1. Introduction
Green synthesis of Cu and CuO NPs is more advantageous than chemical and physical synthesis as it is a clean, nontoxic, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly approach. It bypasses the use of harsh, toxic, and expensive chemicals [1] and, instead, utilizes biological entities like bacteria [2], yeasts [3], fungi [4], algae [5], and plants [6]. Among all these natural organisms used in the green synthesis of Cu and CuO NPs, plants rich in bioactive compounds can serve as a reducing, stabilizing, and capping agent during NP synthesis; this makes them the best choice. They are nonpathogenic to humans, and the downstream processing steps are simple [7]. Unlike some bacterial and fungal strains that produce the NPs intracellularly, plant-mediated NP synthesis yields the NPs in the mixture solution, which can be easily obtained by filtering, rinsing, and drying [8][9]. The size, morphology, and stability of NPs can also be easily optimized for medicinal and pharmaceutical usage using this green method [10][11][12].
Green synthesis of Cu and CuO NPs is more advantageous than chemical and physical synthesis as it is a clean, nontoxic, cost-effective, and environmentally friendly approach. It bypasses the use of harsh, toxic, and expensive chemicals [22] and, instead, utilizes biological entities like bacteria [23], yeasts [24], fungi [25], algae [26], and plants [20]. Among all these natural organisms used in the green synthesis of Cu and CuO NPs, plants rich in bioactive compounds can serve as a reducing, stabilizing, and capping agent during NP synthesis; this makes them the best choice. They are nonpathogenic to humans, and the downstream processing steps are simple [27]. Unlike some bacterial and fungal strains that produce the NPs intracellularly, plant-mediated NP synthesis yields the NPs in the mixture solution, which can be easily obtained by filtering, rinsing, and drying [11,28]. The size, morphology, and stability of NPs can also be easily optimized for medicinal and pharmaceutical usage using this green method [5,29,30].
2. Plant-Based Green Synthesis of Copper and Copper Oxide Nanoparticles
The most important phytochemicals in plants are phenols and flavonoids, found in different parts of the plants, such as shoots, leaves, stems, flowers, roots, and fruits. These phenolic compounds possess hydroxyl and ketone groups, contributing to the iron chelation and subsequently demonstrating a strong antioxidant property [13]. NPs synthesized through this green method increased in stability, prevented the agglomeration and deformation of the NPs and allowed adsorption of phytochemicals on the surface of the NPs, which enhance the reaction rate of NPs [14]. One of the common techniques in synthesizing Cu and CuO NPs is mixing a known concentration of plant extract to a known concentration of precursor and heating the mixture to a fixed temperature, with continuous stirring at a given time (Figure 1).
The most important phytochemicals in plants are phenols and flavonoids, found in different parts of the plants, such as shoots, leaves, stems, flowers, roots, and fruits. These phenolic compounds possess hydroxyl and ketone groups, contributing to the iron chelation and subsequently demonstrating a strong antioxidant property [43]. NPs synthesized through this green method increased in stability, prevented the agglomeration and deformation of the NPs and allowed adsorption of phytochemicals on the surface of the NPs, which enhance the reaction rate of NPs [44]. One of the common techniques in synthesizing Cu and CuO NPs is mixing a known concentration of plant extract to a known concentration of precursor and heating the mixture to a fixed temperature, with continuous stirring at a given time ().
Figure 12.
Plant-based synthesis of copper oxide nanoparticles. The boiling of respective parts of the plant can be used to extract biomolecules from the plant. The resulted filtrate is the plant extract, which can reduce the copper precursor to synthesize copper/copper oxide nanoparticles (Cu/CuO NPs). The biomolecules’ presence in plant extracts serves as reducing, stabilizing, and capping agents in Cu/CuO NP synthesis.
Occasionally, certain organic chemicals were added to prevent agglomeration and obtain fine NPs while maintaining the greener approach. The synthesized NPs eventually form various shapes and sizes, which carry unique properties in many applications [6]. Different characterization techniques can analyze the physical and chemical properties of NPs. In addition to size and shape, the size distribution, degree of aggregation, surface charge, surface area, and surface chemistry of the NPs can also be analyzed [15] (Figure 2).
