Autism spectrum disorder (ASD) is a heterogeneous, behaviorally defined, neurodevelopmental disorder that has been modeled as a brain-based disease.
1. Introduction
Autism was first described by a psychiatrist named Leo Kanner based on his observations on 11 children with severe communication problems, repetitive behavior, and acute lack of social interaction. Kanner’s original description has led to the recognition of autism as a disorder decades later
[1]. It is part of a broader range of conditions known as autism spectrum disorder (ASD). The term autism and ASD are used interchangeably. ASD is defined as a complex neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by impairments in social interactions and communication, as well as by the presence of purposeless repetitive behaviors and restrictive interests
[2]. Individuals with ASD have difficulty in expressing and understanding certain emotions and moods, abnormal eye contact, restricted ways of using toys, preferences of isolated play and minimal changes to routine. These characteristics have made it difficult for them to establish relationships with others, act in an appropriate way and live independently
[3].
Developmental disabilities ranging from mild disabilities such as speech and language impairments, to more serious developmental disabilities such as intellectual disabilities, cerebral palsy and autism, have been identified in approximately 1 in 6 children in the United States. The prevalence of ASD has dramatically increased in the last few decades at the rate of 1 in 2500 children around 1980s to 1 in 150 children in 2007
[4]. According to the data from the Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring (ADDM) Network of the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), approximately, 1 in 68 children have been identified with ASD from 2010 to 2012
[5]. For 2014, the overall prevalence of ASD has increased to 16.8 per 1000 (1 in 59) children aged 8 years
[6]. The rate of ASD diagnosis was four times more common in males than females
[7]. The increase in ASD prevalence was partly attributed to the increased awareness and reporting practice of the disorder, as well as an improved diagnostic criteria
[8].
Approximately, 90 percent of ASD cases have been classified as idiopathic, while about 10 to 20 percent were caused by known genetic etiology
[9]. In recent years, intense scientific works have revealed that ASD is genetically driven with heritability indices estimated at 85 to 92 percent and could be triggered by environmental risk factors especially those influencing fetal and early-life development
[10,11][10][11]. The symptoms of autism appeared before 36 months of age, while regression or loss of skills usually occurred between 18 and 24 months in 30 percent of the affected children
[12]. It may persist throughout life, often in a more muted form
[2]. In fact, ASD has affected more children than diabetes, acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS), cancer, cerebral palsy, cystic fibrosis, muscular dystrophy and Down’s syndrome combined
[13]. The Global Burden of Disease Study 2010 reported that the global prevalence and burden of disease for ASD in 2010 was 1 in 132 individuals, which translated to 52 million cases of ASD and 7.7 million disability-adjusted life-years (DALY) across the globe
[14]. Among the mental disorders, ASD was the leading cause of disability in children under 5 years of age in terms of years lived with disability (YLDs). ASD was also ranked among the 20 leading causes of disability for the under 5-year age group. These data indicated that ASD is accounted for indisputable health loss across the lifespan.
The proposed pathogenesis of ASD comprises many distinct mechanisms including chronic neuroinflammation, gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) imbalance, monoaminergic dysregulation and mitochondrial dysregulation
[15]. However, the precise mechanism underlying the pathophysiology of ASD remained unknown and currently, there is no cure or effective treatment for this disorder. Major challenges toward finding an effective cure for this disorder include heterogeneity of its etiology and the lack of consistent and reliable genetic or biologic diagnostic markers for accurate classification and early diagnosis of ASD
[16].
