Based on the aforementioned precedents on COVID-19 pathogenesis, the blockade of excessive cytokine release by targeting some of its critical triggers would avoid the multiple organ damage/failure and reasonably palliate the adverse outcome of the disease, as well as contribute to implementing effective curative strategies. In this regard, melatonin stands out as one of the best-positioned intervention therapy options to return to equilibrium the critical gears of uncontrolled immune inflammation. Although the current investigation into direct protection of ACE2 by melatonin is inconclusive
[165][136], the evidence of its anti-inflammatory capacity is indisputable. Noteworthily, melatonin modulates inflammation as a hormesis-like process, activating moderate pro-inflammatory mechanisms in the course of the homeostatic immune response to intruder pathogens and contrarily stopping inflammatory mechanisms in contexts of hyper-inflammation, attenuating circulating cytokines and pro-inflammatory effectors
[106][76]. For this reason, melatonin may ameliorate the exacerbated host inflammatory response and thereby prevent the irreversible pulmonary fibrosis and chronic respiratory damage of severely ill COVID-19 patients
[10[10][137],
166], as the indoleamine has demonstrated in experimental studies
[167,168][138][139]. This damped response rests on positive modulation of anti-inflammatory cytokines such as IL-10 and attenuation of pro-inflammatory ones, such as IL-1β, IL-6, IL-8, or TNF-α exerted by melatonin
[169][140]. A similar rationale supports the use of melatonin to treat gut complications caused by hyper-inflammation and exacerbated innate immune response against SARS-CoV-2
[170][141]. The combined anti-inflammatory and immunomodulatory capabilities of pleiotropic melatonin endow it with an extraordinary potential to prevent the gastrointestinal complications associated with SARS-CoV-2 infection
[170][141]. In addition, the reciprocal interaction between the gut microbiome and pulmonary physiology, termed the “gut–lung axis”, provides microbiota with a relevant role in the immune homeostasis and the deadly recurrent ARDS in COVID-19
[171][142]. Melatonin reduces gut membrane permeability and is active in the chronoregulation and maintenance of a healthy balanced gut microbiome
[172][143]. A recent work has elucidated the immunomodulatory importance of melatonin, both pineal and systemic, in COVID-19 severity, mediated by a complex myriad of factors, including the alpha 7 nicotinic acetylcholine receptor from lung epithelial and immune cells or the gut microbiome-derived and epigenetic regulator butyrate
[173][144]. A noticeable meta-analysis of the anti-inflammatory capacity of melatonin administration has recently confirmed, based on 13 studies and a global cohort of 749 people, the reduction of TNF-α and IL-6 levels
[174][145], suggesting that it would have a similar effect on COVID-19 patients. However, the initiation of melatonin supplementation must be carefully addressed to ensure its anti-inflammatory potential
[31]. However it is hypothesized that the anti-inflammatory activity of melatonin is mainly achieved by orchestrating the suppression of toll-like receptor (TLR) signaling
[175][146], the inhibition of the multiprotein platform inflammasome promoter NLRP3 (Nucleotide-binding Oligomerization Domain (NOD)-Like Receptor Pyrin domain containing 3)
[176][147], and the blockage of the nuclear translocation of the NF-κB
[76][148]. The result of binding viral proteins and/or genomic ssRNA by TLR/PAMPs would be the recruitment of the receptor–ligand complexes and the activation of apoptosis, lysosomal autophagy, and inflammasome-induced pyroptosis for the clearance of the virus
[166][137]. Additionally, self-components from the autolytic processes activated, and particularly those released from stressed suboptimal mitochondria, initiate another immune–inflammatory cascade known as the “secondary cytokine storm”. These concatenated massive cytokine releases give rise to the fearsome continuous immune–inflammatory process that causes the extensive tissue and organ damage of the critical COVID-19 phase. In this scenario, melatonin may presumably prevent the secondary cytokine storm and associated hyper-inflammation of COVID-19. Different disease models have shown melatonin repressing pro-oxidant TLR2- and TLR4-mediated signaling cascades in the inflammatory phenotypes of ovarian cancer and coronary artery disease
[175][146]. Moreover, TLR4 is commonly associated with the oxidative stress-sensitive NK-κB pathway and the triggering of inflammation. Therefore, in the context of COVID-19, the potential involvement of melatonin in the control of hyper-inflammation through the genetic and/or mechanistic inhibition of certain pro-oxidant TLRs is extremely consistent, as reported in some viral processes. Following these precedents and regarding COVID-19 moderation, in silico-based force-fields, the modeling of putative SARS-CoV-2 mRNA-TLR binding interactions has shed light on the probable activation of the TLR-dependent downstream inflammatory pathway by several mRNAs of SARS-CoV-2
[177][149], opening the way to melatonin intervention.
