Treatment of Peripartum Depression with Antidepressants: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Angela Lupattelli and Version 4 by Bruce Ren.

Peripartum or perinatal depression, which is depression arising in the period between the start of a pregnancy and the end of the first postpartum year.  Multiple CPGs recommend antidepressant initiation or continuation based on maternal disease severity, non-response to first-line non-pharmacological interventions, and after risk-benefit assessment. Advice on treatment of comorbid anxiety is largely missing or unspecific. Antidepressant dispensing data suggest general prescribers’ compliance with the preferred substances of the CPG, although country-specific differences were noted. To conclude, there is an urgent need for harmonized, up-to-date CPGs for pharmacological management of peripartum depression and comorbid anxiety in Europe. The recommendations need to be informed by the latest available evidence so that healthcare providers and women can make informed, evidence-based decisions about treatment choices. 

  • clinical practice guideline
  • depression
  • anxiety
  • antidepressant
  • psychotropic medications
  • peripartum

1. Introduction

Peripartum or perinatal depression, which is depression arising in the period between the start of a pregnancy and the end of the first postpartum year, to use a broad definition, affects approximately one in eight women [1]. Peripartum and perinatal depression are used interchangeably, although the former term relates more specifically to the woman. The disorder often persists throughout the peripartum period, with as many as 47% of women with postnatal depression having experienced an antenatal episode [2]. In many cases, depression concurs with anxiety, and this adds a substantial mental health burden to the woman [3]. One recent study has proposed multiple subtypes of perinatal depression, which differ in terms of symptom dimension and time of onset [4]. Women may, therefore, need tailored treatment strategies, including pharmacotherapy, depending on their individual depression course, timing of onset, and prominent symptom typology.
Perinatal depression is associated with a spectrum of obstetric and long-term negative outcomes in the offspring [5][6][5,6], including possible adverse impacts on the mother-infant relationship [7][8][7,8]. It also substantially affects women’s well-being and functioning, and it can even lead to suicide [9]. In moderate to severe cases or after non-response to first-line psychotherapy, pharmacotherapy with antidepressants is often needed [10]. Pooled results from 40 cohort studies [11] indicate that selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) are the most commonly used antidepressants, with a population prevalence of filled prescriptions ranging from 3.5% before pregnancy to 3.0% during gestation and 4.7% in the first year postpartum. Augmentation with antipsychotics or adjuvant pharmacotherapy with benzodiazepines or sedative antihistamines may be needed in some cases [10]. Nevertheless, pregnancy remains a major driver for discontinuation of antidepressants, and 49% of those individuals who chose to continue have low antidepressant adherence [12][13][12,13].
The decision-making process about antidepressant treatment during pregnancy or lactation is complex, as it involves weighing the possible risk of exposure in utero or in breast milk against the potential adverse effects of sub-optimally treated maternal peripartum depression to both the mother and child. Clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) for peripartum depression management may facilitate this decision-making process. However, many countries have not established CPGs for peripartum depression, and for those available, the recommendations are not always uniform [14]. In 2018, one systematic review evaluated the content of the available CPGs, and it was found that only four countries recommend continuation into pregnancy of a pre-existing antidepressant treatment [14]. This prior work extracted only recommendations from CPGs adhering to the quality criteria of the Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation (AGREE) instrument. Thus, there are still knowledge gaps on current clinical practices from CPGs not meeting such quality criteria. Furthermore, the extent to which national CPGs are followed in relation to antidepressant and other psychotropic prescribing remains unknown.

2. Treatment of Peripartum Depression with Antidepressants

2.1. Identified Clinical Practice Guidelines

Figure 1 describes the flow diagram of the various search strategies to achieve the final sample of CPGs included in the study. Across the 48 countries examined, thwe researchers were unable to identify a contact person or did not receive a response in 22 (45.8%) of the countries. The researchers receWe received a response or identified a CPG in the literature search for 26 countries in Europe, of which 10 (38.5%) (i.e., Austria, Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus, France, Greece, Iceland, Portugal, Turkey, and Bosnia and Herzegovina) did not have a national CPG for intervention strategies of peripartum depression or mental health, either specific or broader for the adult population, with mention of the peripartum population. In Ireland, the researchers cwe could only retrieve an information leaflet on peripartum depression for women, which is not classified as a CPG. In Ukraine (personal communication), the criteria for treatment of peripartum depression were reported to be in place, which included pharmacotherapy interventions with amitriptyline, phenazepam, relanium, frenolone, and with vitamins (e.g., ascorbic acid). However, no further information was obtained. Belgium and Sweden used protocols or guidelines for screening and treatment of peripartum depression based on international guidelines (NICE). However, pharmacotherapy interventions are not mentioned [15][16][15,16]. Of the searches in PubMed and the GIN database, thwe researchers scrscreened three CPGs from Spain, Poland, and the UK, which were duplicates of the ones obtained via the contact persons in these countries. The researchers We included and fully evaluated 12 CPGs. In the CPG from Latvia, recommendations on pharmacological interventions were only provided for the postpartum period.
Figure 1. Flow chart of the hrevierew process for the clinical practice guideline synthesis. Abbreviations: CPG = clinical practice guideline; GIN = Guidelines International Network. * No response or identification in Albania, Andorra, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Croatia, Czech Republic, Estonia, Georgia, Hungary, Kazakhstan, Kosovo, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Moldova, Montenegro, North Macedonia, Romania, Russia, Slovakia, Slovenia, and Switzerland.

