Photocatalytic Properties of SnO2: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by André L. Menezes de Oliveira and Version 5 by Catherine Yang.

SnO2 is an n-type semiconductor with a band gap between 3.6 and 4.0 eV, whose intrinsic characteristics are responsible for its electrical conductivity, good optical characteristics, high thermal stability, and other qualities. Such characteristics have provided excellent results in advanced oxidative processes, i.e., heterogeneous photocatalysis applications. This process involves semiconductors in the production of hydroxyl radicals via activation by light absorption, and it is considered as an emerging and promising technology for domestic-industrial wastewater treatment.

  • tin oxide
  • SnO2
  • synthesis method
  • heterogeneous photocatalysis
  • persistent organic pollutants
  • POPs
  • organic dyes

1. Tin-Oxide-Synthesis, Structure, Properties, and Applications as Heterogeneous Photocatalyst

Tin dioxide (SnO2), obtained by combining Sn4+ and O2−, is a ceramic material that has been used in a wide variety of applications, such as gas sensors, photovoltaic energy converters, and photocatalysts [1][2][3][65,66,67]. The success for multiple applications of SnO2 is due to its intrinsic characteristics, such as: n-type conductivity, which is responsible for the conductivity of the material, and in addition to optical and electrical characteristics, high thermal stability, and high surface area [4][5][6][36,49,68]. Electrical conductivity can be described in terms of the movement of negatively charged electrons, and this gives rise to an n-type semiconductor [4][5][7][8][9][36,49,50,69,70,71].
As for the crystal structure of SnO2, at room temperature, it adopts a rutile-type tetragonal structure (cassiterite) with P42/mnm space group, as illustrated in Figure 14. This structure is formed by a tetragonal unit cell defined by three (3) parameters: the a and c lattice parameters and the internal parameter, u, which defines the oxygen position (u, u, and 0). At room temperature, the theoretical lattice parameters for SnO2 are a = 4.7374 Å, c = 3.1864 Å [10][72], and u = 0.3056 Å. It has been reported that SnO2 can also adopt an orthorhombic, CaCl2-type (Pnnm) structure, besides existing in an orthorhombic α-PbO2-type (Pbcn), a cubic pyrite-type (Pa-3), an orthorhombic ZrO2-type (Pbca), and a cotunnite-type (Pnma) structure. However, these structures are metastable at ambient conditions, and it is hard to follow these phase transitions through traditional methods under low pressure and temperatures [11][12][63,64].
Figure 14. (a) A P42/mnm tetragonal crystal structure of SnO2 showing (b) environment of distorted SnO6 octahedron and (c) lattice parameters, obtained using VESTA software and structural parameters reported in [13][73].
The structure of SnO2 consists of chains of SnO6 octahedra in which each Sn atom is octahedral, surrounded by six oxygen atoms, while each oxygen is surrounded by three Sn atoms arranged at the corners of an equilateral triangle. The structure’s Sn:O coordination is 6:3, with each octahedron not being regular, showing a slight orthorhombic distortion [10][13][72,73].
SnO2 can present nano- and micro-structured characteristics, however, most researchers have been dedicated to the synthesis of SnO2 in the form of nanoparticles. Such characteristics have offered good opportunities to explore new physical and chemical applications. Recently, SnO2 has been applied to the degradation of antibiotics [14][74], fuel cell catalysts [13][73], gas sensors [15][75], sodium ion batteries [16][76], light-emitting diodes [17][77], heterogeneous photocatalysis, and antimicrobial activity [18][19][78,79]. There are several synthesis routes and experimental conditions to obtain SnO2 in powder form, the choice of which may influence the particles’ morphology and texture, besides their structural, optical, and electronic properties, which will consequently impact the efficiency and final application of the material. In relation to SnO2-based thin films, chemical deposition methods have appeared to be the most used [20][21][22][23][24][25][62,80,81,82,83,84].
With respect to the applications in photocatalysis, SnO2 catalysts with a tetragonal, rutile-type structure are the main phases investigated, but a recent work reported that the coexistence of mixed tetragonal–orthorhombic phases affected the photocatalytic efficiency of SnO2 [26][85].

