Revolutionizing HIV-1 Viral Load Monitoring in India: History
View Latest Version
Please note this is an old version of this entry, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Contributor:
Madhuri Chandane Tak
,
Anuradha Vaidyanathan
,
Anupam Mukherjee

India continues to grapple with a significant burden of HIV infections. Despite notable progress in prevention and treatment efforts, multiple challenges, such as high-risk populations, inadequate testing facilities, and limited access to healthcare in remote areas, persist. Though the Government of India offers HIV-1 plasma viral load testing at various medical centers, aiding treatment decisions and monitoring antiretroviral therapy effectiveness, enhancing care for individuals living with HIV under the National AIDS Control Program (NACP), the nation’s large population and diverse demographics further complicate its outreach and response. Hence, strategic interventions and alternative methods of testing remain crucial to curbing HIV transmission and improving the quality of life for those affected. Dried blood spot (DBS) sampling has emerged as a convenient and cost-effective alternative for HIV-1 viral load testing, revolutionizing the landscape of diagnostic and monitoring strategies for HIV infection. Though the plasma-based viral load remains the gold standard for monitoring HIV-1, DBS-based HIV-1 viral load testing holds immense promise for improving access to care, particularly in resource-limited settings where traditional plasma-based methods may be logistically challenging. DBS entails the collection of a small volume of blood onto filter paper, followed by drying and storage. This approach offers numerous advantages, including simplified sample collection, transportation, and storage, reducing the need for cold-chain logistics. 

  • HIV/AIDS
  • HIV-1
  • viral load
  • dried blood spot (DBS)
  • diagnosis

1. Conventional Method of HIV-1 Viral Load Testing

The conventional method of HIV-1 viral load testing primarily relies on quantifying the amount of HIV-1 RNA in a patient’s plasma, providing a crucial indicator of the viral replication activity within the body (Figure 1). This process involves the collection of a venous blood sample from the patient. The collected blood is then transported under controlled conditions to a diagnostic laboratory, where specialized equipment, such as real-time polymerase chain reaction (PCR) machines, is utilized. PCR amplifies the viral RNA in the sample, enabling precise quantification. The process requires technical expertise and an established infrastructure of laboratories. Moreover, cold-chain logistics are crucial to maintaining the integrity of the plasma samples during transportation, adding to the complexity and cost of the conventional method. Despite being the established gold standard, the conventional approach has limitations, especially in resource-limited settings, due to its demanding infrastructure requirements, cost, and dependence on a well-developed healthcare system.
Healthcare 12 00413 g002
Figure 1. Flowchart illustrating the process of HIV-1 plasma viral load testing: This figure provides a detailed flowchart outlining the sequential steps involved in the conventional method of plasma HIV-1 viral load testing.

2. The Potential of Dried Blood Spot Analysis as a Convenient and Cost-Effective Alternative for HIV-1 Viral Load Measurement

