Passivhaus: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 3 by Nicole Yin and Version 6 by Vicky Zhou.

Passivhaus or Passive House buildings are low-energywell-insulated buildings in which the design is driven by quality and comfort, hence achievingthat achieve acceptable levels of comfort throughdelivered by post-heating or post-cooling of fresh air. Additionally, Passivhaus building design followss must adhere to the Passivhaus design criteria, as described in the Passive House Planning Package (PHPP). This article aims to iintroduces the Passivhaus background, development, and basic design principles. Finally, it also presents a brief description of the performance of Passivhaus buildings and the basics of its design criteria. 

  • Passivhaus
  • Low-energy buidlings
  • Energy-efficient buildings
A Passive House, or “Passivhaus”, which is the original German term, is: “[…] a building, for which thermal comfort (ISO 7730) can be achieved solely by post-heating or post-cooling of the fresh air mass, which is required to achieve sufficient indoor air quality conditions—without the need for additional recirculation of air

 1. Definition

Passive House, or ‘Passivhaus’, which is the original German term, is: “[…] a building, for which thermal comfort (ISO 7730) can be achieved solely by post-heating or post-cooling of the fresh air mass, which is required to achieve sufficient indoor air quality conditions – without the need for additional recirculation of air

[1].”

.”

2. Passivhaus Background

The Passivhaus method evolved from Swedish super-insulated homes and passive solar architecture, which seek to minimise space heating and to improve the thermal transmittance (U-values) of the building envelope (building fabrics, windows, and doors). These developments led advances in insulation, thermal bridging, airtightness and controlled ventilation, and the commercialisation of triple glazing windows

Passivhaus evolved from passive solar architecture and super-insulated homes developed in Sweden to reduce space heating and to improve the thermal transmittance (U-values) of building fabrics, windows and doors. This lead to the commercial development of triple glazing windows

[2].

, along with further developments in insulation, thermal bridging, airtightness and controlled ventilation.

The term “Passivhaus” was created from a research project in 1988 by Professor Wolfgang Feist from the Institute for Housing and Environment (Germany), Professor Bo Adamson from Lund University (Sweden), and

The ‘Passivhaus’ term was forged from a research idea generated in 1988 by Professor Bo Adamson from Lund University (Sweden) and Professor Wolfgang Feist from the Institute for Housing and Environment (Germany)

[3]. The first Passivhaus dwellings were built in Darmstadt (Germany) in 1990 as an outcome of their experiments and were followed by the establishment of the Passive House Institute (PHI) in 1996.

. In 1990, as a result of their early experiments, the first Passivhaus dwellings were built in Darmstadt, Germany, and later, in 1996, the Passive House Institute (PHI) was established.

The Passivhaus construction design method is founded on five essential principles: (i) super-insulation, (ii) thermal bridge-free construction, (iii) airtight building envelopes, (iv) mechanical ventilation systems with heat recovery (MVHR), and (v) high-performance doors and windows

The Passivhaus standard is based on five fundamental design principles — super-insulation, thermal bridge free construction, airtight building envelope, mechanical ventilation systems with heat recovery (MVHR), and high-performance doors and windows —, which should ensure the quality of the indoor environment, especially on the indoor air quality

[4]. The correct application of these principles should guarantee high levels of indoor environment comfort, especially indoor air quality. Finally, to reduce further the energy consumption, the use of energy-efficient electric appliances and lighting is critical to achieving the low-primary energy demand required. Table 1 presents the main criteria for Passivhaus certification. The complete design criteria are available in the Passive House Planning Package (PHPP)

. Energy-efficient electric appliances and lighting are necessary to achieve the low-primary energy demand required to obtain certification. The principal criteria for Passivhaus certification are presented in Table 1. Detailed design criteria are described in the Passive House Planning Package (PHPP) version 9

[5]—current version: version 9. During the certification process, a Passivhaus certification body verifies the PHPP analysis, construction record, and post-completion tests (blower door and ventilation rates). The different certification levels for Passivhaus buildings are EnerPHit for refurbishment projects, Passivhaus Plus for near-zero-energy buildings, Passivhaus Premium for positive energy buildings, and Passivhaus Classic for low-energy buildings.

. As part of the certification process, the PHPP analysis and post-completion tests (blower door and ventilation rates) are verified by a Passivhaus certification body. Passivhaus buildings can achieve different certification levels, EnerPHit for refurbishment projects, PassivHaus Plus for near-zero-energy buildings, PassivHaus Premium for positive energy buildings and PassivHaus Classic for low-energy buildings.