Occasionally, certain organic chemicals were added to prevent agglomeration and obtain fine NPs while maintaining the greener approach. The synthesized NPs eventually form various shapes and sizes, which carry unique properties in many applications [20]. Different characterization techniques can analyze the physical and chemical properties of NPs. In addition to size and shape, the size distribution, degree of aggregation, surface charge, surface area, and surface chemistry of the NPs can also be analyzed [88] ().
Figure 23.
Characterization of synthesized copper/copper oxide nanoparticles (Cu/CuO NPs). (
a) Transmission microscopy image of CuO NPs synthesized from Syzygium alternifolium (Wt.) Walp [16]. (
) Transmission microscopy image of CuO NPs synthesized from Syzygium alternifolium (Wt.) Walp [84]. (
b
,
c
) Scanning electron microscopy image (SEM) (
b
) and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy EDS (
c) of Cu NPs synthesized using Cissus vitiginea leaf extract [17].
) of Cu NPs synthesized using Cissus vitiginea leaf extract [62].
2.1. Synthesis Strategy of CuO, Cu2O, and Cu4O3 NPs
Cu exists with variable oxidation numbers; this includes Cu(I), Cu(II), and very few Cu(III) ions. To date, the synthesis strategy reported for CuO, Cu2O, and Cu4O3 is the same in terms of parameters such as plant extract, precursor concentration, pH, and temperature. However, these parameters mainly affect the type of Cu particles formed during green synthesis [18].
Cu exists with variable oxidation numbers; this includes Cu(I), Cu(II), and very few Cu(III) ions. To date, the synthesis strategy reported for CuO, Cu2O, and Cu4O3 is the same in terms of parameters such as plant extract, precursor concentration, pH, and temperature. However, these parameters mainly affect the type of Cu particles formed during green synthesis [91].
2.2. Factors Affecting the Green Synthesis of Cu and CuO NPs
A few parameters play a crucial role in determining the characteristics of the Cu and CuO NPs synthesized; these include reaction temperature, pH, time, concentration of plant extracts, precursor used, and mixing speed. The reaction medium’s temperature was found to influence the nature of the NPs formed. As the reaction temperature increases, the reaction rate increases, consuming metal ions to form the nuclei of the NPs; this may lead to smaller NP sizes [19]. Generally, green synthesis is conducted below 100 °C or at ambient temperature [20]. NPs can undergo aggregation, shrink, or grow during long-term storage and it also has a shelf life that eventually affects its overall potential [21][22]. Studies have implied that the size of NPs is dependent on the reaction time [23][24][25][26]. It can be seen that increases in the time taken for green synthesis increase the size of the NPs. The biomolecules in plant extracts can act as natural capping and reducing agents during the green synthesis of NPs. These metabolite compositions vary depending on the types and parts of the plant and the extraction procedure [27]. Hence, the volume of plant extracts and the amount of biomolecules present in the plant extract used can affect the synthesis rate due to the availability of these molecules for the rapid bioreduction of metal salts and the stabilization of NPs [28]. The precursor is a salt and alkali metal solution. Numerous soluble copper salts were used in the green synthesis of Cu and CuO NPs. The pH of the reacting mixture in the biosynthesis of NPs is also one of the factors affecting the size of NPs. The optimum pH of the reaction medium ranges from 7–9, suggesting an alkaline condition is favorable for synthesizing NPs [29].
A few parameters play a crucial role in determining the characteristics of the Cu and CuO NPs synthesized; these include reaction temperature, pH, time, concentration of plant extracts, precursor used, and mixing speed. The reaction medium’s temperature was found to influence the nature of the NPs formed. As the reaction temperature increases, the reaction rate increases, consuming metal ions to form the nuclei of the NPs; this may lead to smaller NP sizes [96]. Generally, green synthesis is conducted below 100 °C or at ambient temperature [97]. NPs can undergo aggregation, shrink, or grow during long-term storage and it also has a shelf life that eventually affects its overall potential [99,100]. Studies have implied that the size of NPs is dependent on the reaction time [49,64,73,87]. It can be seen that increases in the time taken for green synthesis increase the size of the NPs. The biomolecules in plant extracts can act as natural capping and reducing agents during the green synthesis of NPs. These metabolite compositions vary depending on the types and parts of the plant and the extraction procedure [102]. Hence, the volume of plant extracts and the amount of biomolecules present in the plant extract used can affect the synthesis rate due to the availability of these molecules for the rapid bioreduction of metal salts and the stabilization of NPs [103]. The precursor is a salt and alkali metal solution. Numerous soluble copper salts were used in the green synthesis of Cu and CuO NPs. The pH of the reacting mixture in the biosynthesis of NPs is also one of the factors affecting the size of NPs. The optimum pH of the reaction medium ranges from 7–9, suggesting an alkaline condition is favorable for synthesizing NPs [107].
