2. Classification of Medical Waste
According to estimates by the WHO, 15 to 20% of medical wastes can be classified as hazardous materials due to their infectivity, toxicity, and, sometimes, radioactivity
[13][14]. However, medical waste management practices are not constant or standardised in all countries because this categorisation is unclear or decisive
[15].
Medical waste refers directly or indirectly to infectious, toxic, or otherwise hazardous waste (HMW), illustrated in
Figure 1 and described with examples in
Table 1. Medical institutions generate this type of waste during medical or preventative care and related activities, specifically infectious, pathological, damaging, pharmaceutical, and chemical waste
[1]. On the other hand, non-hazardous medical waste (NHMW) includes all different regular non-infectious fractions of waste, such as municipal solid waste. HMW is usually contaminated with pathogens. Therefore, it can cause a wide range of infections and diseases in the case of misuse or poor handling and discarding. Adding to that, it can cause environmental contamination in the case of poor management, causing pollution to land, water, plants, animals, and air, leading to the spread of diseases.
Figure 1. Different types of hazardous medical waste.
Table 1. Healthcare waste categorisation according to WHO and the EU
[3][16].
Table 2. A comparison between treatment methods in terms of advantages and disadvantages.
-
Leaching to the soil and underlying aquifers,
-
-
Bioaccumulation,
-
Leaving a footprint on the environment,
-
Destruction of habitats.
In the production phase of any medical equipment, the impact of these types of equipment must be considered by performing a life cycle analysis (LCA) and practicing proper treatment techniques. However, the methods and techniques for treatment have minimal impact in terms of carbon emissions released into the ambient air. For example, a single intravitreal injection causes the release of 0.05 kg CO
2e during the disposal phase
[21].
Several treatment methods for MW are illustrated in
Table 2, with their primary advantages and disadvantages. Despite these challenges, these methods can reduce the hazards mentioned earlier. The treatments currently in the field are incineration, autoclave disinfection, microwave disinfection, and mechanical and chemical disinfection
[20].
MW can also affect physical and mental health and patients’ and health workers’ quality of life
[17]. The plastic portion of MW is approximately 20% to 30%
[18].
3. Medical Waste Management Process
Medical waste management is a series of steps where the MW generated is handled from the generation point until it can be disposed of safely. The steps of the MW management process are shown in
Figure 2. The success of the waste management process is demonstrated in limiting the waste going for disposal and achieving a circular economy, where the materials used within the medical system are maximally utilised, reaching almost zero waste.
Figure 2. Flow scheme for medical waste management.
3.1. Waste Generation
The medical waste generated is of various classifications, as mentioned in the previous section. The critical aspect of this step is the amount of waste produced and how it is handled to prevent hazards to the personnel in contact with it. The waste generated from medical institutions can be minimised to reduce waste accumulation. The minimisation can be approached from different directions, such as reduction in waste at source, recycling, and stock management. The reduction in waste at the source can be achieved by reusing materials that will not harm the users, such as washable tablecloths, tableware, and refill containers for cleaning supplies
[19]. Recycling can aid in minimising waste by recycling plastics and metals and composting food waste. Finally, stock management will help set an organised system of the medicines inventory to prevent duplication and purchase of unnecessary products that could expire, thus reducing potential waste
[19].
3.2. Waste Segregation
Segregation identifies the various types of waste and how they can be collected separately. Segregation is mainly achieved by separating different categories of MW in different colour bins or bags specified for each category
[19]. Therefore, this causes a problem when collecting from various sources due to the lack of standardisation of the colours associated with each waste category
[14], thus increasing the needed time and financial cost of labour and equipment to separate the waste and direct it to the proper waste stream, resulting in a problem. The segregation should mostly occur at the point source except for the waste undergoing the same treatment, which could be separated in the treatment facility
[19]. The sharp objects should always be separated at the source
[19]. The segregation is carried out by medical staff, which requires training to safely dispose of waste to avoid infections
[14]. If a mistake occurs while segregating waste, it should not be corrected to prevent the contamination of the other waste
[19]. Medical waste should be stored safely to avoid unauthorised human contact, which can cause infections
[14].
3.3. Waste Collection and Transportation
The frequency of MW collection should be as high as once per day to avoid the accumulation of waste, which can spread infections. In addition, the personnel responsible for collection should be equipped with safety gear to prevent contaminations and infections that should be safely disposed of
[19]. The waste is collected from the health care entity and transported using secondary transportation to the treatment facility for disposal, recycling, and treatment processes. Treatment facilities are either located within the health care facility or off-site in a separate location
[14].