Historically, the concept of dried blood spots as a sample type originated around the end of World War II. The dried blood spot (DBS) technique primarily employs filter paper to absorb blood samples, which are subsequently utilized for laboratory testing [1]. Robert Guthrie notably pioneered the application of DBS for phenylketonuria screening in 1960. Today, DBS finds wide-ranging utility in serological diagnosis, encompassing diseases like AIDS, hepatitis, trypanosomiasis, hepatic amebiasis, congenital rubella, and more [2].
In the early 2000s, there was a growing interest in employing DBS for therapeutic monitoring of HIV infection, particularly in resource-limited settings where access to nearby laboratories remains a substantial challenge due to constraints in human and financial resources. DBS emerges as a cost-effective alternative, notably in remote, challenging-to-reach rural areas where plasma specimen preparation and transport are hindered by costly cold-chain requirements and a scarcity of trained personnel for venipuncture and plasma separation. In light of this, recent WHO guidelines for antiretroviral therapy advocate for DBS as a viable option to enhance access to viral load monitoring for HIV, HBV, and HCV diagnosis [3].
Numerous studies have consistently demonstrated a robust correlation between DBS viral load assessments and plasma-based viral load testing [4][5]. These investigations have underscored the exceptional sensitivity and specificity of DBS specimens for detecting HIV-1 viral loads. DBS analysis presents compelling advantages as an accessible and cost-effective alternative for quantifying HIV-1 viral loads. It eliminates the need for intrusive venipuncture, streamlining sample collection and enabling self-sampling, especially in remote or resource-constrained regions where healthcare accessibility and transportation pose challenges. The dried form of DBS samples ensures convenient storage, transport, and reduced biohazard risks compared to liquid samples. Furthermore, it reduces the demand for complex cold-chain logistics, resulting in substantial cost savings and widened testing availability.
DBS analysis also demands smaller blood volumes, mitigating patient discomfort and facilitating pediatric testing. This approach proves particularly beneficial in regions where traditional plasma-based techniques face hurdles due to infrastructure limitations. DBS samples can be efficiently collected, shipped, and analyzed, promoting timely diagnosis, treatment monitoring, and therapy adjustments. These advantages firmly establish DBS analysis as a transformative tool, addressing gaps in HIV-1 viral load monitoring and advancing global HIV control and healthcare objectives.

3. Advantages of Dried Blood Spot over Plasma Specimen

Dried blood spots offer distinct advantages over plasma specimens, primarily in terms of their simplicity and cost-effectiveness in the collection and transportation process. To obtain a DBS sample, a simple finger prick is all that is needed; it does not require the presence of a trained phlebotomist for blood collection. This convenience extends to the possibility of collecting DBS samples outside clinical settings, reducing the burden on patients who would otherwise have to visit a clinic.
Following collection, DBS cards are left to air-dry overnight, then packaged and sent to a testing facility for analysis at room temperature. Unlike other methods, DBS specimens can be shipped to public health laboratories through standard mail, courier services, or express delivery as exempted specimens under the regulations issued by the International Air Transporter Association (IATA), the World Health Organization, and the International Civil Aviation Organization. DBS eliminates the need for expensive cold-chain transport and cryopreservation, as detailed in the CDC guidelines [6].
This streamlined approach significantly simplifies the pre-analytical phase of sample collection. Moreover, because DBS samples don’t require a cold-chain system to maintain their integrity, the overall cost of viral load testing in research studies is substantially reduced, making it a highly cost-effective option.
Performance assessment and implementation of DBS specimens for HIV-1 viral load testing have been the subject of numerous studies. The journey began with the WHO 2013 consolidated guidelines on antiretroviral drug use, which emphasized the need for higher detection thresholds when using DBS specimens for viral load testing, given uncertainties about their accuracy, especially below 1000 copies/mL.
In 2016, a study on DBS for HIV-1 viral load assays reported approximately 80% sensitivity and 90% specificity [7]. Misclassification rates were slightly lower in high viral load cases but ranged from 20.3% to 23.6% in low viral load cases. A 2017 study comparing DBS-fingerprint and DBS-venous methods found a sensitivity of 93% and a specificity of 95% for both DBS approaches [8]. In another 2017 study using Abbott and Roche platforms, DBS showed sensitivity and specificity of 93.9% and 88.0%, respectively, for Abbott platforms. Sensitivity was 100% for CAP/CTM, albeit with slightly lower specificity compared to Abbott [9]. A 2017 field evaluation in Kenya, a resource-limited setting, reported DBS performance at a threshold of ≥1000 copies/mL, with sensitivity ≥88.1% and specificity ≥93.1% [10]. A WHO pre-qualification study in 2018 reported DBS sensitivity of 76.0% and specificity of 89.7% at the 1000 RNA copies/mL threshold [2][11]. A cross sectional study comparing DBS HIV VL with plasma values on the Hologic Panther platform demonstrated a positive correlation of 0.96 [4]. A meta-analysis by the WHO and CDC in 2022 indicated that four out of six technologies using DBS samples for viral load testing achieved sensitivity and specificity above 83% at a treatment failure threshold of 1000 copies/mL. Notably, Abbott Real Time HIV-1, BioMerieux NucliSENS HIV-1, Roche COBAS TaqMan with FVE protocol, and Siemens VERSANT HIV-1 RNA performed exceptionally well under this threshold [12]. Furthermore, studies have highlighted the potential for enhanced DBS performance through the adoption of proper extraction protocols [5][13][14][15][16]. In summary, ongoing technological advancements are continually improving the reliability of DBS specimens in HIV-1 viral load testing (Table 1).
Table 1. Reported performance of DBS for HIV-1 viral load monitoring.
Assay Platform VL Threshold Sample Size Sensitivity Specificity References
Abbott RealTime HIV-1, BioMerieux, Roche, and Siemens VERSANT 1000 10,871 >83% >83% [12]
Roche CAP/CTM, Abbott RealTime HIV-1, and the bioMérieux NucliSENS EasyQ 1000 323 80% 90% [7]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 1000 497 93% 95% [8]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 1000 200 93% 88% [9]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 1000 793 88.1% 93.1% [10]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 1000 323 76.0% 89.7% [11]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 2000 100 95% Not reported [13]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 1000 130 50–100% 100% [14]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 1000 203 90.1% 96.2% [15]
Abbott RealTime HIV-1 1000 87 94.8% Not reported [16]

