β-glucosidases: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 4 by Diego Mariano and Version 3 by Catherine Yang.

β-glucosidases (EC. 3.2.1.21) are enzymes that hydrolyze glucosidic bonds of oligosaccharides, in special disaccharides, such as cellobiose, realizing glucose at the end of the process. They are highly used in second-generation biofuel production. 

  • enzymes
  • bioinformatics
  • β-glucosidase
  • biofuel
  • second-generation biofuel

1. Introduction

In second-generation biofuel production, they act in synergy with other classes of enzymes, such as endo-glucanases and exo-glucanases [2][3], to obtain fermentable sugars from biomass. However, the literature has described that most β-glucosidase enzymes are inhibited by glucose, which has been considered one of the most impacting bottlenecks for high-efficient industrial production [4].

Recently, a more efficient class of β-glucosidases have been described in the literature. They are called glucose-tolerant, due to their high resistance to inhibition even in high glucose concentrations [5]. This class of enzymes has excellent potential for use in industrial applications such as biofuel production. Hence, glucose-tolerant β-glucosidase enzymes have been an essential target of several studies to detect mutations that transform non-tolerant enzymes into glucose-tolerant enzymes [6].

Most glucose-tolerant β-glucosidases are obtained from glycoside-hydrolase family 1 (GH1). Below, you can see the sequence of the beta-glucosidase from a metagenome sample collected in the South China Sea. This sequence was obtained in the BETAGDB database (available at http://bioinfo.dcc.ufmg.br/betagdb/). GH1 beta-glucosidases present aproximadelly 400 residues (each letter represents an amino acid residue). 

>Yang_Y et al. (2015) tr|D5KX75|D5KX75_9BACT Beta-glucosidase OS=uncultured bacterium PE=3 SV=1 
MTKISLPTCSPLLTKEFIYGVATASFQIEGGSAHRLPCIWDTFCDTPGKIADNSNGHVAC 
DHYNNWKQDIDLIESLGVDAYRLSISWPRVITKSGELNPEGVKFYTDILDELKKRNIKAF 
VTLYHWDLPQHLEDEGGWLNRETAYAFAHYVDLITLAFGDRVHSYATLNEPFCSAFLGYE 
IGIHAPGKVGKQYGRKAAHHLLLAHGLAMTVLKQNSPTTLNGIVLNFTPCYSISEDADDI 
AATAFADDYLNQWYMKPIMDGTYPAIIEQLPSAHLPDIHDGDMAIISQSIDYLGINFYTR 
QFYKAHPTEIYEPIEPTGPLTDMGWEIYPKSFTELLVTLNNTYTLPPIFITENGAAMPDS 
YNNGEINDVDRLDYYNSHLNAVHNATEQGVRIDGYFAWSLMDNFEWAEGYLKRFGIVYVD 
YSTQQRTIKNSGLAYKALISNR

Another example is the β-glucosidase structures obtained from fungi, such as Humicola grisea and Humicola insolens. The sequence below illustrates the primary structure of a fungi β-glucosidase Pstructure.

>de Giuseppe et al. (2014); Benoliel et al. (2010) tr|O93784|O93784_HUMGT Beta-glucosidase OS=Humicola grisea var. thermoidea GN=bgl4 PE=1 SV=1 PDB=4mdo
MSLPPDFKWGFATAAYQIEGSVNEDGRGPSIWDTFCAIPGKIADGSSGAVACDSYKRTKE
DIALLKELGANSYRFSISWSRIIPLGGRNDPINQKGIDHYVKFVDDLIEAGITPFITLFH
WDLPDALDKRYGGFLNKEEFAADFENYARIMFKAIPKCKHWITFNEPWCSAILGYNTGYF
APGHTSDRSKSPVGDSAREPWIVGHNILIAHARAVKAYREDFKPTQGGEIGITLNGDATL
PWDPEDPADIEACDRKIEFAISWFADPIYFGKYPDSMRKQLGDRLPEFTPEEVALVKGSN
DFYGMNHYTANYIKHKTGVPPEDDFLGNLETLFYNKYGDCIGPETQSFWLRPHAQGFRDL
LNWLSKRYGYPKIYVTENGTSLKGENDMPLEQVLEDDFRVKYFNDYVRAMAAAVAEDGCN
VRGYLAWSLLDNFEWAEGYETRFGVTYVDYANDQKRYPKKSAKSLKPLFDSLIRKE

