The investigation of the toxicity mechanism of micro- and nanoplastics (MNPs) is a topic of major concern for the scientific community. The use of transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics has suggested that the main pathways affected by polystyrene (PS) MNPs are related to energy metabolism, oxidative stress, immune response, and the nervous system, both in fishes and aquatic invertebrates.
FISHES | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Method Used | Organism Tested | PS MNPs Size | Concentration Tested | Time of Exposure | Organ/Tissue Target | Life Stage | Effect | References |
qRT-PCR | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
10 µm | 200 particles/mL | 120 hpf | Whole organism | Larvae | ↑ sod1, sod2, cat, gst and cyp | [35] |
qRT-PCR | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
500 nm | 0.1, 1 and 10 ppm | 96 hpf | Whole organism | Larvae | ↑ p53, cas-3 and cas-9; ↓ bcl and bdnf | [46][49] |
qRT-PCR | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
30 nm | 0.1, 0.5 and 3 ppm | |||||
Adult | ||||||||
↑ antioxidant genes at 1 µg/mL PS-COOH. ↓ | ||||||||
sod | ||||||||
at 1 µg/mL PS-NH | ||||||||
2, | ||||||||
↑ | ||||||||
mt | ||||||||
at both the concentrations tested PS-NH | ||||||||
2 | ||||||||
. ↑ the immune-related gene | ||||||||
NF-kB | ||||||||
and | ||||||||
LBP/BPI | ||||||||
by PS-NH | ||||||||
2 | ||||||||
[ | ||||||||
30 | ||||||||
] | ||||||||
FISHES | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Method Used | Organism Tested | PS MNPs Size | Concentration Tested | Time of Exposure | Organ/Tissue Target | Life Stage | Effect | References |
ELISA | Danio rerio |
FISHES | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Method Used | Organism Tested | PS MNPs Size | Concentration Tested | Time of Exposure | Organ/Tissue Target | Life Stage | Effect | References | |||||||||||||||||
(zebrafish) | 50 and 500 nm | 0.1, 1, 10 mg/L | 12 and 72 hpa | Whole organism | Larvae | Slight ↑ Il-10, Tnf-α and Nf-κB at the lowest dose. ↓ Il-10, Tnf-α, FgF20a and Nf-κB at the higher dose | |||||||||||||||||||
1H NMR | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
5 µm | 50 and 500 μg/L | 21 d | Intestine | Adult (5 months) |
Changes in 36 metabolites. ↑ proline, propylene glycol, alanine, glutamine, leucine, ornithine, carnitine, threonine, TMAO; ↓ lysine, phenylalanine, tyrosine, | [76][88] | |||||||||||||||||
linoleic acid, palmitic acid, triglycerides. | [ | 31 | ] | WB | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
||||||||||||||||||||
GC-MS | Danio rerio | 5 µm | 50 ng/mL |
(zebrafish) | 100 nm | 250 and 2 × 107 d | 4Whole organism | Larvae | ↑ iNOS and Nf-κB | items of PS MNPs in 50 mL | 72 hpf | Whole organism | Embryo | Changes in 508 metabolites. Disorders in unsaturated fatty acids, linoleic acid, taurine, hypotaurine, nicotinate, nicotinamide, alanine, aspartate, glutamate.[77][89] | |||||||||||
[ | 22 | ] | 120 hpf | Whole organism | Larvae | ↑ | sod1, sod2 | , cas-1, cas-8, and il1β; ↓ hsp70, bcl-2, ache, DNA repair genes gadd45α and rad51 | AQUATIC INVERTEBRATES | [ | |||||||||||||||
GC-MS | Danio rerio (zebrafish) | 47 | ] | [ | 5–50 μm | 50 | ] | ||||||||||||||||||
100 and 1000 μg/L | 7 d | Whole organism | Embryo | Changes in 78 (5 μm) and 121 (50 μm) metabolites. Disorders in carbohydrates, fatty acids, amino acids, nucleic acids and others. | [ | 102 | ] | [114] | qRT-PCR | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
1 µm | 1000 µg/L (around 1.91 × 107 particles/L) | 96 hpf | Whole organism | Larvae | WB↑ | Brachionus koreanus (marine rotifer)il1β; ↓ cat |
[ | |||||||
LC-MS/MS | 0.05 and 0.5 μm | Danio rerio | 10 µg/mL | 48 | 24 h |
(zebrafish) Perca fluviatilis (perch) | ] | [51] | |||||||||||||||||
5–12 µm | 1, 50 e 100 mg | Whole organism | 21 d | Neonates | ↑ phosphorylation of JNK and p38 Mapk related to ↑ ROS level | Gills and liver | Adult | Changes in 33 metabolites. Zebrafish gills: ↓ phenylalanine, carnitine, proline, salicylic and lactic acid, choline. Perch gills: ↑ phenylalanine, salicylic acid; ↓ acetyl-carnitine, alanine, glutamic and pyruvic acid. Zebrafish liver: ↑ adenine, adenosine, glutamine; ↓ hypoxanthine, uridine, deoxyadenosine, valine, arginine, phenylalanine, asparagine, proline. Perch liver: ↑ arginine, succinic acid, adenosine; ↓ hypoxanthine, oxoglutaric acid, citrulline, creatinine, adenine[78][90] |
qRT-PCR and RNA-seq | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
5 μm | 20–100 μg/L | 21 d | ||||||||||||