4. Feasibility Study Results of Implementation of Dried Blood Spot for Viral Load Testing in Different Setups

The feasibility of implementing the DBS specimen for expanding viral load programs has been rigorously examined by scientists worldwide, and the results suggest promising potential for its practical application in the field. Numerous studies conducted across various platforms have consistently highlighted the complementary nature of DBS as a valuable adjunct to plasma samples for improving access to viral load monitoring [12][17]. This complementarity is especially pronounced in resource-limited rural settings, where the advantages of DBS, such as its economical transport mechanism and ease of handling, become particularly significant. While DBS stands out as a crucial complementary tool, it is essential to recognize that, in resource-limited settings, it is often suggested as a primary approach due to its cost-effectiveness, simplified logistics, and potential to address challenges associated with traditional plasma-based methods. In India, where the HIV epidemic is primarily concentrated among high-risk groups and key populations like female sex workers, men who have sex with men, transgender individuals, and injecting drug users, the NACO initiated a study in 2012. This study identified the essential need for implementing DBS as an alternative sample type in India, taking into account its suitability for HIV-1 viral load testing [14]. DBS has been validated for HIV-1 viral load and HIV-1 DBS qualitative assays on various platforms, including the Indian Council of Medical Research-National AIDS Research Institute (ICMR-NARI) in India. A recent review published in 2022 by ICMR summarized the usage of dried blood specimens for screening sexually transmitted infections (STIs) and emphasized its role in expanding the HIV-1 viral load program to achieve the global 95-95-95 target in India [18]. In our proposed study, the research team has devised a protocol to assess the feasibility of alternative methods for viral load expansion in India, with a specific focus on the implementation capabilities of DBS in HIV-1 viral load expansion in the country [19]. A feasibility study conducted in Thailand in August 2021 reported a correlation coefficient of 0.62 between HIV viral load measured from plasma and DBS, with a mean difference of 0.02 (SD: 1.06) log10 IU/mL. At the threshold defining treatment failure (1000 copies/mL), the sensitivity of DBS HIV-1 RNA detection was 86% (95% CI, 74–94%). This study also demonstrated the high stability of HIV RNA in DBS after 2 to 4 days of shipping, compared to HIV RNA before shipping, even under varying temperature and humidity conditions [5]. A Vietnam feasibility study on dried blood spots for routine viral load monitoring, particularly to reach hard-to-reach populations, showed comparable results with plasma during virological failure and highlighted the usefulness of DBS in monitoring hard-to-reach patients during HIV care [20].
The feasibility of DBS for viral load testing has also been explored in the United States, where at-home DBS collection and longitudinal VL monitoring among low-ART-adherence MSM living with HIV showed promise. This mode of viral testing improved viral suppression in this group by simplifying sample collection and transport procedures for viral load testing [21]. Additionally, an African study reviewing progress in viral load expansion identified limitations related to transport conditions and turnaround times for specimen transfer to VL testing facilities. It discussed the need for implementing DBS and point-of-care (POC) testing, where applicable [5].
In a study conducted across seven PEPFAR-supported countries (Côte d’Ivoire, Kenya, Malawi, Mozambique, Namibia, South Africa, and Uganda) with a high pediatric HIV burden, an increasing proportion of VL tests were observed using dried blood spots, and lower sample rejection rates were noted for DBS compared to plasma [22]. A recent article published in AIDS Patient Care and STDs in 2023 asserted that DBS is a suitable and cost-effective tool for viral load monitoring when an ideal implementation protocol is followed to increase viral load testing in the population [23].

