The major challenge of follicular IVG is to ensure the growth of the primary follicle, the development of granulosa and theca cells, and subsequently the development of an antrum
[19][29]. Probably the most critical limitation is the failure to maintain the follicular spherical structure, disrupting the cellular interactions between the oocyte and GCs and compromising the further in vitro development. Several of the gap junctions and the intercellular communication between the oocyte and GCs are weakened during in vitro culture
[20][30]. The conventional 2D culture of follicles impedes spherical growth and the preservation of the special arrangements between GCs and the oocyte tend to decrease, leaving the oocyte denuded and unable to complete the maturation process. In longer culture periods as when culturing primordial follicles, the importance of the special arrangements is even greater, leading to an interest in 3D culture to recapitulate the structure and function of the follicles
[21][31].
3.2. Three-Dimensional Culture Systems
During the physiological reproductive cycle process, the ovarian microenvironment is in constant remodeling, providing clues to the potential role of these microenvironmental aspects in this process. Maintenance of the intricate 3D architecture and GCs and oocyte cell interaction may be critical for the successful in vitro maturation of follicles. Respecting its 3D structure is therefore crucial to maintain proper follicular physiology and obtain responses resembling the expected behavior of follicles in vivo. The 3D culture involves the use of the homogeneous hanging drop or hydrogel encapsulation to preserve the architecture. The early antral follicles culture is strongly influenced by the composition and architecture of its supporting tissue. This generates the need to develop extracellular matrixes and biomaterials that could imitate the ovarian physiologic milieu for optimal follicle development
[22][23][32,33].
In addition to the spatial arrangement of the cells, the extracellular matrix (ECM) is a structural support network made up collagen, laminin, and fibrinogen, and is increasingly recognized as a master regulator in the communication between cells and in cell differentiation
[24][34]. Matrices are needed to support follicle growth and maturation in 3D culture systems. Several biomaterials such as collagen, alginate, or Matrigel have been explored as an alternative to mimic the ECM within the ovary and to encapsulate and support human secondary and antral follicles. Although some attempts have been successful for culturing human follicles, collagen presents a few challenges such as a limited transparency for monitoring follicular development or the accelerated shrinkage of this material during prolonged culture. One commercially available ECM tested for follicular growth is Matrigel
[25][26][35,36]. Matrigel is composed of collagen IV, laminin, fibronectin, entactin, and a variety of factors.
3.3. Critical Cell–Cell and Cell–Matrix Interactions for Improved Oocyte Survival and Growth
Nonetheless, 3D culture still presents numerous challenges. For instance, the role of mechanical signaling has been mostly overlooked. There is increasing evidence that physical properties of the ECM play a critical role in follicle development. Indeed, mechanical stiffness may impact cellular proliferation and differentiation and even oocyte-specific gene expression levels in oocytes
[27][53].
Combining different imaging modalities, Ouni et al.
[28][56] studied some biophysical characteristics of the ovary microenvironment at different stages of a woman’s reproductive life, concluding that there is a correlation between rigidity and fertility. This link between ECM stiffness and antrum formation was also demonstrated in a study in rodents with the greatest antrum formation observed at 0.7% alginate hydrogel compared to 1.5 and 3%
[29][40]. In contrast, an opposite link between rigidity and follicle growth was observed in primates, where follicle survival was higher in 0.5 vs. 0.25% calcium alginate
[30][41]. The ovarian stroma of primates is more rigid than that of rodents, which may benefit from stiffer biomaterials. The physical attributes of the 3D matrix selected for IVG need to be tailored to meet species-specific requirements.
Within the ovary, there is an increase in vascularization as we move further away from the ovarian cortex up the medulla where the secondary follicles are, suggesting a strong need of oxygenation during the final follicular stages. The effect of oxygen tension on follicle and oocyte development has received little attention. Follicles have traditionally been grown in standard incubators with an atmospheric oxygen concentration. However, the oxygen pressure in the peritoneal cavity where the ovaries are located is approximately 5% O
2 [31][57]. Primordial follicles exist in the relatively poorly vascularized cortex of the ovary and an abundance of blood vessels is found in the region of the ovary that contains secondary and antral follicles. It is possible that there is a dynamic oxygen transition from relative hypoxia in primordial follicles to a greater oxygen tension in preantral follicles. A lower oxygen tension during IVM improved blastocyst formation using mouse oocytes
[32][58].
