Eco-Sustainable Approaches for Fungal Biodeterioration on Easel Painting: History
Please note this is an old version of this entry, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Subjects: Art
Contributor: , , ,

Cultural Heritage (CH) materials are susceptible to being complexly damaged physically, chemically, and aesthetically by the growing and metabolic activities of living beings, as investigators know as biodeterioration. Historical easel paintings have a mixture of materials and layers, increasing their conservation complexity. Materials such as cellulose on the support, rabbit skin glue, egg yolk, linseed oil, or varnishes on the polychromy are some organic materials that can compound an easel painting, although the painting layer also contains inorganic pigments. These organic materials can be degraded by fungi if the environmental conditions are favorable. Eliminating and controlling fungal biodeterioration is one of the most important challenges of easel painting conservation.

  • biodeterioration
  • fungi
  • easel paintings
  • wood
  • textile fibers

1. Introduction

Cultural Heritage (CH) materials are susceptible to being complexly damaged physically, chemically, and aesthetically by the growing and metabolic activities of living beings, as investigators know as biodeterioration [1]. Many studies have been performed concerning vegetal or microbiological biodeterioration on inorganic materials, such as mural paintings [2,3,4,5], stone buildings [6,7,8,9], or stone sculptures [10,11,12,13,14]. Easel painting biodeterioration is a less-studied topic, although, in the last ten years, there has been more interest in their biological control and prevention [15,16,17,18,19,20].
Historical easel paintings have a mixture of materials and layers, increasing their conservation complexity. Materials such as cellulose on the support, rabbit skin glue, egg yolk, linseed oil, or varnishes on the polychromy are some organic materials that can compound an easel painting, although the painting layer also contains inorganic pigments [37,38]. These organic materials can be degraded by fungi if the environmental conditions are favorable (Figure 1). More common fungi are mesophiles, whose ideal conditions revolve around 20–30 °C and a Relative Humidity (RH) higher than 70%, and pH conditions between 4 and 6 [18,20,39,40,41].
Figure 1. (A) Filamentous fungi growth on the obverse a Bartolomé Mongrell’s oil on canvas painting (Museu Municipal d’Alzira, València, Spain). (B) Fungal growth on the reverse of Santos Juanes Church’s (València, Spain) oil on canvas marouflage.
In the specific literature about fungal biodeterioration of easel painting, there are many fungal families that can grow on this kind of surface, of which the most prevalent are exposed in Table 1. All those fungi are mostly from the phylum Ascomycota, although there are fungi from the phylum Basidiomycota or Mucoromycota, which are three types of filamentous fungi. Filamentous fungi are formed by hyphae—large cell filaments—that generally have walls between them and are called coenocytic hyphae. Depending on their function, this kind of fungi has two different types of structures: vegetative mycelium, which penetrates the substrate and absorbs nutrients, and aerial mycelium and fruitful bodies, which are responsible for reproductive function [42] (Figure 2).
Figure 2. (A) Cross-section of A. niger cultivated in agar. (1) Fruitful bodies (dark parts): spores-production structures. (2) Aerial mycelium: white hyphae on surface. (3). Vegetative mycelium: white hyphae into the agar medium. (B) Penicillium spp. fruitful bodies and areal mycelium on a cotton canvas mock-up.
Table 1. Most common fungal species on easel painting.
Species Genus Order Phylum References
Aerobasidium pullulans Aerobasidium Dothideales Ascomycota [38,43,44,45,46,47,48]
Alternaria alternata Alternaria Pleosporales Ascomycota [38,45,47,48,49,50]
Aspergillus clavatus Aspergillus Eurotiales Ascomycota [38]
Aspergillus flavus Aspergillus Eurotiales Ascomycota [45,46,51,52]
Aspergillus fumigatus Aspergillus Eurotiales Ascomycota [48]
Aspergillus niger Apergillus Eurotiales Ascomycota [43,44,47,48,49,50,51,53,54]
Aspergillus sp. Apergillus Eurotiales Ascomycota [41,55]
Aspergillus versicolor Aspergillus Eurotiales Ascomycota [43,45,48,50]
Bjerkandera adusta Bjerkandera Polyporales Basidiomycota [38]
Chaetonium globosum Chaetonium Sordariales Ascomycota [44,47,48,52,56]
Cladosporium cladosporioides Cladosporium Capnodiales Ascomycota [43,44,45,46,48,50]
Cladosporium sp. Cladosporium Capnodiales Ascomycota [41]
Filobasidium magnum Filobasidium Filobasidiales Basidiomycota [38,41,45]
Mucor spp. Mucor Mucorales Mucoromycota
Penicillium chrysogenum Penicillium Eurotiales Ascomycota [20,38,43,44,45,50,52,53,54]
Penicillium sp. Penicillium Eurotiales Ascomycota [20,41]
The development of fungal strains damages easel painting materials in different ways, causing a multitude of pathologies depending on the substrate and the strain [57]. Generally, fungal growth produces acidification, chromatic changes, structural damage across chemical mechanisms—liberation of fatty acids and enzymatic action— and mycelium growth [19] (Figure 3). Microbial deterioration usually affects the painting support in the first instance, reaching and colonizing the pictorial layers in later phases [58]. The organic nature of these materials presents a large carbon source for microorganisms, which makes them susceptible to biological attack. In addition, the presence of glues or coating pastes applied as sizing treatments increases that susceptibility. Aesthetical damages are generally related to pigment production. Ascomycota strains such as A. niger produces azanigerones B and C—yellow [59]—or other colors from pale yellow to brown [60]. Cladosporium sp. and Fusarium sp. produce anhydrofusarubin—red [61,62]—or A. versicolor produces asperversin—yellow [63]. Red-orange, β-carotene, is the most produced pigment by Mucoromycota as a preventive measure for stress oxidative damages [64].
Figure 3. Fungal biodeterioration mechanism and damages on canvas painting (adapted from Poyatos et al., 2018 [19]). (A) (1) Non-biodeteriorated oil on canvas painting; (2) presence of fungal spores (orange) on the surface; (3) moisture of canvas (blue) due to RH increase and fungal development. (4) Biodeteriorated painting. (B) Damages on painting strata; (1) Pigmentation (pink); (2) mechanical damage of painting film; (3) dissolution of painting film. (C) Damages on canvas support; (1) pigmentation (pink); (2) fiber’s debilitation (red); (3) fiber’s disintegration.