2. CNS and Social Function
Vast parts of brain regions, which are made of the neural circuitry, are involved in various aspects of social cognition and perception. Social cognition is referred to as the fundamental ability to perceive, categorize, remember, analyze, reason with and behave towards others
[17]. The ability to perceive is not only dependent on vision and hearing, but also sensation (sense of smell and somato-sensation). It also depends on the connection with memories and emotions in the amygdala-hippocampal complex and other limbic structures
[18]. Meanwhile, social response formation involves automatic, stereotyped motor patterns encoded in brain stem nuclei, hypothalamus, central limbic and medial temporal structures, which interplay with the frontal cortex. Some parts of the cerebellum and the corpus callosum are also important for the “social brain”. The monoaminergic neurotransmitter systems that are involved in the functioning of the “social” circuits and controlling the activity in vast areas of the brain comprise the serotogenic, mesolimbic dopaminergic and norepinephrinergic systems. In addition, the GABAergic anti-excitatory system, peptidergic systems and neurons under the influence of steroid hormone are all essential for social functioning
[18].
ASD has been linked to abnormal social brain function and neurological disorder
[19]. As a disorder that features profound deficits in several aspects of social perception and cognition, neuroanatomical structure of the brain has become the focus in understanding brain mechanisms in research related to ASD. Additionally, ASD is characterized through behavioral and cognitive features that are predominantly thought to be as a result of atypical development of the brain itself.
3. Central Nervous Changes and ASD
Autism is also referred to as an early-onset disorder of the developing CNS
[20]. Although the underlying mechanisms remain largely unknown, autism is commonly described as a brain-based disorder since many documented changes are registered in the brain
[21]. In fact, the symptoms of ASD have been associated with pervasive atypicalities in the CNS
[22].
3.1. Brain Structure and Function Abnormalities in ASD
Certain brain regions including the limbic system, particularly the hippocampus, amygdala and cerebellum, have been implicated in the pathophysiologic mechanisms and clinical expressions of the disorder
[23]. Evidence from neuroimaging and postmortem studies has revealed structural abnormalities in those regions of the brain. Hypothetically, the core abnormalities in the pathogenesis of autism are located in the amygdala, adjacent limbic structures and corpus callosum
[18].
The amygdala is a collection of nuclei that lies beneath the uncus of the temporal lobe at the anterior end of the hippocampal formation and the inferior horn of the lateral ventricle of the brain
[24]. It influences drive-related behavior and related emotions. Amygdala stimulation is commonly followed by fear emotion, while bilateral destruction of amygdala causes reduced aggression. Amygdala deficit in autism might lead to abnormal fear responses in children; they may either show too little or too much fear compared to non-autistic children
[24]. The hippocampus is also the key component of the neural system and one of the most thoroughly studied areas of the mammalian CNS. It mediates the emotion perception and regulation, and hence is also thought to be involved in the pathophysiology of autism
[25].
Studies have shown that the damage to the amygdala is associated with impairments in social cognition and interpretation of emotions
[26]. Abnormal patterns of the amygdala and hippocampal development were found during childhood and adolescence phases of autistic cases. In a previous study by Pierce, et al.
[27], structural and neurofunctional activities in the brain regions related to face processing were evaluated using functional magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The study revealed a significant decrease in amygdala volume in autistic adults compared to normal control subjects. The study is consistent with an earlier MRI study by Aylward, et al.
[28], which demonstrated a significantly smaller amygdala volume in non-mentally retarded autistic male adolescents and young adults compared to healthy community volunteers. A significant reduction in hippocampal volume in relation to total brain volume was also noted in autistic subjects. The authors concluded that these volume reductions were related to reduction in dendritic tree and neuropil development, which likely reflected the underdevelopment of neural connections of limbic structures with other parts of the brain.
Findings of another study, however, documented that amygdala lesions did not lead to autistic symptoms
[29]. The subjects were two women with developmental-onset bilateral amygdala lesions. By using comprehensive interviews, behavioral observations and widely used ASD screening questionnaires, it was found that both subjects did not exhibit autistic symptomatology despite having the amygdala lesions. This suggests that it is the abnormal connectivity between the amygdala and other structures rather than overt amygdala pathology, which contributes to ASD.
On the contrary, several studies have found that amygdala and hippocampal volumes of ASD subjects were increased from childhood to young adulthood. Three-dimensional coronal MRI measurement acquired from autistic children revealed enlargement of amygdala and hippocampi
[23]. Schumann, et al.