Below you can see a comparison between both sequences generated using the Clustal Omega web tool (available at https://www.ebi.ac.uk/Tools/msa/clustalo/). Humicola insolens β-glucosidase is shown above, and Uncultured bacteria's β-glucosidase sequence from the South China Sea is shown below. The asterisks (*) represent conserved amino acid residues, while the punctuation mark (:) represents a modification for an amino acid residue with similar characteristics. Take notein that β-glucosidase sequences from this e same family present similar sequence.

Humicola        ----------MSLPPDFKWGFATAAYQIEGSVNEDGRGPSIWDTFCAIPGKIADGSSGAV	50
uncultured      MTKISLPTCSPLLTKEFIYGVATASFQIEGGS--AHRLPCIWDTFCDTPGKIADNSNGHV	58
                            *  :* :*.***::****.     * *.******  ******.*.* *

Humicola        ACDSYKRTKEDIALLKELGANSYRFSISWSRIIPLGGRNDPINQKGIDHYVKFVDDLIEA	110
uncultured      ACDHYNNWKQDIDLIESLGVDAYRLSISWPRVITKSGE---LNPEGVKFYTDILDELKKR	115
                *** *:. *:** *::.**.::**:**** *:*  .*.   :* :*:..*..::*:* : 

Humicola        GITPFITLFHWDLPDALDKRYGGFLNKEEFAADFENYARIM-FKAIPKCKHWITFNEPWC	169
uncultured      NIKAFVTLYHWDLPQHLEDE-GGWLNRETA-YAFAHYVDLITLAFGDRVHSYATLNEPFC	173
                .*. *:**:*****: *:.. **:**:*     * :*. :: :    : : : *:***:*

Humicola        SAILGYNTGYFAPGHTSDRSKSPVGDSAREPWIVGHNILIAHARAVKAYREDFKPTQGGE	229
uncultured      SAFLGYEIGIHAPGKVGKQYGR----K------AAHHLLLAHGLAMTVLKQNSPTTLN--	221
                **:***: * .***:...:       .      ..*::*:**. *:.. :::   * .  

Humicola        IGITLNGDATLPWDPEDPADIEACDRKIEFAISWFADPIYFGKYPDSMRKQLGDRLPEFT	289
uncultured      -GIVLNFTPCY-SISEDADDIAATAFADDYLNQWYMKPIMDGTYPAIIEQLPSAHLPDIH	279
                 **.**         **  ** *     ::  .*: .**  *.**  :.:  . :**:: 

Humicola        PEEVALVKGSNDFYGMNHYTANYIKHKTGVPPEDDFLGNLETLFYNKYGDCIGPETQSFW	349
uncultured      DGDMAIISQSIDYLGINFYTRQFYKAHPTEI-------------YEP-IEPTGPLTDMGW	325
                  ::*::. * *: *:*.** :: * :                 *:   :  ** *:  *

Humicola        LRPHAQGFRDLLNWLSKRYGYPKIYVTENGTSLKGENDMPLEQVLEDDFRVKYFNDYVRA	409
uncultured      E-IYPKSFTELLVTLNNTYTLPPIFITENGAAMPDSYNN---GEINDVDRLDYYNSHLNA	381
                   : :.* :**  *.: *  * *::****::: .. :      ::*  *:.*:*.::.*

Humicola        MAAAVAEDGCNVRGYLAWSLLDNFEWAEGYETRFGVTYVDYANDQKRYPKKSAKSLKPLF	469
uncultured      VH-NATEQGVRIDGYFAWSLMDNFEWAEGYLKRFGIVYVDYSTQQRTIKNSG-LAYKALI	439
                :   .:*:* .: **:****:********* .***:.****:.:*:   :..  : * *:

Humicola        DSLIRKE	476
uncultured      ----SNR	442
                     :.