2. Synthesis Methods and the Influence of Experimental Parameters on the Characteristics and Photocatalytic Properties of SnO2-Based Materials

One of the main aspects this rentryview refers to is the approach of how different synthesis methods and experimental parameters affect the photocatalytic properties of SnO2-based materials. Researchers have employed different methods to produce new materials with specific properties and applications. The choice of an appropriate condition to prepare a material is crucial to modifying its physicochemical characteristics, such as crystal structure and morphological and texture characteristics of the particles (size, shape, surface area, and surface charge characteristics), as well as the electronic and optical properties. The variation on these characteristics may change the applicability of the material. In this sense, different researchers have devoted to obtaining SnO2-based materials with specific characteristics and efficient photocatalytic behaviors. Among the great variety of methods known in the literature, SnO2-based photocatalysts have been obtained, in their powder form, by a solvothermal reaction [27][28][86,87], the microwave-assisted hydrothermal method [29][88], chemical precipitation [6][68], the polymeric precursor method [30][89], and sol-gel [31][14], all which are mostly used. In relation to the photocatalytic properties of SnO2 particles, although there is a variety of organic pollutants, organic dyes such as Methylene blue (MB), Rhodamine B (RhB), and Methyl orange (MO) have been the most used as target molecules to evaluate the photocatalytic efficiency of SnO2. However, other organic dyes such as Congo red (CR), Malachite green (MG) and Eriochrome black T (EBT) have also been explored for such purposes. In this context, the photodegradation of these organic dyes is highlighted in this review. Apart from powdered SnO2 materials, SnO2-based films have also been used as photocatalysts for dye photodegradation [32][33][34][35][90,91,92,93]. For the preparation of films, chemical [12][21][25][27][30][64,80,84,86,89] and physical-based deposition methods [12][64] are used. In the following sections, photocatalytic applications of pure and doped SnO2-based catalysts, as well as the composites based on SnO2 in powdered and film forms prepared by different techniques, are also discussed.

2.1. Pure SnO


-Based Photocatalysts

Besides being synthesized in its pure form, SnO2 has been prepared in its doped form with metals or nonmetal ions, as well as in the form of composites with other semiconductor materials, or even impregnated in inert, non-active photocatalytic materials. It is well known that the generation of electrons/holes (e/h+) pairs by absorption of a photon of equal energy, to or higher than the band gap energy induced by light, is a basic prerequisite for a semiconductor to be used in photocatalysis. Because of its wide band gap of SnO2 (3.6 eV), no absorption response to the visible light would be achieved, and this is the main disadvantage of this material, which restricts its application in practical devices. A wide variety of pure semiconductor materials, particularly SnO2, have been investigated regarding the photocatalytic properties, but only few of them are considered effective photocatalysts. Besides the value of the forbidden band energy corresponding to absorption in the visible region, it is required that the energy levels of the conduction and valence bands are suited to the redox potential of the water, so as to produce reactive agents to promote breaking of organic pollutants molecules. Therefore, different authors have employed various synthesis methods and varied experimental conditions in order to change particle characteristics, which include size, morphology, and texture, as well as the crystallinity and the presence of defects, in order to design efficient photocatalysts under UV irradiation. These parameters can play an important role during photocatalysis, as they can affect the adsorptive and photo-absorption capacity of the catalyst, besides reducing photogenerated changes of recombination during photoexcitation. In addition, some authors also explored the reaction mechanisms involved in the photodegradation of the dyes and how the reactive species act for the photocatalysis to occur.