3. Application of Cu and CuO NPs
3.1. Antibacterial
Plant-mediated Cu NPs effectively repressed Gram-negative bacteria in urinary tract infection, such as Escherichia coli (E. coli), Enterococcus sp., Proteus sp., and Klebsiella sp. [17]. This implies the potential of these NPs in treating such infection. Cu and CuO NPs have also shown a suppressive effect on the growth of Gram-positive bacteria Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), Bacillus subtilis (B. subtilis), and Streptococcus pyrogenes (S. pyrogenes).
Plant-mediated Cu NPs effectively repressed Gram-negative bacteria in urinary tract infection, such as Escherichia coli (E. coli), Enterococcus sp., Proteus sp., and Klebsiella sp. [62]. This implies the potential of these NPs in treating such infection. Cu and CuO NPs have also shown a suppressive effect on the growth of Gram-positive bacteria Staphylococcus aureus (S. aureus), Bacillus subtilis (B. subtilis), and Streptococcus pyrogenes (S. pyrogenes).
3.2. Antifungal
CuO NPs can induce antifungal properties via different mechanisms (Figure 3).
CuO NPs can induce antifungal properties via different mechanisms ().
Figure 35.
Graphical representation of the proposed mechanism for antifungal activity in response to copper oxide nanoparticles (CuO NPs). The CuO NPs distorted the cell wall of fungus such as Aspergillus flavus. Internalization of these particles induced reactive oxygen species (ROS) generation, which resulted in DNA and mitochondrial damage that contribute to the antifungal activity. Alternatively, the antifungal activity of CuO NPs may be attributed to their antioxidant property.
3.3. Anticancer
Numerous studies have reported the anticancer effect of plant-mediated Cu/CuO NPs, particularly breast [30][31][32][33][34][35][36][37], cervical [31][32][38], colon [30], skin (epithelioma) [32], gastric [39], blood (leukemia) [30], liver [40], lung [32][41][42][43] and ovarian [34] cancers (Table 1).
Numerous studies have reported the anticancer effect of plant-mediated Cu/CuO NPs, particularly breast [37,53,54,66,78,81,111,112], cervical [53,54,79], colon [37], skin (epithelioma) [54], gastric [86], blood (leukemia) [37], liver [65], lung [54,56,69,70] and ovarian [78] cancers ().
Table 14.
Anticancer effects of the plant-derived Cu and CuO NPs biosynthesized.
Types of Cells/ Cell Line |
Cu/CuO NPs |
Toxicity (IC50) (μg/mL) |
Biological Function (Targeting) |
Reference |
Size (nm) |
Shapes |
Breast cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
AMJ-13 |
20–50 |
Spherical |
1.47 |
3.4. Wound Healing and Anti-Inflammatory Activity
Plant-mediated Cu/CuO NPs also demonstrate wound healing and anti-inflammatory properties. Studies indicate the potential of plant-mediated Cu/CuO NPs in reducing inflammation, relieving pain, and promoting wound healing [23][48].
4. Toxicity Evaluation
This aspect should be evaluated thoroughly before utilizing these NPs in medicine. Here, we review the toxicity of plant-based green-synthesized Cu and CuO NPs in vitro and in vivo studies. A previous study has demonstrated that plant-mediated Cu NPs are relatively safe on normal human cell lines (Table 2). These data revealed that the Cu and CuO NPs have minimal toxicity in normal cells, with a cytotoxicity effect on cancer cells at low concentrations, suggesting their safe application. Nevertheless, the toxicity and optimal dosage to be administrated should be evaluated. It is crucial to evaluate the toxicity of plant-mediated CuO NPs in various animal models.
Human embryonic kidney cells |
Human umbilical vein endothelial cells |
5. Comparison of the Efficacy of Plant-Based-Synthesized and Commercial Cu and CuO NPs
It was documented that the efficacy of these NPs in suppressing cancer proliferation was comparable to commercial CuO NPs or was even better in some of the cases (Table 3). These findings imply the potential of plant-based CuO NPs in cancer therapy without causing significant toxicity to normal cells.
