Vitamin E: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Francesca Gamna and Version 2 by Lily Guo.

Vitamin E is a common compound used for tocopherols and tocotrienols (α, β, γ, δ); it is the component of many natural products of both plant and animal origin. 

  • vitamin E
  • biomaterials
  • biomedical applications

1. Introduction

1.1. Structure of Vitamin E

Vitamin E was first discovered and described by Evans and Bishop in 1922; it includes eight natural forms (α, β, γ, δ; tocopherols and tocotrienols), and it can be found in various products bearing fats of both vegetable and animal origin, such as in olive or almond oil, hazelnuts, and egg yolk, and in the liver. Basically, tocopherols and tocotrienols have the same chemical structure, characterized by a 16-carbon lateral chain attached to position 2 of a benzopyran ring. The two isoforms differ substantially from the saturation of the long radical chain: tocopherols have a fully saturated chain, while tocotrienols have an unsaturated chain. As Figure 1 explains, the two homologs were named according to the position and number of the methyl group bound to the phenolic ring [1][2][3][1,2,3].
Figure 1.
Structure of tocotrienol and tocopherol.
Among all the isoforms of vitamin E, α-tocopherol is the most abundant in the blood, because it is the only one that is absorbed within the body, while the other isoforms are excreted through the intestine. The liver, which takes up nutrients after they are absorbed by the small intestine, absorbs vitamin E thanks to the plasmatic lipoproteins that function as carriers. Among all the various forms of the vitamin E, alpha-tocopherol is re-secreted through the liver protein of α-tocopherol transfer (α-TTP) and distributed to circulating lipoproteins (LDL, IDL, VLDL). The other forms are metabolized and then expelled through the intestine (Figure 2) [4].
Figure 2.
Vitamin E metabolism.

1.2. Biological Role of Vitamin E

Alpha-tocopherol is a phenolic antioxidant. The scavenging mechanism involves the donation of hydrogen from the hydroxyl group (-OH) of the phenolic ring to free radicals (ROS). In this way, the free radicals become unreactive and unable to do any more damage. After this reaction, also the phenolic compound itself becomes relatively unreactive with a higher stability. Its stability is guaranteed by the now unpaired electron which is on the oxygen atom and which is delocalized in the structure of the aromatic ring. α-tocopherol is located within the phospholipid membrane of the cell, and it occurs with the radical chain embedded in the hydrophobic core of the double layer [5]. Its concentration, compared to the lipids present in the membrane, is very low, but in spite of this, it plays an important role in preserving the integrity of the membrane by preventing lipid peroxidation which causes damage of cellular membranes, lipoproteins, and other molecules that contain lipids, in conditions of oxidative stress [1][6][7][1,6,7].
Oxidative stress is a pathological condition caused by the imbalance between the generation and elimination of chemical oxidant species (ROS), and it is involved in several neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s disease that are implicated in free radical processes and oxidative damage [8]. That said, it is easy to think of vitamin E that, thanks to its important qualities as an antioxidant, may have an important role in the integrity of the brain. To confirm this, a high level of α-TTP was found in the brain [9].
Vitamin E is an important anti-inflammatory molecule since it acts on many different factors that affect, directly or indirectly, the immune system. Vitamin E is able to modulate inflammation through different ways: it has effect on proinflammatory enzymes such as COX, responsible for prostaglandins (PG)E2 production [10][11][10,11]; (PG)E2 is a proinflammatory mediator that has been associated with several senility-related diseases such as cancer, arthritis, and cardiovascular diseases [4][7][12][4,7,12]). It modulates the proliferation and activation of certain cells of the immune system such as T cells, lymphocytes, and NK cells [13]. Finally, it acts on the secretion of proinflammatory cytokines such as IL-6 and TNF-α. Thanks to these factors, vitamin E plays an important role in helping to prevent chronic inflammation [11][13][11,13]. Chronic inflammation is strictly linked to oxidative stress [14] and, together with it, it is the main cause of age-related disease and cancer [11].
Vitamin E has also an important role in the inhibition of platelet aggregation, inhibiting various enzymes such as PKC, which is a key signal transduction pathway in several cell types [1][15][1,15]. α-tocopherol, thanks to its free-radical scavenging and anti-inflammatory properties, has a benefit also in dermatology: it protects the skin from UV radiation, and accelerates the wound healing process after an injury such as ulcers or burns [16]. Inflammation could be associated also to a large number of different phenomena related to bone health: it is thought that thanks to its anti-inflammatory action and regulation of cytokine secretion, vitamin E can influence bone remodelling, being able to protect the bone against osteoclastic activity, increasing osteoblasts differentiation, and protecting cartilage health [17][18][19][17,18,19]. In addition, recent studies have shown that vitamin E also has biomechanical effects, being able to increase specific characteristics such as load and yield [20]. Together with all these considerations, vitamin E, due to its antioxidant function, role in anti-inflammatory processes, inhibition of platelet aggregation, and immune system-enhancing activity [1][9][1,9], brings a wide range of benefits, from anti-cancer effects [21] to the prevention of disease progression, and in improving quality of life in the elderly [22]. The figure below (Figure 3) shows a schematic representation of the biological role of vitamin E.
Figure 3.
Biological role of vitamin E.
More controversial and still under study, is the anti-bacterial role of vitamin E. In the literature, it is possible to find vitamin E used as a natural compound to treat infections caused by specific Gram-positive or negative bacteria [23][24][23,24] or as an antibiotic adjuvant used in combination with antibiotics for the treatment of infections [25][26][25,26]. Moreover, the addition of vitamin E to materials may have the ability to reduce biofilm formation on the surface. As the literature suggests, it is possible to believe that tocopherol is able to reduce the biofilm formation capacity of a big range of strains (S. aureus and S. epidermidis, etc.), regardless of the classification of the bacterium (Gram-negative or -positive) [27]. This, however, comes into opposition with other studies that show instead that vitamin E, in composition with other materials, did not reduce biofilm formation [28].
Once the biological role of vitamin E is understood, it is certainly interesting to analyse its application and detection methods, when it is combined to a biomaterial. Over the past 20 years, there has been a strong increase in interest in scientific research on α-tocopherol combined with various biomaterials (Figure 4). This review selected about 100 reviews best suited to the topic discussed.
Figure 4.
Studies inherent to α-tocopherol combined with biomaterials over the years.