2.2. Doped SnO



Although pure SnO2 nanoparticles with a different morphology have shown efficiency in the degradation of dyes under irradiation, different authors have developed strategies to overcome the low photoactivity of SnO2 under visible light exposure. For instance, doping SnO2 with different foreign ions has shown to be an efficient way to shorten its band gap and enhance its photoactivity. Based on this fact, N. Mala et al. [36][98] synthesized SnO2 nanoparticles doped with Mg2+ + Co3+ cations by a low-cost chemical solution method and investigated the antibacterial activity and photocatalytic efficiency toward the degradation of Methylene blue (MB) and Malachite green (MG) dyes. The authors revealed that the samples presented a tetragonal crystalline phase, with an average crystallite size of 24 and 25 nm for pure SnO2 and SnO2-Mg:Co, respectively. The authors suggested that this slightly increase of the crystallite size after doping was due to local distortions in the SnO2 lattice induced by the presence of dopants. A nanorod-like morphology was confirmed through SEM images, with a reduction in the crystal length and in the average diameter after doping. Surprisingly, an increase in the band gap energy estimated for SnO2 (3.52 eV) and SnO2-Mg:Co (4.22 eV) was observed. This behavior is attributed to the quantum confinement effect that normally happens when the nanoparticle size decreases. However, no meaningful variation was observed in the particle size for pure and doped SnO2 samples. Regarding the photocatalytic activity of SnO2 and SnO2:Mg:Co nanoparticles, the authors observed that SnO2 presented an efficiency of 82 and 86%, while SnO2-Mg:Co displayed 89 and 92% efficiency toward MB and MG dyes degradation, respectively, under visible light after 60 min. Although doped SnO2 is most prepared in powder, thin films based on doped SnO2 have also been studied in photocatalysis. For instance, S. Vadivel and G. Rajaraja et al. [25][84] prepared magnesium-doped SnO2 films by the chemical bath deposition method, varying Mg2+ molar concentrations (1, 5, and 10%). The films were deposited on glass, and after deposition they were annealed at 500 °C for 5 h in air to promote crystallization. From XRD analysis, the tetragonal rutile phase was confirmed in all films. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) images revealed that the surface roughness decreases with increasing dopant concentration. The optical band gap energy for pure SnO2 was 3.63 eV, decreasing to 3.42 eV for the film doped with 10% Mg. The photocatalytic activities of the films were evaluated by the degradation of Methylene blue (MB) and Rhodamine B (RhB) dyes under UV irradiation. The maximum photodegradation of the dyes was reached for 10% Mg-doped SnO2 film, degrading 80% of MB and 90% of RhB after 120 min. Fast electron transfer and high efficiency in electron–hole pairs separation led to a significant improvement of photocatalytic activity in the doped sample. In the work conducted by Haya et al. [23][82] films of pure SnO2 and doped with 2, 4, 6, and 8% of Sr2+ were prepared by a chemical solution deposition method using the sol-gel method to deposit the solution coating on a glass substrate. The effect of doping on the structural, optical, morphological, and photocatalytic properties of the films were studied. According to the results, the increase in Sr2+ doping promotes a decrease in crystallite size and an increase in the lattice distortion. These effects generate a greater number of defects, such as grain boundaries, micro-stresses, and displacements in the thin film lattice. The average crystallite size decreased from 7.61 nm for undoped SnO2 to 3.80 nm for 8% Sr-SnO2. It was also observed by UV-visible analysis that the presence of dopants introduced new intermediate levels in the semiconductor band gap (Eg), decreasing Eg from 3.86 eV for pure SnO2 film to 3.76 eV for Sr-richer SnO2 film. Additionally, the morphology of the films was analyzed by AFM, and a smaller grain size was observed for 8% Sr-SnO2 (4.96 nm). Consequently, it showed the lower surface roughness when compared to the other films. Concerning the photocatalytic activity, the greatest efficiency in the degradation of MB dye under irradiation was attained for 8% Sr-SnO2 film, which was attributed to smaller grain sizes and surface roughness, as well as the introduction of new energy levels below the conduction band of the pure material, resulting from the Sr doping. Using a non-conventional method to prepare thin films, Loyola Poul Raj et al. [24][83] prepared SnO2 thin films doped with 3 and 6 mol% of Tb3+ on a glass substrate by the spray nebulized pyrolysis (NSP) method and calcined them at 400 °C to crystallize the materials. The authors investigated the photocatalytic property of the films in the degradation of MB dye under UV irradiation. According to the authors, doping SnO2 films with up to 6% of Tb3+ cations induces a decrease in the grain size from 80 to 56 nm, and the band gap from 3.51 to 3.36 eV, which directly impacts photocatalysis, as reported by other authors. Indeed, a maximum of 85% of dye degradation was observed after 120 min under UV irradiation using SnO2 film doped with the 6 mol% Tb3+. Using PL spectroscopy, the authors reveal that Tb doping leads to the creation of more defects that act as reactive sites for catalyzed reactions. As a consequence of the study, the authors concluded that Tb doping favored photocatalytic reactions by reducing particle size, and therefore increasing the surface area and the number of reactive sites on the surface, which allows the dye adsorption. In addition, Tb doping induces a decrease in the band gap of the materials, which favors photo-absorption, aiming to potentialize charge carriers to participate in photocatalytic reactions.

