Pain Management for Inflammatory Bowel Diseases: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Pauline Wils and Version 3 by Beatrix Zheng.

Up to 60% of inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) patients experience abdominal pain in their lifetime regardless of disease activity. Pain negatively affects different areas of daily life and particularly impacts the quality of life of IBD patients. Despite the optimal management of intestinal inflammation, chronic abdominal pain can persist, and pharmacological and non-pharmacological approaches are necessary. Integrating psychological support in care models in IBD could decrease disease burden and health care costs. Consequently, a multidisciplinary approach similar to that used for other chronic pain conditions should be recommended. 

  • inflammatory bowel disease
  • abdominal pain
  • quality of life

1. Overview

Many inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) therapies (anti-TNF, anti-integrin, anti-interleukin, small molecules) demonstrated their efficacy in multiple randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Nevertheless, pain improvement was not considered a key endpoint in the majority of studies even though it is an essential outcome for patients. More recently, endpoints have evolved, and abdominal pain improvement is considered a secondary endpoint in RCTs evaluating jak inhibitors (tofacitinib and upadacitinib) versus placebo in ulcerative colitis (UC)UC [1][2][63,64]. Control of disease activity in IBD is the first step in the management of abdominal pain, but despite an optimal management of intestinal inflammation, chronic abdominal pain can persist, and pharmacological and non-pharmacological approaches can be necessary [3][4][5][6][6,30,65,66]. Recently, the American Gastroenterological Association consensus has described the key principles in the management of functional gastrointestinal symptoms in IBD patients [7][5].
Figure 12 summarizes in an algorithm a sequential approach for abdominal pain management. The treatment of acute pain depends on pain intensity (assessing by VAS or NRS). Simple analgesics are often proposed in the first step, and in the case of severe pain (VAS > 55 mm or NRS > 7), opioids can be temporarily prescribed. An evaluation of IBD activity is recommended, and IBD therapies were modified accordingly. In quiescent diseases, a low FODMAPs diet may be an interesting option in IBD–IBS patients, psychological interventions may be proposed in patients with associated mood disorders, and adjuvant drugs with antidepressant and analgesic effects can be useful in most patients with chronic pain. Integrating psychological support in care models in IBD could decrease disease burden and health care costs. Consequently, a multidisciplinary approach with a mental health professional for assessing the degree of anxiety and/or depression and evaluating the probability of responding to specific medications or psychological therapies is recommended for IBD patients.
Figure 12.
Proposed algorithm for pain management with pharmacological agents and non-pharmacological interventions available for improve chronic abdominal pain.

2. Current Pharmacological Options

No therapies have yet proven to be effective in managing IBD-related pain.
Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs are not recommended for long-term use because of the risk of relapse or mucosal injury. Although there is no definite evidence in IBD patients, antispasmodics are commonly used in mild pain [8][67]. However, antispasmodics and simple antalgics are often not sufficient, leading to the prescription of opioids. Despite their potential side effects, a high proportion of IBD patients received opioids for chronic abdominal pain [9][10]. Notably, in a large epidemiological study, approximately 5% of IBD patients were heavy users of opioids within 10 years of diagnosis [10][13]. However, the chronic use of opioids should be avoided in IBD patients due to the risks of dependence, hyperalgesia, narcotic bowel syndrome [11][68], and premature mortality in heavy users [7][12][5,69].
Alternative drugs to opioids should be encouraged [3][5][6][13][6,7,65,66]. Antidepressant and anxiolytic medications may be an interesting option for abdominal pain especially if there are coexisting mood disorders. In particular, a retrospective cohort study involving 81 patients with IBD revealed that tricyclic antidepressants (amitriptyline, nortriptyline, or desipramine) improved gastrointestinal symptoms (not abdominal pain specifically) [14][70]. An open-label preliminary study on selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (citalopram, paroxetine, fluoxetine, and escitalopram) in psychiatric disorders suggested the efficacy of paroxetine on abdominal pain in eight IBD patients [15][71]. Serotonin–norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (SNRIs) were effective for the control of chronic pain syndromes in IBS patients. Interestingly, a large Canadian cohort study of 403,665 patients with new-onset depression investigated the impacts of depression and antidepressant therapies on the development of IBD. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors and tricyclic antidepressants were associated with a reduced risk of developing both CD and UC, and SNRIs were protective against UC [16][72]. Nevertheless, these treatments are not devoid of side effects, (nausea, dry mouth, muscle spasms, constipation), bringing an additional burden to patients. Other studies suggest a potential abdominal pain-relieving effect of gabapentin and pregabalin (usually prescribed for neuropathic pain), but these have not been investigated in IBD patients [3][6]. Other interventions have been associated with a reduction of abdominal pain [6][66]. In a randomized controlled trial evaluating the efficacy of antibiotics on 29 CD patients with small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, the antibiotics metronidazole and ciprofloxacin improved abdominal pain in 50% and 43% of cases, respectively [17][73]. Rifaximin, a non-absorbed antibiotic, was an effective treatment of small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, improving symptoms in 67% of patients in a recent meta-analysis [18][74]; it could be an option for IBD patients with small intestinal bacterial overgrowth. Furthermore, restoring the microbial flora seems to be an interesting option in the management of IBS. Some probiotics have demonstrated their effectiveness in improving symptoms, including abdominal pain for patients with IBS (for example L. Plantarum 299v, B. Bifidum MIMBb75) [19][20][75,76]. The use of probiotics in IBD could be a therapeutic option to improve dysbiosis but requires further studies. Another randomized study demonstrated the efficacy of transdermal nicotine patches in 72 active UC patients versus placebo: 49% in the nicotine group had complete remission compared with 24% in the placebo group (p = 0.03), with less abdominal pain in the nicotine group (p = 0.05) [21][77]. A small trial evaluating loperamide oxide in CD patients with chronic diarrhea indicated an improvement in abdominal pain after one week of treatment [22][78]. Previous studies reported that around 10% of IBD patients use cannabis and derivatives to improve symptoms [23][79]. Patients developed a growing interest in the potential therapeutic effect of cannabis on IBD-related symptoms and IBD course. Data regarding the inflammatory effects of cannabis and derivatives are still limited: small studies reported an improvement of several IBD-related symptoms, including abdominal pain, but without any significant improvement of inflammation markers or disease course [24][25][26][11,80,81]. A phase 2a trial evaluating the efficacy and tolerability of cannabidiol in steroid-dependent CD patients is still ongoing [27][82]. Table 1 details pharmacological options in IBD patients with chronic abdominal pain.

