Infrared Thermography for Condition-Based Monitoring in Electrical Energy: History
Please note this is an old version of this entry, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Contributor: , , , , , ,

Condition-based monitoring (CBM) has emerged as a critical instrument for lowering the cost of unplanned operations while also improving the efficacy, execution, and dependability of tools. Thermal abnormalities can be thoroughly examined using thermography for condition monitoring.

  • condition-based monitoring
  • diagnosis
  • fault detection
  • infrared thermography

1. Theoretical on Thermography and Thermal Imaging

The cornerstone for IRT is the physical phenomenon that anybody with a temperature over absolute zero (−273.15 °C) emits electromagnetic radiation. The strength and spectrum composition of emitted radiation from a body is inextricably linked to its surface. Calculating the radiation intensity of an object may be used to determine its temperature in a non-contact method [14]. Figure 1 and Figure 2 demonstrate the electromagnetic spectrum and emissive power distribution as a function of wavelength, respectively.
Figure 1. The electromagnetic spectrum [15].
Figure 2. Distribution of emissive power with wavelength [16].
Amongst the most significant benefits of IRT-based condition monitoring is the minimal amount of equipment needed. The equipment includes a thermal camera, a tripod or camera platform, and video output devices to show the gathered infrared thermal pictures for such applications. Infrared cameras have progressed through three generations since their inception [17]. Zhang et al. [18] and Wan [19] go into considerable detail about the creation and basic concepts of various infrared sensors. The first cameras employed a single element sensor and two scanning mirrors to create pictures. They were apprehensive about the possibility of whiteout (i.e., saturation owing to high intensity). The second-generation cameras used two scanning mirrors, a significant linear array or a tiny 2-D array as detectors, and a time delay integration system for picture improvement. The lack of mirrors in third-generation cameras and the use of large focal plane array (FPA) sensors and on-chip image processing leads to higher system dependability and sensitivity [17]. The two kinds of thermal detectors are cooled and uncooled. Modern solid-state advancements have cleared the road for developing novel sensors that are more precise and have better resolutions. Uncooled cameras have a thermal sensitivity of about 0.05 degrees Celsius (°C), while cooled cameras have a thermal sensitivity of 0.01 °C [20]. These cameras provide excellent spatial and temperature solutions, compactness, and mobility to mention a few benefits. Furthermore, these cameras are lighter, use silicon wafer technology, and are less costly than cooled infrared cameras [21,22]. As a result, current IRT technology will aid electrical utilities for CBM analysis since all advancements will provide accurate data analysis using recent AI algorithms in computer vision.
A standard experimental setup for IRT-based condition monitoring research can be seen in Figure 3. The produced thermal pictures are exhibited on a computer, enabling the specific temperature of the object to be calculated without touching it. The obtained thermal pictures are often pseudo-color-coded, making interpretation more straightforward and faster. The source snapshot and a typical infrared thermal picture of a structural element are shown in [20].
Figure 3. Schematic of a typical experimental setup for IRT.
Before selecting an infrared camera, many factors must be examined since the ability to create a clear and accurate thermal picture is highly dependent on these performance criteria [23]. A few key factors are covered further down.

1.1. Spectral Range

The spectral range is the region of the infrared spectrum where the infrared camera will work. The thermal radiation that an item generates gets more concentrated in shorter wavelength bands as its temperature increases. For observing objects at ambient temperature, a long-wavelength band (7.5–14 μm) is preferable. This is due to two factors: first, bodies at room temperature emit mainly at these wavelengths; second, measurements taken at some of these wavelength ranges are unaffected by solar radiation (accurate for outdoor measurements) since solar radiation is primarily in the relatively short wavelength bands. The use of short wave (2–5 m) technology is recommended [8].

1.2. Spatial Resolution

Temperature resolution refers to the minor temperature fluctuation seen by the infrared camera in view. Object temperature, ambient room temperature, object to camera distance, filters, and other experimental factors all affect temperature resolution. Noise equivalent temperature difference (NETD), minimal resolvable temperature difference (MRTD), and minimum detectable temperature difference (MDTD) are the most often utilized temperature resolution criteria. NETD readings for Stirling cycle cooled cameras at room temperature are usually smaller than 0.025 Kelvin (K) [20].