[30] showed that autistic children had larger right and left amygdala volumes than control children; however, similar changes were not seen in the adolescent group. The hippocampal volume was enlarged in all study groups. The authors speculated that amygdala is initially larger in children with autism, but they did not undergo the age-related increase in volume that normally occurs in developing children. In another study, Groen, et al.
[25] measured amygdala and hippocampal volumes in a group of adolescent with autism and found significant enlargement of these parts of the brain compared to control group
[25].
In a more recent study, volumetric MRI of amygdala and hippocampal subfields were measured in infant subjects with risk of ASD
[31]. The authors showed significant enlargements of amygdala and hippocampi in each hemisphere and whole brain in ASD group compared to normal control. Amygdala enlargement at an early age has been related to severity of social, communication and emotional problems in ASD group
[25,30][25][30]. The volumetric enlargement of amygdala and hippocampus were postulated to be an adaptive response to increased neuron activity throughout childhood and adolescence in autism. It is also plausible that the hippocampus is enlarged in response to heightened amygdala activity since the hippocampus has a regulatory role on amygdala activity through a dense network of reciprocal connections
[25].
Considering this, abnormalities in those brain regions seemed to follow a different time course and the findings in adolescence and adult were quite sparse, which are summarized in
Table 1. There are certainly limitations that may contribute to this discrepancy. For instance, the small sample size in some studies may result in insufficient statistical power. Several studies have included a broader age range, which may hinder the detection of developmental changes in the brain. These results need to be replicated before a definitive conclusion can be made. Nonetheless, the changes in amygdala and hippocampal structure and function reported in previous studies were in accordance with the theory that autism is caused by abnormalities of certain brain regions.
Table 1.
Summary of previous studies on brain structure and function abnormalities in autism spectrum disorder (ASD).
Reference |
Subjects |
Sex |
Age Group |
Test Samples/Regions |
Method |
Major Findings |
[27] |
7 autistic adults, 8 normal control |
Male |
21 to 41 years |
Brain: Fusiform gyrus, inferior temporal gyrus, middle temporal gyrus, amygdala |
fMRI |
⇓ bilateral amygdala volumes in autistic subjects; fusiform gyrus volume was ⇓ but not statistically significant. |
[28] |
14 autistic subjects, 14 normal control |
Male |
11 to 37 years |
Brain: Hippocampus, amygdala |
MRI |
⇓ amygdala volume (with and without total brain volume correction); ⇓hippocampal volume (with correction) in autistic subjects. |
[29] |
2 adults with bilateral damage to amygdala |
Female |
23-and 48-years |
Autism Diagnostic Questionnaire Observation Schedule, Social Responsiveness Scale and other questionnaires |
|
No evidence of autistic changes in all measurements. |
[23] |
45 children with ASD, 26 typically- developing (TD), 14 developmentally- delayed (DD) children |
Male, female |
36 to 58 months |
Brain: Cerebellum, cerebrum, amygdala, hippocampus |
MRI |
⇑ cerebral volume in ASD compared to TD and DD children; ⇑ cerebellar volume in ASD compared to TD; ⇑ bilateral amygdala and hippocampi volume in ASD. |
[30] |
19 low-functioning autism (LFA), 27 high-functioning autism (HFA), 25 Asperger’s and 27 typically developing control children |
Male |
7.5 to 18.5 years |
Brain: Amygdala, hippocampus |
MRI |
⇑ right and left amygdala in children with autism than control (7–12.5 years old); ⇔ amygdala volume in adolescent group (12.75–18.5 years old). |
[25] |
23 adolescents with autism, 29 control |
Male, female |
12 to 18 years hippocampus |
Brain: Amygdala, |
MRI |
⇑ right amygdala and left hippocampus in adolescent with autism. |
[31] |
60 infants with risk of ASD, 211 normal control Brain: Amygdala, |
Male, female |
23 to 27 months |
Brain: Amygdala, hippocampus |
MRI |
⇑ amygdala and hippocampus in each hemisphere and the whole brain in ASD group. |