2.3. SnO


-Based Composite Photocatalysts

As one can see from studies discussed in the sections above, pure and doped SnO2 particles and films have been well explored. However, SnO2 has also been combined with other different semiconductors in order to reduce recombination of the photoinduced charge carriers, to therefore improve photocatalytic activity. Considering this fact, Abdel-Messih et al. [37][105] synthesized SnO2/TiO2 nanoparticles with a spherical mesoporous morphology synthesized by the sol-gel process, using polymethylmethacrylate as a template. The amount of SnO2 (0–25%) in relation to the mass of pure TiO2 was varied to obtain composites with different compositions. The samples were calcined at 800 °C for 3 h to ensure complete organic polymer decomposition. In relation to the photocatalytic property of the materials, photodegradation of Rhodamine B (RhB) dye was performed under UV irradiation using a catalyst/dye concentration of 1 g L−1. The photodegradation efficiency of the composites increased with the increase of tin oxide content up to 10% (about 92% of the dye degraded after 3 h). However, the sample with 25 mol% of SnO2 showed the lowest efficiency, which was attributed to the loss of the titanium anatase phase. The authors concluded that there is an optimal amount of SnO2 to achieve the maximum efficiency. In addition, the remarkable reduction in particle size by the existence of SnO2 in the composites enhanced the oxidizing power and extended the photoinduced charge separation, and these were the main reasons for the increase in the catalytic activity of the samples.

2.4. Final Remarks

The number of materials for the formation of the SnO2 with a different particle size and morphology, besides doped SnO2 with an appropriate amount and type of dopant, and also the formation of the composite with SnO2, plays an important role in improving the photocatalytic activity of the SnO2 material. In relation to composites, the excess of both species can be harmful to the contact surface between the phases, mainly due to the high degree of particle agglomeration. Tests using scavengers, such as p-benzoquinone (BZ, C6H4O2), isopropanol (ISO, (CH3)2CHOH), and ammonium oxalate monohydrate (AO, (NH4)2C2O4·H2O) indicate OH is the main species in most photocatalytic mechanisms. However, to obtain more insights about the photocatalytic mechanism involved in composite materials, thwe reseachers seek to understand the charge transfer between the phases from the band structures of each individual material. Structural and electronic defects can also generate energy levels between the VB and CB, and, therefore, modify the photocatalytic mechanism of composites. The creation of different interfaces between the phases may reduce charge carriers’ recombination, leading to the formation of a great number of free radicals to improve photocatalysis. In addition, several other parameters can impact the photocatalytic efficiency of composites, such as phase composition, surface area, morphology, particle size, pore structure, electron–hole recombination rate, and band gap energy of the individual components. Some authors showed that the high surface area and the presence of pores are more effective parameters that affect dye degradation since the existence of several active sites, responsible for the adsorption of molecules, is crucial for the photocatalysis to occur. Based on the findings above, it can be concluded that to design a new photocatalytic material with specific characteristic, one has to consider optimizing type and amount of dopants and interface characteristics between materials, or even the nature of the desired product (powder, film, etc.), besides the microstructure of the material (particle size and morphology), and by a choice of specific synthesis methodology and appropriate experimental conditions.
Video Production Service