5. Principle of Dried Blood Spot-Based HIV-1 Viral Load Testing

The principle of DBS-based HIV-1 viral load testing revolves around the collection, drying, and subsequent analysis of a small volume of blood from an individual living with HIV (Figure 2). This method eliminates the need for immediate sample processing and enables easy transportation and storage.
Healthcare 12 00413 g003
Figure 2. Workflow of dried blood spot viral load testing: This figure presents a detailed workflow illustrating the process of conducting viral load testing using DBS samples. The workflow begins with the collection of a small blood sample, typically obtained through a fingerstick. The DBS cards, on which the blood is applied, are then allowed to dry thoroughly. Subsequently, the dried blood spot cards are packaged and transported to the testing facility. Within the laboratory, the DBS samples undergo extraction of RNA and are subjected to molecular assays, such as polymerase chain reaction (PCR), to quantify HIV-1 RNA levels. The final steps involve result interpretation, contributing to a comprehensive understanding of the DBS viral load testing procedure.

Methodology for Working with Dried Blood Spot

Dried blood spots are specimens prepared by collecting the blood spots from a finger or heel prick and spotting them directly onto a filter paper, which is then used for testing in the laboratory as a sample. The detailed process involves the following steps:
  • Blood Collection: A small volume of blood, usually obtained through a finger prick, is collected onto a filter paper card specifically designed for DBS collection. The filter paper absorbs the blood and preserves it.
  • Drying: The blood-soaked filter paper is allowed to air-dry completely, usually at room temperature. This step stabilizes the blood components on the filter paper, preventing degradation of the biological material.
  • Sample transport and storage: Once dried, the DBS card can be stored at room temperature for an extended period. This eliminates the need for immediate cold-chain transportation and storage, making it particularly advantageous in resource-limited or remote settings.
  • Sample extraction and analysis: To perform HIV-1 viral load testing, a small disc or punch is cut from the dried blood spot on the filter paper. This disc is then extracted to obtain the genetic material (RNA) of the virus. The extracted RNA is then subjected to nucleic acid amplification techniques, such as reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), to quantify the amount of HIV-1 viral RNA present in the blood.
The viral load determined through DBS analysis directly reflects the quantity of the virus present in an individual’s bloodstream. This metric holds immense significance as it serves as a critical gauge for assessing HIV progression and gauging the effectiveness of antiretroviral therapy. HIV-1 viral load testing through DBS analysis presents a streamlined, cost-efficient, and pragmatic means of monitoring the HIV-1 viral load, especially in regions grappling with limited resources or intricate logistical challenges.

