3.1. Effect of Organic Residues on the Adsorption-Desorption of Pesticides
The combined application of pesticides and organic residues in soils modifies the former’s physicochemical behavior, mainly through their adsorption-desorption by the amended soils [
78,
79]. Organic amendments increase soil OC content, and this parameter is the most relevant factor influencing the adsorption process and the affinity of hydrophobic pesticides by soils [
80,
81]. Adsorption-desorption determines the environmental fate of any organic pollutants in the soil-water environment [
82]; it directly or indirectly controls the availability of pesticides to be transported to surface waters by runoff or to groundwaters by leaching, to the air by volatilization, to be degraded/transformed by microbial attack, or be taken up by plants [
83]. Thus, the weak adsorption and/or strong desorption of pesticides promotes leaching, run-off, volatilization, biodegradation and even ecotoxicological impacts on non-target organisms, including human beings, while strong adsorption prevents losses of pesticides by such processes [
84].
Accordingly, the addition of organic amendments to soil could lead to a greater or lesser degree of pesticide immobilization in the amended soil. This effect has consequences for pesticide degradation, persistence or mobility, enhancing a pesticide’s subsequent chemical, physical, and biological transformation or degradation, decreasing its transport through the soil profile, and consequently reducing groundwater pollution in some cases [
28,
78]. However, it could also affect the final concentration bioavailable for absorption by the targeted weeds [
37]. Therefore, adsorption and desorption processes help to understand how to predict the mobility and availability of pesticides in unamended and amended soils. Numerous references report the ability that organic amendments have to adsorb pesticides [
29,
85,
86,
87].
Adsorption is a physicochemical process in which pesticide molecules are retained on a solid surface (especially by the soil colloidal fraction) within a solution through hydrophobic interactions, van der Waals forces, π–π interaction, and covalent, ionic or hydrogen bonds [
88,
89]. Soil OM and its more active components, humic acids (HAs) and fulvic acid (FAs), are the principal adsorbents for pesticides, followed by clay colloids and oxyhydroxides of iron and manganese, which interact with pollutants when they reach the soil [
90,
91]. HA is the OM fraction with the highest reactivity (determined by the number and type of functional groups) and largest surface area. OM’s highly variable composition means it can interact with neutral or ionizable molecules [
75]. The pesticide adsorption capacity varies, in general, according to the physicochemical characteristics of the adsorbent and pesticide properties, mainly its water solubility and its hydrophobic, polar, or ionic character [
37,
92].
The nature and composition of the amendment’s OM vary, with the consequent difficulty in predicting its efficiency for adsorbing pesticides [
34,
76]. The addition of organic amendments to soil introduces not just SOM but also DOM (). The influence of the SOM and DOM content of organic residues on the adsorption of pesticides with different characteristics by amended soils has been frequently studied [
34,
76,
77]. The DOM content in unamended soil is usually very low, but it could become relevant if the organic amendment has a high content in this fraction [
93]. DOM is a diverse mixture of complex compounds with different chemical structures and molecular weights that might enhance the formation of multiple interactions with organic pesticides, controlling their distribution in the soil [
94]. This is why DOM may modify the movement of pesticides, generally decreasing their adsorption by SOM and increasing their leaching, leading to groundwater contamination [
78,
95,
96], although other authors have indicated that DOM could also be adsorbed by the soil, increasing the adsorption of pesticides and decreasing their leaching [
97].
Different processes have been proposed to explain the decreased adsorption of pesticides in the presence of DOM [
94,
98,
99,
100] (). These include the competition between DOM and pesticide molecules for the adsorption sites in soil, the saturation of soil adsorption sites by DOM, masking these sites for the adsorption of pesticides, the co-sorption of pesticides by DOM, and the formation of mobile DOM-pesticides complexes. Some authors have also indicated that DOM has characteristics similar to surfactants with the capacity to decrease surface tension and increase the solubility of pesticides, reducing their adsorption [
101]. The extent and nature of DOM-pesticide interactions depend on factors such as pesticide molecular weight and polarity [
102]. These relative effects of DOM will be greater for more hydrophobic chemicals, and will be influenced by the concentration, source, size, polarity, and molecular configuration of the organic colloids [
95].