Melatonin also has the ability to prevent the activation of NLRP3 inflammasome in respiratory disease and other disturbances. This is the case of acute lung injuries such as sepsis or pneumonia, in which melatonin has been reported to reduce lung inflammation by selectively inhibiting the assembly of the NLRP3 inflammasome
[178,179][150][151]. Excessive inflammation is a clue factor in the negative evolution of COVID-19 and other viral infections. Accordingly, it would make perfect sense that the NLRP3 complex directly or indirectly drives the hyper-inflammatory cascade associated with the explosive cytokine storm syndrome, as a large body of recent evidence points out
[180][152]. Melatonin directly targets NLRP3 and precludes the activation of the inflammasome complex, enabling it to modulate inflammation. Therefore, it seems reasonable to launch the clinical trials with supplemental melatonin in the acute interval of ARDS, the height of hyper-inflammation of COVID-19, as recently proposed
[25,31][25][31]. Nevertheless, direct experimentation is required on this matter to screen the auxiliary treatment of COVID-19 by the interference of inflammasome activation and open the alternative intervention routes and treatment schedules that are so urgently needed.
In addition to the above findings, a hypothetical method that adds to the therapeutic possibilities of melatonin to moderate the inappropriate inflammatory response of COVID-19 is the control of Nuclear Factor (erythroid-derived 2)-like 2 (NRf2), a pivotal regulator of antioxidant responses that induce phase-II antioxidant enzymes
[29]. Nrf2 is in a close mechanistic relationship with sirtuin 1 and NK-κB, whose close coordination in the protection from acute lung disease and acute respiratory distress syndrome has been raised as possible
[181][153]. On a related topic, an association is observed between the cytokine release syndrome and the elevation of the gene expression modulator miR155, which also appears to be raised in the high-risk comorbidities of SARS-CoV-2
[106][76]. miR155 sustains the upregulation of cytokines in immunocytes and, in this regard, the demonstrated ability of melatonin to drop its levels
[182][154] highlights the potential of this indoleamine in improving the clinical expression of COVID-19. Furthermore, the close relationship between melatonin and miR155 in different cell types is an additional indication that melatonin can be more efficient in the control of this transcriptional regulator than specific miR155-targeted drugs
[106][76]. These studies provide strong support that exogenous and/or endogenous melatonin acts on inflammatory cascades and may correct the pro- vs. anti-inflammatory inputs in the course of mitigating hyper-inflammation. There is therefore enough evidence to take very seriously the adequacy of the functional biology of melatonin to the pathophysiology of COVID-19.
In parallel with activation of phagocytes and intracellular PRR/TLR pathways of innate immunity, melatonin cross-activates proliferation and the maturation of natural killer cells as well as T and B lymphocytes in the bone marrow and peripheral tissues
[166][137]. These actions could help to deploy the adaptive cell/humoral immune response through specific antibodies fitted to the idiosyncrasy of SARS-CoV-2 and improve the detrimental outcome of COVID-19 patients. A proof-of-concept of the immune–endocrine axis and the role of melatonin in bidirectional communications is the production of melatonin in immune cells
[183][155] and the association of inflammatory tone with nocturnal melatonin depletion
[184][156]. The reinforcement of T-cells is relevant to the role attributed to melatonin against COVID-19 because in many asymptomatic patients or with mild symptoms, a low level of humoral antiviral response has been detected and, in contrast, a strong response mediated by T lymphocytes
[45].