2. Methods to Detect and Quantify Vitamin E within Materials

Vitamin E can be easily detected in different liquid media, such as in oils, serum, human milk, foods, etc., by different methods including HPLC, FTIR, RAMAN, UV-VIS, and spectrophotometric methods. Recently, some protocols were also developed for the analysis of vitamin E incorporated into cosmetics and food packaging and contained in food [29][30][31][32][33][34][84,85,86,87,88,89].
The first method usually used to allow a simple and rapid quantitative determination of α-tocopherol is High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC). In fact, HPLC is one of the most powerful tools for the determination of fat-soluble vitamins and has been widely used for their separation and detection; different detectors can be used for vitamins such as UV-VIS, fluorescence, and mass spectrometry. In the case of vitamin E, typically the HPLC column is connected to an UV absorbance detector as the compound absorbs the ultraviolet light, particularly around 290 nm. This method is, in fact, used not only to analyse quantitatively the content of alpha-tocopherol in food or beverages, but also in cosmetics and in biological samples including human plasma and human milk [31][34][35][36][37][86,89,90,91,92]. Another way to detect and quantify α-tocopherol is the Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR). Sandra et al. developed a quick procedure for the quantitative analysis of α-tocopherol in vegetable oils as an alternative to HPLC methods, using FTIR-ATR methodology. By analysing 13 vegetable oils, with a known content of vitamin E, a research team created a calibration curve which was then used to measure the alpha-tocopherol content of the vegetable oil concerned quantitatively [38][93].
For qualitative measurements, FTIR was also used for detecting the functional groups of a hydrophobic film of vitamin E deposited on a copper substrate [39][94]. Thanks to its clear absorbance peak at 290 nm, visible ultraviolet spectroscopy (UV-Vis) proved to be able to detect the presence of vitamin E even at low concentrations [40][41][95,96].
Along with FTIR, RAMAN is a potential alternative method to have qualitative detection of the molecule. It is used to detect vitamin E in oil water emulsions and in biological samples [42][43][97,98]. Surface-enhanced Raman spectroscopy (SERS) technology is of a high level of interest: it exploits the amplification of Raman diffusion by molecules adsorbed on a metal or on metallic nanoparticles [44][45][99,100]. Typically, most SERS techniques use metal aqueous colloids as a substrate, which require that compounds to be analysed must be water soluble. For water insoluble analytes, such as vitamin E, the matter is more complicated. Given the disadvantage of using colloidal Ag nanoparticles to measure SERS of the analyte directly, Tiantian Cai et al. have successfully tried other methods to analyse vitamin E: after dissolving the compound in chloroform, the solution obtained is dripped onto the surface of a metal substrate with surface Raman activity. Another method could be to immerse the metal substrate in the sample solution containing vitamin E directly, to extract it after a certain time, and to measure it at RAMAN after the solvent has evaporated [46][101].
Thanks to its antioxidant properties, vitamin E can also be analysed and quantified through all those methods that exploit chemical reactions, typically redox, to develop coloured compounds that are then measured spectrophotometrically. In general, spectrophotometric methods for vitamin E determination use oxidation of the aromatic ring of α-tocopherol, creating tocopherylquinone, by oxidizing agents that ultimately yield products with spectrophotometric staining. Among these methods, there is definitely the DPPH method, which uses a free radical of purple colour, which discolours when it reacts with vitamin E. Valeria M. et al. have used the DPPH method to compare the antioxidant power of drugs containing alpha-tocopherol. The problem of the DPPH method is its low reproducibility due to the low stability of the radical [47][102].
Another such methodology is the Folin–Ciocâlteu (FC) reagent in an aqueous solution. In this case, however, given the insolubility of vitamin E in water, this methodology is not the optimal one. However, modifications have been made to the FC method to enable the measurement of lipophilic and hydrophilic antioxidants concentrations simultaneously [48][103].
Albeit less used and dated, there are many other methods using different oxidizing reagents such as Fe(III)-bathophenanthroline, Cu(II)-neocuproine, or silver nitrate, but they require a rigid control of the conditions for precise results [49][104]. Another method is the Emmerie and Engel colour reaction with ferric chloride: it is a precise and easy-to-perform reaction, and therefore the approach of choice for a routine clinical laboratory [50][105]. Based on this work, more recently, Jameel G. Jargar et al. took advantage of different reagents such as 2,2′-bipyridyl, ferric chloride, and xylene to perform the colour reaction [51][106].
Finally, although a very old and no longer used method, nitric acid combined with ethanol was used to oxidise α-tocopherol, forming the coloured red o-quinone which can be detected spectrophotometrically (Figure 56) [52][107].
Figure 56.
Formation of Tocored with Nitric Acid.