Table 1. Overview of the main Passivhaus certification criteria for Central European climates. Adapted from

Table 1. Overview of the principal PassivHaus certification criteria for Central European climates. Adapted from: 

[6].
Passivhaus Certification Criteria

(Residential)
Cool-Moderate Climate

(Central European)
Specific heating demand≤15kWh/(m2a)
OR specific heating load≤10W/m2
Specific cooling demand≤15kWh/(m2a) + 0.3 W/(m2aK). DDH
OR specific cooling load≤10W/m2
AND specific cooling demand≤4kWh/(m2a). σe + 2 · 0.3 W/(m2aK). DDH-75 kWh/(m2a)
Specific total primary energy demand≤120kWh/m2/a
Airtightness n50≤0.6h−1 (@50 Pa)
Overheating frequency10%Percentage of time with operative temperature above 25 °C
σe Annual mean external air temperature (°C); DDH refers to Dry Degree Hours.
In cold climates, heating load and heating demand are the most critical aspects to avoid the use of conventional heating systems, ensuring comfortable indoor environment levels

PassivHaus certification criteria (residential)

Cool-moderate climate (Central Europe)

Specific heating demand

≤ 15

kWh/(m²a)

OR Specific heating load

≤ 10

W/m²

Specific cooling demand

≤ 15

kWh/(m²a) + 0.3 W/(m²aK). DDH

OR Specific cooling load

≤ 10

W/m²

AND Specific cooling demand

≤ 4

kWh/(m²a) .σe + 2 • 0.3 W/(m²aK). DDH-75 kWh/(m²a)

Specific total primary energy demand

≤ 120

kWh/ m2/a

Airtightness n50

≤ 0.6

h-1 (@50Pa)

Overheating frequency

10%

Percentage of time with operative temperature above 25°C

DDH refers to Dry Degree Hours.

σe Annual mean external air temperature (°C).

In cooler climates, the most crucial factors are heating load and heating demand so that the building does not require conventional heating systems to maintain comfortable indoor environment levels

[7]. The Passivhaus design and calculations are set to provide the highest level of thermal comfort only by air heating. Comfortable indoor temperatures (indoor operative temperature ≤25 °C) are achieved and maintained without conventional heating through the supply-air heating load that should not exceed 10 W/m

. Indoor thermal comfort is the focus of Passivhaus design. The supply-air heating load should not exceed 10W/m

2. To achieve such levels of thermal comfort, the volumetric capacity of the system, supplied flow rates (30 m

so that a comfortable indoor climate (indoor operative temperature ≤25°C) can be maintained without conventional heating. Thus, thermal comfort is taken into account in line with the peak supply-air heating load, by considering the volumetric capacity of the system, supplied flow rates (30m3/h per person), indoor temperatures and treated floor area in the project[5]. Excellent indoor environment comfort is linked directly to energy efficiency as an incentive; the PassivHaus standard originated as an ultra-low-energy concept rather than to reduce CO2 emissions. By prioritising energy-efficient design, the Passivhaus standard addresses energy demand reduction and thermal comfort, unlike other low-carbon standards.

Passivhaus ventilation should remove the moisture when the infiltration air volume flow is insufficient to remove it[8] — this would require a total outdoor airflow of 5-10 l/s per person (equivalent to 18-36m

3/h per person), indoor temperatures, and treated floor area in the project are considered to calculate the peak supply-air heating load

/h per person or 0.3-0.6 air changes per hour)[9]. This airflow should guarantee that CO2 peaks levels should be no higher than 1,500ppm, as described in the DIN1946 German standard, the foundation for Passivhaus ventilation design.

Passivhaus was developed for buildings in Central European countries. However, it has become more popular, and examples are found beyond Europe. As of March 2018, the Passivhaus database[10] had registered 212 buildings outside of Europe, built predominantly in the US (92), Canada (42), New Zealand (22), Japan (21) and China (16).

3. Passivhaus design concept

3.1 Building form

Passivhaus buildings may have freedom in design, but their shape, size and orientation need to be planned carefully to minimise their on energy consumption. The ratio of the surface area of the building envelop to the volume (A/V ratio) of the building places a considerable load on heating and cooling demands, regardless of the thermal transmittance value (U-value) of the exterior of the building, also known as the building envelope[6]. Passivhaus buildings reduce energy consumption by avoiding energy losses in the way of heat or cooling through the building envelope. The more compact a Passivhaus building, the less energy it requires and the higher its A/V ratio, the greater potential for heat transfer. In simple words, small buildings have greater disadvantages, while larger buildings may have a lower A/V penalty for complex forms.

