2. Interactions between Entomopathogenic Fungi and Pests
Biological control of invasive pests also relies on certain entomopathogenic fungi (EFs) that can infect hosts in agroecosystems and appear suitable for plant protection exploitation. For many years, the search for such species used their isolation from insect carcasses, followed by identification using conventional light or electron microscopy techniques. Thanks to the development of molecular methods, especially DNA sequencing and omics technologies, it is now possible to identify the most crucial EFs species and detect their presence in different ecological niches, including the soil or plant environments.
EFs number around 1000 species
[[1816]], the best-known being
Aspergillus spp.,
Penicillium spp.,
Fusarium spp., and
Acremonium spp.
[[1917]]. Infection usually occurs through propagules that germinate and invade the host body after contact; the invasive mycelium then coloni
zses the host until it dies. Conidiation from emerging hyphae and/or the production of resting propagules follow the host death
[[2018]].
Among the EFs primarily used for pest control, some
Beauveria spp. (Hypocreales, Cordycipitaceae) are widely used against, for example, the coffee berry weevil
Hypothenemus hampei (Ferrari, 1867) (Coleoptera, Curculionidae)
[[1715]], the Asian corn borer
Ostrinia furnacalis Guenée, 1854 (Lepidoptera, Crambidae), and the sweet potato weevil
Cylas formicarius (Fabricius, 1798) (Coleoptera, Brentidae)
[[2119]]. Many studies have deepened the knowledge about the role of
Beauveria bassiana (Bals.) Vuill, 1912, as its insecticidal activity is due not only to the hyphae penetrating and spreading in the host body but also to the effect caused by various toxins
[[2220]]. This fungus demonstrated its relevance in banana crops protection from
Cosmopolites sordidus (Germar, 1824) (Coleoptera, Dryophthoridae)
[[2321],[2422],[2523]] due to its ability to significantly reduce the weevil survival
[[2523]].
Beauveria bassiana products are widely applied on banana plantations to manage
C. sordidus and use pheromone for mass trapping. Another
Beauveria species,
Beauveria caledonica, is responsible for the lethal infections of
C. sordidus in banana plantations in South America. This fungus produces various secondary metabolites and can modulate the pest immune response
[[2523],[2624]]. Studies with
Metarhizium anisopliae (Metschn.) Sorok, 1883 reported the potential of this fungus in controlling adult weevils
[[2725]].
Several studies are underway to control
P. spumarius, indicated as the main vector of the bacterium
Xylella fastidiosa Wells, Raju et al., 1986 involved in the OQDS (Olive Quick Decline Syndrome) in the Salento Peninsula (southern Italy). The insect can acquire and inoculate the bacterium from/to different host plants
[[2826]]; therefore, it is essential to limit the transmission of
X. fastidiosa by managing its vector. Recent studies analy
zse the ability of some
Trichoderma spp. isolates in decreasing the survival of
P. spumarius [[29]27]]. An innovative IPM approach may include developing EF-based biocontrol actions. EF also represents an essential source of natural molecules capable of affecting
P. spumarius metabolism and reproduction, thus limiting the pests’ indirect damage to plants
[[2927]].
Species of the genus
Trichoderma are among the most studied and used biocontrol agents worldwide. They not only produce benefits as plant growth promoters but also act, with various mechanisms, against other microorganisms in plant defen
sce. Volatile and non-volatile compounds produced by some species of
Trichoderma can be perceived by the olfactory structures of
P. spumarius [[2927]], modifying and directing the insect’s food preferences towards other areas of reduced agricultural interest
[[2927],[3028],[3129]].
Although supported by valid research data, the information available in the literature on the exploitation of EFs as biocontrol agents still needs to be comprehensive. Critical data on the exploitation of EFs as practical means of biological control and information on the mechanisms involved in fungal-insect interactions still need to be included in many world regions. Therefore, efforts are still required to identify and characteri
zse new fungal strains to investigate their entomopathogenic capacity as an alternative to pesticides.