Thanks to the vitamin E detection methods employed in various applications involving cosmetics, food packaging, and so on, it is possible to apply the above methods to the biomedical field for the detection of vitamin E when combined with different biomaterials.
Certainly, it is easy to find detection methods in the literature when vitamin E is combined with UHWMPE, as it is the most widely applied biomaterial coupled with vitamin E today.
For quantification methods, with HPLC analysis, it is convenient to quantify the vitamin E content within UHMWPE using a calibration curve produced from the areas of the HPLC peaks [53][108]. Instead, Hufen Julia et al. developed an accurate method to detect α-tocopherol content in UHWMPE using HPLC analysis to separate it and determine its concentration by UV-Vis spectroscopy with a corresponding calibration curve [54][109]. However, it is also possible to use only UV-VIS in absorbance mode combined with FTIR to quantify vitamin E within UHMWPE [55][110]. Vitamin E blended with polyethylene induces yellowing of the sample; Martínez-Morlanes et al. exploited this characteristic using the colorimetric technique and reflectance spectroscopy to detect vitamin E embedded in polyethylene samples quantitatively [56][111]. These types of methods, especially HPLC, are also used in drug delivery to calculate the drug encapsulation efficiency, resulting in the quantification of the vitamin E encapsulated within polymeric nanoparticles [57][58][59][62,64,65]. With the same object, in tissue engineering, HPLC is used to quantify vitamin E content inside the matrices or scaffolds [60][61][44,112].
For qualitative methods, since vitamin E is an extremely hydrophobic molecule, another important way to detect the presence of tocopherol on different substrates is definitely the measurement of the contact angle, the quickest test to evaluate a surface modification [62][113]. Filippo Renò et al. used the contact angle measurement on PLA blended with Vitamin E, and they discovered that the blend enriched with vitamin E was more easily wetted [63][64][48,49].
To get a more in-depth understanding of the chemical bonds between the substrate and the deposited molecule, the XPS technique is useful, as in the case of Elena Stoleru et al. who used XPS to have information about the stability of the chitosan/vitamin E coating deposited on a polyethylene substrate [62][113].
Once the characteristic peaks of vitamin E are known, the FTIR analysis is helpful, not only to detect vitamin E [65][42], but also to analyse the eventual shifts in wavenumber of the peaks that denote an interaction between tocopherol and the combined biomaterials. Ahmad Salawi et al. used the FTIR technique to analyse the interaction between a new copolymer called Soluplus and α-tocopherol for a wound-healing application [66][114], and Joana T. Martins et al. studied the physiochemical effect of the incorporation of α-tocopherol in chitosan-based films through a different analysis including FTIR [67][115].
In the biomedical field, the DPPH test is used to analyse the radical scavenging ability of vitamin E combined with biomaterials, as Elena Stoleru et al. did on a film electrosprayed with a chitosan/vitamin E formulation [62][113]. DPPH was used also by Zhou Nier et al. to test the antioxidant activity of Au nanoparticles functionalized with Trolox (hydrophilic analogue of alpha-tocopherol) [68][69][67,68]. The table (Table 14) reports the characterization methods used to detect vitamin E when combined with different biomaterials.
Table 14.
Method of Vitamin E detection when it is combined with biomaterials.
Technique Combined Material Molecule Detected Method Information Ref.
HPLC UHWMPE α-tocopherol HPLC connected to UV/Vis diode array detector at 297 nm, construction of calibration curve of HPLC peak area. Quantitative [53][108]
UHWMPE α-tocopherol HPLC connected to UV/Vis diode array detector, construction of calibration curve of absorbance peak area at 290 nm Quantitative [54][109]
Collagen mesh α-tocopherol HPLC connected to a fluorescence detector, detection at excitation wavelength of 290 nm and emission wavelength of 330 nm Quantitative [61][112]
Alginate and hyaluronate film α-tocopherol acetate HPLC connected to UV/Vis diode array detector, construction of calibration curve of absorbance peak area at 285 nm Quantitative [60][44]
Hyaluronic-acid-based β-cyclodextrin copolymer α-tocopherol HPLC connected to UV/Vis diode array detector Quantitative [58][64]
PNIPAM-b-PCL-b-PNIPAM copolymer α-tocopherol HPLC equipped with a differential refraction index detector Quantitative [59][65]
UV-VIS UHWMPE α-tocopherol Construction of calibration curve of absorbance peak area at 290 nm Quantitative [55][110]
UHWMPE α-tocopherol Analysis of reflectance spectra which presents a minimum around 290 nm and a decrease of reflectance at 400–500 nm. Detection [56][111]
Hyaluronic acid α-tocopherol succinate Construction of calibration curve of absorbance peak area at 285 nm Quantitative [70][116]
PLA+PCL α-tocopherol acetate Construction of calibration curve of absorbance peak area at 284 nm Quantitative [65][42]
Colorimetric Assay UHWMPE α-tocopherol The yellowing of the sample was analysed through three parameters (a,b,L) of CIELAB colour space, and a calibration curve of colour distances was constructed. Quantitative [56][111]
FTIR-ATR UHWMPE α-tocopherol Analysis of peaks.

