Antibody-Mediated Alphavirus Immunity

Antibody-Mediated Alphavirus Immunity: Comparison

Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Lisa F.P. Ng and Version 2 by Peter Tang.

Alphaviruses are mosquito-borne pathogens distributed worldwide in tropical and temperate areas causing a wide range of symptoms ranging from inflammatory arthritis-like manifestations to the induction of encephalitis in humans. Historically, large outbreaks in susceptible populations have been recorded followed by the development of protective long-lasting antibody responses suggesting a potential advantageous role for a vaccine.

alphavirus
antibody
immunity
alphavirus vaccine

1. Introduction

Mosquito-borne alphaviruses are Group IV viruses that belong to the family Togaviridae [1]. They are enveloped, positive-sense, single-stranded RNA viruses with a size of ≈70 nm bearing a ≈11.7 kilobases genome which encodes four non-structural proteins (nsP1, nsP2, nsP3 and nsP4) that serve as the virus’ replication machinery, and five structural proteins (capsid, E3, E2, 6K and E1) that participate in the envelope assembly process [1]. Clinically, alphavirus infections in humans results in the development of viremia followed by an onset of febrile symptoms [2]. The development of inflammatory conditions compromising joints and muscle tissues has been associated to arthritogenic alphaviruses such as chikungunya virus (CHIKV), O’nyong nyong virus (ONNV), Mayaro virus (MAYV), Ross River virus (RRV), Semliki Forest virus (SFV) and Sindbis virus (SINV) with records of persistent polyarthralgia in a fraction of patients. Conversely, neurotropic alphaviruses such as Eastern Equine Encephalitis virus (EEEV), Western Equine Encephalitis virus (WEEV) and Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis virus (EEEV) have been linked to the induction of lethal encephalitis in humans and animals ^[3][4][3,4].

Historically, alphaviruses have a proven record of causing massive outbreaks in susceptible populations ^[5][6][7][8][5,6,7,8]. Additionally, the appearance of mutations favoring their ecological fit to new vectors has fueled alphavirus propagation worldwide ^[9][10][9,10]. A clear example of their potential as a health threat is the re-emergence of CHIKV in 2004 after a hiatus of more than 50 years since its discovery [5]. More recently, tropical emerging alphaviruses such as ONNV and MAYV are believed to have the potential to become future major epidemics ^[11][12][13][11,12,13]. This is due, in part, to the lack of robust diagnostic tests to differentiate alphavirus infections from other febrile tropical diseases and the absence of continuous epidemiological surveillance masking their real potential for spread beyond endemic areas ^[14][15][16][14,15,16].

Although alphavirus infections are generally not life threating the economic and social costs incurred during outbreaks are thought to be high ^[17][18][19][17,18,19]. Moreover, the lack of approved treatments leaves management of alphavirus infections to supportive care [20]. Interestingly, a body of work suggests that the alphavirus infection triggers potent humoral responses in exposed populations which seem to confer protection against re-infection [21]. Therefore, a better understanding of the antibody responses against alphaviruses is crucial for the development of vaccines, which would represent a big advantage in the control of alphavirus infections.

2. Antibody-Mediated Alphavirus Immunity

2.1. Virus-Specific Antibody Kinetics Upon Natural Infection with Alphaviruses

The current knowledge on the role of antibody-mediated immunity upon viral infection has been gathered from cohort studies following major alphavirus outbreaks. Serological surveys following CHIKV re-emergence in 2004 reported the quick development of IgM responses between five to seven days post-illness onset (PIO) ^[22][23][22,23]. IgM is generally detectable for up to three months post-infection ^[24][25][26][24,25,26]. However, long-lasting IgM has been often reported in patients with long-term CHIKV-induced polyarthralgia, which might indicate a constant antigenic stimulation due to viral persistence [27]. After the initial detection of IgM antibodies, IgG seroconversion reportedly occurs between 4 to 10 days PIO taking over as the main immunoglobulin detected in serum ^[22][28][22,28]. Notably, IgG3 antibodies become the dominant IgG subtype produced upon infection and have been associated to efficient viral clearance and protection against chronic CHIKV symptoms [23]. Importantly, IgG responses persist for several years and might be potentially lifelong [29].

ONNV and MAYV, both closely-related to CHIKV, are re-emerging arthritogenic alphaviruses believed to be confined to sub-Saharan Africa, and Latin America, respectively ^{[6][11][12][15]}[6,11,12,15]. Following the largest ONNV outbreak in Uganda involving more than two million cases between 1959–1962 ^[6][30][6,30], the induction of potent neutralizing antibodies was described [31]. The first study cohort that evaluated IgM kinetics upon ONNV infection in Uganda [32] reported the appearance of IgM antibodies during the second week PIO which remained elevated for two months. In contrast, reports from imported ONNV cases in Europe described detectable IgM levels as early as five days PIO ^[33][34][33,34]. ONNV-specific IgG levels are increased in serum after the third week and remain high beyond two months PIO ^[11][34][11,34]. However, whether IgG responses are long-lasting remains unknown. Similarly, endemic MAYV infections are characterized by the early appearance of IgM antibodies (3–8 days PIO) that might last for one to three months ^[35][36][35,36]. IgG becomes detectable around 4–10 days PIO [35] and remains elevated after 6–12 months ^[37][38][37,38]. Interestingly, unlike ONNV and CHIKV infections, persistent arthralgia has been reported in more than half of MAYV-infected individuals and although MAYV-specific antibody responses are critical for disease resolution it is seemingly insufficient to protect patients from the development of chronic joint manifestations [39].

Other alphaviruses linked to continuous small outbreaks associated with arthritic manifestations in human populations are RRV and SINV. RRV is endemic to Australia and is responsible for approximately 4000–5000 cases annually [40]. Typically, antibody kinetics upon RRV infection are characterized by the development of IgM titers between 7–10 days PIO, peaking at two to three weeks and lasting for 1–3 months ^[41][42][41,42]. IgM response rapidly declines after three weeks PIO as IgG becomes dominant ^[42][43][42,43]. Interestingly, IgM persistence has been reported in some RRV cohorts [41]. In one study [44], 19/116 (16.4%) of participants had detectable IgM levels that lasted between seven months to eight years PIO. Likewise, less prevalent SINV has also been linked to the development of persistent virus-specific IgM levels. Although, generally, the antibody response upon SINV infection generates IgM antibodies after 6–9 days PIO and IgG antibodies after 9–14 days, some reports described the presence of detectable IgM levels up to four years suggesting active viral replication ^[45][46][47][45,46,47]. The clinical relevance of persistent IgM levels following RRV and SINV infection is yet to be determined.

Neurotropic alphaviruses such as EEEV, WEEV and VEEV cause sporadic cases of human encephalitis in the Americas [4]. While the natural reservoirs for these viruses are primarily birds and equines, humans are susceptible to infection when the enzootic cycle of transmission leaks into mosquito populations with a wide range of hosts [48]. Given that human cases are rare, there is a lack of information regarding the development of antibody responses upon natural infections by neurotropic alphaviruses. In a paired serology study [49], virus-specific antibody responses were profiled in a cohort of 20 EEEV and 17 WEEV-infected patients. IgM antibodies were observed as early as 1 PIO, peaking after 1–2 weeks and remaining detectable for up to three months. In contrast, IgG responses appeared during the second week PIO and remained elevated until the end of the follow-up period.

2.2. Experimental Evidence of the Role of Antibodies in Alphavirus Immunity

To better understand the role of antibody-mediated immunity upon alphavirus infection, several animal models have been used allowing the detailed examination of the cellular compartments responsible for the initiation of humoral immunity. The role of B cells in alphavirus immunity has been described in experimental CHIKV infections. Inoculation of µMT mice (lacking mature B cells) with CHIKV resulted in higher viremia that persisted up to 402 days post-infection (DPI). In contrast, infected wild type (WT) mice were able to control the virus during the second week post-inoculation [50]. Similar findings were reported in other studies, where mouse strains lacking B cells (µMT, Rag1, Rag2/IL2rg, NRG) infected with CHIKV displayed increased and persistent viremia for up to 515 DPI ^[51][52][51,52].