Melatonin has also revealed beneficial for shielding oxidative stress and inflammation generated by an excess of reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS) in acute lung parenchyma injury and ARDS, as well as in the respiratory stress and delirium arising from intubation and assisted ventilation of patients under intensive care
[185][157]. Particularly, circulating IL-6, the central milestone of the cytokine storm, is an independent predictor of lung injury and the severity of pneumonia in COVID-19 patients
[158][129]. Critical COVID-19 patients present advanced inflammation, dyspnea, severe septic hypoxemia, and pneumonia that reduce breathing and respiratory efficiency and lead patients to long periods of intensive care and eventually intubation. The high pressure of oxygen in forced mechanical ventilation conditions produces oxidative stress and an epithelial–mesenchymal transition leading to fibrosis, thus making very plausible the role that melatonin could play in the management of this clinical phenotype. In addition, melatonin protects alveolar surfactant from peroxidation by infiltrating neutrophils, thus preventing the obliteration of pulmonary ways
[186][158] and thereby improving the gas exchange in seriously diseased COVID-19 patients.
4.6. Mitochondrial Disruption Aggravating COVID-19
2.6. Mitochondrial Disruption Aggravating COVID-19
Mitochondrial dysfunction, such as depletion of energy generation (OXPHOS deficiency), RONS overproduction, or inhibition of membrane potential (membrane leakage), among others, is increasingly associated with the molecular pathogenesis of a growing number of diseases, including those neural, muscle, and endocrinopathies severely incapacitating and specifically denominated “mitochondrial disorders”
[187][159]. Many viral infections may affect mitochondrial architecture and dynamics and interfere, either inducing or inhibiting their important spectrum of biochemical functions
[188,189][160][161]. However, regarding COVID-19 pathogenesis, mitochondria have not focused enough interest, in spite of the fact that perturbation of this integrative center of energy and metabolism hinders an adequate host–pathogen defense
[190][162]. It must be taken into account that immune response has a strong demand for biosynthetic and mitotic activities, which are strongly dependent on energy produced by mitochondria. In connection with immune interference, acute COVID-19 patients present subsets of dysfunctional T-cells with dysmorphic mitochondria exhibiting altered ultrastructure and cytochrome c release
[191][163]. In agreement with this rule, recent studies of the global SARS-CoV-2 interactome map reported high-confidence protein–protein interactions that demonstrated the putative targeting of host mitochondria proteins by viral components
[192[164][165],
193], including the innate immune system. Similarly, computational machine learning models have predicted the preferential enrichment of genomic SARS-CoV-2 RNA in the mitochondrial matrix and nucleolus of the host
[194][166]. Overall, SARS-CoV-2 may target mitochondria and disrupt their internal organization and functionality
[195][167], so energy failure and increased RONS generation in the suboptimal stressed mitochondria determine the hyper-inflammation that aggravates the COVID-19 outcome
[196][168]. With regard to this, the analysis of public transcriptome datasets has led to finding a transcriptional signature induced by SARS-CoV-2 that includes the induction of OXPHOS genes
[197][169]. Analogously, transcriptome profiling of human lung cancer cells infected with SARS-CoV-2, influenza A virus, or MERS-CoV (subsequently validated on human nasopharyngeal specimens positive for COVID-19 and their control counterparts) revealed that SARS-CoV-2 can specifically disrupt inflammatory responses and mitophagy/autophagy machinery, as well as deregulate a myriad of genes linked to inflammation and cytokine signaling, cell cycle, RONS balance, mitochondrial organization, and translation
[198][170]. These proof-of-concept studies demonstrate that “mitochondrial hijacking” to hinder the innate immune mechanisms and favor self-destructive hyper-inflammation and sepsis is strategic for viral infection
[190][162]. Furthermore, the worse outcome and death risk of COVID-19 in males
[199][171] has been related, among other unanswered hypotheses, to the sexual hormone-dependent dimorphism of mitochondria
[200][172] and to sex-linked differences in immune response due to their matrilineal inheritance
[201][173]. Of note, the apparent superiority in stress resilience of maternal mitochondria has been related to their greater performance in the production of melatonin
[166][137].