3. Multitrophic Interactions of Entomopathogenic Fungi, Crops, and Insects
Insect pathogens were isolated from Mediterranean soils (Alicante, SE Spain) using
Galleria mellonella L., 1758 (Lepidoptera, Pyralidae) larvae baits
[[3230]]. Samples from 61 sites were from agroecosystems and forests, while soils under
Nerium oleander L., 1753, gave results from natural environments and gardens. Entomopathogenic fungi (EFs) are the most frequent insect pathogens (32.8% soils).
Beauveria bassiana is the most abundant species (21% soil).
Metarhizium anisopliae (6.4%) and
Akanthomyces lecanii (Zimm.) Spatafora, Kepler
, and Shrestha, 2017 {
Lecanicillium lecanii (Zimm.) Gams [=
Verticillium lecanii Zimm.]} (4.8%) are less frequent.
Beauveria bassiana also scored the highest virulence in a single soil sample (ca. 90% infected insects) and is the most frequent EF (77.8%) in soils under
N. oleander. Soils from commercial crop fields of food security importance, such as bananas, are also reservoirs of EFs
[[3331]]. Reports indicate that
B. bassiana is a cosmopolitan entomopathogen, especially in warm areas
[[3432]]. Economically important pests, such as thrips
[[3533]], aphids
[[3634]], or pine processionary (
Thaumetopoea pityocampa [Denis and Schiffermüller, 1775] [Lepidoptera, Notodontidae])
[[3735]], were detected naturally infected with EFs.
Beauveria bassiana (isolate Bb203) also infected adults of the Red Palm Weevil,
Rhynchophorus ferrugineus Olivier, 1790 (RPW), in the field (palm groves) just at the first weevil introduction in south-eastern Spain
[[3836]].
Beauveria bassiana 203 proved more pathogenic to
R. ferrugineus than strains from other hosts and sources
[[3937]]. The strain applied three times at three-month intervals to field palms naturally infested with RPW caused 70–85% insect mortality
[[4038]]. Therefore, EFs are present in arid environments and have great potential for IPM of severe insect pests
[[4139],[4240]].
EFs can also coloni
zse plants and plant waste. The latter is the most frequent component of soil organic matter. Evaluation of the growth and multiplication (conidiation) of common entomopathogens rises from inoculation (on almond peels) and gardening (palm waste) substrates obtained from Mediterranean ecosystems by-products of agriculture
[[4341]]. The development of entomopathogens depends on the type of substrate.
Akanthomyces lecanii grows and sporulates well on almond mesocarp, but
Paecilomyces farinosus (Holmsk.) A.H.S.Br. and G.Sm., 1957 does not.
Beauveria bassiana uses palm seed nutrients for growth and sporulation, and leaves of the Mediterranean dwarf palm
Chamaerops humilis L., 1753 promote the growth and sporulation of both
A. lecanii and
B. bassiana. The date palm (
Phoenix dactylifera L., 1753) has a mycobiota that includes-sporulating fungi (
Penicillium spp. and
Cladosporium spp.).
Fusarium oxysporum Schltdl., 1824 saprotroph and an undescribed
Lecanicillium c.f.
psalliotae (Treschew) Zare and W. Gams, 2001 entomopathogen colonise leaves infested with Marlatt red-scale (
Phoenicococcus marlatti Cockerell, 1899—Hemiptera, Phoenicococcidae)
[[4442]]. Palm pathogens, entomopathogenic and saprotrophic fungi strongly interact with each other;
B. bassiana strongly inhibits
Penicillium vermoesenii [=
Nalanthamala vermoesenii (Biourge) Schroers, 2005] (
Figure 1), a fungal necrotrophy of palms.