Also, proteins from the GH1 family have a conserved folding structure called TIM-barrel [7]. Figure 1 illustrates the three-dimensional structure of GH1 β-glucosidase from the fungus Humicola insolens complexed with a glucose molecule [8]

GH1 beta-glucosidase from the fungus Humicola insolens in complex with glucose (PDB 4MDP). Generated using ChimeraX.Figure 1. GH1 β-glucosidase from the fungus Humicola insolens. Obtained from PDB ID: 4MDP. Figure generated using ChimeraX [9].

In conclusion, β-glucosidase enzymes have an excellent potential for second-generation biofuel production. However, genetic engineering applications are still necessary to improve the activity of non-tolerant enzymes. Additionally, bioinformatics applications have been successfully used to bring new insights to detect sites for mutations that could improve their activity. 

2. Application

References

  1. James R. Ketudat Cairns; Asim Esen; β-Glucosidases. Cellular and Molecular Life Sciences 2010, 67, 3389-3405, 10.1007/s00018-010-0399-2.
  2. Leon Sulfierry Corrêa Costa; Diego César Batista Mariano; Rafael Eduardo Oliveira Rocha; Johannes Kraml; Carlos Henrique Da Silveira; Klaus Roman Liedl; Raquel Cardoso De Melo-Minardi; Leonardo Henrique Franca De Lima; Molecular Dynamics Gives New Insights into the Glucose Tolerance and Inhibition Mechanisms on β-Glucosidases.. Molecules 2019, 24, 3215, 10.3390/molecules24183215.
  3. Diego Mariano; Naiara Pantuza; Lucianna H. Santos; Rafael E. O. Rocha; Leonardo Lima; Lucas Bleicher; Raquel Cardoso De Melo-Minardi; Glutantβase: a database for improving the rational design of glucose-tolerant β-glucosidases. BMC Molecular and Cell Biology 2020, 21, 1-15, 10.1186/s12860-020-00293-y.
  4. Andreza P. Garbin; Nayara F.L. Garcia; Gabriela F. Cavalheiro; Maria Alice Silvestre; André Rodrigues; Marcelo F. DA Paz; Gustavo G. Fonseca; Rodrigo S.R. Leite; β-glucosidase from thermophilic fungus Thermoascus crustaceus: production and industrial potential. Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências 2020, 93, e20191349, 10.1590/0001-3765202120191349.
  5. Diego Mariano; C. Leite; L.H.S. Santos; L.F. Marins; K.S. Machado; Adriano Velasque Werhli; L.H.F. Lima; R.C. De Melo-Minardi; Characterization of glucose-tolerant β-glucosidases used in biofuel production under the bioinformatics perspective: a systematic review. Genetics and Molecular Research 2013, 16, 1, 10.4238/gmr16039740.
  6. Diego César Batista Mariano; Lucianna Helene Santos; Karina Dos Santos Machado; Adriano Velasque Werhli; Leonardo Henrique França De Lima; Raquel Cardoso De Melo-Minardi; A Computational Method to Propose Mutations in Enzymes Based on Structural Signature Variation (SSV). International Journal of Molecular Sciences 2019, 20, 333, 10.3390/ijms20020333.
  7. Nozomi Nagano; Christine A Orengo; Janet Thornton; One Fold with Many Functions: The Evolutionary Relationships between TIM Barrel Families Based on their Sequences, Structures and Functions. Journal of Molecular Biology 2002, 321, 741-765, 10.1016/s0022-2836(02)00649-6.
  8. Priscila Oliveira de Giuseppe; Tatiana De Arruda Campos Brasil Souza; Flavio Henrique Moreira Souza; Leticia Maria Zanphorlin; Carla Botelho Machado; Richard Ward; Joao Atilio Jorge; Rosa Dos Prazeres Melo Furriel; Mario Tyago Murakami; Structural basis for glucose tolerance in GH1 β-glucosidases. Acta Crystallographica Section D Biological Crystallography 2014, 70, 1631-1639, 10.1107/s1399004714006920.
  9. Eric F. Pettersen; Thomas D. Goddard; Conrad C. Huang; Elaine C. Meng; Gregory S. Couch; Tristan I. Croll; John H. Morris; Thomas E. Ferrin; UCSF ChimeraX : Structure visualization for researchers, educators, and developers. Protein Science 2020, 30, 70-82, 10.1002/pro.3943.
More