This entry is adapted from the peer-reviewed paper 10.3390/healthcare12040413

References

  1. Blaurock, G.; Rische, H.; Rohne, K. Development of the blotting paper method in the dried blood reaction for syphilis. Dtsch. Gesundheitsw. 1950, 5, 462–464.
  2. Tuaillon, E.; Kania, D.; Pisoni, A.; Bollore, K.; Taieb, F.; Ontsira Ngoyi, E.N.; Schaub, R.; Plantier, J.-C.; Makinson, A.; Van de Perre, P. Dried Blood Spot Tests for the Diagnosis and Therapeutic Monitoring of HIV and Viral Hepatitis B and C. Front. Microbiol. 2020, 11, 373.
  3. WHO. Consolidated Guidelines on HIV Prevention, Diagnosis, Treatment and Care for Key Populations; WHO: Geneva, Switzerland, 2016.
  4. Simushi, P.; Kalunga, M.N.; Mwakyoma, T.; Mwewa, M.; Muchaili, L.; Hazeemba, N.; Mulenga, C.; Mwewa, P.; Chiyenu, K.O.R.; Kachimba, J.; et al. Verification of Dried Blood Spot as a Sample Type for HIV Viral Load and Early Infant Diagnosis on Hologic Panther in Zambia. BMC Res. Notes 2023, 16, 75.
  5. Makadzange, A.T.; Boyd, F.K.; Chimukangara, B.; Masimirembwa, C.; Katzenstein, D.; Ndhlovu, C.E. A Simple Phosphate-Buffered-Saline-Based Extraction Method Improves Specificity of HIV Viral Load Monitoring Using Dried Blood Spots. J. Clin. Microbiol. 2017, 55, 2172–2179.
  6. CDC. Shipping Guidelines for Dried-Blood Spot Specimens; CDC: Atlanta, GA, USA, 2017.
  7. Pannus, P.; Claus, M.; Gonzalez, M.M.P.; Ford, N.; Fransen, K. Sensitivity and Specificity of Dried Blood Spots for HIV-1 Viral Load Quantification: A Laboratory Assessment of 3 Commercial Assays. Medicine 2016, 95, e5475.
  8. Tang, N.; Pahalawatta, V.; Frank, A.; Bagley, Z.; Viana, R.; Lampinen, J.; Leckie, G.; Huang, S.; Abravaya, K.; Wallis, C.L. HIV-1 Viral Load Measurement in Venous Blood and Fingerprick Blood Using Abbott RealTime HIV-1 DBS Assay. J. Clin. Virol. 2017, 92, 56–61.
  9. Zeh, C.; Ndiege, K.; Inzaule, S.; Achieng, R.; Williamson, J.; Chih-Wei Chang, J.; Ellenberger, D.; Nkengasong, J. Evaluation of the Performance of Abbott M2000 and Roche COBAS Ampliprep/COBAS Taqman Assays for HIV-1 Viral Load Determination Using Dried Blood Spots and Dried Plasma Spots in Kenya. PLoS ONE 2017, 12, e0179316.
  10. Schmitz, M.E.; Agolory, S.; Junghae, M.; Broyles, L.N.; Kimeu, M.; Ombayo, J.; Umuro, M.; Mukui, I.; Alwenya, K.; Baraza, M.; et al. Field Evaluation of Dried Blood Spots for HIV-1 Viral Load Monitoring in Adults and Children Receiving Antiretroviral Treatment in Kenya: Implications for Scale-up in Resource-Limited Settings. J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 2017, 74, 399–406.
  11. WHO. Public Reports of World Health Organization Prequalified IVDs: Abbott RealTime HIV-1 (M2000sp). PQDx 0145-027-00; WHO: Geneva, Switzerland, 2023.
  12. Gutema, G.; Hailu, H.; W/semeyat, B.; Yilma, A.; Abdela, S.; Kidane, E.; Adane, S.; Yimer, M.; Tsegaye, A. Effect of Sample Management on Quantitative HIV-1 Viral Load Measurement at Saint Paul’s Hospital Millennium Medical College, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. PLoS ONE 2022, 17, e0269943.
  13. Vidya, M.; Saravanan, S.; Rifkin, S.; Solomon, S.S.; Waldrop, G.; Mayer, K.H.; Solomon, S.; Balakrishnan, P. Dried Blood Spots versus Plasma for the Quantitation of HIV-1 RNA Using a Real-Time PCR, M2000rt Assay. J. Virol. Methods 2012, 181, 177–181.