Viruses evolved strategies to hijack mitochondrial machinery and evade the recognition by the viral sensor (RIG-I)-like receptors (RLRs). Once entering the cell, key intracellular receptors housed in the mitochondrial outer membrane named MAVS signalosome
[202][174] usually recognize viral antigens and activate the defense system to restrain microbe invasion. In the case of SARS-CoV-2, it has been hypothesized that viral protein ORF9b would suppress MAVS downstream signaling (through Tumor necrosis actor Receptor-Associated Factor (TRAF)3 and TRAF6) and thereby the innate immunity and the related release of interferons could lose robustness
[190][162]. In accordance with this prediction, it has been recently demonstrated that ORF9b from SARS-CoV-2 colocalizes on mitochondria and interacts with TOM70 protein in the outer membrane to suppresses IFN-I responses
[203][175], and ORF9c interacts with complex I of the respiratory chain
[204][176]. ORF9b may promote virus replication by inhibiting the apoptotic destruction of infected cells and by supporting their survival and viability through induction of mitochondrial elongation and fusion. In short, ORF9b disarticulates mitochondrial processes, such as mitophagy, which increases the oxidative stress, allowing inflammation and the mitochondrial complement to be kept fully functional
[195][167]. Moreover, the hijacking of mitochondria deteriorates their structure, increases their permeability and the release of mitochondrial materials to the cytosol, and contributes to inflammation. In addition, SARS-CoV-2 depends on mitochondria (as well as endoplasmic reticulum and Golgi apparatus) to ambush itself, assemble the membrane-associated replication complexes, and put the genetic and biochemical machinery of the organelle at the service of its own replicative and immune escape requirements
[194][166].
Recent findings have shown that melatonin is abundant and may be enzymatically synthesized in mitochondria
[205,206,207][177][178][179]. Moreover, cellular and mitochondrial membranes are embedding melatonin transporters that allow bidirectional mobilization and concentration of the indoleamine
[208][180]. Therefore, mitochondria can take extracellular melatonin when circulating or cerebrospinal fluid levels rise above normal
[209][181]. All this evidence points out that this “second pool” of the indoleamine
[165][136] is abundant because high levels are needed for the homeostasis of mitochondria. SARS-CoV-2 can dramatically manipulate the mitochondrial biochemistry, shifting their energy profile from OXPHOS to an abnormal preponderance of aerobic glycolysis (“Warburg effect”). This change maximizes ATP production and provides immune cells with energy and resources to sustain their intense phagocytic activity and massive release of cytokines
[210][182]. In this regard, night-time pineal melatonin is active, resetting the immune system and strengthening defense responses through OXPHOS optimization
[210][182]. Therefore, the exogenous melatonin should revert the preponderance of cytosolic glycolysis induced by SARS-CoV-2 and promote the switching to OXPHOS. Supplemental melatonin may improve mitochondrial metabolism and provide the acetyl-CoA for the in situ synthesis of the indoleamine
[146][117]. Consequently, targeting glycolysis and resetting the energy metabolism of mitochondria to healthy interval exogenous melatonin may help to reverse the impact of SARS-CoV-2, especially the cytokine storm syndromes and ulterior devastating immune–inflammatory exacerbation. In this manner, the most severely detrimental COVID-19 symptomatology would be relieved
[146][117].
Mitochondria are active sources of melatonin and also producers of large amounts of RONS and other free radicals. Nevertheless, melatonin preserves the homeostasis of mitochondrial structure and functionality thanks to its competence in scavenging RONS excess (melatonin binds up to 10 free radicals per molecule;
[211][183]), which protects them from apoptosis and enhances their anti-oxidative systems
[143][114]. Viral respiratory processes heal with hyper-production of free radicals and nitro-oxidative stress, leading to inflammation and tissue damage
[212][184], hence the interest in the direct and indirect scavenging activity of melatonin as well as in the therapeutic relevance of its anti-inflammatory properties
[213][185]. RONS are microbiocidal in origin and therefore are buffered by mitochondrial antioxidant systems into the physiological range
[214][186]. Conversely, RONS excess produces chemical insults on cell macromolecules and induces the highly inflammatory mitochondrial lytic pyroptosis. In this regard, the ability of melatonin to quench the overload of RONS and mitigate nitro-oxidative stress is another reason to be confident in its therapeutic potential against the COVID-19 pandemic, as repeatedly postulated
[31], since the protection deployed on mitochondrial membrane potential, RONS homeostasis, and energy metabolism is effective to orchestrate an innate immune response in the intensity range more lethal for SARS-CoV-2.
