Coronary Microvascular Dysfunction: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Federico Vancheri and Version 2 by Nicole Yin.

Coronary microvascular dysfunction (CMD) is defined as the clinical syndrome of angina, electrocardiographic ischemic changes in the absence of obstructive CAD. The pathophysiological basis is impaired microvascular vasodilatation, leading to inadequate increase in blood flow to match myocardial oxygen needs (previously referred to in the literature as “cardiac syndrome X”).

  • Coronary microcirculation
  • endotheial dysfunction
  • Coronary microcirculation, endothelial dysfunction

1. Introduction

CMD is functionally expressed as reduced coronary flow reserve (CFR), which is the maximum increase in coronary blood flow above the resting value after pharmacological coronary vasodilatation. Reduced CFR due to functional and/or structural abnormalities of the microcirculation has been reported in about 50% of patients with chronic coronary syndromes and up to 20% of those with acute coronary syndromes, in the absence of epicardial coronary flow obstruction[1][2][3][4][5] [12,20–23].

Until recently, the prognosis of non-obstructive CAD was thought to be benign, and patients were often inappropriately reassured, without further investigation, despite clinical features requiring coronary angiography. Instead, this condition represents a major cause for myocardial ischemia and is associated with a high risk of major adverse cardiovascular events, including MI, progressive heart failure, stroke, and even sudden death[6][7][8][9][10][11][12] [10,14,24–28]. Moreover, in most patients there is evidence for close interactions between microvascular dysfunction and atherosclerotic epicardial coronary disease[13][14] [29,30]. CMD is a strong determinant of prognosis even in patients with coronary stenosis of intermediate severity[15] [31].

2. Pathophysiology of CMD

In contrast to coronary epicardial atherosclerosis, CMD does not develop atheroma. However, coronary microcirculation can develop structural and functional atherosclerotic changes, particularly in patients with cardiovascular (CV) risk factors. CMD is expressed as either the inability of the coronary arteries to dilate appropriately to meet myocardial oxygen demand (vasodilator abnormality) and/or as the abrupt reduction in coronary blood flow (coronary microvascular spasm). The underlying mechanism for coronary vasomotor dysfunction may be endothelium-dependent or endothelium-independent. Endothelium-dependent dysfunction is a consequence of an imbalance between endothelium-derived relaxing factors, such as nitric oxide (NO), and endothelium-derived constrictors, such as endothelin. Endothelium-independent function is based on myocyte tone. Moreover, CMD can occur in the absence and/or in the presence of obstructive epicardial coronary artery disease[16] [55]. The myocardial consequences of coronary blood flow abnormalities related to CMD are different from those caused by epicardial flow-limiting stenosis. In the latter, the impairment in myocardial perfusion is homogeneously distributed in the region perfused by the stenosed artery, resulting in segmental impairment of wall contraction. In contrast, the myocardial ischemia in CMD may not involve all microvessels originating from an epicardial artery but may have a patchy distribution. This explains why these patients may have symptoms without myocardial wall contraction abnormalities[17] [56].

2.1. Endothelial Dysfunction

Despite the fact that endothelial structure and function may vary considerably among different vascular regions, they have a common feature in secreting substances that regulate vascular tone and permeability, thus contributing to vascular protection[18] [57]. The endothelium has a crucial role in CV homeostasis, in particular in the myocardial capillaries where endothelial cells are directly in contact with adjacent cardiomyocytes[19] [58]. Normally, under physiological stimuli such as exercise, the vascular endothelial cells modulate an appropriate dilatation of coronary arteries by locally releasing vasodilator substances, in particular NO[20][21][22] [59–61]. NO also protects the integrity of the endothelium through its anti-inflammatory properties by inhibiting fibrosis, platelet aggregation, and apoptosis and by promoting angiogenesis.

CMD is initiated by the low-grade inflammatory response to CV risk factors, similar to those of obstructive CAD, although they have been shown to account for <20% of variability in microvascular function, leaving a large proportion unexplained[23][24][25] [62–64]. The inflammatory response reduces NO bioavailability, which is the link between atherosclerosis and microvascular dysfunction, leading to impairment of both endothelium-dependent and endothelium-independent coronary microvascular vasomotor function, thus increasing the risk of myocardial ischemia. Functional changes induced by endothelial dysfunction may be simultaneously present in coronary microcirculation and in the epicardial arteries, as well as peripheral vascular sites, thus representing a systemic disorder[26][27] [65,66]. Inflammation-induced endothelial dysfunction is thought to be mediated by elevated C-reactive protein (CRP) levels[23][28][29][30] [62,67–69]. However, it is still controversial whether high CRP concentration is cause or effect of atherosclerosis, or confounding factor[31][32][33] [70–72].

