recommend using microsphere material as a scaffold material to better complete tissue repair.
Organoids are micro-organs with three-dimensional structure grown in vitro using adult stem cells. Their genetic background and histological characteristics are very similar to those of in vivo organs; they have complex structures similar to those of real organs and can partially mimic the physiological functions of the source tissues and organs, which has made them a hot research topic in recent years
[59]. A popular cutting-edge technology, stem cell populations propagated through an organoid can replace damaged or diseased tissues for the purpose of treating diseases. It is expected that when this technology reaches a certain stage of development, doctors will use pluripotent stem cells to build organoids that can replace damaged tissues in patients. Scientists can use human-derived stem cells to treat fractures after growing osteogenic-like organs in vitro. A segment of bone unit containing cortical bone, cancellous bone, and a junction interface, injected into the site of a bone defect, can spontaneously assemble and thus heal the fracture
[60][61]. Low concentration gelatin methacrylate (GelMA) is a synthetic material that has excellent biocompatibility with cellular structures, and Xie et al. were able to rapidly print uniform GelMA microdroplets measuring approximately 100 μm using an electro-assisted bioprinting method. Due to the low external force applied to separate the droplets, the printing process results in minimal cell damage and can provide an excellent microenvironment for stem cell growth
[62]. Alginate, chitosan, cell-laden PEG hydrogel, and other similar natural polymers are compatible with electrohydrodynamic spraying (EHS), and can all be used to generate controlled sized cell-loaded microspheres for potential applications in cell delivery and organoid culture
[63]. PDMS microspheres with different elastic modulus (34 kPa, 0.6 MPa, and 2.2 MPa) were prepared and doped into MSCs, thus modulating the mechanical properties of the MSCs growth microenvironment and affecting MSCs differentiation, as MSCs differentiation is tension dependent
[64]. It has been shown that MSCs in microspheres exposed to low contractile force are more conducive to adipose tissue differentiation than those exposed to high tension, which are more conducive to osteogenic differentiation
[65]. When PDMS microspheres were incorporated into the cell sphere, the interfacial tension was increased due to the decrease in adhesion and the decrease in cadherin
[66]. In addition, the introduction of material supports or spacers into the cell sphere increases the cell’s free volume, thus allowing a more frequent exchange of oxygen, nutrients, and waste with the exterior of the cell, thus facilitating cell growth and differentiation
[67].
Preparation of cell-laden microspheres by 3D printing is an efficient means to achieve rapid construction of functional large-scale organoids
[68]. Current 3D bioprinting technologies for manufacturing different types of organs mostly use droplet-based, extrusion-based, laser-induced forward transfer, and stereolithography bioprinting. Among them, extrusion-based 3D printing is the most popular choice. Hydrogel materials have become the obvious choice for 3D printed microspheres, which provide a highly hydrated environment with excellent biocompatibility. Bulk hydrogels have good shear-thinning properties for extrusion-based bioprinting, whereas granular hydrogels can only achieve this rheological property if they are “jammed”
[69]. Jamming means that the particle system changes from a fluid to a solid state. When the particle-to-volume fraction reaches (Φ) to approximately 0.58, the jamming transition can be found. In theory, the monodispersed hard-spherical particles should be maximally jammed in a random configuration at Φ = 0.64 and be perfectly packed at Φ = 0.74. However, packaging of soft hydrogel particles is much more complicated due to inter-particle friction, charge, hardness, and microgel heterogeneity. In addition to this, microscale pores are necessary for cell growth. Therefore, there is currently an unmet need to develop granular jammed hydrogels that can preserve the microscale pores
[70]. Ataie and co-workers programmed microgels for reversible interfacial nanoparticle self-assembly, enabling the fabrication of nanoengineered granular bioinks with well-preserved microporosity, enhanced printability, and shape fidelity
[71]. Four-dimensional printing is a rapidly emerging field that has been developed from 3D printing, where printed structures change in shape, properties, or function when exposed to predetermined stimuli, such as humidity and temperature photoelectric stimuli. Four-dimensional bioprinting is a promising method to build cell-laden constructs that have complex geometries and functions for tissue/organ regeneration applications. A single-component jammed micro-flake hydrogel has been developed for 4D bioprinting with shear-thinning, shear-yielding, and rapid self-healing properties. As such, it can be printed smoothly as a stable three-dimensional biological structure when a photoinitiator and a UV absorber are added, and a gradient in cross-linking density is formed. After performing shape deformation, the hydrogel produced well-defined configurations and high cell viability, which may provide a number of applications in bone tissue engineering
[72].
3.2. Endochondral Ossification for the Reparation of Large Bone Defects
Endochondral ossification has become an effective strategy in the repair of large segmental bone defects. The process of endochondral ossification occurs through the formation of a calcified cartilage matrix containing hypertrophic chondrocytes. MSCs undergo cartilage template formation, blood vessel formation, and mineralization. This avascular cartilage template secretes angiogenic factors that induce vascular growth in the defect site, a process that also activates osteogenic signaling pathways and ultimately promotes their restructuring into bone
[73]. Mikael et al. combined gel phase with load-bearing and porous biodegradable matrices to produce hybrid matrices, with the PLGA polymer matrix providing mechanical stability, while the (hyaluronic acid-fibrin) gel-phase was expected to support the seeded MSC chondrogenesis, hypertrophy, and bone formation
[74]. Endochondral ossification was achieved by incorporating gelatin particles capable of relatively rapid release of TGF-β1 and mineral-coated hydroxyapatite particles, allowing a more sustained release of BMP-2 into MSCs aggregates, in order to take advantage of the sequential release of dual growth factors. This method did not need long-term in vitro chondrogenic priming, and it exhibited greater mineralization than pure cell aggregates treated with exogenous growth factors
[75]. Lin et al. applied the mechanism of endochondral ossification and co-cultured human umbilical vein endothelial cells with MSCs to create pre-vascularized bone-like tissue, which exhibited greater potential than either of the two cells cultured separately.