3.2. Pharmacological Interventions for Treatment of Antenatal Depression

Table 1 shows that most CPGs advise initiation of antidepressants in women with new onset or moderate-to-severe antenatal depression. This treatment should be undertaken after an individualized risk–benefit evaluation and following non-response to psychotherapy. In contrast, the CPG in Poland discourages the use of antidepressants in the first trimester and states that this medication should be discontinued before delivery. All the CPGs seem unanimous in recommending or mentioning the possibility to continue antidepressants in pregnancy for preexisting moderate-to-severe depression (Table 1). In the UK CPG, monotherapy (if possible) and the lowest effective dose are advised in the context of both initiation and continuation of the antidepressant. On the basis of filled prescription and drug utilization data, there was a decrease in the prevalence of antidepressant use from preconception (range: 1.6–9.6%) into pregnancy (range: 0.3–4.1%), with SSRI being the most commonly prescribed group in most countries (Table 1). For many countries in Eastern Europe, no such utilization data were available.
Table 1. Overview of recommendations in the CPGs about antidepressant treatment in women with antenatal depression, with prevalence estimates of antidepressant and other psychotropic medication use in the country.
Country, Publication Year, Type New Depression, Initiate AD Preexisting Depression, Continue AD AD Dose Adjustment and Monitoring Switching AD Preferred or

Not Preferred AD
AD Use before vs during Pregnancy (%) Most Common ADs Used during Pregnancy Treatment of Co-Morbid Anxiety Other Psychotropics during Pregnancy (%)
Denmark [17] PMH-S
There is general agreement between the CPGs in evaluating individual drug response in the period prior to pregnancy in the decision making about antidepressant continuation during pregnancy. The CPGs provide less uniform guidance regarding switching antidepressants during pregnancy (Table 1). In the CPGs of Malta and Norway, switching is discouraged unless the drug is ineffective. The CPG in the Netherlands considers switching from paroxetine to a preferred antidepressant but before pregnancy. Multiple CPGs (Finland, Germany, Italy, and Serbia) do not provide guidance on switching. Likewise, information on antidepressant level monitoring in serum or plasma and on dosage adjustment is missing for the CPGs in Italy and Denmark.
Multiple CPGs mention sertraline and citalopram as preferred antidepressants in pregnancy, whereas others (i.e., Finland, Serbia, and Spain) list the class of SSRIs. Paroxetine was mentioned as not a preferred antidepressant in most CPGs, except for Serbia, the UK, and Norway. In the two latter countries, the CPGs advise basing the choice of the antidepressant on maternal prior response and its safety profile. Generally, the antidepressants recommended in the CPGs were also the ones most often used in gestation, except in Denmark (for fluoxetine), the Netherlands and Spain (for paroxetine), and Germany (for amitriptyline). Paroxetine ranked among the most commonly used antidepressants in pregnancy in specific countries (i.e., Italy, the Netherlands, or Spain).