includes a summary of the main results obtained from the recent literature on the adsorption and/or desorption of pesticides by some organic residues and by soils amended with different organic residues used as amendments. An organic material widely studied for these purposes is biochar (BC). It is an efficient adsorbent and a potential material for soil amendment [
30]. It is a carbonaceous and porous product generated from the partial combustion of biomass, and its effects as soil amendment in the adsorption–desorption of pesticides has been assessed from different points of view. The effects of different types of BC, treatments or aging periods, and their different doses or application forms as organic amendments in soils have been reported for pesticides with different characteristics. Parlavecchiaetal. [
103] have investigated the effect of two types of BC from grape vine pruning residues (BC-G) and spruce wood (BC-S) and two vermicomposts (VC) involving digestates from a mixture of manure and olive mill wastewater (VC-M) and buffalo manure (VC-B) in the sorption-desorption capacity of the fungicide metalaxyl-M. Both types of amendments (BC and VC) have a significant capacity to adsorb the high-water-soluble fungicide. However, BC has recorded a much higher sorption efficiency than VC and lower desorption, which is explained by the composition and structural differences in OM between the two (VC has less aromatic carbon and a higher content of hydrophilic functional groups interacting with polar compounds and solvents than BC). Metalaxyl-M is adsorbed to a similar extent on the two VCs, while a different sorption behavior is observed in BC-G and BC-S due to their different porous structures. Likewise, Wu et al. [
89] have assessed the effects of different types of BC from peanuts (BCP), chestnuts (BCC), bamboo (BCB), maize straw (BCM), and rice husk (BCR), and the effects of BCR aging on the sorption, degradation and bioavailability of the herbicide oxyfluorfen in various amended soils. The sorption capacity of the five BC differs significantly due to their physicochemical properties. The sorption capacity of BC for oxyfluorfen is significantly correlated with the specific surface area and elemental composition, but it decreases with longer aging time. BC reduces the bioavailability of oxyfluorfen in amended soils, but a higher bioavailability is recorded with an increase in the aging period of BC. Nevertheless, the sorption capacity of amended soil for oxyfluorfen after six months is still better than the unamended soil, highlighting that BCR is an effective way of reducing the risk of contaminating soil with oxyfluorfen, although it could also diminish the herbicide’s bioavailability and efficacy. Deng et al. [
104] have studies the effect that BC obtained from cassava residues at 750 °C (MS
750) applied at different rates between 0% and 5% has on the sorption-desorption and mobility of atrazine. The MS
750 application significantly enhances the sorption capacity and decreases the sorption reversibility of atrazine in the amended soil compared to the unamended soil, due to the larger surface area and greater aromaticity of MS
750 (with favorable sorption domains for organic compounds). Moreover, sorption affinity increases with higher BC application rates, although it is also influenced by solution pH, ambient temperature, and contact time between soil and BC (equilibrium time). The entrapment of atrazine in micropore or pore deformation could lead to desorption hysteresis in BC-amended soils.
Table 1. Adsorption–Desorption of pesticides by organic residues and amended soils.
Mendes et al. [
105] have recently studied the effect that BC from cow bone applied to the topsoil or incorporated into the surface layer has on the sorption-desorption of the herbicides hexazinone, metribuzin, and quinclorac in an unamended soil, pure BC, and BC-amended soil under laboratory conditions. The results indicate low values of K
f adsorption and desorption constants in the unamended soil. BC increases these K
f values, stimulating the retention of all the herbicides in the surface soil. The low C content of BC has a minimal impact on the total OC of amended soils, with the main changes occurring in pore size (up to 60,000 nm), volume (0.225 cm
3 g
−1), and area (133 m
2 g
−1) to increase herbicide adsorption by the soil. The desorption data for all herbicides were consistent with the values found for adsorption in the unamended soil, where quinclorac was the herbicide with the highest K
foc (adsorption) and lowest K
foc (desorption). The desorbed amount of herbicides was close to zero after the addition of BC in the soil or in pure BC, confirming the high adsorption potential of BC regardless of the material’s method of application. Similar high sorption has been reported for two weak acid herbicides, aminocyclopyrachlor and mesotrione, in amended soils with the same cow bone char [
106]. The comparison of organic residue application at varying rates and with two different particle size groups (0.3–0.6 and 0.15–0.3 mm) indicates that higher BC application rates increases the adsorption and decreases the desorption of both herbicides, regardless of particle size.