B cells also play an important role in alphavirus-induced encephalitis. Although SINV infections in humans are known to cause arthritic manifestations, SINV has been frequently used as a model of alphavirus-induced encephalomyelitis in adult immunocompetent mice given the virus ability to infect neurons [53]. Intracerebral inoculation of SINV in µMT and severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID) mice resulted in defective viral clearance from the brain, brain stem and lumbar spinal cord, virus persistence and recrudescence compared to WT mice [54]. The individual contributions of IgM and IgG antibodies to SINV clearance from brain tissues were assessed in another study [55] where infection in AID^−/− (unable to produce IgG), sIgM^−/− (unable to produce IgM) and AID^−/− sIgM^−/− double-knockout mice resulted only in AID^−/− sIgM^−/− being unable to control infection efficiently suggesting that either IgM or IgG antibodies are sufficient to clear SINV from the central nervous system (CNS). Similar results were obtained in SFV models of encephalitis where infection of µMT [56], SCID [57] and nude mice with impaired antibody switching [58] led to viral persistence.

Infiltrating virus-specific B cells were observed in infected tissues in a murine model of SINV-induced encephalitis ^[59][60][59,60]. Following intracranial virus inoculation, expansion of IgM-secreting plasmablasts was reported in the cervical lymph nodes. Infiltration of CD19+ B cells occurred between 3–7 DPI and coincided with the starting of viral clearance. During the clearance of persistent viral RNA (from 8–80 DPI), the accumulation of SINV-specific IgG and IgA-secreting B cells was observed being associated with increased SINV antibody titers over time [60]. In a subsequent study, it was reported that the brain microenvironment during the early stages of SINV infection facilitates the migration, differentiation, expansion and long term survival of SINV-specific B cells [59].

Follicular helper T cells (T_FH) are a subset of CD4 T cells involved in the activation of B lymphocytes and the establishment of robust antibody responses following antigen stimulation. T_FH promotes B cell differentiation, isotype switching and affinity maturation. In experimental CHIKV infections, the use of CD4-deficient mice ruled out the role of CD4 T cells in viral clearance from infected tissues [61]. However, one study demonstrated impaired IgM and IgG (IgG2c, IgG1, and IgG2b) production in mice lacking CD4 T cells following CHIKV inoculation [62]. Albeit reduced virus-specific antibody levels, the neutralizing capacity of sera from virus-infected CD4-deficient mice was marginally affected [62]. Likewise, another study showed similar results upon CHIKV inoculation of MHCII^Δ/Δ mice (defective of T_FH) [51]. MHCII^Δ/Δ animals were unable to generate IgG1 antibodies and produced ≈100 fold lower IgG2c levels than WT controls. Nonetheless, MHCII^Δ/Δ mice were still able to control virus infection [51]. The generation of virus-specific neutralizing antibodies in MHCII^Δ/Δ mice suggests a T-cell independent B cell activation characterized by the inability to generate memory B cells. Whether CHIKV-specific antibody responses in mice lacking CD4 T cells are long-lasting remains to be elucidated.

2.3. Viral Antigenic Regions Targeted by Neutralizing Antibodies

The notion of targeting humoral immunity as a therapy against alphavirus infection has been investigated since the late 1930s following the isolation of EEEV, WEEV and VEEV. In a series of seminal studies involving immunization of guinea pigs ^{[63][64][65][66]}[63,64,65,66], the subcutaneous inoculation of live EEEV and WEEV strains protected guinea pigs from lethal intracranial infection [63]. Additionally, it was observed that immunization with formalin-inactivated virus strains induced the production of neutralizing antibodies at a comparable level than animals immunized with live viruses ^[64][65][66][64,65,66]. Subsequent studies reported that passive transfer of hyperimmune rabbit serum protected mice, guinea pigs and rabbits from WEEV infection ^[66][67][66,67]. Similarly, passive serum transfer was shown to be effective at protecting mice from the development of neurological complications upon infection with a neuroadapted strain of SINV ^[68][69][68,69]. Comparable observations were reported in experimental infection models of VEEV [70], CHIKV ^[71][72][71,72], RRV [73] and SFV [74].

The first attempts in identifying the exact structural regions, recognized by most neutralizing antibodies produced upon infection, were conducted in experimental infection models of alphavirus encephalitis. Structurally, the envelope of an alphavirus virion has a T = 4 icosahedral symmetry [75]. E1 and E2 are two envelop surface glycoproteins exposed in the viral spike as a heterodimer [75] (Figure 1). It is believed that the E1-E2 heterodimer interacts with host receptors thus mediating viral entry [75]. Additionally, the E1 and E2 glycoproteins were postulated as highly immunogenic regions since their location in the spike facilitates antigenic recognition. In line with this, early works mapped antigenic sites involved in VEEV, SINV and SFV neutralization to the E1 and E2 proteins using competitive binding assays but the exact amino acid sequences were not determined ^[76][77][78][76,77,78]. Later, a major antigenic region involving three epitopes important in the neutralization of RRV was identified in the E2 protein (incorporating residues 216, 232 and 234) [79]. Similarly, analysis of antibody escape variants determined important antigenic regions between amino acids 181 and 216 on the E2 protein of SINV [80]. A major neutralization domain was also identified between residues 182–207 for VEEV [81].

Figure 1. Structure of the alphavirus E1-E2 heterodimer. Ribbon diagram (PDB: 3N41) highlighting (A) E1 glycoprotein (domain I: red, domain II: yellow, domain III: blue, fusion loop FL: orange, E2: grey) and (B) E2 glycoprotein (domain A: cyan, domain B: green, domain C: pink, beta-ribbons: purple, E1: grey). (C) Table summarizing reported antibody binding regions in the E1 and E2 glycoproteins of arthrogenic and neurotropic alphaviruses. Numbers in the table refer to in-text citations describing such binding sites (See Reference list). Background color matches protein doimains depicted in (A) and (B). To assess for the degree of conservation among common antigenic regions across alphaviruses a sequence aligment analysis was conducted (See Supplementary Figure S1).

Following CHIKV reemergence in 2004 several reports identified major linear antigenic sites in the CHIKV E2 protein that induced the production of potent neutralizing antibodies. Using a CHIKV proteome-wide screening approach, a single linear peptide located at the N-terminus of the E2 glycoprotein, E2EP3, was reported as strongly recognized by convalescent CHIKV patients from different cohorts [23]. Furthermore, experimental CHIKV infection in mice and non-human primates (NHP) validated E2EP3 as an immunodominant linear epitope inducing potent neutralizing antibodies ^[23][62][82][23,62,82]. Interestingly, mice immunization with E2EP3 alone reduced joint swelling and viremia upon CHIKV challenge [23]. In another study focusing on human antibody responses to SINV in cohort from Finland, 6 linear epitopes, located in the capsid, E2, E1 and PE2 (uncleaved E3-E2) proteins, were reported [83]. Three of these epitopes were located to the glycoprotein spike complex between the residues 209–226 of E1 (E1-P5), 273–290 (E2-P3) and 308–325 (E2-P4) of E2 [83]. Interestingly, the E2EP3 equivalent of SINV remained non-reactive suggesting that antibody kinetics against linear E2EP3 between populations exposed to CHIKV and SINV might differ [83].