3.2 Super insulation

Passivhaus buildings use super-insulation to decrease heat transfer through the external ceiling, walls and flooring. Super-insulation is critical when the indoor and outdoor temperature differences are high, but as this difference reduces, it becomes slightly less necessary, as there is no need to maintain an indoor temperature different from outdoors[11]. An extensive range of thermal insulation is available to achieve typical U-values (0.10-0.15W/m2K) required for Passivhaus[12]. However, foam insulations should be avoided where possible, as they might compromise safety in terms of IAQ and fire[13]. External insulation in Passivhaus is typically between 20-40cm thick, and pipework and ductwork must be insulated as well, to avoid condensation and heat loss from the pipes.

3.3 Thermal bridge-free construction

A thermal bridge is a part of the building envelope that conducts heat between indoor and outdoor environments, causing internal condensation and dampness. Thermal bridges have the potential to become a source of unquantified thermal loss and contribute as much as 50% of the transmission heat in PassivHaus buildings[14] and condensation depending on the indoor air temperature, the surface temperature in walls or windows and air moisture content. Thermal bridges need to be modelled and assessed carefully at the design stage through virtual simulation, with software such as THERM. However, time can be saved by replicating any of the reference detail sources for PassivHaus, such as the IBO Book[15][16].

The most common types of thermal bridges are ‘constructional’, whereby a construction material penetrates the insulation. Other options include geometric thermal bridges, caused by the shape of the building (i.e. corners), point thermal bridges, caused by structural connections or insulation fixing, and linear thermal bridges, caused by a gap between the edges of two pieces of insulation or when one building material meets another[17].

3.4 High-performance doors and windows

High-performance doors and windows reduce, or even eliminate, the risk of condensation, mould growth and drafts while achieving acceptable thermal comfort. Passivhaus windows, including frames, are designed to make the most of solar gains warming up the building. They have two or three layers of glass, usually clear, which can be filled with different gases. The solar heat transfer that enters through a proportion of the window compared to the energy that reaches the window is known as G-value. A higher G-value means higher solar transmission. A suitable Passivhaus window has a higher U-value (<0.8W/m2K) than its walls (0.10-0.15W/m2K), so they should be used carefully. Passivhaus windows are usually limited to 0.8W/m2K

[5]. Thus, high levels of indoor environment comfort are linked directly to energy-efficient design as an incentive. Hence, the Passivhaus standard began as an ultra-low-energy concept rather than to reduce CO2 emissions. The Passivhaus standard addresses energy demand reduction and thermal comfort, unlike other low-carbon standards prioritising energy-efficient design. In Passivhaus buildings, moisture is removed through ventilation as the infiltration air volume flow is minimal due to high levels of airtightness and is hence insufficient to remove it

; however, this can change in warmer climates[18][19]. As with windows, doors must have a U-value of 0.8W/m2K and be airtight. Window sizing is an important issue, in PassivHaus dwellings windows tend to be small to reduce heat loss and solar gains. However, this has an impact on the opening size and ventilation that may lead to overheating[20].

Installation is as important as the characteristics of the windows and doors. A correctly installed window will avoid thermal bridge losses while improving the overall U-value by up to 50%. If they are positioned “within the insulation plane of the thermal envelope and that insulation overlaps the frame as far as possible, the thermal bridge loss coefficient of installation can be 0[7].” Passivhaus approved windows are the best way to optimise solar gains.

3.5 Airtightness

The building envelope should adhere to high levels of airtightness to avoid thermal losses through air infiltration. The most common uncontrolled air leakage occurs due to poorly installed doors, windows, services (pipes and ducts), suspended floors, ventilation systems, internal partitions, poorly designed construction systems, and small cracks and holes in the building envelope[21]. Air barriers that seal construction joints and penetration across the envelope are indispensable to achieve good airtightness[22].

The airtight barrier also works as a vapour control layer — usually in the warm side of the building —, to protect the insulation and building structure from interstitial warm air and moisture. An additional wind barrier layer — usually on the outside of the building fabric — helps to stop cold air entering the building. Both layers are a requirement and should be appropriately marked in the design. The on-site airtightness test (blower door test) measures total leakage through the building envelope. An under-pressure and over-pressure blower door test are part of the PassivHaus certification process. The airtightness result must achieve an n50 ≤0.6h-1 @50Pa[7]. The airtightness target is defined by the number of air changes per hour at a reference of ±50 Pascal, known as n50 test (see [23] for more details). As a consequence of the high airtightness achieved, air exchange is reduced around 27%  in Passivhaus buildings[24], making ventilation systems essential to ensure proper airflows.