1.3. Spatial Resolution Laser Pointer and Interchangeable Lens

To see where the camera’s lens is aimed and prevent coming into close contact with hot regions, laser pointers may be utilized. You may change lenses based on your requirements using interchangeable lenses. Flexibility with external equipment and measuring equipment, as well as speedy data transfer through cable, Wi-Fi, and Bluetooth, and the inclusion of text and voice feedback, are all benefits [24]. The thermal camera has become a more helpful instrument.

1.4. Temperature Range

The temperature range specifies the temperature values that an infrared camera can detect at the highest and lowest levels. Temperatures typically range from 20 degrees Celsius (°C) to 500 °C. Different filters may be used to extend the content up to 1700 °C [20].

1.5. Frame Rate

The number of frames acquired every second by an infrared camera is the frame rate. Higher frame rate cameras are often preferred for monitoring motion information or dynamic events like the propagation of heat fronts. The standard frame rate is 50 Hertz (Hz) [20].

1.6. Accuracy

The precision with which the thermal camera measures the temperature is reflected in its accuracy. The advanced thermal camera is accurate to within 1 percent (%) [25].

2. IRT Applications in Condition Monitoring for Electrical Energy

Component failure is mainly caused by excessive heat and resistance. Figure 4 shows how infrared cameras monitor this heat, which may be employed in several applications. An infrared camera detects the IR energy of an object, converts it to temperature, and displays the temperature distribution for structural health monitoring and non-destructive examination [46]. Thermography is a valuable diagnostic technique in the electrical sector that is crucial to assessing problems across various assets such as switchboards, transformers, cables, and other electrical components with electrical defects and high resistance connections. Non-contact temperature monitoring systems have grown in popularity as online condition monitoring technology has become an unavoidable aspect of today’s maintenance plan. As online condition monitoring technology has become an inevitable part of maintenance strategies in today’s scenario, with loss of insulation materials (e.g., refractory) in high or low-temperature process equipment, damage to rotating equipment, electrical and cooling issues that are not visible to the naked eye, non-contact type monitoring strategies have become more popular. Non-contact temperature monitoring systems have grown in popularity as online condition monitoring technology has become an unavoidable aspect of today’s maintenance plan. Infrared thermography [47] is a non-contact method of obtaining a precise, reproducible surface temperature profile. The applications for which infrared thermography may be used are shown in Figure 5.
Figure 4. Keyword co-occurrence map in the context of IRT [48].
Figure 5. Different methods and applications of IRT [49]. (SHM: Structural Health Monitoring, CM: Condition Monitoring. NDE: Non-Destructive Examination, DPA: Destructive Physical Analysis.)

2.1. Results in the Electrical and Electronics Applications

According to numerous assessments, IRT thermography is widely employed in the electrical and electronics engineering field [8,39,50]. Many of the applications in this field are connected to industry, but they also include tertiary sectors, transportation, and power plants, to name a few. The maintenance of electrical systems is an essential application of IRT. Experts have used the IRT camera for years to inspect panel boards, bus bars, electric cables, and other critical elements of these installations like transformers, power meters, or capacitor banks for reactive power compensation [39,51,52,53,54,55,56,57], where experts use the IRT camera to observe the correct operation of the equipment based on established limits. For electrical and electronic applications in condition monitoring, Bellow identified numerous criteria, examples, and methodologies.