3. Non-Pharmacological Interventions

3.1. Dietary Measures

The presence of indigestible carbohydrates or osmotic molecules in the luminal gut may result in high fermentation, the production of gas and short chain fatty acids, and distention and could participate in IBS-like symptoms such as abdominal pain in IBD patients [32][87]. Lactose and fructose malabsorption are frequent in CD patients, an estimated 42% and 61% of patients, respectively, in a previous study [33][88] and could be associated with abdominal pain. Several dietary measures including lactose-reduced or low fermentable oligosaccharides, disaccharides, monosaccharides, and polyols (FODMAPs) diets may improve functional gastrointestinal symptoms [32][87]. Despite the low grade of evidence, the low-FODMAP diet proved to be effective for the IBS-like symptoms of IBD patients in remission [28][83]. In addition, a randomized controlled cross-over trial reported an exacerbation of functional gastrointestinal symptoms in quiescent IBD patients exposed to FODMAPs [34][89]. However, considering the risk of compromised nutritional status, the use of restrictive diets in IBD patients in remission should be carefully supervised by a dietician.

3.2. Psychological Approaches

Psychosocial factors impact the quality of life of IBD patients and often can benefit from non-pharmacological approaches. Notably, the consequent association between pain and depression, stress, or anxiety suggests that the optimal management of these mood disorders may improve pain levels and QOL. In the IBD field, psychological interventions, particularly cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT), have been found as valid approaches for functional gastrointestinal symptoms and pain [6][13][7,66]. Coping skill training, another psychological and educational intervention, developed to increase individuals’ ability to manage uncomfortable or anxiety-provoking situations, improved somatic symptoms in IBD adolescents but did not significantly affect pain [29][84]. Notably, psychological interventions were associated with clinical improvement in pediatric and adult IBD patients with anxiety or depression [30][35][36][85,90,91]. However, another randomized controlled trial evaluating the impact of a 10-week cognitive behavioral therapy in adult IBD patients did not find an influence of CBT in the course of IBD over 24 months [37][92]. Another proposed option is hypnotherapy, a technique used to create a state of focused attention and help to gain control over undesired behaviors or treat stress with suggestions for relaxation. Hypnotherapy has been associated with positive outcomes for different chronic-pain conditions (e.g., cancer, low-back pain, arthritis pain). For IBD, a prospective study demonstrated a significant effect of gut-directed hypnotherapy on prolonging clinical remission in 54 patients with quiescent UC [30][85]. There is also consistent evidence for a contribution of stress in the IBD disease course [38][93]. For this reason, a stress management program including 45 CD patients was proposed. A significant reduction in abdominal pain was detected in subjects who received training in self-directed and therapist-led stress management [31][86]. Acupuncture, derived from traditional Chinese medicine, is a practice designed to rebalance a patient’s Qi. In IBD patients, acupuncture can be a complementary approach that helps reduce chronic abdominal pain [39][94].
Video Production Service