The development of mouse and human monoclonal antibodies against different alphaviruses helped further the understanding of antigenic responses upon infection by the identification of conformational epitopes. Early works have shown the therapeutic value of mouse monoclonal antibodies in models of alphavirus encephalitis by SINV ^{[84][85][86][87][88]}[84,85,86,87,88], SFV ^[56][57][89][56,57,89] and VEEV [78]. Interestingly, it was observed that neutralizing monoclonal antibodies target antigenic regions in the E2 protein. Whereas, non-neutralizing antibodies bind to the E1 protein, yet both are able to confer protection upon alphavirus infection, thereby suggesting other mechanisms of protection in vivo besides virus neutralization [48]. Several monoclonal antibodies targeting both E1 and E2 proteins have been reported in the context of arthritogenic alphavirus infection. Mouse monoclonal antibodies targeting the A and B domain of E2 and the domain II of E1 ^[90][91][92][90,91,92] and the capsid protein ^[93][94][93,94] have been reported for CHIKV. Likewise, human anti-CHIKV monoclonal antibodies were found to target conformation epitopes in the E2 glycoprotein A (containing a putative RBD [95]) and B (shielding the fusion loop in E1 [96]) domains and proved therapeutic value in experimental NHP infections ^[90][97][98][90,97,98]. Monoclonal antibodies recognizing epitopes predominantly between residues 58–80 (domains A) or residues 180–215 (domain B) of the E2 glycoprotein have been also reported in the context of SINV [83], VEEV [81], EEEV ^{[99][100][101]}[99,100,101], RRV [102] and MAYV [103].

The combined evidence suggested the existence of common antigenic sites in the viral spike across alphaviruses, particularly in the E2 protein. These sites are likely required for interaction with host cell receptors suggesting that antibody binding might inhibit infection during viral attachment, entry, fusion or egress [90]. In line with this, a recent study reported the discovery of Mxra8, a cell adhesion molecule, as a host receptor required for viral entry of multiple arthritogenic alphaviruses [104]. Genetically altering mouse or human Mxra8 resulted in diminished infection, conversely, overexpression of Mxra8 in cell lines increased infection rates by CHIKV, ONNV, MAYV and RRV ^[104][105][104,105]. Interestingly, mutagenesis experiments suggested E2 domains A and B as the putative binding site for Mxra8 [104]. This notion was later confirmed by cryo-electron microscopy images of Mxra8 bound to CHIKV ^[106][107][106,107]. Mxra8 sits onto a cleft formed by two contiguous CHIKV E2-E1 heterodimers in one trimeric spike while engaging a neighboring spike [106]. It is believed that this interaction works against the virus by obstructing viral fusion [106]. Importantly, human neutralizing antibodies that recognize regions of the A domain of E2 inhibited the binding of Mxra8 supporting the interactions determined in the cryo-EM atomic model. Notably, Mxra8 seems to not be a receptor for neurotropic alphaviruses [104]. The alignment of CHIKV residues involved in Mxra8 binding reveled a degree of conservation in arthritogenic alphaviruses (44%), but diverged from neurotropic Alphaviruses (14%) which might explain the negative results in the context of SINV, EEEV, WEEV and VEEV infections [106]. In summary, the characterization of alphavirus antigenic epitopes has proven beneficial to pave the way for the development of antibody therapies and vaccines.

3. Alphavirus Vaccine Development

Recent decades have seen increased rates of geographic dispersal of arboviral re-emergence, due to factors such as growth of global transportation, urbanization and failure of mosquito control ^{[108][109][110][111]}[108,109,110,111]. Given that humans appear to be the only amplification hosts and viral reservoir during urban transmission ^[112][113][112,113], another effective means of controlling the spread of infection is through vaccination. While there are currently no licensed or approved vaccines available for alphaviruses, a multitude of approaches have been used to develop vaccine candidates capable of, not only generating high levels of antibodies, but also providing long-lasting protection, with the ease of administration and production requirements. Multiple methods such as live-attenuated viruses, inactivated viruses, virus-like particles (VLP), recombinant subunit vaccines and chimeric vaccines have been explored for vaccine options (Figure 2 and Table 1).

Figure 2. An outline of the current vaccine options against arthritogenic (left panel) and neurotropic (right panel) alphaviruses. Most of these vaccine candidates are currently under preclinical testing (early preclinical—vaccine candidates tested in mouse models; late preclinical—vaccine candidates currently under testing in non-human primates (NHP)), while a minority of them are currently undergoing clinical trials (Phase 1, 2 or 3). LAV; live-attenuated virus; VLP, virus-like particle; SIN, Sindbis virus; ISFV, Isfahan virus; May, Mayaro virus; EILV, Eilat virus, VSV/VSIV, vesicular stomatitis virus; MV, measles virus; MVA, modified vaccinia virus Ankara. Data curated from literature reported through February 2021. Numbers in superscript refer to reference numbers (See Reference list ^{[23][73][114][115][116][117][118][119][120][121][122][123][124][125][126][127][128][129][130][131][132][133][134][135][136][137][138][139][140][141][142][143][144][145][146][147][148][149][150][151][152][153][154][155][156][157][158][159][160][161][162][163][164][165][166][167][168][169][170][171][172][173][174][175][176][177][178][179][180][181][182][183][184][185][186][187][188][189][190][191][192][193][194][195][196][197][198][199][200][201][202][203][204][205][206][207][208][209][210][211][212][213][214][215][216][217][218][219][220]}[23,73,114,115,116,117,118,119,120,121,122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131,132,133,134,135,136,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144,145,146,147,148,149,150,151,152,153,154,155,156,157,158,159,160,161,162,163,164,165,166,167,168,169,170,171,172,173,174,175,176,177,178,179,180,181,182,183,184,185,186,187,188,189,190,191,192,193,194,195,196,197,198,199,200,201,202,203,204,205,206,207,208,209,210,211,212,213,214,215,216,217,218,219,220]).

Table 1. List of vaccine candidates against relevant alphaviruses currently under development ¹.