2.2. Hotspot Detection

The easiest approach to find the hotspot inside the IRT picture is to use segmentation. The authors of [58] compare many picture segmentation approaches and discuss their advantages and disadvantages. Because of its straightforward implementation, the thresholding approach has become a popular picture segmentation technique. The grey-level histogram separates the target object from the background at a defined threshold. The automatic threshold technique of the T. Otsu method is widely used in many applications. Capacitors, transformers, and other electronic components have been utilized to identify flaws using the Infrared Thermal Anomaly Detection Algorithm (ITADA). ITADA is based on Otsu’s statistical threshold selection technique and detects flaws in capacitors, transformers, and other electronic components using grey-level histograms. Support vector machines (SVMs), used to segment color images, have a promising future. In [59], it is shown how to segment stochastic photos using random walker segmentation based on partial differential equations (PDE). Additionally, ref. [60] describes the use of thermographic image processing to identify faults in lightning arresters. To perform fault categorization, it utilized a collection of neuro-fuzzy networks. The neuron-fuzzy classifier is used to detect faults. It is also possible to use edge-based segmentation algorithms such as the Robert, Sobel, Prewitt, and Canny operators [61]. This approach identifies the moment when grey level intensity levels abruptly shift. Color picture segmentation may be done using spectrum analysis. However, previous information about the object’s hues is difficult to come by. The topic of picture segmentation has seen a lot of research [59,61,62,63,64,65]. However, only a handful have been examined in terms of employing thermal image processing to monitor electrical equipment state [5,33,60,66,67,68,69,70]. Consequently, in the context of electrical equipment condition monitoring, this work focuses on picture segmentation methods for thermographic pictures obtained by IR cameras. The condition of the spinning gear is monitored using various signal processing techniques [71,72], e.g., the implementation of an unsupervised online detection using artificial neural networks (ANNs) has been described in [73]. Yazici et al. [74] have reported an adaptive, statistical time-frequency method for the detection of bearing faults. In [75], a fuzzy fault detector using Concordia patterns was used to detect stator unbalance and open-circuit faults. Broken bar faults can also be detected by time- and frequency-domain analysis of induced voltages in search coils placed internally around stator tooth tip and yoke and externally on the motor frame. Stator fault detection using external signal injection is discussed in [76]. Power transformers’ fault detection methods and techniques are also discussed in several articles, e.g., frequency-response analysis (FRA) addressed in [72] is a powerful diagnostic method in detecting winding deformation, core, and clamping structure for power transformers, the multiple linear regression model is proposed in [77], for the early detection of transformers with accelerated oil aging, the vibroacoustic method (first noticed in aviation technology) will be applicable, transformers with a rated power of several tens of MVA [78], and a numerical procedure has been developed using the wavelet transform for processing and analysis of vibration signatures produced by the operation of tap changers [79,80]. In certain circumstances, non-contact thermographic image measurement may be beneficial. As a result, the current project tries to address these issues. The majority of scholars in this field [59,60,62,66,69,81] have used grayscale for processing. It has been discovered that the Sobel operator performs better for thermal pictures based on several image criteria. Following that, the Otsu approach is used on the identical photos, yielding good results. Figure 6 depicts hot zone identification using grayscale pictures and image processing techniques: (a) RGB image, (b) grayscale image, (c) Prewitt, (d) Roberts, (e) Sobel, (f) Otsu. On the other hand, the offered approaches locate the interest area without classifying the intensity of the equipment’s condition, necessitating human determination of crucial parameters, most notably the method’s threshold value.
Figure 6. Identification of a hotspot area picture in grayscale: (a) RGB image, (b) grayscale image, (c) using Prewitt, (d) using Roberts, (e) using Sobel, (f) using Otsu [82].

2.3. Improving Inspection Techniques

The quality of measurements has increased as new advances in current IRT equipment have been made. Surface temperature variations of less than 0.1 °C may be resolved by most contemporary IR imagers [83,84]. Despite the advantages of modern IRT camera designs coupled with powerful image processing and display systems, there are still various considerations to consider while performing an inspection, even if temperatures can be reliably detected. This is crucial particularly for outside assessments conducted in substations, underground, and aerial distribution [7]. Procedural, technical, and environmental/ambient variables are the main elements that influence the accuracy of IRT measurements [83,85]. If certified or competent personnel are used, it may reduce the procedural component. The essential technical features are the emissivity of the equipment under examination, load current variation, the distance of the item under inspection, and IRT camera characteristics [83,85,86]. Results may be misconstrued or inaccurate if all these aspects are ignored. Table 2 highlights all the environmental consequences that must be considered when doing an IRT examination [6,83,85,86,87]. Before beginning, any IRT examination should complete preliminary research. In this case, most thermographers will need some data from the target site. It is sometimes required to investigate the history of the target place and the electrical power equipment. To acquire the most essential and most precise measurement, you need to use a suitable and appropriate tool. IRT devices’ long-wave (usually 8–14 m) sensing is ideal for prolonged outside inspections, particularly during bright seasons. This is because thermal detectors in this wave range are more sensitive to ambient temperature objects and have robust smoke transmission [6,88]. Table 2 and Table 3 outline all of the criteria for the inspection tools and the target equipment, respectively.
Table 2. Consideration of environmental factors during the inspection.
Table 3. The characteristics of factors related to the target equipment and the inspection tool.