The inflammatory response of endothelial cells is strongly influenced by WSS, which is the tangential component of the mechanical friction exerted by the flowing blood on the vascular endothelial surface[34][35] [73,74]. Specific biomechanical receptors in the glycocalyx, a surface proteoglycan layer, translate WSS into biochemical signals that modulate the vascular tone, platelet activity, leukocyte adhesion, and endothelial permeability[36] [75]. While physiological WSS promotes the maintenance of anti-inflammatory properties of endothelial barrier, low WSS induces inflammation, and atherogenesis through decreased endothelial production of NO[37][38] [76,77]. This results in impairment of dilator function and blunted coronary blood flow augmentation in response to myocardial metabolic demands. Impaired endothelial function may also release vasoconstrictor substances (endothelin, prostaglandin, and thromboxane), thus shifting the vasomotor response to physiological stimuli from dilatation to constriction, reducing the blood flow[39] [78]. Vasomotor abnormalities in patients with CMD include coronary spasm, which affects large and small coronary arteries. Following intracoronary infusion of acetylcholine, about 50% of patients with exertional angina and no evidence of obstructive CAD develop coronary microvascular spasm, defined as angina and ischemic ECG changes without changes in epicardial coronary artery diameter[40] [15].

The decreased production of NO by impaired endothelial cells also increases collagen deposition, reduces angiogenesis and collateral development, and promotes the conversion of endothelial cells into mesenchymal cells, leading to microvascular rarefaction defined as loss of perfused microvessels, fibrosis, and hypertrophy[41][42] [79,80]. Moreover, while under normal conditions endothelial cells produce anti-proliferative and antithrombotic mediators, inflammation promotes a switch in endothelial function from a quiescent to an activated state, involving platelet activation, lipid oxidation, and leukocyte adhesion and migration which, in turn, accelerate inflammation[43][44] [81,82]. Microvascular inflammation and reduced NO availability directly promote proliferation of fibroblasts, which increase the production of fibronectin and collagen leading to cardiac remodeling following myocardial infarction, pressure overload, and myocarditis[45][46][47] [83–85]. Additionally, proliferation of fibroblast and increased content of extracellular matrix proteins increase the distance of oxygen diffusion between capillaries and myocytes, exposing the myocardium to the risk of hypoxia under the condition of reduced blood flow.

Microvascular functional abnormalities, characterized by persistent changes in microvascular tone, are also associated with the development of structural abnormalities, which include luminal narrowing, due to inward remodeling of intramyocardial arterioles, rarefaction of microvessels, and microembolization after atherosclerotic plaque rupture or during coronary intervention. Remodeling is mainly caused by medial wall thickening because of proliferated smooth muscle cells, surrounded by perivascular fibrosis[48][49] [86,87]. Both arteriolar remodeling and decrease in capillary density (estimated as capillary number per unit area) contribute to increased microvascular resistance and reduced CFR[50][51][52][53] [88–91]. Coronary microvascular microembolization by debris from epicardial atherosclerotic plaques together with thrombogenic and inflammatory substances may develop acutely following plaque rupture or erosion[54][55] [92,93]. This may occur spontaneously or may be induced during percutaneous coronary intervention after myocardial infarction. Release of debris and thrombogenic substances from atherosclerotic epicardial lesions may also be chronic and asymptomatic, leading to progressive microvascular dysfunction.

2.2. Autonomic Nervous System

Sympathetic and parasympathetic nerves can modulate arterial tone directly acting on vascular smooth muscle cells or stimulating the release of NO from the endothelium[56] [36]. The physiological role of coronary blood flow control by the vagus nerve is uncertain. However, under controlled conditions, the intracoronary infusion of acetylcholine results in dilatation of resistance vessels and a three to four-fold increase in blood flow. In contrast, in patients with coronary atherosclerosis, the response is attenuated or results in epicardial or microvascular coronary spam[40] [15]. Such effects of acetylcholine on the coronary endothelium are used to test the endothelium-dependent coronary function.