Dysregulation of ion trafficking across mitochondrial channels is a major cause of pathophysiology, as occurs with iron in COVID-19 in which a clear correlation between serum hyperferritinemia and disease severity as well as between ferritin blood load and circulating IL-6 cytokine have been reported
[57,215][96][187]. At this point, the action of melatonin in moderating cytokine secretion, preventing oxidative stress, and reducing the hyperferritinemia associated with hemodialyzed patients under inflammation
[216][188] supports the dual proactive role of melatonin in COVID-19 as an anti-inflammatory and regulator of iron overload.
Given the short history of SARS-CoV-2 in science, many important details of its biology remain unknown. Soon, these lags will be elucidated, and new approaches to reducing infectivity, neutralizing tropism, cancelling spread-out, and overcoming the health issue of COVID-19 will be available. The natural history of COVID-19 is still being written, but an undoubted fact emerges from the chapters already known: SARS-CoV-2 enhances self-replication, impairing mitochondrial biosystems until defective autophagy and mitophagy, the deterioration of proteostasis, the depletion of OXPHOS in favor of anaerobic glycolysis, the overproduction of RONS, and the subsequent nitro-oxidative stress. All these impairments ultimately damage peripheral target organs such as the lungs, gut, or brain
[217][189] and eventually lead to death. This central role played by mitochondria makes them strategic in the infective cycle of SARS-CoV-2 and therefore putting their biochemical capacities into play is one of the best options to treat COVID-19. Regarding this, mitochondria are active factories of melatonin production and one of the main operational centers of the indoleamine. In view of this, it seems clear that this molecule is a leading actor in the orchestration of immune, metabolic, oxidative, and inflammatory responses driven and coordinated by mitochondria.
4.7. Melatonin in Adjuvant Therapy Combination Against SARS-CoV-2 Infection
2.7. Melatonin in Adjuvant Therapy Combination Against SARS-CoV-2 Infection
Evidence in the melatonin field has suggested its use as a combination treatment with the possibility of enhancing the therapeutic activity of different drugs and/or reducing the possible side effects when they are administered, which would suggest interesting beneficial perspectives. Additionally, melatonin has vasodilation effects on pulmonary arteries based on its antioxidant and anti-inflammatory capacities, and this vasoactive potential is another favorable support for adjuvant prescription of indoleamine to pandemic-affected individuals
[218][190]. In this sense, adjuvant melatonin administration in combination with the current low-efficacy standard antiviral treatments promotes important improvements in symptomatology, clinical outcome, and support requirements of COVID-19 patients
[113[83][191],
219], in part because different molecules have different targets and mechanisms of action. Thus, melatonin can reconcile the need for delivering mechanical respiratory support in some acute COVID-19 patients and the damage inherent in forced ventilation. In accordance with its affordability and expected accuracy, much scientific press is echoing the formidable therapeutic and/or prophylactic expectations of adjuvant melatonin for the treatment of COVID-19 patients, alone or in synergistic combination with other natural products that share its nuclear receptor and signaling profile, such as vitamin D
[220][192]. More recently, it has been suggested that the supplementation of vitamin D, zinc, melatonin, and possibly additional nutraceuticals could reduce the risk and aid control of COVID-19 and a range of other viral infections
[221][193]. Therefore, in the context of “antioxidant therapy”, a cocktail with antioxidant supplements such as vitamins C and E,
N-acetylcysteine, and melatonin in combination with the hemorrheologic agent pentoxifylline could contribute to the mitigation of the aggressive and lethal development COVID-19
[222][194]. Likewise, given the rich evidence that this extensive literature compiles and the international prestige of some of the personalities that bona fide endorse this clinical strategy, it is difficult for us to find resounding words and a new convincing voice to persuade public health dealers and professionals about the urgency of undertaking standardized clinical trials. Additionally, melatonin upregulates B-cell proliferation and therefore potentiates refined humoral immune responses
[166][137] and modulates positively the innate and adaptive immunities as a vaccine adjuvant
[223][195]. Noticeably, the immunomodulatory action as adjuvant of melatonin may enhance the effectivity of vaccination in immunocompromised individuals, such as aged people and patients with comorbidities, who are at great risk of lethal COVID-19. Specifically, melatonin pre-treatment can increase the intensity and temporal coverage of the immune response, enhancing natural killer and CD4
+ cells in addition to reducing the side effects of vaccination
[23,32][23][32]. Melatonin has also been documented targeting the activity of CD147, which takes part in the cytokine storm that causes inflammatory injury in the lung
[101][71]. In this context, and considering the involvement of CD147 S glycoprotein in RONS production and inflammatory responses, supplemental melatonin has been proposed as a possible adjuvant to ameliorate the COVID-19 symptomatology and the side-effects associated with the current repurposed therapeutics, especially among frail, elderly, and immune-compromised patients
[104][74]. Furthermore, using a systems biology and artificial-intelligence-based approach to reducing the severe pulmonary complications caused by SARS-CoV-2, the combined action mechanism of melatonin and pirfenidone predicted that they may modulate the high levels of proinflammatory chemokines and cytokines, improving the pathophysiology of COVID-19 patients
[224,225][196][197]. In this same line, using a network-based methodology for systematic identification of putative repurposable drugs was identified as a combination of mercaptopurine plus melatonin, which may synergistically inhibit multiple cellular targets in the infectious process of SARS-CoV-2
[24].