2.4. Methods of Measurement and Analysis

Electrical equipment’s thermal condition may be measured in two ways. The first is known as quantitative, and it involves taking the equipment’s precise temperature. The second form is qualitative, which measures a hotspot’s relative temperature to other equipment areas under comparable circumstances. Electrical components’ evaluation often employs qualitative analysis [35,95]. IRT inspection is governed by the International Electrical Testing Association (NETA), the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM)—E 1934, and the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA)—NFPA 70-B. The application of methods allows for a quick, reliable, and comprehensive assessment of the severity of observed issues. The NETA standard is often used in the testing process for electronic components, employing the delta T criterion as indicated in Table 4 to establish the degree of severity. Temperature increases over a predefined reference, such as ambient air temperature, a comparable component under similar circumstances, or the maximum allowable temperature, determine these delta Ts. Rather than using current standards, some thermographers create their testing specification tables from their own experiences. The severity level rating is often based on the highest temperatures for both qualitative and quantitative data. As shown in Figure 7a, the maximum temperature values may be estimated using any commercial infrared image analysis tool by choosing an area or specifying a spot on the components or equipment. As shown in Figure 7b, a single line temperature profile can depict the temperature changes throughout all stages. In general, automated area of interest selection may improve the human selection process.
Figure 7. (a) Techniques for extracting temperature values and (b) the temperature profile across Line 1 [8].
Table 4. NETA and MIL-STD2194 standards for IRT-based electrical equipment inspection features [8,48,96].

2.5. Application to Motors

Induction motors with three phases are the most used prime movers in numerous industrial applications. Thermography for motor condition monitoring and problem diagnostics is necessary and may be justified economically [97]. The stator, rotor, and bearings are the main components of an induction motor (IM). IMs will fail if any of these components or their subcomponents are damaged. The stator, bearing, rotor, and other mechanical flaws are the most common IM faults, although the wide categorization of IM faults is presented in Figure 8.
Figure 8. Classification of faults in induction motors [98].
Although IMs are quite constant in their functioning, their failure limits the smooth operation of IMs, which costs the industries a lot of money. The Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) and the Institution of Electrical and Electronics Engineers conducted statistical analyses of IM failures, as shown in Figure 9 (IEEE). In Figure 9, a bar chart depicts a comparison of several problems that often occur in rotating machinery. Bearing, stator, rotor, and other defects are the different types of faults. The percentage frequency of their occurrence is clearly shown in the bar chart. According to [9], the majority of induction motor defects (41%) and winding (37%) are connected, as indicated in Figure 9’s bar chart. The inter-turn defect is the more dangerous of the two since it may cause a rise in motor surface temperature. Due to a short circuit, this might result in a full loss of phase and potentially deadly accidents. However, a failure of the cooling system might cause a temperature increase in an induction motor [12,13].
Figure 9. Study of induction motor faults by IEEE and EPRI [98].

2.5.1. Failure of Cooling System

The discrepancy between the input electrical power Pi  and the output mechanical power P0 is referred to as Ploss(1). These losses are dissipated in the form of heat. This heat is evacuated into the environment through convection and radiation processes. Heat is dispersed into the surroundings in a self-cool motor by forced convection Pfconv radiation Prad, as defined in (2) [68]. The collection of debris, obstruction of air passages, damage or loose fans, and poor clearance during installation are all major causes of cooling system failure [97]. When the cooling system fails, forced convection is disrupted, causing the motor surface temperature to rise. A thermographic examination can identify this temperature increase. The International Electrical Testing Association (NETA) suggested a standard for thermographic testing of electrical systems, as illustrated in Table 4. This is used to determine the severity of a malfunction and the degree of maintenance priority for electrical systems and spinning machinery. Early identification of cooling system failure may be aided by recreating this defect in the laboratory and measuring the temperature of the motor at the target area of interest in line with NETA standards. Figure 10 and Figure 11 depict a healthy cooling system and a cooling system failure, respectively, using thermography [97].
 