At rest, the sympathetic control of coronary vasomotor tone is negligible and depends on the balance between β-adrenergic mediated arterial dilatation, which is prevalent, and α-adrenergic mediated vasoconstriction that has only a limited effect[56] [36]. During exercise, coronary tone is modulated by sympathetic activation through release of norepinephrine by sympathetic nerves of coronary circulation, as well as by circulating norepinephrine and epinephrine. β-adrenergic activation, involving mainly β2-adrenoceptors, contributes to coronary vasodilatation to compensate for the increased myocardial oxygen consumption, accounting for approximately 25% of exercise hyperemia[57] [94]. However, when the coronary circulation is impaired by atherosclerotic endothelial dysfunction, the α1-adrenergic mediated vasoconstriction becomes more intense, reduces blood flow, and may lead to myocardial ischemia[58][59] [95,96].

3. Clinical Presentation

Conditions presented as symptoms and signs of myocardial ischemia without significant coronary artery stenosis (<50% diameter stenosis) are termed “ischemia with non-obstructive coronary artery disease” (INOCA)[2][11][60][61] [20,27,97,98]. Endothelial dysfunction accounts for approximately two-thirds of INOCA [99]. Among these patients, the clinical feature of microvascular angina (MVA), defined as the clinical manifestation of myocardial ischemia due to CMD in the absence of flow-limiting CAD[62][63] [18,100], is present in 52%, vasospastic angina (VSA) defined as a manifestation of epicardial spasm in 17%, and mixed forms in 20%[64][65] [101,102].

Myocardial infarction with non-obstructive coronary artery disease (≤50% diameter stenosis in a major epicardial artery) is termed MINOCA (Figure 1). This is a heterogeneous group of conditions including epicardial and microvascular causes of myocardial ischemia, such as plaque disruption, epicardial coronary spasm, spontaneous coronary dissection, microvascular spasm, and coronary distal embolization[66][67][68][69][70][71][72] [2,4,103–107]. The features of Takotsubo cardiomyopathy and myocarditis, initially included in the definition, were subsequently excluded[66] [2]. The prevalence of MINOCA is approximately 10% of all type 1 myocardial infarction (MI), more common in women and in patients presenting with Non-ST-elevation myocardial infarction (NSTEMI)[73][74] [108,109]. CMD, expressed by coronary microvascular spasm, accounts for about 20% of MINOCA patients[67][73][75] [4,108,110].  A seasonal pattern of occurrence with a peak in summer and autumn has been observed in patients with MINOCA[76] [111]. In contrast, it is still uncertain whether MI due to CAD is equally distributed across seasons or more frequent in winter, in association with respiratory tract infections. These differences may be related to different pathophysiologic triggers leading to MI, e.g., microvascular spasm in patients with MINOCA or atherosclerotic plaque rupture in MI due to CAD.

Figure 1. A hypertensive, smoker, young male patient was admitted for inferior ST-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI). Coronary angiography was performed with no coronary lesions on the left (panel A, 1,2, and 3) and right (panel B, 4) coronary artery. Subsequentially, cardiac magnetic resonance (CMR) was performed. Delayed enhancement sequences, from apex to base, show sub-endocardial lesions (white arrows, image 1 and 4) with transmural extension (white arrows 2 and 3), confirming the ischemic lesions of the inferior-lateral wall.

CMD may occur in asymptomatic individuals and may be diagnosed incidentally. Symptoms of myocardial ischemia are indistinguishable from those caused by epicardial stenosis. One to two-thirds of patients present typical exertional angina, more common in postmenopausal women than in men[77] [112]. Atypical symptoms, including retrosternal chest pain at rest or angina-equivalent, such as dyspnea on exertion, are also common. Effort-induced symptoms tend to occur in the post exercise recovery period, due to persistence of imbalance between metabolic demand and oxygen delivery. Nitrates are less effective in relieving symptoms because their vasodilator effect is more pronounced in the epicardial arteries compared to microvascular circulation. Standardized criteria for clinical diagnosis of MVA have been developed by the “Coronary Vasomotion Disorders International Study Group” (COVADIS), based on symptoms, absence of obstructive CAD, evidence of myocardial ischemia, and evidence of microvascular dysfunction (Table 1)[62] [18].