3.4. Waste Treatment
Medical waste treatment is a process carried out before the disposal of MW to limit the hazardous effects of this type of waste on the environment and health. The lack of proper treatment can have several impacts, as follows
[20]:
3.4.1. Incineration
Incineration is the most widely practised treatment method due to its applicability to treating all waste types
[22]. The incineration process is carried out in furnaces operated at temperatures of 800–1200 °C
[22]. High temperatures kill pathogens, destroy 90% of organics, and change waste characteristics such as weight, volume, and shape
[22]. This process is governed by several parameters such as
[20]:
Incineration produces fly ash and emissions such as dioxins, furans, and mercury
[22]. Dioxins and furans are considered carcinogenic, have a half-life ranging from 7 to 11 years, and are persistent footprints on the environment
[22]. Dioxin emissions can be reduced if the complete combustion of waste is achieved
[22]. The dioxins emitted can also be treated using selective non-catalytic reduction (SNCR)
[23]. This technology depends on the production of free nitrogen via the reaction between nitric oxide and ammonia, and this gas is considered to be of high effectiveness and low cost
[23]. Mercury represents 3–9% of the emissions from incineration, which impacts the nervous system and general health
[22]. Fly ash is the solid residue from incineration, rich in heavy metals
[24]. Fly ash can be recycled but has to undergo chemical pre-treatment first by using ethylene diamine tetra acetic acid disodium (EDTA) or sodium sulphide, which removes the heavy metals from the fly ash
[24]. Approximately 3 kg of CO
2 is produced from burning 1 kg of clinical waste, therefore, incinerating MW contributes to global warming by releasing significant amounts of greenhouse gases (GHG), mainly CO
2 [25].
3.4.2. Autoclave Disinfection
Autoclave disinfection is a treatment method using temperature and steam simultaneously to kill microbes
[14]. It is operated at a lower temperature than incineration but with pressure and steam influence to achieve disinfection
[19]. The operating conditions are 60 min, at 121 °C and 1 bar, followed by a cycle of 60 min at 134 °C to ensure the complete disinfection of waste
[19]. The following aspects govern the operation of the autoclave
[20]:
-
Temperature (121–134 °C),
-
Steam penetration,
-
Waste load,
-
Length of the treatment cycle,
-
Chamber air removal.
Due to the low operating temperatures of autoclaving, the waste appearance does not change, and the pathogens are not removed, which requires pre-treatment of the waste by incineration to be disposed of in landfills
[14]. Thus, the autoclave is not optimum for all waste types.
3.4.3. Microwave Disinfection
Microwave disinfection uses low-temperature and high microwaves for the reverse polymerisation and degradation of organic substances and microorganisms
[22]. The waves induce molecular bond vibrations, saving energy and preventing emissions, making it a more environmentally friendly method
[22]. The disinfection is operated at temperatures ranging between 177 and 540 °C electromagnetic waves of wavelength ranging between 1 mm and 1 m and frequency ranges between 300 and 3000 MHz
[22]. Microwave disinfection has high costs and can be combined with incineration and autoclave
[22]. The following aspects govern the operation of this method
[20]:
3.4.4. Chemical Disinfection
Chemical disinfection is used to kill microorganisms and fight off pathogens by using chemicals
[19]. It is primarily used for treating liquid infectious wastes such as blood, urine, faeces, or hospital sewage
[19]. The chemical disinfectants that are commonly used are bleach solution (1%) or a diluted active chlorine solution (0.5%)
[19]. In addition, other disinfectants such as lime, ozone, ammonium salts, and peracetic acid can be used
[19]. This treatment method directly affects those in charge of the treatment due to the inhalation of volatile chemicals or irritations to the skin and eyes
[19]. The following aspects govern the effectiveness of this method
[20]:
The residues of this treatment are liquid and solid residues
[22]. The liquid residues are disposed of in the sewer system, and solid residues are disposed of in the landfill
[22]. Determining an adequate treatment method involves defining the waste characteristics, type, and desired outcome, which should be checked against each treatment method to show the advantages and shortcomings of each process
[20].
3.5. Waste Recycling
Waste recycling is using produced waste or by-products for the same or different purposes. Most of the waste produced by the medical sector is non-hazardous waste that is mainly disposed of in landfills. The use of waste dumps and landfills can be reduced by recycling used products such as plastics, batteries, paper, glass, metals, and silver used in photographic processing
[19]. Food and organic waste can be used for composting purposes
[19]. Fly ash from incineration can be used after treatment in concrete mixtures and as building blocks
[24]. The heat produced from the incineration could be used to heat water for a centralised heating system
[19].
3.6. Waste Disposal
Rejects of the previous steps are transported to a sanitary landfill for disposal. However, landfills are not the optimum solution for handling MW due to their environmental effects. These effects are soil and water pollution caused by leachate and gas emissions into the air due to waste degradation
[22]. Thus, the waste being disposed of should be minimised to the most, and achieving a circular economy guarantees that. The long-term decomposition of waste is the primary process responsible for waste disposal in landfilling
[22]. Preventive measures should be taken to ensure the safe disposal of MW, which are
[19]:
-
Rapid cover of waste,
-
Burying it under the old municipal waste of minimum burial of three months,
-
Waterproof bottom,
-
Minimum 2 m above the water table,
-
No disposal of chemicals.