1. Introduction
With the development of human civilization, many refractory pollutants were discharged to the environment, which are hard to be degraded by traditional purification methods. For example, pollutants like tetracycline
[1], bisphenol A
[2], Astrazone Black
[3], estriol
[4], and tetraethylated rhodamine
[5] can hardly be degraded by normal waste-water treatment plants. Generally, the degradation of recalcitrant organic pollutants relies on the consumption of energy, such as the Fenton process. Photocatalysis has drawn much attention because of the utilization of solar energy and friendliness to the environment.
In photocatalysis, the heterojunction of two different materials is deemed as an efficient strategy to develop diverse hybrid composites with multiple functionalities
[6]. Photocatalysts normally possess some defects that restrict the utilization of the material, for example, ultrafast recombination of photo-induced charge carriers
[7], low efficient utilization of sunlight, and wide bandgap
[8]. Hybridization of two different catalysts would be an excellent way to improve the photoactivity. Lots of photocatalysts were synthesized in order to enhance the photoactivity of the catalysts, such as MoS
2/g-C
3N
4 [9], CuInS
2/g-C
3N
4 [10], Ag
2O/g-C
3N
4 [11], Ag
2O/TiO
2 [12], AgI/CuBi
2O
4 [13], CuS/BiVO
4 [14], Ag
3PO
4/MoS
2 [15], g-C
3N
4/SiO
2 [16], ZnFe
2O
4/TiO
2 [17], LaFeO
3/SnS
2 [18], Bi
2O
3/g-C
3N
4 [19], and Ag
2O/Bi
5O
7I
[20]. Recently, heterojunctions based on BiOCl and g-C
3N
4 drew much attention because of the abundance of the materials in the environment.
Graphitic carbon nitride is regarded as a nice photocatalyst because of its nontoxicity, stability in pH over a broad range (0–14), easy to prepare, and the narrow bandgap
[21]. After being first synthesized in 1834
[22], carbon nitride has been used in many areas, such as virus inactivation
[23], activation of benzene
[24], H
2 revolution
[25,26][25][26], fuel cells
[27], CO
2 reduction
[28], and organic pollutants degradation
[29]. However, because of its high recombination rate of the photogenerated charge carriers and low BET surface area, the application of g-C
3N
4 is restricted. Recently, many studies focused on building heterojunctions to improve its photoactivity, such as the system of WO
3/g-C
3N
4 [30], ZnWO
4/g-C
3N
4 [31], and In
2S
3/g-C
3N
4 [32]. According to these studies, coupling graphitic carbon nitride with other kinds of semiconductors could construct better photocatalysts by reducing the recombination rate of the photogenerated charge carriers or increasing the surface area.
On the contrary, layered structure of BiOCl facilitates the photogenerated charge carriers’ separation and endows it with a strong ability to degrade organic pollutants
[33]. Morphology control was employed by many researchers to improve the pristine catalyst
[34]. For example, according to E. Ramírez Meneses and co-workers
[35], the addition of capping agents could affect the morphology of BiOCl. However, the as-prepared catalysts were unable to be excited by visible light. In order to expand the light absorption range of BiOCl, many researchers synthesized heterostructures like carbon dots/BiOCl
[36], BiOCl/g-C
3N
4 [37], WO
3/BiOCl
[38], Bi
2MoO
6-BiOCl
[33], BiOCl/BiOBr
[39], m-Bi
2O
4/BiOCl
[40], BiOCl/BiVO
4 [41], Bi
2O
2CO
3/BiOCl
[42], and BiOI/BiOCl
[43].
Among them, the composition of BiOCl and g-C
3N
4 is considered as an excellent combination. The heterojunction could enhance the separation of the photo-induced charge carriers and enable the catalyst to respond to visible light
[43,44][43][44]. Noble metal doping is also considered as a good method to improve the semiconductor. However, the high cost of noble metal doping restricts its utilization. If a noble metal doping catalyst is used repeatedly, the catalyst will be eroded, and perhaps generate new pollutants
[45]. Heterojunctions of semiconductors is friendly to the environment, stable, and abundant in nature. Especially, the system of g-C
3N
4/BiOCl could be used repeatedly and facile to be produced.
Some researchers also found the photoactivity of g-C
3N
4/BiOCl heterojunctions could be further enhanced by combining them with other materials. For example, the systems of Bi
2S
3/BiOCl/g-C
3N
4 [46], BiOCl/g-C
3N
4/kaolinite
[47], and g-C
3N
4/CDs (carbon dots)/BiOCl
[48]. Notably, through the addition of mediators, Z-scheme catalysts can be synthesized, such as the systems of g-C
3N
4/Au/BiOCl
[49] and BiOCl/RGO/protonated g-C
3N
4 [50]. However, few researchers have focused on figuring out which method could prompt the photoactivity of the binary heterojunction. According to all the articles reviewed here, analysis of the proposed mechanism was an important section. Based on the adopted characterizations and experiments, the mechanism was discussed to help readers to understand the whole photocatalysis process.