Antioxidant, loss of membrane potential, and DNA fragmentation |
[ |
34 | ] | [ | 78 | ] |
MCF-7 |
5–24 |
Cuboidal, spherical, and oval-shaped |
>100 |
ROS generation, loss of mitochondrial membrane potential, apoptosis, and cell cycle arrest |
[33] | [66] |
|
10–40 |
Spherical |
50.3 |
Growth inhibition |
[30] | [37] |
|
12 |
Spherical |
19.77–27.44 (depends on source of plant extract) |
Antioxidant and apoptosis |
[32] | [54] |
|
18.9–45.2 |
Spherical |
53.89 |
Growth inhibition |
[44] | [75] |
|
20 |
Spherical |
85.58 |
Growth inhibition |
[45] | [77] |
|
20 |
Spherical |
24.5 |
ROS generation and antiangiogenic |
[36] | [111] |
|
30–40 |
Spherical, cubical |
35 |
Growth inhibition |
[46] | [52] |
|
36 ± 8 |
Spherical |
21.56 |
ROS and NO generation, apoptosis, DNA fragmentation, induces proinflammatory (TNF-α) cytokines, and inhibits anti-inflammatory cytokine (IL-10) |
[31] | [53] |
|
>200 |
Spherical |
21.5 |
ROS generation and antiangiogenic |
[36] | [111] |
MDA-MB-231 |
10–50 |
Spherical |
30 |
ROS generation |
[35] | [81] |
|
20 |
Spherical |
11 |
ROS generation and antiangiogenic |
[36] | [111] |
|
>200 |
Spherical |
7.5 |
ROS generation and antiangiogenic |
[36] | [111] |
Cervical cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
HeLa |
12 |
Spherical |
26.73–20.32 (depends on the source of plant extract) |
Antioxidant and apoptosis |
[32] | [54] |
|
~26.6 |
Spherical |
~0.5 mg/mL |
ROS generation, loss of mitochondrial membrane potential, and apoptosis |
[38] | [79] |
|
36 ± 8 |
Spherical |
24.74 |
ROS and NO generation, apoptosis, DNA fragmentation, induces proinflammatory (TNF-α) cytokines, and inhibits anti-inflammatory cytokine (IL-10) |
[31] | [53] |
|
60–100 |
Spherical |
119.1 μg/mL |
Growth inhibition |
[47] | [55] |
Colon cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
HT-29 |
10–40 |
Spherical |
33.0 |
Growth inhibition |
[30] | [37] |
Epithelioma |
|
|
|
|
|
Hep-2 |
12 |
Spherical |
21.66–29.58 (depends on source of plant extract) |
Antioxidant and apoptosis |
[32] | [54] |
Gastric cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
AGS |
5–22 |
Spherical |
25–50 |
Apoptosis |
[39] | [86] |
Leukemia |
|
|
|
|
|
MOLT-4 |
10–40 |
Spherical |
>80 |
Growth inhibition |
[30] | [37] |
Liver cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
HepG2 |
23–57 |
Spherical, hexagonal, cubical |
>500 |
Antioxidant |
[40] | [65] |
Lung cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
A549 |
12 |
Spherical |
18.11–37.19 (depends on the source of plant extract) |
Antioxidant and apoptosis |
[32] | [54] |
|
20 |
Spherical |
81.57 |
Growth inhibition |
[45] | [77] |
|
33.47 |
Spherical, irregular |
25 |
Apoptosis |
[41] | [56] |
|
577 |
Spherical |
200 |
Loss of mitochondrial membrane potential, ROS generation, and apoptosis |
[42] | [69] |
|
577 |
Spherical |
200 |
Regulates histone deacetylases, downregulates oncogenes and upregulates tumor suppressor genes, intrinsic and extrinsic apoptosis, and downregulates inflammatory genes (TNF-α and COX-2) |
[43] | [70] |
Ovarian cancer |
|
|
|
|
|
SKOV-3 |
20–50 |
Spherical |
2.27 |
Antioxidant, loss of membrane potential, and DNA fragmentation |
[34] | [78] |
6. Future Perspective in Cancer Therapy of Cu and CuO NPs