Vaccine Against Virus		Name			Strain Vaccine Modelled After			Phase					Immunization								Challenge					Humoral Immune Response(s)			Ref
Vaccine Against Virus		Name			Strain Vaccine Modelled After			Phase			Dose			Route			Schedule			Dose (Strain, Genotype)			Route			Humoral Immune Response(s)			Ref
	Live-attenuated
CHIKV, ONNV		RH-CHIKV		EV-CHIKV		RHEV-CHIKV			LR2006 OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 3 week old			10⁶ PFU			s.c. in the ventral side of the right hind footpad			Single dose			10⁶ PFU LR2006 OPY1 or WT-ONNV IMTSSA/5163, 3 mpim			s.c. in the ventral side of the right hind footpad			IC50, 613 (RH-CHIKV), 3407 (EV-CHIKV), 921 (RHEV-CHIKV)		[130]
CHIKV		Δ5nsP3 (VLA1553-301 in clinical trials) and Δ6K			LR2006 OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 5 to 6 week old			10⁴ or 10⁵ PFU			s.c. in both flanks			Single dose			10⁶ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 7 wpim			s.c.			NT50, 100 to 1000		^[131]^[132]^[133]	[131,132,133]
								Cynomolgus macaques, 3–4 years old			10⁵ PFU			s.c. in the right upper back side			Single dose			100 AID50 (corresponding to 7000–10,000 PFU) LR2006 OPY1, 123 dpim			i.v.			NT50, >1000
								Human clinical trial, Phase 1			3.2 × 10³,		3.2 × 10 ⁴ or 3.2 × 10⁵ TCID50			i.m.			Two doses (0 and 6 months, or 0 and 12 months)			NA			NA					GMT, 592.6 to 686.9
CHIKV		CHIKV-NoLS			LR2006 OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 21 days of age			10⁴ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10⁴ PFU of LR2006 OPY1 or Ross River virus, 30 dpim			s.c.			<10% cells infected at 10^-1 serum dilution		[127]
CHIKV		Stop CHIKV		SuperStop CHIKV			LR2006 OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 5 week old			10⁴ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			ND			ND			~5–25 (Stop CHIKV) and ~10–25 (SuperStop CHIKV) fold reduction compared to mock		[134]
CHIKV		ChikV HR			37997			C57BL/6 mice, 28 days of age			∼10³ PFU			s.c. into the left footpad			Single dose			10³ PFU CHIKV SL15649, 28 dpim			s.c. in the footpad			PRNT50, 5 to ~500		[135]
CHIKV		Heparin sulfate cell culture adapted			LR2006 OPY1			CD-1 mice, 21 days old			10⁵ GE			s.c. in the rear footpad			Single dose			10³ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 21 dpim			NA			~40 to 1000 fold change compared to mock		[136]
VEEV		V3526			IA/B Trinidad donkey			BALB/c, 6 to 8 week oldC3H/HeN mice, 6 to 8 week old			10⁵ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10⁵ PFU of TrD, 28 dpim			NP			ND		^[137]^[138]^[139]^[140]	[137,138,139,140]
								Cynomolgus macaques (age not specified)			2.5 × 10⁶ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			∼10⁸ PFU VEEV IE 68U201, 8 wpim			aerosol			PRNT80, 28 to 2560
								Rhesus macaques (2 to 4 years old)			1.3 × 10⁵ or 7.5 × 10⁴ PFU			s.c. or i.t./i.s.			Single dose			ND			ND			PRNT80, ~80 to 300
								Human clinical trial, Phase 1			25 or 125 PFU			s.c.			Single dose			NA			NA			NA
VEEV		V4020			IA/B Trinidad donkey			BALB/c mice, 4 to 8 week old			10⁴ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10⁴ PFU of VEEV TrD, 28 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 160 to1280		^[141]^[142]	[141,142]
VEEV		V4020			IA/B Trinidad donkey			Cynomolgus macaques (age not specified)			~10⁴ PFU			s.c. in the right leg			Single dose (or second dose at 2 x 10⁴ PFU i.m. if did not seroconvert)			10⁶ to 10⁷ PFU of the VEEV TrD, 73 dpim			aerosol			PRNT80, >640		^[141]^[142]	[141,142]
EEEV		5′U4&6 C65-69 E71-77 3′U11337 mutants			FL93-939			CD-1 mice, 5 to 6 week old			1.5 × 10⁵ GE			s.c. in footpad, or i.c.			Single dose			10⁵ PFU EEEV FL93, 21 dpim			s.c. in both footpads			PRNT80, 16 to ~4000		[143]
	Live-attenuated (IRES)
CHIKV		CHIKV/IRES			LR2006 OPY1			A129 mice, 3 or 10 week old			10⁴ PFU			i.d.			Single dose			100 PFU LR2006 OPY1, 94 dpim			i.d.			PRNT80, >320		^[144]^[145]	[144,145]
								C57BL/6 mice, 3 week old			10⁵ PFU			s.c. in the hind leg			Single dose			10^6.5 PFU Ross CHIKV, 21 dpim			i.n.			Mean PRNT80, 62
								A129 mice, 8 to 10 week old			10⁵ TCID50			s.c.			Single dose			100 PFU LR2006 OPY1, 50 dpim			i.d.			Mean PRNT80, 1152
								Cynomolgus macaques, >3 years old			10⁵ PFU			s.c. or i.d.			Single dose			10⁵ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 52 dpim			s.c. in the upper deltoid			PRNT80, 40 to 640PRNT50, 160 to 1280
ONNV		CHIKV/IRES			LR2006 OPY1			A129 mice, 6 to 7 week old			10⁴ PFU			i.d.			Single dose			10⁵ PFU ONNV SG650, 38 dpim			i.d.			PRNT80, 160		[146]
VEEV		ZPC/IRESv1, ZPC/IRESv2			ID ZPC738			CD-1 mice, 6 to 8 week old			10⁵ PFU			s.c. in the scruff of the back			Single dose			10⁵ PFU VEEV 3908, 4 wpim			s.c. or aerosol			PRNT80, 40 to 324		[114]
VEEV		ZPC/IRESv1, ZPC/IRESv2			ID ZPC738			Cynomologous macaques, age not specified			10⁵ PFU			s.c. in the upper deltoid			Single dose			~ 8 × 10⁵ to 9 × 10⁶ PFU VEEV 3908, 35 dpim			aerosol			PRNT80, <20 to 20PRNT50, <20 to 160		[114]
EEEV		EEE/IRES			FL93-939			NIH Swiss mice, 3 to 4 week old			10⁴ PFU			s.c. in the medial thigh			Single dose			10³ PFU of FL93-939, 4 wpim			i.p.			PRNT80, 160 to 640		[147]
VEEV		68U201/IRESv1 68U201/IRESv2			IE 68U201			CD1 mice, 6 to 8 week old			10⁵ PFU			s.c. in right hind leg			Single dose			(Lethal dose, NP) 68U201 at 1, 3, or 12 mpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 64 to ~300		^[148]^[149]	[148,149]
VEEV		68U201/IRESv1 68U201/IRESv2			IE 68U201			Cynomolgus macaques (age not specified)			10⁵ PFU			s.c. in the upper deltoid			Single dose			4 × 10⁴ PFU VEEV IE 68U201, 49 dpim			aerosol			PRNT80, ~100 to 340		^[148]^[149]	[148,149]
VEEV		VEEV/IRES/C			IA/B Trinidad donkey			CD-1 mice, 8 week old			10⁵ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10⁴ PFU of VEEV 3908, 6 wpim			s.c.			Mean PRNT80, 184		[150]
MAYV		MAYV/IRES			MAYV-CH			BALB/c, 6 week old			2 × 10⁵ PFU			s.c. i.pl. route			Single dose			2 × 10⁵ PFU of WT MAYV, 28 dpim			s.c. i.pl. route			PRNT50, >640 (at 21dpi)		^[146]^[151]^[152]	[146,151,152]