Table 1. Clinical criteria for the diagnosis of microvascular angina (MVA).

1. Symptoms of myocardial ischemia

-Effort and/or rest angina

-Angina equivalents (exertional dyspnea)

2. Absence of obstructive CAD (<50% diameter reduction or FFR > 0.80) by coronary CTA or invasive angiography


3. Objective evidence of myocardial ischemia

-Ischemic ECG changes during chest pain

-Stress-induced chest pain and/or ischemic ECG changes with or without transient

 or reversible abnormal myocardial perfusion and/or wall motion abnormality

4. Evidence of impaired coronary microvascular function

-Impaired coronary flow reserve ≤ 2.0

-Coronary microvascular spasm, defined as symptoms and ischemic ECG changes but

 not epicardial spasm during acetylcholine testing

-Abnormal coronary microvascular resistance indices (IMR > 25)

-Coronary slow flow phenomenon, defined as TIMI frame count > 25

Definitive MVA if all 4 criteria are present. Suspected MVA if symptoms of ischemia with no obstructive coronary artery disease are present (criteria 1 and 2) but only objective evidence of myocardial ischemia (criteria 3) or evidence of impaired coronary microvascular function (criteria 4) alone. CAD = coronary artery disease; ECG = electrocardiogram; CTA computed tomographic angiography; FFR = fractional flow reserve; IMR = index of microcirculatory resistance; TIMI = thrombolysis in myocardial infarction. For details, please refer to: Changed.

3.1. Gender Differences in CMD

Several studies have shown that females have a lesser extent of obstructive CAD compared with males[9][74] [25,109].  In contrast, they have higher prevalence of angina without obstructive CAD[78][79][80] [19,113,114]. In the presence of non-obstructive CAD, myocardial ischemia may be due to microvascular endothelial dysfunction, epicardial and microvascular spasm, or conduit artery stiffening. Moreover, in patients without angiographically obstructive CAD, intracoronary imaging studies using IVUS (intravascular ultrasound), which allows direct cross-sectional visualization of the arterial wall, have shown high prevalence of positive remodeling and preserved lumen size[13][14] [29,30]. This may explain the absence of flow-limiting lesions which can only outline contrast-filled coronary lumen. These features are more frequent in women and are associated with increased risk of CV events[81][82] [115,116].  Additionally, women have higher prevalence of MINOCA—10.5% compared to 3.4% for men[67][83] [4,117].

Symptomatic women are generally older than men and often have greater number and severity of CV risk factors. Moreover, most patients are in the peri- or post-menopausal stage, suggesting that reduced levels of estrogen have a role in the development of CMD[84] [118]. Angina in the absence of obstructive CAD is also psychologically relevant, as recognition of the ischemic heart disease may be delayed. This may induce anxiety in the patient because there is no clear diagnosis, thus reducing the patient’s quality of life.

3.2. Clinical Classification

CMD includes a wide spectrum of conditions variously associated with atherosclerosis. Accordingly, the traditional CMD classification takes into account the clinical and pathophysiological setting in which it may occur[5][85] [23,119].This classification has been recently updated in relation to the severity of CAD [20] (Table 2).

Table 2. Clinical classifications of coronary microvascular dysfunction (CMD).

A.              CMD in chronic coronary syndrome

     with non-obstructive chronic coronary syndrome

     with obstructive chronic coronary syndrome

CMD in acute coronary syndrome (ACS)

     with non-obstructive ACS

     with obstructive ACS

     with coronary no-reflow phenomenon

CMD following successful revascularization after MI


B.              Group 1. CMD in the absence of obstructive CAD and myocardial disease

Group 2. CMD in the presence of myocardial disease

Group 3. CMD in the presence of obstructive CAD

Group 4. CMD after successful percutaneous coronary intervention


C.              CMD without atherosclerosis

CMD with non-obstructive atherosclerosis

CMD with obstructive atherosclerosis

In addition, because CMD may be associated with clinical conditions in which atherosclerosis is minimal or absent or associated with obstructive or non-obstructive coronary atherosclerosis, a simplified classification has been proposed, including three main CMD phenotypes: without atherosclerosis, with non-obstructive atherosclerosis, and with obstructive atherosclerosis[39] [78].