4. Organ-on-a-Chip Technology
Although the activation of growth of primordial follicles has been achieved, a limited number of follicles progress to secondary follicles [33][67]. Decent results were obtained in primates using expandable matrixes in 3D systems but the fertilization ability of the oocytes obtained was low and no blastocyst development was observed [34][35][68,69]. One of the reasons for the limited success of this technology can be found in the lack of more appropriate and physiological culture systems because it does not recapitulate the heterogeneous nature of the ECM in the ovary, with the medulla being much softer than the cortex. The ECM is believed to not only provide a 3D network to support the ovarian tissue architecture but also to regulate (together with hormones and nutrients) cell-ECM and cell–cell interactions that are important for follicle development. Choi et al. [36][70] revealed the crucial role of mechanical heterogeneity in the ovary in regulating follicle development by producing ovarian microtissues by encapsulating early secondary preantral follicles in microcapsules consisting of a softer, biodegradable collagen (0.5%) hydrogel core and a harder, slowly degradable alginate (2%) hydrogel shell. Folliculogenesis mainly depends upon hormones and nutrients, and their disturbance can cause abnormal follicle growth. Hence, a precise culture system that ensures the diffusion of nutrients and gases within the tissue, maximizing the retention of essential growth factors of oocyte maturation, is needed.
Considering the aforementioned aspects, a pioneering technology known as Organ-on-a-Chip (OOC) offers the means to replicate tissue architecture and emulate fluidic conditions in an in vitro setting. Broadly, these systems facilitate the miniaturization of experimental models, resulting in several advantages such as reduced working volumes, quicker reaction times, cost-effectiveness, and enhanced precision and control over experimental designs. This innovative approach holds significant promise in advancing research capabilities and improving the efficiency of experimental processes within the field.
OOC platforms, which are founded on microfluidic devices, facilitate three-dimensional organized cell culture by employing various types of ECMs. This methodology aims to emulate tissue architecture and replicate the cellular environment, mechanisms, and physiological responses of organs in an in vitro setting. The microenvironment is established through dynamic interactions among cells, fluids, and the ECM, influencing cellular processes and functions via biophysical and biochemical signals. A distinctive advantage of OOC lies in its ability to operate under flow conditions, enabling the continual replenishment of media, a process that mirrors in vivo blood supply or interstitial flow. Consequently, fluid flow ensures a consistent and adjustable supply of nutrients and oxygen, along with the supplementation of stage-specific growth factors. This dynamic environment sustains physical interactions while preventing cellular stress induced by the formation and accumulation of reactive oxygen substances [37][38][74,75].
Another pertinent aspect of this technology is the capability to tailor the devices based on design specifications including shaped microchannels, compartments, and reservoirs or the materials used to make the devices such as polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS; most prevalent), thermoplastics, or glass. Careful consideration is essential in material selection, as the inherent physicochemical properties of certain materials may impose limitations, including transparency, cost, flexibility or rigidity, and gas permeability, as well as considerations about time-consuming fabrication processes. The choice of material is contingent upon factors such as the intended application of the device, volume requirements, and production costs.
5. Conclusions
Ovarian follicular growth has great potential to restore fertility in young women suffering from cancer or adult women that need an imminent treatment and cannot undergo the cryopreservation of oocytes and embryos, avoiding the transplant and the risk of reintroducing malignant cells. However, the development of an optimal culture system to resemble in vivo folliculogenesis is necessary. The use of a dynamic culture system based on microfluidics, the definition of the mechanical characteristics of the matrix, and a stage-dependent modulation of this matrix composition should be addressed in order to obtain meiotically competent oocytes.
Advanced biomimetic devices such as microfluidic technology combined with ERC matrices may be valuable as a better in vitro culture system to preserve fertility, mimicking the dynamic supply of substances and gases in the ovary and recapitulating the 3D mechanical, physiological, and anatomical milieu in the ovary. This in vitro culture system is an ambitious pathway and is still maturing but may lead to a new assisted reproductive technique for clinical practice. OOC technology could revolutionize the field of reproductive biology.