								AG129			2 × 10⁴, 2 × 10³ or 2 × 10² PFU			s.c. i.pl. route			Single dose			2 × 10³ PFU of WT MAYV, 14 dpim			s.c. i.pl. route			ND
								CD-1, 28-day old			10⁵ PFU			s.c. over the dorsum			Single dose			ND			ND			PRNT80, 160 to ≥ 640
								AG129, 5 to 8 week old			10⁴ PFU			i.d. on the left foot			Single dose			10⁴ PFU of WT MAYV, 29 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 320 to ≥ 640
	Inactivated
CHIKV		Vero cell adapted			DRDE-06			Swiss albino mice, 3 to 4 week old			10, 25 or 50 ug			s.c.			Three doses (0, 14 and 28 days)			ND			ND			PRNT90, 6400		[153]
CHIKV		BPL/formalin-inactivated CHIKV		BBV87 (in clinical trials)			IND-06-AP3			BALB/c mice, 4 to 6 week old			10, 20 or 50 μg			i.m.			Two doses (0 and 14 days)			2.5 x 10⁴ TCID50 IND-06-AP3, 4 or 22 wpim			i.n.			GMT, NT50, 80 to 1280		[154]
CHIKV		BPL/formalin-inactivated CHIKV		BBV87 (in clinical trials)			IND-06-AP3			Human clinical trial, Phase 1			10, 20 or 30 μg			i.m.			Three doses (0, 29 and 57 days)			NA			NA			NA		[155]
RRV		Vero cell culture-derived whole-virus RRV vaccine Ross River Virus (RRV) Vaccine			T48			CD-1 mice, 7 to 8 week old			0.0025, 0.01, 0.039, 0.156, 0.625, 2.5 or 10 μg			s.c.			Two doses (0 and 28 days)			10⁶ TCID50 RRV T48, 42 dpim			i.v.			Mean NT, ≤2.9 to 46.2		^[73]^[115]^[128]^[129]	[73,115,128,129]
								A129 mice, 7 to 8 week old			0.063, 0.25 or 1 μg			i.m.			Two doses (0 and 21 days)			10^2.5 TCID50 T48, 42 dpim			s.c. into left footpad			Mean NT, ≤14 to 21
								CD-1 mice, age not specified			10 μg			s.c.			Two doses (0 and 28 days)			10⁶ TCID50 T48, 6 wpim			i.v.			1000 TCID50
								Guinea pigs (Duncan Hartley), age not specified			10 μg			s.c.			Single or two doses (0 and 6 weeks)			10⁶ TCID50 T48, 10 or 34 wpim			i.v.			NP
								Human clinical trial, Phase 1/2			1.25, 2.5, 5, or 10 μg			i.m.			Three doses in escalation (0, 21 days, 6 months)			NA			NA			GMT, 50 to 520.9
								Human clinical trial, Phase 3			2.5 ug			i.m.			Three doses (0, 3 weeks, 6 months)			NA			NA			μNT GMT, ~0 to 85
EEEV		TSI-GSD-104 (formalin inactivated)			PE-6			Human clinical trial, Phase 2			NP			s.c. (0 and 28 days), i.d. (6 months)			Three doses (0, 28 days and 6 months)			NA			NA			PRNT80 >40 in 60% subjects (primary doses) versus 84% subjects (completed the 2-dose primary series and the 6-month dose)		^[156]^[157]^[158]	[156,157,158]
EEEV		fCVEV1219		iCVEV1219		gCVEV1219			CVEV1219			BALB/c mice, 6 to 8 week old			0.1 to 5 µg of inactivated EEEV			i.n., s.c. or i.m.			Single dose or two doses (0 and 28 days)			Lethal dose of EEEV FL93-939, at 28 dpim (single dose) or 56 dpim (two doses)			aerosol			PRNT80, ~1 to 1000		[159]
VEEV		V3526 virus			V3526			BALB/c mice, 6 week old			0.2 μg (s.c.) or 0.04 μg (i.m.)			s.c. or i.m.			Two doses (0 and 28 days)			10⁴ PFU VEEV TrD, 56 dpim			aerosol or s.c.			GMT PRNT80, ~60 to 2500		[160]
VEEV		F-iV3526			V3526			BALB/c mice, 8 to 10 weeks old			1, 3 or 5 μg			i.n., s.c. (under the skin over the neck) or i.m. (thigh muscle of the hind leg)			Single dose			454 (i.n.), 897 (i.m.) or 55 (s.c.) PFU VEEV-TrD, 56 dpim			aerosol			Microneutralization titer of 100 to 3500		^[161]^[162]	[161,162]
	Virus-like particle
CHIKV		VRC 311		Or		VRC-CHKVLP059-00-VP/ PXVX0317 (in clinical trials)			37997			BALB/c mice, 6 to 8 week old			19 μg			i.m.			2 doses (2 and 5 weeks)			ND			ND			IC50, 10703 to 54600		^[116]^[117]^]	[116^[118]^[163,117,118,163]
												Cynomolgus macaques, 3 to 4 years old			20 μg			i.m.			3 doses (0, 4 and 24 weeks)			10¹⁰ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 15 wpim			i.v.			IC50, 10219 to 15072
												Human clinical trial, Phase 1			10, 20 or 40 μg			i.m.			3 doses (0, 4 and 24 weeks)			NA			NA			IC50, 4525 to 8745
												Human, clinical trial Phase 2			20 μg			i.m.			2 doses (0 and 28 days)			NA			NA			EC50 GMT, 2005
												Human clinical trial (Phase 2b, recruitment completed)			6, 10 or 20 μg			NP			Two doses (0 and 14 or 28 days)			NA			NA			NA
CHIKV		Baculovirus-expressed VLP			S27			AG129, 6 week old			1 μg			s.c.			2 doses (0 and 21 days)			1000 TCID50 S27, 6 wpim			i.p.			PRNT95, 40 to 80		^[164]^[165]	[164,165]
CHIKV		Baculovirus-expressed VLP			S27			C57BL/6 mice, 6 to 12 week old			0.1 or 1 μg			s.c.			Single dose			10⁴ CCID₅₀ LR2006 OPY1, 6 wpim			s.c.			NT95, ~1,100
CHIKV		Yeast-expressed VLP			DRDE06/DRDE07			BALB/c mice, 4 week or 2 days old			10, 20 or 40 ug			s.c.			Three doses (0, 14 and 28 days)			ND			ND			NT50, 128 to 2048		[166]
VEEV		Venezuelan Equine Encephalitis Monovalent Virus-Like Particle Vaccine (VEEV)			NA			Human clinical trial (Phase 1, not recruiting)			2, 10, or 20 μg			i.m.			Dose escalation (0, 28 days, and day 140 booster)			NA			NA			NA		[167]
WEEV, EEEV, and VEEV		VRC-WEVVLP073-00-VP (Trivalent vaccine)			WEEV CBA87, EEEV PE-6 and VEEV TC-83			BALB/c mice, 6 to 8 week old			monovalent (5 μg) or trivalent (5 μg each)			i.m.			Two doses (0 and 21 days)			2.5 × 10³ PFU WEEV CBA87, 8.9 × 10³ PFU EEEV FL93-939, and 1.3 × 10³ PFU VEEV Trinidad donkey, 56 dpim			aerosol			PRNT80, ~250 to 100000		[168]
								Cynomolgus macaques, age not specified			Monovalent (20 μg) or trivalent (20 μg each)			i.m.			Two doses (0 and 28 days)			10⁶ PFU WEEV CBA87, 10⁸ PFU EEEV FL93-939, and 10⁸ VEEV Trinidad donkey, 56 dpim			aerosol			PRNT80, ~1000 to 10000		[168]
								Human clinical trial, Phase 1			6, 30 or 60 μg			i.m.			Dose escalation (0 and 8 weeks)			NA			NA			NA		[169]
DNA/RNA
VEEV		VEEV 26S DNA plasmid			I/AB TrD			BALB/c mice, 6 to 8 week old			∼3 μg			DNA/gene gun, delivered to two sites on the abdomen of each mouse			Three doses (at 3-week intervals)			∼10⁴ PFU of TrD, 9 wpim			s.c., aerosol			PRNT50, GMT <1.6 to 2.5		^[170]^[171]	[170,171]