3.6 Mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR) systems

The MVHR system’s primary purpose is to provide a continuous supply of fresh air while optimising occupant comfort by recovering heat from extracted air[7] thereby reducing energy losses in the way of heat or cool, as well as to protecting against outdoor air pollution[6]. Passivhaus air change rates should not exceed 30m3/h/person

[81]. In order to do this, outdoor airflow of 5–10 L/s per person (~0.3–0.6 air changes per hour or equivalent to 18–36 m

. Lower airflow rates may compromise the health and well-being of the occupants and higher may result in dry air. The supply air is delivered to the living areas — rooms where the occupants spend extended periods of time — and extracted from wet rooms — rooms where occupant activities may produce increased moisture or odours. The recommended extract airflow () rates from wet rooms are 60m3/h for kitchens, 40m3/h for bathrooms and 20m

3/h per person) is recommended

/h for other rooms. Passivhaus dwellings should also meet a minimum whole-house air change rate per hour (ach/h) of 0.3 guaranteeing:

      • Fresh air demand: 30m3/h x number of occupants.
      • Recommended minimum extract rate from wet rooms (kitchen + bathroom): 60m3/h + 40m3/h.
      • Minimum air change rate: 0.3ach/h x treated floor area x floor to ceiling height (maximum of 2.5m height).

3.7 Energy-efficient electric appliances and lighting

Once the heat and cooling demands are met, and efficient technologies for domestic hot water are implemented, electrical appliances are the most significant component of any final energy demand in dwellings. “It is a part of the Passive House philosophy that efficient technologies are also used to minimise the other sources of energy consumption in the building, notably electricity for household appliances[7].” Hot water connections for washing machines and dishwashers, airing cabinets, fluorescent lamps and LED bulbs are examples of techniques that may help to reduce energy consumption, without sacrificing comfort

[97]. Such levels of ventilation should guarantee that CO2 peak levels are not higher than 1500 ppm, as stated in the German standard (DIN1946). The Passivhaus ventilation design is based on the German standard (DIN1946). Passivhaus was developed for buildings in Central European countries. Nonetheless, it has expanded beyond Europe as it has gained popularity across the globe. As of March 2018, the Passivhaus database [1012] had recorded 212 buildings outside of Europe, built predominantly in the USA (92), Canada (42), New Zealand (22), Japan (21), and China (16). The Passivhaus standard is starting to gain popularity in warmer climates such as those found in Latin America. This article aims to define the Passivhaus background, design concept, and principles, as well as present an overview of the studies that have shaped the Passivhaus. Finally, it briefly presents the performance of Passivhaus buildings, although it is not intended as an exhaustive literature review.

.