The effectivity and rate of application of other organic residues as adsorbents of pesticides has also been reported in different studies. Marín-Benito et al. [
107] have studied the effect of large amounts of lignocellulosic residues from forestry and industrial activities on the adsorption–desorption of certain pesticides by soils. The study involves two wood wastes (pine and oak wood) at two different doses (5% and 50%) and various incubation times (0, 5 and 12 months) in two soils with different textures (sandy loam and sandy clay). The effect on the adsorption–desorption of two herbicides and one fungicide (linuron, alachlor, and metalaxyl) has revealed that the application of oak or pine wood to soils increases the adsorption of linuron and metalaxyl by both soils, and of alachlor by the sandy loam soil at a lower dose (5%), while the adsorption of the three pesticides increases under all conditions at the highest dose (50%). The results also indicate the influence of soil type on alachlor desorption and/or its possible bioavailability from wood-soils, but not for linuron and metalaxyl, although this behavior changes with incubation time. The role of the nature of the OC (K
oc values) for sorption has been evidenced for alachlor and metalaxyl, but not for linuron. Other residues, such as the SS applied to the soil at various rates (0.1%, 1%, and 10% w∙w
–1), have a non-significant effect on the sorption–desorption of aminocyclopyrachlor and mesotrione [
108]. Both herbicides follow a similar adsorption behavior in all treatments, although K
d for mesotrione is ≈3.5-fold higher than for aminocyclopyrachlor due to the latter’s higher water solubility. This leads to a higher bioavailability of aminocyclopyrachlor in soil solution for its absorption by weeds and crops.
Fewer studies have addressed the adsorption–desorption of several pesticide-organic residue combinations or the amendment effect on soil physical properties. Duhan et al. [
109] have studied the behavior of five herbicides commonly used in sugarcane production (imazapic, atrazine, hexazinone, diuron, and metribuzin) by eleven waste materials (mill muds) and by three soils amended with them at different rates (5–25%, dry weight basis). The authors have observed that all the amendments enhance the adsorption efficiency for four of the five herbicides, depending on the rate of application, especially in the soil with low OC. Even at the lowest application rate, the adsorption of the herbicides increases from two to ten times. Mill muds in soil also reduce the rate and extent of herbicide desorption, especially at a 5% application rate and for mobile herbicides such as metribuzin and atrazine. Marsico et al. [
110] have studied the effect that the mucilage extracted from Chia seeds (
Salvia hispanica L.) has as a soil amendment on soil physical properties and on the sorption-desorption behavior of four herbicides (MCPA, diuron, clomazone, and terbuthylazine) used in cereal crops. The assessment of the changes in the microstructural characteristics caused by the reactions between the mucilage and soil particles in three soils indicates that mucilage amendment reduces soil porosity due to a decrease in larger pores (radius > 10 μm) and a significant increase in finer pores (radius < 10 μm), as well as in particle surface. Higher herbicide adsorption has been observed in the amended soils than in the unamended ones. Moreover, herbicide desorption is severely inhibited in the amended soils.
Although many organic amendments have proven to be effective adsorbents of pesticides, only a few studies have evaluated the functional groups involved in the adsorption process [
111,
112,
113,
114]. Accordingly, Gaonkar et al. [
112] have used spectroscopy to characterize the DOM from two organic amendments (mixed waste compost and dried goat manure) and the amended soils, and assess their influence on the sorption of the insecticides dichlorvos and chlorpyrifos. The DOM contained large amounts of highly humified and aromatic molecules. DOM led to a non-significant increase in dichlorvos adsorption (hydrophilic pesticide), due mainly to the additional sites provided by the adsorbing DOM and no interactions between DOM and the insecticide in solution. However, a significant reduction in chlorpyrifos adsorption (hydrophobic pesticide) was observed, probably due to interactions between DOM and the insecticide mostly in solution, and to some extent at the soil/solution interface, increasing the solubilization of chlorpyrifos. This reduction in adsorption depended on the nature and concentration of the DOM, as well as on insecticide properties. In agreement with the adsorption results, chlorpyrifos desorption was significantly increased by the DOM residue. In another recent study, García-Delgado et al. [
114] have determined the OC functional groups from four organic amendments (spent mushroom substrate (SMS), GC, manure, and SS) by elemental analysis and
13C-NMR, and their effects on the adsorption of four herbicides with different structures (triasulfuron, chlorotoluron, flufenacet, and prosulfocarb) by two unamended and amended soils with different textures. The chemical composition and structure of the organic amendments (especially OC content and structural C type), and external factors such as herbicide polarity (hydrophobicity) and soil properties controlled the adsorption process. The adsorption of herbicides was promoted by carbon-rich organic amendments with aliphatic and aromatic structures, while the irreversible adsorption (hysteresis) of herbicides in the amended soils was enhanced by the abundance of O-alkyl and N-alkyl groups of organic amendments.