VEEV		VEEV 26S DNA plasmid			I/AB TrD			Hartley guinea pigs, age not specified			~5 μg			DNA/gene gun, delivered to two sites on the abdomen of each mouse			Three doses (0, 4 and 8 weeks)			∼10⁴ PFU of TrD, 21 wpim			aerosol			PRNT50, 0 to 640		^[170]^[171]	[170,171]
VEEV		DNA-Ad			TC-83			BALB/c mice, 6 to 8 week old			1 μg of DNA per dose and 107 PFU of RAd/VEEV #3 per boost			gene guni.n.			immunised with the DNA vaccines on day 0, 14 and 28 and Ad-based vaccine on day 42			100 LD50 of virulent airborne VEEV, 63 dpim			aerosol			PRNT50, 160		[172]
VEEV		AG4-1C7		AG4-1G2 AG2-5A7		AG2-5A10 plasmid DNA			I/AB TrD			BALB/c mice, 6 to 8 week old			4 μg			particle-mediated epidermal delivery (i.d.)			Three doses (at 3-week intervals)			∼10⁴ PFU of VEEV TrD (≥1000 LD50), 70 dpim			aerosol			PRNT80, ~1 to 5.5 log₁₀ GMT		[173]
VEEV		pTC83 iDNA			TC-83			BALB/c mice, 3 week old			50 μg			i.m. electroporation			Single dose			10⁵ PFU VEEV 3908, 21 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 10 to 320		[174]
WEEV		pE3-E2-6K-E1		pE3-E2		P6K-E1			71V-1658			BALB/c, age not specified			2 μg			gene gun			Three doses (14 days apart)			1500 PFU WEEV 71V-1658,		Fleming, or CBA87, 42 dpim			i.n.			ND		[175]
CHIKV		pCHIKV-Capsid, pCHIKV-Envelope (pMCE321)			Consensus			C57BL/6 mice, 3 to 4 week old			25 µg, 2–3 times			Electroporation			Two doses (2 weeks apart)			ND			ND			ND		^[176]^[177]^[178]	[176,177,178]
								C57BL/6 mice, 6 to 8 week old			25 μg			i.m. electroporation			Three doses (0, 14 and 21 days)			7log₁₀ PFU of PC-08, 35 dpim			i.n.			NP
								BALB/c mice			25 μg			i.m. electroporation			Two doses (2 weeks apart)			7log₁₀ PFU PC-08			i.n.			TCID50, 20 to 320
								Rhesus macaques, age not specified			1 mg			i.m. electroporation			Three doses (4 weeks apart)			ND			ND			TCID50, 80 to 1280
CHIKV		Δ5nsP3 and Δ6K DNA			LR2006 OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 5 to 6 week old			20 μg			i.d. with DermaVax electroporation			Single dose or two doses (0 and 3 weeks)			10⁶ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 7 wpim			s.c.			NT50, 100 to 10000		[131]
CHIKV		CHIKV-NoLS RNA			LR2006 OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 28 days of age			2 μg			s.c. in the ventral/lateral side of the right foot			Single dose			10⁴ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 30 dpim			s.c. in the ventral/lateral side of the right (ipsilateral) or left (contralateral)			PRNT80, 0		[126]
CHIKV		CHIKV-NoLS RNA			LR2006 OPY1			AG129 mice, 28 days old			2 μg			s.c. in the ventral/lateral side of the right foot			Single dose			10⁴ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 30 dpim			s.c. in the ventral/lateral side of the right (ipsilateral) or left (contralateral)			ND		[126]
VEEV, WEEV and EEEV		3-EEV			VEEV IAB TrD, WEEV CBA874 and EEEV FL91-46794			C57BL/6 mice, 6 to 8 week old			15 μg			i.m. electroporation			Two doses (0 and 21 days)			10⁴ PFU VEEV IAB TrD or 2 × 10⁴ PFU WEEV CBA874 or 105 PFU EEEV FL91-46794, 7 wpim			aerosol			PRNT80, ~1 to 1000		[179]
MAYV		scMAYV-E			NA			C57BL/6 mice, 5 to 8 week old			25 μg			i.m. electroporation			Single, two doses or three doses (at 2 week intervals)			ND			ND			PRNT50, 789.8		[180]
MAYV		scMAYV-E			NA			A129 mice, 4 to 6 week old			25 μg			i.m. electroporation			Single, two doses or three doses (at 2 week intervals)			10² PFU MAYV 15537			i.p.			ND		[180]
CHIKV		p181/25-7			TSI-GSD-28			BALB/c mice, 3 week old			10 μg			i.m. electroporation			Single dose			6 × 10⁶ PFU CHIKV Ross, 28 dpim			i.n.			PRNT80, 160 to 1280		[181]
CHIKV		dMaB			NA			BALB/c mice, age not specified			100 μg			Electroporation			Single dose			10⁷ PFU Del-03			s.c. or i.n.			IC50, 3 to 4.5log₁₀		[182]
CHIKV		iRNAΔ5nsP3		iDNAΔ5nsP3			LR2006 OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 8 week old			0.125, 1.25 or 10 μg			i.m. in the gastrocnemius muscle of the left hind leg			Single dose			10⁶ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 5 wpim			s.c. at the dorsal side of each hind foot			NT50, ~1 to 10⁴		[183]
VEEV		pMG4020 DNA plasmid			TC-83			BALB/c, 4 to 8 week old			0.5 or 5 ug			i.m. electroporation			Single dose			10⁴ PFU VEEV TrD, 28 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 320 to >1280		[141]
VEEV		VEEV_WT VEEV_COCAP		VEEV _CO			IAB TrD			BALB/c, 6 to 8 week old			25, 5, or 1 μg			i.m. electroporation			Two doses (3 weeks apart)			∼10⁴ PFU VEEV IAB strain TrD, 7 wpim			aerosol			PRNT80, 1 to ~4.5log₁₀		^[184]^[185]	[184,185]
										New Zealand White rabbits, age not specified			500 μg of VEEV_CO			i.m. electroporation			Three doses (0, 28 and 230 days)			ND			ND			PRNT80, ~3log₁₀ to 5log₁₀
										Cynomolgus macaques, age not specified			50 or 500 μg of VEEV_CO			i.m. electroporation			Two doses (0 and 56 days)			3 × 10⁸ PFU VEEV IAB TrD			aerosol			PRNT80, ~0.8log₁₀ to 3.5log10
										Human clinical trial, Phase 1			0.5 or 2 mg			i.m. electroporation or i.d. electroporation			Three doses (days 0, 28, and 56)			NA			NA			GMT PRNT80, 7 to 78
WEEV		pVHX-671V-1658		pVHX-6 CBA87		pVHX-6 Fleming			Fleming, CBA 87 or 71V-1658,			BALB/c mice, age not specified			2 shots × 2.5 μg precipitated on 0.5 mg gold			gene gun			Four doses (2 weeks apart)			1.5 × 10³ PFU WEEV Fleming, CBA 87 or 71V-1658, 8 wpim			i.n.			ND		[186]
WEEV and EEEV		LANAC E1ecto			WEEV McMillan			CD-1 mice, 4 to 6 week old			10 μg			s.c. injection dorsal to the cervical spine			Two doses (2 weeks apart)			10⁴ PFU WEEV McMillan, Montana-64, or EEEV Florida-93, 4, 5, 9, 11, or 13 wpim			i.n. or s.c.			PRNT50, <40 to 200		[187]
CHIKV		mRNA-1388 (or VAL-181388 in clinical trials)			NA			Human clinical trial, Phase 1			25, 50 or 100 μg			i.m.			Dose escalation procedure (0 and 4 weeks)			ND			ND			‘dose-dependent increase’ in neutralizing and binding antibody titers		[188]
CHIKV		mRNA-1944			SL15649			AG129, age not specified			0.4, 1 or 10 mg/kg			i.v. tail vein injection			Single dose			10^2.5 TCID50 of CHK			subcutaneous injection in the footpad and hock of the right leg			ND		^[189]^[190]	[189,190]