Consequently, in the pressing context created by the COVID-19, we herein propose that melatonin upregulation or its adjuvant administration with current repurposed pharmacological prescriptions can be pivotal to achieving more effective treatments to curb the current spread of disease and improve the clinical management of patients. As other authors have emphasized, in the worst scenario, “melatonin is not yet guaranteed as an effective treatment, it likely would be useful and is unlikely to do any harm”
[165][136], and we will have nothing to regret. On the contrary, in the probable case that it provides part of therapeutic expectations demonstrated in other pathological scenarios, the contribution of ancient melatonin to global public health in this dramatic sanitary alert will be historical.
This preliminary evidence points out the prophylactic and/or supportive therapeutic potential of adjuvant melatonin in respiratory and non-respiratory complications of COVID-19. Specifically, self-limitation or abrogation of the local and systemic inflammatory mechanisms account for the multiply reported benefits of melatonin in respiratory disorders with pulmonary involvement
[226][198], and it could be analogously assumed against the lung damage in COVID-19 patients. The initial backgrounds, therefore, highlight the rationale for undertaking with no delay observational studies of large-scale cohorts, as well as randomized clinical trials, to validate the clinical effectivity of the indoleamine in reducing symptoms and/or its prophylactic utility
[25,29][25][29]. In the absence of effective drugs against SARS-CoV-2 and palliative therapies for COVID-19 and taking into consideration the difficulties encountered by vaccination against previous viral processes
[18], it is time to implement other therapy options. In this regard, the combination of current treatment protocols with multitasking melatonin may be the gold standard that humanity imperatively needs to fight COVID-19 and that science is desperately searching for.
The therapeutic potential of melatonin to fight COVID-19 is very wide, as we have depicted along point 4. To summarize the properties, we elaborate in
Table 2.
Table 2.
Melatonin potential effects against COVID-19 disease.
COVID-19 Actions |
Melatonin Potential Properties |
Sleep and circadian rhythms dysregulation. Melatonin deficiency = higher risk |
-
Resynchronization of circadian disruption [10,87,91][10][57][61].
|
Refractory hypoxemia and myocardial injury. Thrombotic events and inflammatory injury in the lung and heart failure. |
-
Binds viral protease Mpro [27].
-
Exerts anti-PAK1 activity [114][84].
|
Low-grade basal inflammation, weakening of immune and antioxidant defenses, and metabolic syndrome abnormalities are predisposing conditions to COVID-19 aggravation. |
-
Controls the innate and adaptive immunity [140][111] and inflammation [141][112].
-
Regulates neuroimmune–endocrine system [142][113].
-
Reduces oxidative stress and contributes to preventing hyper-inflammation and innate immune exacerbation [143,144,145][114][115][116].
|
Obesity, cardiac disorders, and type 2 diabetes increase mortality. |
-
Melatonin-related signaling pathways have an extensive influence on glucose homeostasis and energy metabolism [147][118].
-
|
Life-threatening immune–inflammatory cycle. |
|
Mitochondrial disruption. |
-
May improve mitochondrial metabolism and reset energy metabolism [31,146,210][31][117][182]
|