References

  1. PHI. Passipedia: The Passive House Resourse, Basics. 2017. Available online: https://passipedia.org/basics (accessed on 23 March 2018).Basics . Passipedia: The Passive House Resource. Retrieved 2020-7-10
  2. Adamson, B. Towards Passive Houses in Cold Climates as in Sweden; Lund University: Lund, Sweden, 2011. B. Adamson, Towards Passive Houses in Cold Climates as in Sweden. Lund: Lund University, 2011.
  3. Wang, Y.; Kuckelkorn, J.; Zhao, F.-Y.; Spliethoff, H.; Lang, W. A state of art of review on interactions between energy performance and indoor environment quality in Passive House buildings. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2017, 72, 1303–1319. Yang Wang; Jens Kuckelkorn; Fu-Yun Zhao; Hartmut Spliethoff; Werner Lang; A state of art of review on interactions between energy performance and indoor environment quality in Passive House buildings. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2017, 72, 1303-1319, 10.1016/j.rser.2016.10.039.
  4. Rangel, A.M.; Sharpe, T.; McGill, G.; Musau, F. Indoor Air Quality in Passivhaus Dwellings: A Literature Review. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Heal. 2020, 17, 4749. Alejandro Moreno-Rangel; Tim Sharpe; Gráinne McGill; Filbert Musau; Indoor Air Quality in Passivhaus Dwellings: A Literature Review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2020, 17, 4749, 10.3390/ijerph17134749.
  5. Feist, W.; Bastian, Z.; Ebel, W.; Gollwitzer, E.; Grove-Smith, J.; Kah, O.; Kaufmann, B.; Krick, B.; Pfluger, R.; Schnieders, J.; et al. Passive House Planning Package Version 9, The Energy Balance and Design Tool for Efficent Buildings and Retrofits, 1st ed.; Passive House Institute: Darmstadt, Germany, 2015. W. Feist et al., Passive House Planning Package Version 9, The energy balance and design tool for efficient buildings and retrofits, 1st ed. Darmstadt, Germany: Passive House Institute, 2015
  6. Hopfe, C. The Passivhaus Designer’s Manual; Informa UK Limited: London, UK, 2015. C. J. Hopfe and R. S. McLeod. The PassivHaus designer’s manual: A technical guide to low and zero energy buildings; Routledge: London, 2015; pp. -.
  7. Schnieders, J.; Hermelink, A. CEPHEUS results: Measurements and occupants’ satisfaction provide evidence for Passive Houses being an option for sustainable building. Energy Policy 2006, 34, 151–171. Jürgen Schnieders; Andreas Hermelink; CEPHEUS results: measurements and occupants’ satisfaction provide evidence for Passive Houses being an option for sustainable building. Energy Policy 2006, 34, 154, 10.1016/j.enpol.2004.08.049.
  8. Guillén-Lambea, S.; Rodríguez-Soria, B.; Marín, J.M. Review of European ventilation strategies to meet the cooling and heating demands of nearly zero energy buildings (nZEB)/Passivhaus. Comparison with the USA. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 2016, 62, 561–574. Silvia Guillén-Lambea; Beatriz Rodríguez Soria; José M. Marín; Review of European ventilation strategies to meet the cooling and heating demands of nearly zero energy buildings (nZEB)/Passivhaus. Comparison with the USA. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 2016, 62, 561-574, 10.1016/j.rser.2016.05.021.
  9. Feist, W.; Schnieders, J.; Dorer, V.; Haas, A. Re-inventing air heating: Convenient and comfortable within the frame of the Passive House concept. Energy Build. 2005, 37, 1186–1203. Wolfgang Feist; Jürgen Schnieders; Viktor Dorer; Anne Haas; Re-inventing air heating: Convenient and comfortable within the frame of the Passive House concept. Energy and Buildings 2005, 37, 1186-1203, 10.1016/j.enbuild.2005.06.020.
  10. PHI. Passive House Database. 2014. Available online: http://www.passivhausprojekte.de/index.php?lang=en (accessed on 26 March 2018).Passive House Database . Passive House Database. Retrieved 2020-7-10
  11. M. Wassouf. De la casa pasiva al estándar Passivhaus, la arquitectura pasiva en climas cálidos.; Gustavo Gili: Spain, 2014; pp. -.
  12. J. Schnieders, “CEPHEUS – measurement results from more than 100 dwelling units in passive houses,” in ECEEE 2003 Summer Study, 2003, pp. 341–351.
  13. T. Woolley. Building materials, health and indoor air quality: No breathing space?; Routledge: Abingdon, 2017; pp. -.
  14. J. Schnieders, Passive Houses in South West Europe. A quantitative investigation of some passive and active space conditioning techniques for highly energy efficient dwellings in the South West European region, 2nd ed. Darmstadt: Passive House Institute, 2009.
  15. T. Waltjen, W. Georgii, K. Torghele, H. Mötzl, and T. Zelger. Passivhaus-Bauteilkatalog / Details for Passive Houses: Okologisch Bewertete Konstruktionen / A Catalogue of Ecologically Rated Constructions; Birkhauser: Basel, 2009; pp. -.
  16. IBO. Details for Passive Houses: Renovation : A Catalogue of Ecologically Rated Constructions for Renovation; Birkhauser: Basel, 2017; pp. -.
  17. J. Cotterel and A. Dadeby. The PassivHaus handbook: a practical guide to constructing and retrofitting buildings for ultra-low energy performance; Green Books: Cambridge, 2012; pp. -.
  18. PHI, Passive Houses for different climate zones, 1st ed. Darmstadt: Passive House Institute, 2011.
  19. Jürgen Schnieders; Wolfgang Feist; Ludwig Rongen; Passive Houses for different climate zones. Energy and Buildings 2015, 105, 71-87, 10.1016/j.enbuild.2015.07.032.
  20. Seyed Masoud Tabatabaei Sameni; Mark Gaterell; Azadeh Montazami; Abdullahi Ahmed; Overheating investigation in UK social housing flats built to the Passivhaus standard. Building and Environment 2015, 92, 222-235, 10.1016/j.buildenv.2015.03.030.
  21. NHBC Foundation, A practical guide to building airtight dwellings. 2009.
  22. M. H. Sherman and R. Chan, “Building Airtightness: Research and Practice,” 2004.
  23. Passivhaus primer: airtightness guide; airtightness and air pressure testing in accordance with the Passivhaus Standard . BRE Trust. Retrieved 2020-7-10
  24. Viorel Badescu; Benoit Sicre; Renewable energy for passive house heating. Energy and Buildings 2003, 35, 1077-1084, 10.1016/j.enbuild.2003.10.001.
More