								Cynomolgus macaques, 2 to 3 year old			0.5 mg/kg			i.v.			Single dose			ND			ND			FRNT50, 5 to 12
								Human clinical trial, Phase 1 (active, not recruiting)			0.1, 0.3 and 0.6 mg/kg			i.v.			Dose escalation			NA			NA			NT50, ‘all participants also showed circulating neutralizing antibody activity’
Subunit
CHIKV		CHIKV-sE1 and -sE2			S27			AG129 mice, 6 week old			2 μg			s.c.			Two doses (0 and 21 days)			1000 TCID50 of S27 isolate, 9 wpim			i.p.			NT95, <25		^[164]^[165]^[191]	[164,165,191]
CHIKV		rE2p			IND-06-AP3			BALB/c, 6 to 8 week old			10, 20 or 50 μg			i.m.			Two doses (2 weeks apart)			Mice immunized with 50 μg challenged with 7 log10 TCID50 /mL, 4 or 22 wpim			i.n.			NT50, 0.25log10 to 2.5log10		[154]
CHIKV		CHIKE1 and CHIKE2 recombinant proteins			DRDE-06			BALB/c			40 μg			s.c.			Three doses (0, 21 and 35 days)			ND			ND			PRNT90, 32 to 512		[192]
	Chimeric virus
		Measles virus-based chimeras
CHIKV (VLP)		MV-CHIKV			06–49			CD46-IFNAR, 6 week old			10³ to 10⁵ TCID50			i.p.			Single or two doses (30 days apart)			100 PFU of CHIKV 06-49, 2 mpim			i.p.			PRNT50, 450 to 4050		PRNT90, 50 to 450		^[193]^[194]^[195]^[196]^[197]	[193,194,195,196,197]
								Cynomolgus macaques, age not specified			5 × 10⁵ (± 0.5 log) TCID50			i.m.			Two doses (28 days apart)			1.4 × 10⁵ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 56 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 40 to >640
								Human clinical trial, Phase 1			1.5 × 10⁴, 7.5 × 10⁴ or 3.0 × 10⁵ TCID50			i.m. or s.c.			Dose escalation (0 and 28 days, or 0 and 90 days)			NA			NA			PRNT50, 5 to 433
								Human clinical trial, Phase 2			5 × 10⁴ or 5 × 10⁵ TCID50			i.m.			Three doses (0, 28, and 196 days)			NA			NA			PRNT50, ~5 to 5000
		Alphavirus-based chimeras
CHIKV		VEE/CHIKV		EEE/CHIKV		SIN/CHIKV			LR2006 OPY1			NIH Swiss, C57BL/6, >3 week old			5.8 log₁₀ PFU (VEE/CHIKV and SIN/CHIKV), 5.3 log₁₀ PFU (EEE/CHIKV)			s.c. in the medial thigh			Single dose			6.5 log₁₀ PFU (Ross CHIKV strain), 21 dpim			i.n.			PRNT80, 20 to 320		[198]
CHIKV		VEE/IRES-CHIKV		VEE/IRES-C/CHIKV			NA			A129 mice, 6 to 9 week old			10⁴ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10² PFU of LR2006 OPY1, 5 weeks post immunization			s.c.			PRNT80, >640		[199]
CHIKV		EILV-CHIKV			CHIKV 996659			C57BL/6 mice, 4 week old			8.8 log₁₀ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			6 log₁₀ PFU 99659, 30 dpim			i.d.			PRNT80, ≥ 80		^[125]^[220]	[125,220]
								IFNα/βR−/−, 6 week old			8.8 log₁₀ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			3 log₁₀ PFU 99659, 292 dpim			i.d.			PRNT80, 160 to 1280
								Cynomolgus macaques, 3 to 5 years			8.1 log₁₀ PFU			i.m. into the right quadriceps			Single dose			5 log₁₀ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 31 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 80 to 640
EEEV		EILV/EEEV			EEEV FL-93			Adult CD-1 mice (age not specified)			10⁸ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10⁵ PFU EEEV-FL93, 70 dpim			i.p.			PRNT80, 80 to 640		^[125]^[220]	[125,220]
EEEV		Trivalent EILV/EEEV EILV/VEEV EILV/CHIKV			EEEV FL-93, VEEV IAB TC-83, CHIKV 996659			Adult CD-1 mice (age not specified)			10⁸ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10⁵ PFU EEEV-FL93, 70 dpim			i.p.			PRNT80, 40 to 640 and 20 to 640 for mono- and trivalent vaccines respectively
VEEV		EILV/EEEV			VEEV IAB TC-83			Adult CD-1 mice (age not specified)			10⁸ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10³ PFU VEEV-IC 3908, 70 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 80 to 1280
VEEV		Trivalent EILV/EEEV, EILV/VEEV EILV/CHIKV			EEEV FL-93, VEEV IAB TC-83, CHIKV 996659			Adult CD-1 mice (age not specified)			10⁸ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10³ PFU VEEV-IC 3908, 70 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 40 to 640 and 20 to 80 for mono- and trivalent vaccines respectively
EEEV (Sindbis virus)		SIN/NAEEEV			EEEV FL93-939			NIH Swiss mice, 8 week old			3.7, 4.7 or 5.7 log₁₀ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			6 log₁₀ PFU FL93-939, 28 dpim			i.p.			PRNT80, 125 to 660		[200]
EEEV (Sindbis virus)		SIN/SAEEEV			EEEV BeAr436087			NIH Swiss mice, 8 week old			3.8, 4.8 or 5.8 log₁₀ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			6 log₁₀ PFU FL93-939, 28 dpim			i.p.			PRNT80, 28 to 308		[200]
VEEV		SIN-83			VEEV IAB TC-83			Weanling NIH Swiss mice, 6 day old			10³, 10⁴, 10⁵ or 10⁶ PFU			s.c.			Single dose			10⁶ PFU VEEV IC ZPC738 IC SH3			s.c.in medial thigh			PRNT80, 30 to 960		^[201]^[202]	[201,202]
		SIN-83			VEEV IAB TC-83			NIH Swiss mice, 6 week old			5 × 10⁵ PFU			s.c.			Two doses			2 x 10⁵ or 10⁶ PFU VEEV ZPC738, 8 wpim			s.c., i.c., or i.n.			PRNT80, 55 to 73 (single), 100 to 160 (booster)
		SAAR/TRD			VEEV IAB TrD			NIH Swiss mice, 6 week old			5 × 10⁵ PFU			s.c.			Two doses			2 x 10⁵ or 10⁶ PFU VEEV ZPC738, 8 wpim			s.c., i.c., or i.n.			PRNT80, 126 to 167 (single), 152 to 160 (booster)
		SIN/TRD			VEEV IAB TrD			NIH Swiss mice, 6 week old			5 × 10⁵ PFU			s.c.			Two doses			2 x 10⁵ or 10⁶ PFU VEEV ZPC738, 8 wpim			s.c., i.c., or i.n.			PRNT80, 37 to 57 (single), 50 to 73 (booster)
		SIN/ZPC			VEEV ID ZPC738			NIH Swiss mice, 6 week old			5 × 10⁵ PFU			s.c.			Two doses			2 x 10⁵ or 10⁶ PFU VEEV ZPC738, 8 wpim			s.c., i.c., or i.n.			PRNT80, 187 to 253 (single), 253 to 487 (booster)
		All the above			VEEV IAB TC-83, IAB TrD, ID ZPC738			Syrian golden hamsters, 6 week old			5 × 10⁵ PFU			s.c. in the medial thigh			Single dose			10⁶ PFU			s.c.in medial thigh			ND
WEEV		SIN/CO92			WEEV CO92-1356			NIH Swiss mice, 6 week old			3.5, 4.5, or 5.0 log₁₀ PFU			s.c. in the medial thigh			Single dose			5.3 log₁₀ PFU WEEV TBT235, 28 dpim			i.n.			PRNT80, 20 to 640		[203]
		SIN/SIN/McM			WEEV McMillan			NIH Swiss mice, 6 week old			4.8 or 5.8 log₁₀ PFU			s.c. in the medial thigh			Single dose			5.0 log₁₀ PFU WEEV McMillan, 28 dpim			i.n.			PRNT80, 600 to 604