2. Fungal Biodeterioration of Wood on Easel Paintings

Wood was the most important painting support until canvas popularization in the 16th century. It presents well-known biodeterioration problems due to its use in different industries or as a construction material [65]. Wood fungal biodeterioration can be classified as white rot, brown rot (exclusively by Basidiomycota), and soft rot (generally Ascomycota), depending on the produced damages [66,67]. Brown rot fungi feed on cellulose and produce brown pigmentation and structural damage on wood, while white rot fungi also feed on lignin and produce discoloration [68]. Soft rot fungi can produce lignin and cellulose, penetrating the surface at various centimeters, producing cavities and erosion [67]. Recently, Afifi et al., 2023 [69] detected biodeterioration damages produced by Aspergillus sp., such as discoloration or hyphae penetration into the wooden support of mock-ups based on a historical stucco (Sultan al-Ashraf Qaytbay Mausoleum, Egypt).

3. Fungal Biodeterioration of Textile Fibers on Easel Paintings

Starting in the 17th century, textile fibers began to expand as the main artistic support due to their lower cost or technical characteristics, such as the possibility of producing larger and lighter formats, the contribution of texture, or the ease of transport and storage [19,70]. The historical textiles usually used are made of natural fiber fabrics, such as cotton, hemp, linen, or jute. These fabrics’ main component is cellulose, which comes from the plant fibers from which the materials are obtained [58,71]. For example, cotton comprises seed fibers, while flax or jute are made from phloem fibers [58]. The main component of the cell walls of tissues of plant origin is cellulose. Cellulose is a polysaccharide formed by a crystalline region with great resistance to biodeterioration and an amorphous region easily attacked by microorganisms, in which the biological attack usually begins [72]. The fungal deterioration of tissues happens mainly due to the production capacity of intracellular and extracellular hydrolytic enzymes and organic acids, using natural fibers as a carbon source for their growth and development. These enzymes are cellulases, breaking cellulose’s intramolecular bonds and obtaining glucose molecules [71,72]. That is, they decrease the degree of polymerization of the cellulose molecules [73]. This can cause fiber breakage and thinning and, therefore, a decrease in the individual resistance of the fibers and the textile [72].
In addition, organic acids produce minerals for some phototrophs and have a wide variety of pigments, being the first alteration of fungal biodeterioration and complex to eliminate. Therefore, the amount of cellulose in the tissues will be decisive regarding their vulnerability to being colonized by micro-organisms. Of the fabrics widely used as pictorial textile supports, cotton is the material that has the highest amount of cellulose (90%), followed by linen (80%), hemp (77%), and finally, jute (60%) [58,71]. Factors such as composition or fiber and the structural and chemical characteristics of the textile influence the risk of biodeterioration. Increasing the amount of cellulose—in addition to pectins or pentoses—on the textile composition will increase the biodeterioration susceptibility, too. However, some substances are present in textiles that few microorganisms cannot metabolize, such as lignin [71,74]. Structurally and chemically, the cellulose chains’ length, degree of polymerization and crystallinity, the fibers’ orientation or the threads’ thickness, and their chemical, photochemical, and mechanical degradation must be considered [19,71,75,76].

4. Fungal Biodeterioration of Oil Binders in Easel Paintings

On polychromies, fungal biodeterioration affects the chemical and physical stability: while fatty acids acidify the surface, esterases and lipases disaggregate the pictorial layer, damaging the oil medium and producing resistance loss, fracture, and detachments in extreme cases [19,77,78]. Therefore, enzyme liberation supposes triacylglycerols hydrolyzation by lipases and the aqueous part hydrolyzation by esterases, favoring the mycelium growth, which produces microcracks [54,79]. As ideal conditions for fungal growth—high RH—are also prejudicial for easel paintings because of the different mechanical behavior between layers [80], a synergy between biodeterioration agents and other types of alteration is caused, such as moisture, dust, or environmental contaminants [81]. Contrary to support, pictorial films have more factors in the biodeterioration mechanisms, such as pigments. Paintings with Pb, Zn, Cr, or Cd are more resistant to fungal biodeterioration, while earth pigments are more susceptible [82,83]. Different investigations studied the effect of fungal strains isolated from easel paintings. Salvador et al., 2017 [15] analyzed the biodeterioration of different Giorgio Marini (1836–1905) portraits conserved in museums or private collections in Évora, Portugal. Strains of Aspergillus sp., Cladosporium sp., Penicillium sp., and Mucor sp. were isolated, attributing their growth to the presence of proteinaceous binders and inadequate climate conditions. Even in outdoor environments, Poyatos-Jiménez et al., 2021 [41] evaluated the biodeterioration of a collection of paintings placed on different Cloisters of Quito, Ecuador. In their study, researchers isolated strains of Aspergillus sp., Mucor sp., Cladosporium sp., or Penicillium sp. They attributed their biodeterioration pathologies to the semi-tropical environment where the paintings are exhibited.

This entry is adapted from the peer-reviewed paper 10.3390/coatings14010124

This entry is offline, you can click here to edit this entry!