  14. Neogi, U.; Gupta, S.; Rodridges, R.; Sahoo, P.N.; Rao, S.D.; Rewari, B.B.; Shastri, S.; Costa, A.D.; Shet, A. Dried Blood Spot HIV-1 RNA Quantification: A Useful Tool for Viral Load Monitoring among HIV-Infected Individuals in India. Indian. J. Med. Res. 2012, 136, 956–962.
  15. Taieb, F.; Tran Hong, T.; Ho, H.T.; Nguyen Thanh, B.; Pham Phuong, T.; Viet Ta, D.; Le Thi Hong, N.; Ba Pham, H.; Nguyen, L.T.H.; Nguyen, H.T.; et al. First Field Evaluation of the Optimized CE Marked Abbott Protocol for HIV RNA Testing on Dried Blood Spot in a Routine Clinical Setting in Vietnam. PLoS ONE 2018, 13, e0191920.
  16. Benedicto, P.; Dladla, P.; Goba, G.; Shawa, I. Assessment of the Accuracy of Dried Blood Spot (DBS) Sample in HIV-1 Viral Load as Compared to Plasma Sample Using Abbot Assay. Int. J. Res. Med. Sci. 2013, 1, 338.
  17. Mwau, M.; Danda, J.; Mbugua, J.; Handa, A.; Fortunko, J.; Worlock, A.; Nair, S.V. Prospective Evaluation of Accuracy of HIV Viral Load Monitoring Using the Aptima HIV Quant Dx Assay with Fingerstick and Venous Dried Blood Spots Prepared under Field Conditions in Kenya. PLoS ONE 2021, 16, e0249376.
  18. Mahajan, N.B.S.; Aggarwal, S. Use of Dried Blood Spots as a Screening Method in STI Testing: A Mini-Review. Public Health Open Access 2022, 6, 000203.
  19. Kamble, S.; Shidhaye, P.; Mukherjee, A.; Tak, M.; Bembalkar, S.; Aggarwal, S.; Deb, A.; Kapoor, N.; Verma, V.; Das, C.; et al. A Protocol for Feasibility of Plasma Based GeneXpert Platform and Dried Blood Spot (DBS) Based Abbott Platform for HIV-1 Viral Load Testing among the People Living with HIV Attending ART Centers in India. PLoS ONE 2023, 18, e0285942.
  20. Nguyen, T.A.; Tran, T.H.; Nguyen, B.T.; Pham, T.T.P.; Hong Le, N.T.; Ta, D.V.; Phan, H.T.T.; Nguyen, L.H.; Ait-Ahmed, M.; Ho, H.T.; et al. Feasibility of Dried Blood Spots for HIV Viral Load Monitoring in Decentralized Area in North Vietnam in a Test-and-Treat Era, the MOVIDA Project. PLoS ONE 2020, 15, e0230968.
  21. Teran, R.A.; Sobieszczyk, M.E.; Chiasson, M.A.; Uhlemann, A.-C.; Weidler, J.; Shah, J.G.; Chang, J.Y.; Otto, C.; Hirshfield, S. Longitudinal Viral Load Monitoring Using Home-Collected Dried Blood Spot Specimens of MSM Living with HIV: Results from a Feasibility Pilot Study. AIDS Behav. 2021, 25, 661–666.
  22. Hrapcak, S.; Pals, S.; Itoh, M.; Peters, N.; Carpenter, D.; Hackett, S.; Prao, A.K.; Adje-Toure, C.; Eboi, E.; Mutisya, I.; et al. HIV Viral Load Scale-up Among Children and Adolescents: Trends in Viral Load Suppression, Sample Type and Processing in 7 PEPFAR Countries, 2015–2018. Pediatr. Infect. Dis. J. 2023, 42, e102–e104.
  23. Nguyen, L.B.L.; Soumah, A.A.; Hoang, V.T.; Nguyen, A.T.; Pham, T.H.; Royer-Devaux, S.; Madec, Y. Performances of Dried Blood Spots and Point-of-Care Devices to Identify Virological Failure in HIV-Infected Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. AIDS Patient Care STDS 2023, 37, 66–83.
More
© Text is available under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.
This entry is offline, you can click here to edit this entry!
ScholarVision Creations
Feedback