2.3. Pharmacological Interventions for Treatment of Postpartum Depression

Table 2 summarizes the content and recommendations of the CPGs for the postpartum period. Most CPGs (n = 11) recommend initiation or continuation of antidepressant medications in women suffering from depression in the postpartum period. Nearly all CPGs suggest an individual risk–benefit evaluation of the antidepressant treatment in the case of breastfeeding. Recommendations about breastfeeding compatibility with maternal antidepressant use were not specified in three GPGs (Spain, Serbia, and Norway). The CPGs in the Netherlands, Italy, and Finland state that antidepressant use does not prevent breastfeeding, whereas the UK and Denmark advise closely monitoring the exposed breastfed infant for potential adverse effects, such as weight gain. The Maltese CPG advises that only healthy and full-term infants should be breastfed when mothers are taking antidepressants. The Polish CPG gives a detailed recommendation about the timing of antidepressant intake and breastfeeding (i.e., to take one daily dose before the longest sleep of the child and breastfeed directly before that). Recommendations about switching antidepressants are either unspecified (n = 5) in the CPG or discouraged, especially if it affects the woman. The prevalence estimates of antidepressant use postpartum were greater than in the antenatal period and generally returned to the magnitude seen pre-pregnancy. For most of the countries included in this work, no antidepressant utilization data postpartum are available.
Table 2. Overview of recommendations in the CPGs about antidepressant treatment in women with postnatal depression, with prevalence estimates of antidepressants and other psychotropic medication use in the country.
Country, Publication Year, Type Depression, Initiate or Continue AD AD Intake by Time of BF Switching AD Preferred or Not Preferred AD AD Use Postpartum (%) Most Common ADs Postpartum Treatment Co-Morbid Anxiety Other Psychotropic Postpartum (%)
Denmark [17Yes, if severe and no response to psychotherapy ] PMH-SYes NS Yes, if effective for woman’s depression NS No, but weight gain in infant should be monitored. Formula can be considered. No, if the AD is effective and was taken in pregnancy Sertraline, paroxetine

/

Fluoxetine, (es)citalopram, fluvoxamine, venlafaxineSertraline, citalopram

/

Paroxetine, fluoxetine
4.1 [29]2.0 vs.

1.9–4.1 [18][19]
2.0 vs.

1.9–4.1 [18,19]
Citalopram, sertraline, fluoxetine [19] NS BZD: 0.6 [20]

AP: 0.4 [21
NA NS BZD: 1.3 [20]

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA]

Quetiapine: 0.2 [21]
Finland [22] N-PPD NS Yes, in moderate-to-severe cases

Psychotherapy first line
Finland [22Monitoring of response is important ]

N-PPD
NS As for non-pregnant adults, psychotherapy is recommended for mild symptoms No, use of SSRI does not prevent BF NS SSRIs

/

FluoxetineSSRIs

/

Paroxetine, fluoxetine, tricyclics
1.6–4.0 [23] vs.

3.6* [24]
NA NS BZD: 1.2* [25]

AP: 0.8 [21]

Quetiapine: 0.9

NA[21]
NA NS BZD: 0.7–3.2 [47]

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA Germany [26] N-PPD Yes, after individual risk benefit evaluation, individual disease history, preference and availability of alternative treatments Yes, in moderate-to-severe cases. Abrupt discontinuation is discouraged.

Psychotherapy first line
Monotherapy if possible, lowest effective dose

Continuous measurement of plasma levels
NS Sertraline, citalopram

/

Paroxetine, fluoxetine
4.0 [27] vs.

0.4 (unpublished data)
Amitriptyline, (es)citalopram, sertraline (unpublished data) NS BZD: 3.3 [25]

AP: 0.3 [
Germany [26]

N-PPD
21 Yes, after risk–benefit analysis for mother and child and individual disease history, preference, and availability of alternative treatments Yes, after risk–benefit analysis for mother and child NS SSRIs, tricyclics

/

NS
NA NA NS BZD: NA

AP: NA

]

Quetiapine: 0.2

[21]
Quetiapine: NA Italy [28]

PMH-S
Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment
Italy [28Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment ]

PMH-S
NS NS NS Yes, after risk–benefit analysis for mother and child No, use of SSRI does not prevent BF NS NS

/

Fluoxetine
2.5–3.4 [29]3.3–4.4 [29] vs.

1.2–1.6 [29]
Paroxetine, sertraline, citalopram [29] Yes, BZD can be used NA Yes, short-term acting BZD BZD: NA

AP: NA

BZD: 1.4 [30]

AP: 0.8 [31]

Quetiapine: NA

SAH: 0.4* [24]
Quetiapine: NA Malta [32]

PMH-S
Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment; drug choice based on lowest risk, monotherapy if possible and at the lowest effective dose Yes, after individual risk-benefit assessment; drug choice based on lowest risk, monotherapy if possible and at the lowest effective dose; previous response is considered NS If possible, switch paroxetine to other SSRI Sertraline ¥; Fluoxetine

/

Paroxetine
NA Sertraline, fluoxetine (unpublished data) BZD only short term for extreme anxiety or agitation; BZD should be avoided in late pregnancy BZD: NA

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA
Latvia [48]

PMH-S
Yes, after risk–benefit analysis for mother and child in case of BF. For initiation of AD, start with lowest effective dose. Assess whether dosage and regimen are compatible with BF NS SSRIs, sertraline

/

Fluoxetine
NA NA Yes, mirtazapine or atypical AP; quetiapine for augmentation therapy. Olanzapine only at low doses. BZD should be avoided. BZD: NA

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA
The Netherlands [33]

PMH-S
Malta [32]Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment Yes, if woman is stable with medication Yes, lowest effective dose; paroxetine preferably not >20 mg/day If possible, switch paroxetine to other SSRI but pre-pregnancy Sertraline ¥

/

Paroxetine ¥
3.9 vs.