Figure 1. Beauveria bassiana (red arrows) inhibits the fungus palm pathogen Penicillium vermoesenii (green arrows). (A) Both fungi interact directly on the PDA medium. (B) The same two fungi on top of a dialysis membrane overlaid onto PDA.
EFs (
B. bassiana,
Lecanicillium dimorphum (J.D.Chen) Zare and W.Gams, 2001, and
Lecanicillium c.f.
psalliotae) artificially inoculated in living plants act as true endophytes
[[4543]]; fungi survive and spread in date palm (
P. dactylifera) petiole tissues (parenchyma and vascular tissue) at least 30 days after inoculation.
Beauveria bassiana is a natural endophyte from date palm roots
[[4644]]. This fungus was isolated from the roots of date palms in two coastal dune sites with high and low human impact in south-eastern Spain. Root coloni
zsation by endophytic insect-pathogenic fungi has recently been reviewed
[[4745]]. Root and microbiota respiration
[[4846]] depletes oxygen in the rhizosphere. Fungal parasites of invertebrates, such as the nematophagous
Pochonia chlamydosporia (Goddard) Zare and W. Gams, 2001 or the entomopathogens
B. bassiana and
M. anisopliae, breach chitin-rich barriers to infect the host. These biocontrol fungi can also ferment chitosan, a chitin derivative
[[4947]]. Apart from their application in biofuel production, this trait can be an adaptation for survival and insect infection by EFs in the rhizosphere. Entomopathogenic fungi are part of phylloplane and rhizosphere mycobiomes. Their endophytic behavio
ur allows them to coloni
zse plant-derived substrates, affecting plant-volatile emissions during insect infestations
[[5048]]. Plant-derived substrates, such as rice grains, can be used for mass production and formulation of EFs
[[5149],[5250]].
Based on previous reports (see above) on the endophytic behavio
ur of EFs, several studies tested the response of palms to inoculation with these biocontrol fungi.
Beauveria bassiana,
L. dimorphum, and
L. cf.
psalliotae induced proteins in plant defen
sce or stress response
[[5351]]. The plant immune system responds to microbe-associated molecular patterns (MAMPs) derived from conserved structures (i.e., cell walls) of plant pathogens such as chitin
[[5452]]. Chitosan can permeabili
zse the membrane and kill plant pathogens such as bacteria and fungi in its deacetylated form
[[55]53]]. EFs and nematophagous fungi (NFs) are compatible with chitosan since they have evolved low-fluidity membranes
[[5654],[57]55]] and branched cell walls rich in β-1,3-glucan
[[58]56]]. Moreover, EFs and NFs are in contact with chitin during host (insects and nematodes, respectively) infection. Chitosan modifies the transcriptome and biology of fungi and plants, causing cell stress
[[5957]]. Chitosan can enhance the pathogenicity of fungal parasites of nematode eggs
[[58],[59],[60][61][62]]. These are close relatives of EFs, such as
Metarhizium spp.
[[6361]]. Tests will explain the effect of chitosan on the EFs’ pathogenicity.
Acoustics reveals that RPW larvae have briefer movement and feeding activity with
B. bassiana infection
[[6462]]. Researchers also have evidence that
B. bassiana formulates used for RPW biocontrol in the field
[[4038]] repel adults of this insect pest
[[6563]]. Evidence suggested investigating entomopathogenic fungi and close fungal pathogens of invertebrates for volatiles capable of modifying the behavio
ur of insects of economic importance, such as weevils. Entomopathogenic fungi and close relative nematophagous fungi (
Pochonia spp. egg parasites) emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs) capable of repelling
C. sordidus [[33]31]] and RPW
[[66]64]]. P201930831 and P202230103 insect repellents patented VOCs are on field trial for efficacy.
Finally, EFs are a component of plant and soil microbiomes. They are efficient insect pathogens with a multitrophic lifestyle, including plant endophytism, inducing plant defen
sces
, and modifying insect pest behavio
ur with their VOCs, which work as low environmental impact tools for insect pest management.