Xie et al. constructed a 3D culture system based on hydrogel microspheres using digital light-processing, which shows excellent in vitro stepwise-induction of BMSCs and achieves a state of simultaneous proliferation and differentiation of stem cells at the transcriptional level, as well as closely mimics the osteogenesis process. It also closely mimics the composition and behavior of stem progenitor cells in cartilage involved in osteogenesis. After in situ implantation, rapid bone repair was achieved within 4 weeks by advancing the regenerative process of endochondral osteogenesis, which indicates that in vitro construction of osteo-callus-like organs (osteo-callus organoids) according to developmental or regenerative processes is an effective strategy to promote rapid regeneration of bone tissue and the healing of bone defects
[76]. Ji et al. developed a “building block” controlled drug delivery system with macrophage modulating and injectable properties consisting of porous chitosan (CS) microspheres and hydroxypropyl chitosan (HPCH) temperature-sensitive hydrogels, in which dimethoxyglycine (DMOG) was loaded into temperature-sensitive HPCH hydrogels and KGN was grafted onto porous CS microspheres, thus forming the HPCH hydrogels/CS microspheres composite scaffold, which can effectively regulate the regenerative microenvironment at the defect site, recruit autologous stem cells, and provide abundant cell adhesion sites, thus achieving M2 polarization of local macrophages and promoting osteochondral regeneration
[77]. Janus particles are structures that integrate two or more composites with different chemical compositions into a single structural system. Janus particles can integrate different functional properties and perform multiple synergistic functions simultaneously because of their asymmetric composition and structure
[78]. The application of Janus particles allows for the controlled release of drugs, and therefore it has promising applications in bone tissue engineering based on endochondral ossification.
3.3. Construction of Microspheres Integrating Multiple Functions
The generation of microspheres in bone tissue engineering is a fast-growing field, renowned for its therapeutic effects in regenerative medicine, particularly in the regeneration and replacement of bones. However, these microsphere structures are not limited to tissue regeneration, and have been found to have additional functions in recent years
[79]. The “clean-to-repair” rhythm in the dynamic pathological osteoimmune microenvironment is essential to bone healing but is often disturbed by intense inflammation. Extracellular bioactive cations (Mg
2+) were doped into (PLGA)/MgO-alendronate microspheres, and the microspheres effectively regulated the microenvironment by inducing the polarization of macrophages from the M0 to the M2 phenotype and enhancing the production of anti-inflammatory (IL-10) and osteopathic (BMP-2 and TGF-β1) cytokines. This has been proven to promote proliferation and osteogenic differentiation of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells and produce a good bone regenerating effect
[80][81]. Liang et al. combined microfluidic microspheres and self-assembled collagen nanofibers to form an injectable porous microsphere with a hierarchical micro/nanostructure that mimics the extracellular matrix and activates integrin-mediated macrophage (Mφ) polarization, resulting in microenvironmental reprogramming for paracrine transformation
[82]. The microenvironment of bone defects resulting from some diseases produces large amounts of ROS, which not only impairs the regenerative potential of endemic stem cells but also reduces the therapeutic efficacy of stem cells implanted in the defect area. Excess ROS or insufficient antioxidants can make these bone defects difficult to repair. Therefore, for the treatment of refractory bone healing, there is an urgent need for new strategies to fabricate antioxidant microspheres that function as stem cell carriers to promote bone regeneration in the ROS microenvironment
[83]. Yang et al. constructed fullerol-hydrogel microfluidic spheres by using a one-step innovative microfluidic technique for in situ regulation of redox homeostasis in stem cells and promotion of refractory bone healing
[84]. Zheng et al. produced bone targeting antioxidative nano-iron oxide for treating postmenopausal osteoporosis
[85]. Strategies now available for ROS scavenging to regulate the microenvironment include inorganic nanoparticles (cerium oxide nanoparticles, iron oxide nanoparticles, manganese nanoparticles, and carbon nanomaterials) and organic moieties (phenol group, sulfur, and boronic acid)
[86].
The incorporation of antibiotics and some active ingredients from plants, such as cinnamaldehyde and nanosilver, into microspheres gives the microspheres antibacterial effects, thus making them a viable treatment for osteomyelitis bone defects
[87][88][89][90]. Meanwhile, the incorporation of the antitumor drug adriamycin into microspheres for bone tissue engineering can achieve long-term release, resulting in bone regeneration and the destruction of tumor cells, and thus shows good prospects for application
[91]. The doping of M-type ferrite particles (SrFe
12O
19) into the microspheres enables the rapid release of doxorubicin (DOX) under the irradiation of near-infrared laser light, enabling the promotion of osteogenesis and enhancing synergistic photothermal chemotherapy against osteosarcoma
[92]. Bleeding due to bone defects is a clinically recognized category of refractory bleeding, wherein damage to the abundant blood vessels in cancellous bone leads to continuous bleeding (oozing) during the slow bone repair process. Therefore, Liu et al. devised a method to construct multilayer structured microspheres based on branched-chain starch, porous starch, and tannic acid of biomass (maize and grape) origin and MQ
2T
2 with the outmost polyphenol layer having unique platelet adhesion, activation, and erythrocyte aggregation properties. The microspheres had excellent hemostatic and pro-bone repair properties with good therapeutic effects in both rat and beagle models of cancellous bone defects. They also had excellent hemostatic and pro-bone repair properties
[93].