2.1 [34]


PMH-SSertraline,

paroxetine,

citalopram [
Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment; drug choice based on lowest risk, monotherapy if possible and at the lowest effective dose34 Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment; drug choice based on lowest risk, monotherapy if possible, and at the lowest effective dose, previous response is considered NS Iimipramine, nortriptyline, sertraline

/

Citalopram, fluoxetine]
NS BZD: 1.1 [25][35]

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA
BZD: 1.1 [25,35]

AP: NA
NA

Quetiapine: NA
SSRIs e.g., sertraline, paroxetine (unpublished data) Short-term BZD (caution in BF). Close monitoring of babies exposed to BZD via breastmilk. Diazepam should not be used while BF. BZD: NA

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA Norway [36] PMH-S Yes,

if severe and with non-pharmacological therapy
Yes,

after individual risk–benefit assessment. Psychotherapy first line.

Abrupt discontinuation is discouraged.
Yes, serum concentration No Choice based on prior drug response and its safety profile
The Netherlands

33 PMH-S
Yes, continue SSRI after delivery Yes, BF is recommended No, no evidence for switching Paroxetine, sertraline

/

Fluoxetine, citalopram
3.1 [34]2.0 vs. 1.5

[37]
Paroxetine,

citalopram,(Es)citalopram, sertraline, venlafaxine [19]
NS

sertraline [34]
NS BZD: NA

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NABZD: 0.9 [38]

AP: 1.2 [21]

Quetiapine: 0.3 [21]

SAH: 1.0 [24] *
Poland [39]

PMH-S
Individual risk–benefit assessment to be made.

**AD in 1 trimester should be avoided, and AD should be discontinued before delivery
If severe depression or ongoing mild-to-moderate symptoms, AD should be considered.

Gradual discontinuation if mild symptoms with psychotherapy.

** As for new depression.
Monotherapy, lowest effective dose Yes, switching an AD which is effective and offers fewer adverse effects NS

/

Paroxetine
- vs. 0.3 [24] * NA Yes, but do not offer BZD except for the short-term treatment of severe anxiety and agitation
Norway [36] PMH-SBZD: 0.2–14.0 [24][25] *

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA

SAH: 0.4 [24] *
BZD: 0.2–14.0 [24,25] *

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA

SAH: 0.4 [24] *
Yes, if severe after individual risk–benefit assessment NS No Sertraline, paroxetine

/

Doxepin, fluoxetine, citalopram
1.0 [37] NA NS BZD: 0.8 [37]

AP: 0.2 [37]

Quetiapine: NA
Serbia [40]

N-PPD
Yes,

if severe after individual risk–benefit assessment
Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment Yes, serum concentration NS Fluoxetine,

[25
Poland [39]

PMH-S
citalopram,

fluvoxamine,

paroxetine,

sertraline

/

TCA
- vs. 0.3 [24] * (Es)citalopram, sertraline, mirtazapine, duloxetine

(unpublished data)
Yes, Yes, initiate if severe and continue to prevent relapse.

If history of severe depression or ongoing mild-to-moderate symptoms, AD should be considered.
Yes, AD in one daily dose before the child’s longest

sleep, and BF is recommended just before AD intake
No, same treatment pattern should

be used after delivery
] Sertraline, citalopram

/

Fluoxetine

BZD
BZD: 0.2–14.0 [24 * NA]

NA NA BZD: NA

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA
AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA

SAH: 0.4 [24] *
BZD: 0.2–14.0 [24,25] *

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA

SAH: 0.4 [24] *
Spain [41]

PMH-S
Serbia [Yes, after individual risk–benefit assessment 40]

N-PPDYes,

after individual risk–benefit assessment and based on individual drug response
Monotherapy if possible, lowest effective dose; continuous measurement of plasma levels due to fluctuations in pregnancy is recommended Yes, if lower risk to child and effective in mothers SSRIs Yes,

if severe after individual risk–benefit assessment

/

Paroxetine, tricyclics, fluoxetine
- vs. 0.5–0.8

[
NS42 No] Fluoxetine[43]- vs. 0.5–0.8

[42
NA,43] Paroxetine, citalopram, fluoxetine44 Yes, but for acute symptoms for maximum 4 weeks BZD: 1.9 [42]