42.1. CNB Heterojunction
Generally, the proposed mechanism for the generation of reactive radicals on the surface of CNB heterojunction is shown in Figure 2. Photoexcited electrons firstly generated in the conduction band of g-C3N4 by irradiation of visible light because of its relatively mild band gap (2.7 eV). When it comes to dye degradation, photo-induced charge carriers also generated through dye sensitization. Then, electrons transferred to the conduction band of BiOCl because the conduction band of BiOCl is less negative than that of g-C3N4. Photogenerated electrons tend to transfer to a less negative conduction band. Electrons could react with O2 on the surface of CNB to generate superoxide radicals. At the same time, holes remaining in the valence band of g-C3N4 react with surface-absorbed H2O to generate hydroxyl radicals, so that separation of photo-generated charge carriers is improved and the catalyst can response to visible light. However, the redox ability of the heterojunction was sacrificed when photoactivity is improved, because the holes accumulated on VB of g-C3N4.
Figure 2. The mechanism for the generation of reactive radicals over CNB.
The mechanism mentioned above was adopted by Faisal Al Marzouqi and co-workers to explain the degradation of nizatidine over the BiOCl/g-C
3N
4 heterojunction
[63][53]. The degradation efficiency of nizatidine was improved under the irradiation of visible light. According to the XRD pattern, the as-prepared catalyst was constructed by pure BiOCl and g-C
3N
4. The construction of the heterojunction was verified. As shown in the UV-vis diffuse reflectance spectra, the absorption edge of BiOCl was about 364 nm (in the UV range), and that of g-C
3N
4 was about 450 nm (in the visible range). After being combined, the absorption band edge of the heterojunction could be up to 476 nm. The photoactivity of the heterojunction was improved. The bandgap value for 10% BiOCl/g-C
3N
4 sample was 2.6 eV, which endowed the catalyst with the highest photoactivity among all the as-prepared samples. Therefore, the bandgap of the composite was narrowed by combination of the two components. The degradation rate of nizatidine was enhanced by the construction of the heterojunction as shown in
Figure 3b. This improvement was explained by the double-charge transfer mechanism as proposed in
Figure 2. Obviously, the CB and VB of both pristine catalysts did not change. The generation of reactive radicals depicted in the article was the same as that in
Figure 2. However, the article provided no further evidence to prove the main reactive radicals. The presence of hydroxyl radicals was supposed to be the main cause of the degradation of nizatidine in the article. But the study did not exclude the possibility that the hydroxyl radicals could be generated from superoxide radicals. Y. Yang and colleagues demonstrated hydroxyl and superoxide radicals were the main species during the photocatalytic oxidation of MB, too
[60][54]. Hydroxyl radicals were supposed to be produced in the VB of g-C
3N
4.
Figure 3. (a) XPR pattern of as-prepared BiOCl/g-C3N4 samples; (b) Degradation rate of nizatidine at an initial concentration of 5 mg/L and pH = 5.6 with all the prepared samples; (c) SEM image of 10% BiOCl/g-C3N4 sample; (d) UV-vis diffuse reflectance spectra of the obtained samples. Reproduced with permission from Al Marzouqi F et al, ACS Omega; published by American Chemical Society, 2013.
To date, lots of CNB heterojunctions were reported. Wenwen Liu and colleagues constructed a 2-dimensional layered BiOCl/g-C
3N
4 composite, and the photodegradation of MO was greatly improved through constructing a CNB heterojunction
[73][55]. When the mass ratio of BiOCl reached 70%, BiOCl/g-C
3N
4 heterojunction showed the highest photocatalytic performance. EIS images and PL spectra were carried out to prove that better charge separation was realized. The proposed mechanism was similar to that shown in
Figure 2. Electrons generated in the conduction band of g-C
3N
4, and then transferred to the conduction band of BiOCl. As a result, superoxide radicals generated on the surface of the heterojunction. Holes in the valence band of C
3N
4 were accumulated to participate in the degradation of MO degradation. Trapping experiments exhibited •O
2− and holes were the main reactive species in the degradation of MO, which could be the evidence of the proposed mechanism. In this study, the VB and CB positions of BiOCl and g-C
3N
4 were determined by the Mott-Schottky curve. The alignment of band edges during the combination of the two materials was not taken into consideration, though the researchers did not directly adopt the standard values. The presence of the main reactive species was consistent with the proposed mechanism. Liwen Lei and co-workers prepared another heterostructure photocatalyst by combining BiOCl and g-C
3N
4 [34]. Arabic gum (AG) was added while synthesizing the heterojunction. They also proved that the superoxide and holes are the main reactive species through trapping experiments. The mechanism shown in
Figure 2 was also adopted to explain the degradation of RhB over the composite.