For quantitative analysis, calibration curve of these peaks is needed.
Analysis of Vitamin E transformation products in polymer samples prior to extraction and quantitative. [53][108]
Collagen α-tocopherol Analysis of main peaks Characterization of film [71][45]
FTIR-ATR Magnetite α -tocopheryl succinate Analysis of main peaks Characterization of chemical modification of nanoparticles [72][71]
Chitosan α-tocopherol Analysis of peaks Physical bonds and chemical interactions are reflected by changes in characteristic spectral peaks. [67][115]
Chitosan α-tocopherol Analysis of peaks Characterization of nanoparticles [73][59]
PCL/PLA α-tocopherol acetate Analysis of peaks Characterization of membranes [65][42]
Soluplus α-tocopherol Analysis of peaks Analysis of bonding between Soluplus/vitamin E [66][114]
Polyethylene α-tocopherol Analysis of peaks from 600–4000 cm −1 Analysis of interaction between vitamin E and chitosan [62][113]
XPS Polyethylene α-tocopherol All binding energies were referenced to the C1s peak at 285 eV. Analysis of covalent bonding [62][113]
DPPH Polyethylene α-tocopherol The scavenging activity was estimated

RSA (%) =

(1 − (A sample/Acontrol)) × 100, measuring the adsorption at 515 nm after 30 min in dark condition.
Radical scavenging activity evaluation [62][113]
Chitosan α-tocopherol The scavenging activity was estimated

RSA (%) =

(1 − (A sample/Acontrol)) × 100, measuring the adsorption at 517 nm after 30 min in dark condition.
Radical scavenging activity evaluation [67][115]
Collagen/chitosan α-tocopherol DPPH were measured by the adsorption at 517 nm after 30 min in dark condition. DPPH loss which is a concentration of DPPH radicals reacted with antioxidants. Antioxidant activity [61][112]
Contact Angle Polyethylene α-tocopherol Contact angle titrations were performed by measuring sets of contact angles at each pH value. Analysis of hydrophobic behaviour as pH increases [51][106]
PLA α-tocopherol Static contact angle Analysis of material wettability change [63][64][48,49]