		SIN/EEE/McM			EEEV 436087 and WEEV McMillan			NIH Swiss mice, 6 week old			4.6 or 5.6 log₁₀ PFU			s.c. in the medial thigh			Single dose			5.0 log₁₀ PFU WEEV McMillan, 28 dpim			i.n.			PRNT80, 416 to 420
		Vaccinia virus-based chimeras
CHIKV		MVA-CHIKV			LR2006-OPY1			C57BL/6 mice, 6 to 8 week old			10⁷ PFU (first dose), 2 × 10⁷ PFU (second dose)			i.p.			Two doses (2 weeks apart)			10⁶ PFU LR2006-OPY1, 9 wpim			s.c. in the dorsal side of each hind foot			NT50, ~100 to 3000		[204]
CHIKV		MVA-CHIK			LR2006-OPY1			BALB/c mice, 4 to 6 week old			10⁷ TCID50 units			i.d. injection into the left hind footpad.			Single or two doses (28 days apart)			10⁴		LR2006 OPY1 TCID50 units at 39 or 42 dpim			i.d.			TCID50, 5 to 15		[205]
CHIKV		MVA-CHIK			LR2006-OPY1			AG129, 6 to 10 week old			10⁷ TCID50 units			i.d. injection into the left hind footpad.			Single or two doses (28 days apart)			10²		LR2006 OPY1 TCID50 units at 39 or 42 dpim			i.d.			TCID50, 4 to 8		[205]
CHIKV		MVA-6KE1, MVA-E3E2, MVA-6KE1E3E2			CHIKV S27			AG129 mice, 7 week old			5 × 10⁶ TCID50			i.m. into the quadriceps muscles of the left leg			Two doses (3 weeks apart)			10³		TCID50 CHIKV-S27 and CHIKV-IND/NL10, 63 dpim			i.p.			NT100, 10 to 160		[206]
EEEV, VEEV, and WEEV		MVA-BN-E/V/W (monovalent)		MVA-BN-E + MVA-BN-V + MVA-BN-W (triple mixture of monovalent vaccines)		MVA-BN-WEV (trivalent)			WEEV 71 V-1658, EEEV FL93-939NA and VEEV TrD			BALB/c mice, age not specified			10⁸ TCID50			s.c. or i.m.			Two doses (28 days apart)			5 × 10³ or 10⁴ PFU of WEEV Fleming, EEEV PE6, or VEEV TrD, 14 days post booster			i.n.			NT50, ~750 to 3800 (monovalent), ~<60 to 340 (triple mixture of monovalent vaccines) and ~<60 to 380 (trivalent)		[207]
		Adenovirus-based chimeras
CHIKV		CAdVax-CHIK			LR2006 OPY1			CD-1 or C57BL/6, 6 to 8 week old			10⁸ IU			i.p.			Single dose			10⁴ CCID50 LR2006 OPY1 or QIMR, 6.5 wpim			s.c. into side of each hind foot towards the ankle			NT100, ~2000		[208]
CHIKV		ChAdOx1 Chik			NA			BALB/c, 6 to 8 week old			10⁸ IU			i.m.			Single dose			ND			ND			NT50, 5.39 × 10³		^[209]^[210]	[209,210]
	AG129, 5 week old	ChAdOx1 Chik							10⁸ IU			i.m. in each leg			Single dose			9.7 × 10⁴ PFU LR2006 OPY1, 30 dpim			i.d. into the left foot			ND				^[209]^[210]	[209,210]
	ChAdOx1 Chik	ChAdOx1 Chik ΔCap						AG129, 5 week old			10⁸ IU			i.m. in each hind leg			Single dose			9.7 × 10⁴ PFU of LR2006 OPY1, 30 dpim			i.d. into the left foot towards the ankle			PRNT80, 32 to 64 (Chik), 16 to 32 (Chik ΔCap)		[211]
	CHIK001 (in clinical trials)		Human clinical trial, Phase 1						5 × 10⁹, 2.5 × 10¹⁰ or 5 × 10¹⁰ vp			i.m.			Single dose			ND			ND			ND		[212]
MAYV		ChAdOx1 May			NA			AG129, 5 week old			1.6 × 10⁴ PFU			i.m. in each leg			Single dose			1.6 × 10⁴ PFU MAYV-CH, 30 dpim			i.d. into the left foot			PRNT50, 160 to 620		[210]
VEEV		Rad/VEEV#3			VEEV IAB TC-83			BALB/c, 6 to 8 week old			10⁷ PFU			i.n.			Three doses (at 0, 7 and 21 days)			Dose ND, 28 dpim			aerosol			PRNT50 (NP)		[213]
VEEV		Rad/VEEV#3			VEEV IAB TC-83			BALB/c, 6 to 8 week old			10⁷ PFU			i.n.			Two doses (at 0, 21 days)			5000 LD50 TrD, 42 dpim			aerosol			ND		[214]
WEEV		Ad5-WEEV			WEEV 71V-1658			BALB/c mice, age not specified			10⁷ PFU			i.m.			Single or two doses (at 4 weeks)			1.5 × 10³ PFU Fleming or 71V-1658, 13 wpim			i.n.			PRNT50, 160		[215]
WEEV		Ad5-E1			WEEV 71V-1658			BALB/c mice, 6 to 9 week old			10⁷ PFU			i.m. in both leg			Single dose			50 LD50 of 71V-1658, 7 dpim, or		400 LD50 CBA87, 1, 3, 5 or 7 dpim			i.n.			PRNT50, <10		[216]
		Vesiculovirus-based chimeras
CHIKV		rVSVΔG-CHIKV			CHIKV S27			C57BL/6, 3 week old			10⁶ PFU			i.m. into the right hind leg muscle			Single dose			10⁴ PFU LR 2006 OPY1, 30 dpim			s.c. in the left rear footpad			PRNT80, 80 to 640		[217]
VEEV		rVSIV-VEEV			VEEV ZPC738			CD-1, 4 to 6 week old			10⁸/10⁷ PFU			i.m.			Single dose			10⁴ PFU VEEV ZPC738, 35 or 245 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 288 to 600 at 25 and 35 dpim, 304 to 360 at 245 dpim		[218]
VEEV		rISFV-VEEV			VEEV ZPC738			CD-1, 4 to 6 week old			10⁸ PFU			i.m.			Single dose			10⁴ PFU VEEV ZPC738, 28 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, ≥20
VEEV		rISFV-VEEV			VEEV ZPC738			CD-1, 4 to 6 week old			10⁸ PFU			i.m.			Single dose			10⁴ PFU VEEV ZPC738, 35 or 245 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, 40 to 160 at 25 and 35 dpim, 25 to 64 at 245 dpim
EEEV		rISFV-EEEV			EEEV FL93-939			CD-1, 4 to 6 week old			10⁸ PFU			i.m.			Single dose			10⁴ PFU EEEV FL93-939, 28 dpim			s.c.			PRNT80, ≥20
	Epitope-based
CHIKV		E2EP3			NA			C57BL/6 mice, 3 week old			100 μg (50 μg for booster doses)			s.c. in the abdominal flank			Three doses (0, 14 and 21 days)			10⁶ PFU CHIKV SGP11, 30 dpim			s.c. region at the ventral side of the right hind footpad, towards the ankle			~40% reduction from mock control		[23]

¹s.c., subcutaneous; i.v., intravenous; i.m., intramuscular; i.d., intradermal; i.p., intraperitoneal; i.n., intranasal; i.t./i.s., intrathalamic/ intraspinal; i.pl., intraplantar; i.c., intracranial; dpim, days post immunization; wpim, weeks post immunization; mpim, months post immunization; IRES, internal ribosome entry site; PFU, plaque forming units; TCID50, 50% tissue culture infective dose; CCID50, 50% cell culture infectious dose; IC50, 50% inhibitory concentration; GE, genomic equivalents; IU, infectious units; AID50, 50% animal infectious dose; PRNT50, 50% plaque reduction neutralizing antibody titer; PRNT80, 80% plaque reduction neutralizing antibody titer; PRNT90, 90% plaque reduction neutralizing antibody titer; LD50, median lethal dose; NT50, 50% neutralizing titer; GMT, geometric mean titer; μNT, neutralizing titer; SIN, Sindbis virus; ISFV, Isfahan virus; May, Mayaro virus; EILV, Eilat virus, VSV/VSIV, vesicular stomatitis virus; MV, measles virus; MVA, modified vaccinia virus Ankara; NP, not provided; NA, not applicable; WT, wild type. Data curated from literature reported through February 2021.