However, the BiOCl/g-C
3N4 heterojunction prepared by Xiaojing Wang and colleagues showed a different result
[44]. Like the studies mentioned above
[73][55], XPR, FT-IR spectroscopy, and PL emission spectra were carried out to demonstrate the formation of the heterojunction. The light response wavelength of BiOCl was broadened, while the charge separation was enhanced. Trapping experiments were also carried out to detect the main reactive species in the photocatalytic process. It turned out that •O
2− was not the main reactive species, whereas holes played an important role during the degradation of MO.
Why the hydroxyl radicals were not generally supposed to generate during the photocatalytic reaction was not mentioned in the above studies. Zhang Sai and co-workers explained the reason in their study
[86][56], the standard CB and VB potentials of g-C
3N
4 are approximately −1.3 and 1.40 eV, respectively. The standard redox potential of •O
2−/O
2 is −0.13 eV (vs. NHE), which is more positive than the CB potential of g-C
3N
4. So, it is very easy for e- on the CB of g-C
3N
4 to generate superoxide radicals. The VB potential of g-C
3N
4 is less positive than the standard potential of •OH/OH
−, which is +1.99 eV (vs. NHE). This makes holes on the VB of the catalyst and cannot be captured and to produce •OH radicals. If the CB and VB of the g-C
3N
4/BiOCl catalysts stay unchanged after the construction of the type-II heterojunction, electrons accumulate on the CB of BiOCl (−1.1 eV)
[8] to form •O
2−. Holes migrate to the VB of g-C
3N
4, but cannot generate hydroxyl radicals. Therefore, superoxide radicals and holes are the main reactive species in the systems of BiOCl/g-C
3N
4. This theory is consistent with the results mentioned above. The work of L. Song and co-workers also suggested that the standard redox potential of the VB of g-C
3N
4 was not positive enough to generate •OH groups
[69][57]. J. Sun and colleagues directly used the standard potentials of the pristine catalysts to describe the mechanism without taking the alignment of the Fermi energy level into account
[68][58].
Q. Li and co-workers employed the result of X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (VB XPS) spectra to determine the VB of pure g-C
3N
4, which was 1.44 eV NHE
[61][59]. Compared to the standard potential of •OH/OH
−, the generation of •OH was not expected to happen on the VB of g-C
3N
4. The result of trapping experiments suggested that •O
2− and holes were the dominant reactive species during the degradation of MO.
Some other researchers did not only adopt trapping experiments to determine the main species, for example, L. Song and co-workers also adopted ESR spectra and trapping experiments to find out the main reactive species
[59][60]. The presence of superoxide radicals was directly proved by the ESR test. The generation of hydroxyl radicals was not detected. Trapping experiments proved holes also played an important role during the oxidation of RhB.
Just like the aforementioned study of Xiaojing Wang and colleagues
[44], T. Jia and colleagues determined the CB and VB potentials of BiOCl and g-C
3N
4 by using theoretical calculation, then holes were proved to be the main reactive species during the oxidation of MB through trapping experiments
[65][61].
There are some other studies that adopted a similar mechanism to explain the degradation of pollutants over ternary catalysts based on the system of BiOCl/g-C
3N
4, like systems of BiOCl/g-C
3N
4/kaolinite
[47], g-C
3N
4/CDs/BiOCl
[48], BiOCl/CdS/g-C
3N
4 [87][62], and BiOI-BiOCl/C
3N
4 [88][63].
However, Xiaojuan Bai and colleagues demonstrated that hydroxyl radicals were still produced, though the VB of g-C
3N
4 was not positive enough
[89][64]. They synthesized a kind of photocatalyst by modifying g-C
3N
4 with fullerene. After the modification, the degradation rate of MB was improved. Trapping and ESR experiments proved that holes and •OH were the main reactive species in the photodegradation of MB. After the modification, the VB of C
60/g-C
3N
4 was more positive by 0.17 eV. Considering the theory depicted above, that was not positive enough to generate •OH directly on the VB of g-C
3N
4. The mechanism was further researched by adding N
2 to create an anoxic suspension. The degradation of MB was almost unchanged in the presence of N
2, which indicated that the •OH was generated on the surface of the composite, but not through the reaction induced by electrons on the CB of g-C
3N
4. This study seems contradictory to the theory described above that the VB of g-C
3N
4 was not positive enough to produce •OH
[86][56].
The CNB system is a typical type-II heterojunction due to the band structures of the two materials. Trapping experiments were carried out to clarify the main reactive species, which proved to be superoxide radicals and holes. However, according to the study discussed above
[86][56], there is still something unclear about the mechanism depicted in this section. Some more works are required to elucidate the reaction that happened over the heterojunction of CNB.