P l o s s = P i P 0
 
P l o s s = P f c o n v + P r a d
Figure 10. Thermal image of healthy motor at (a) no load and (b) at 50% load condition [97]. Region A1 is motor stator and region A2 is fan cowing.
Figure 11. Thermal images of faulty motor at (a) no load and (b) 50% load condition [97]. Region A1 is motor stator and region A2 is fan cowing.
The regions Al and A2 in Figure 10 and Figure 11 indicate the surface temperature of the motor stator and fan cowing, respectively. The maximum surface temperature of the motor stator and the cooling section are represented by TA1 and TA2. All these tests were carried out at a constant temperature of 27 °C (Ta).

2.5.2. Bearing Faults

Bearings are one of the most important components of rotating equipment, and they are used in a wide range of technical applications such as turbines, heavy machinery, rolling mills, and ships. Bearings, being the principal component of a rotating machine, provide a number of tasks, including decreasing friction between relative moving components and providing support for the spinning shaft [99]. According to IEEE and EPRI, 41 percent and 42 percent of bearing faults occur during operation, respectively, as illustrated in Figure 9. For the CM of bearings in IMs, acoustic emission and vibration signal analysis were compared [100]. Figure 12 depicts an autonomous bearing problem detection framework that uses thermal imaging to identify four distinct bearing states in an induction motor.
Figure 12. Thermal picture of four bearing states (a) No lubrication (b) Inner race defect (c) Outer race defect (d) Healthy. In an electrical laboratory at NITTTR, Chandigarh, thermal pictures of an induction motor were captured using a FLIR E-60 (thermal camera). During the experiment, the camera was placed 2 feet away from the induction motor. Under laboratory circumstances, thermal pictures of an induction motor were recorded. Thermal photos of the four bearing states in the three-phase squirrel-cage induction motor were captured: outer race, inner race, lake of lubrication problems, and healthy. Each condition included 24 thermal photographs [101].

2.5.3. Stator Fault

One of the most well-known issues in IMs is stator winding failure [102]. If an IM isn’t working properly, it might slow down production or even shut down the facility, which can lead to an increase in the frequency of accidents. Early defect identification lowers production time lost, increases operator safety, and decreases maintenance costs [103]. Stator windings, stator frames, and winding laminations are some of the most prevalent stator problems, although stator windings are the most common. Thermal, mechanical, electrical, and environmental stressors all contribute to stator winding breakdown [104]. Thermal stress is one of the most important factors in the breakdown of insulation. According to IEEE and EPRI, stator winding faults occur 28 percent of the time and 36 percent of the time, respectively, as illustrated in Figure 9. An infrared investigation of winding asymmetry is shown in Figure 13.
Figure 13. Infrared investigation of asymmetry in motor windings [105]. Figure 5 illustrates this. The infrared examination of the motor revealed high heating in the motor frame (85.2 °C on the surface and, most likely, over 100 °C within). During the examination, no cooling irregularities were discovered. The bearings were re-lubricated and repaired at a workshop as a preliminary step, but no temperature decrease was noted. After that, the motor terminal box was examined, and just a little temperature differential was discovered between the connections. An ohmmeter was used to test the winding resistance of each phase, and the findings were rather fascinating; there was a large winding asymmetry across phases, resulting in a Max Delta R value of about 9%. Internal high resistance connections, broken twists, or internal shorts might all be the cause of this. This might be the source of the unusual heat dissipation. Finally, rewinding the motor was advised.

2.5.4. Eccentricity Fault

The situation is known as air-gap eccentricity when the distance between the rotor and the stator in the airgap is not uniform. The two types of eccentricity defects are static and dynamic eccentricity, as illustrated in Figure 14. The condition of static eccentricity occurs when the offset between the center of the shaft and the center of the stator is constant, while dynamic eccentricity occurs when the offset between the center of the shaft and the center of the stator is changeable. As indicated in Figure 14, Rr is the rotor’s radius and Rs is the stator’s radius. Methods such as FFT, wavelet, and Hilbert transform have been utilized to extract signals for the detection of eccentricity defects in IMs [106].
Figure 14. Cross-section of induction motor (a) normal (b) static eccentricity (c) dynamic eccentricity [106].

This entry is adapted from the peer-reviewed paper 10.3390/en15166000

This entry is offline, you can click here to edit this entry!
Video Production Service