AP: 0.1 [43]

Quetiapine: NA
Paroxetine

(data unpublished) NS BZD: NA

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA United Kingdom [44][45]

PMH-S
United Kingdom [44,45]

PMH-S
Yes, particularly for moderate-to-severe depression, after discussing

with the woman the risk–benefit assessment of AD; drug choice based on lowest risk, monotherapy if possible and at the lowest effective dose
Yes, particularly for moderate-to-severe depression, after discussing with the woman the risk–benefit assessment of AD; monotherapy if possible and at the lowest effective dose Yes, dosages may need to be adjusted in pregnancy
Spain [Option to be discussed with the woman but aim is to expose fetus to as few drugs as possible 41]

PMH-S
Yes, if severe after individual risk–benefit assessment NS NS Nortriptyline, sertraline,

paroxetine

/

Citalopram, fluoxetineUnspecified, choice based on prior drug response and its safety profile
8.8–9.6 vs.

3.7 [29]
Fluoxetine, citalopram [29] Yes, with ADs. Do not offer BZD except for the short-term treatment of severe anxiety and agitation. NA NA NS BZD: NA

AP: NA

Quetiapine: NA
BZD: 1.2 * [25]

AP: 0.3–4.6 [21][46]

Quetiapine: 0.4 [21]
BZD: 1.2 * [25]

AP: 0.3–4.6 [21,46]

Quetiapine: 0.4 [21]
United Kingdom


[
44
]
[
45
]
PMH-S
United Kingdom


[44,45] PMH-S
Yes, particularly for moderate-to-severe depression after discussing with the woman of the risk–benefit assessment of AD; drug choice based on lowest risk, monotherapy if possible and at the lowest effective dose. Consider risks and benefits of BF, which should generally be encouraged, but monitor baby for any adverse effects. Option to be discussed with the woman, but aim is to expose the breastfed infant to as few drugs as possible. Unspecified, choice based on prior drug response and its safety profile in breastfeeding. 5.5–12.9 [29][46]5.5–12.9 [29,46] SSRI [49] Yes, but do not offer BZD except for the short-term treatment of severe anxiety. BZD best avoided in BF if possible; use drug with shortest half-life. BZD: NA

AP: 0.4 [46]

Quetiapine: NA
The specific substances recommended and not recommended vary considerably between the CPGs, but taken together, sertraline (8/12 CPGs) and paroxetine (5/12 CPGs) are the ones most commonly preferred, while fluoxetine is not preferred in most CPGs (8/12 CPGs) due to its very long half-life with the risk of accumulation in the infant. Paroxetine, citalopram, sertraline, or SSRI in general are also the antidepressants most commonly taken by women postpartum. Fluoxetine does not rank high in drug utilization studies in the postpartum period.

2.4. Pharmacological Interventions for Antenatal or Postpartum Comorbid Anxiety and Use of Other Psychotropics

Treatment recommendations for comorbid anxiety are largely missing for both the antenatal and the postpartum period (Table 1 and Table 2). Only seven GPGs state that benzodiazepines can be offered in the case of severe anxiety during pregnancy but only for short-term treatment. In Malta, benzodiazepines are recommended only as needed, and the treatment of choice is augmentation with quetiapine, both during pregnancy and postpartum. During the latter period, sedative antihistamines represent a treatment option. In the UK, it is advised to treat comorbid anxiety with antidepressants during pregnancy or short-term benzodiazepines, and the latter medication is discouraged at postpartum in case of breastfeeding. The CPG in Latvia recommends treatment of comorbid anxiety postpartum with mirtazapine or atypical antipsychotics, including olanzapine at a low dose, while benzodiazepines should be avoided.
Prenatal use data for benzodiazepines, antipsychotics, and quetiapine specifically are lacking for some countries, and for sedative antihistamines, data are very sparse. During pregnancy, benzodiazepines are often used to a larger extent than antidepressants in specific countries (i.e., Germany, Poland, Serbia, and Spain), while in Norway, the use of benzodiazepine and sedative antihistamines is comparable (about 1%). With regard to the use of other psychotropic medication (as an add-on) in the postpartum period, utilization data are largely unavailable, as only the Nordic countries and the UK report postpartum use of benzodiazepines and antipsychotics in the ranges of 0.8–3.2% and 0.2–0.4%, respectively.
Video Production Service