[ | 103 | ] | [ | 115 | ] | Liver | Adult | ↑ aco and fabp6; ↓ cpt1, ppar-α, acc1, fas, srebp1α, ppar-α. KEGG pathways analysis revealed carbon, lipid and amino acid metabolism effect |
[49][52] | ||||||||||||||||
LC-MS/MS | Crassostrea gigas (Pacific oyster) |
2 and 6 μm | 0.023 mg/L | ||||||||||||||||||||||
LC-MS | Gobiocypris rarus (rare minnow) |
1 μm | 60 d | Oocytes | Gamets | ↓ arginine kinase and ↑ severin | 200 μg/L | 4 w | Liver | Subadult (3 months)[18 |
Changes in 41 metabolites. ↑ glyceraldehyde; cytosine, glucose, fructose, mannose; ↓ mannitol 1-phosphate, acetyl-phenylalanine, mannonate] | ||||||||||||||
[ | 104 | ] | [ | 116 | ] | RNA-seq | LC-MS/MSDanio rerio (zebrafish) |
Daphnia magnasize ranging from 25 to 90 µm | |||||||||||||||||
UPLC-Q-TOF-MS | (water flea) | Oreochromis | 100–1000 µg/L | 20 d |
Liver | Adult | Alteration in pathways related to immune response and lipid metabolism, i.e., sterol biosynthetic process, steroid metabolic process and fatty acid metabolic process | Mean particle size 13.03 ± 7.75 μm | mossambicus 101.6 mg/L[50][53 |
(tilapia) | 100 nm19 d | Whole organism] | |||||||||||||
Adult | Changes in 41 proteins, mostly those related to sulfation, chitin-binding and cuticle’s structural integrity. The less abundant proteins are related to pigment binding, response to stimuli, response to ROS, response to oxidative stress, and response to oxygen-containing compound | [ | 79 | ] | 20 mg/L and recovery | [ | 91 | ] | |||||||||||||||||
7 d | Whole organism | Larvae | Changes in 203 metabolites. Disorders in fatty acyls, carboxylic acids and their derivatives, organooxygen compounds, keto acids and their derivatives. | [ | 105 | ] | [ | 117] | RNA-seq | Danio rerio (zebrafish) |
50 and 200 nm, | RPLC/MS | Daphnia pulex (water flea)100–1000 ppb |
5 d | Whole organism | Larvae | Nervous system development and function pathways | [51][54] | |||||||
LC-MS | Oreochromis niloticus | 500 nm | 1 mg/L |
(red tilapia) | 0.3, 5 and 70–90 μm14 d |
Whole organism | Adult | Changes in 89 proteins, including those involved in P-body assembly, nuclear-transcribed mRNA catabolic process, ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling, energy metabolism and unfolded protein responses | [80][92] | ||||||||||||||||
100 μg/L | 14 d | Liver | Adult | Changes in 31 (0.3 μm), 40 (5 μm) and 23 (70–90 μm) metabolites. Disorders in amino acids, fatty acids, glycerophosphoethanolamines, glycerophosphoserines, glycerophosphocholines, purine nucleosides, eicosanoids. | [ | 106 | ] | [118] | qRT-PCR | Oncorhynchus mykiss (rainbow trout) |
100–400 µm | 500–2411 particles/fish/day | 4 w | Intestine | Adult | No change in immune response related genes | [ | LC-MS/MS52 | Daphnia pulex (water flea)][55 |
Mean particle size 71.18 nm] | |||||
0.5–2 mg/L | 21 d | Whole organism | Adult | 327 proteins ↓, including those involved in cell signaling, immune function, detoxification, energy metabolism, ECM-receptor interaction pathways, and glutathione metabolism | [ | 81 | |||||||||||||||||||
1H NMR | ] | [ | Oryzias javanicus (Javanese medaka) | 93 | ] | ||||||||||||||||||||
5 μm | 100, 500 and 1000 μg/L | 21 d | Gut | Adult | Changes in 9 metabolites. ↑ glucose, lactate, alanine, glutamate, glucoronate, valine, anserine, 2-hydroxyvalerate, creatine. | [ | 107 | ][119] | qRT-PCR | Oncorhynchus mykiss (rainbow trout) |
0.2, 1, 20, 40 and 90 μm | 2 × 105 particles/L | 2 h | Gills | Adult | nLC-MS/MS | Dreissena polymorpha (Zebra mussel)↑ |
1 and 10 μm size | 4 × 106 particles/L mixturesifnγ gene exposed to 0.2 and 40 μm beads; ↓ il1β | 6 d (bead size 1 μm), | Gillss100a | Adult (bead size 40 μm) and saa (1, 40 and 90 μm) | [53 | 78 proteins ↓ and 18 proteins not expressed. Effect of catalytic activity (27%), nucleotide binding, proteins involved in structural molecule activity (12%) and protein binding (11%), proteins related to RNA (5%) and metal ion (4%) bindings | [82] |
GC-MS | Oryzias melastigmas (marine medaka) | ] | [ | 94 | ] | ||||||||||||||||||||
10 and 200 μm | 10 mg/L | [ | 56 | ] | |||||||||||||||||||||
60 d | Liver | Adult | (8 months) | Changes in 83 metabolites. ↑ disaccharides, trisaccharides, fatty acids, fatty acid methyl and ethyl esters; ↓ monosaccharides, organic acids, amino acid. | [ | 108 | ][120] | qRT-PCR | LC-MS/MSOryzias melastigma (marine medaka) |
plain PS, carboxylated PS: PS-COOH and aminated PS: PS-NH2 with a size of 1 μm | 0.02 mg/L | 7 d | Litopenaeus vannamei Whole organism |
(Pacific white shirmp) | 100–200 μmLarvae | ↓ cox1 and cox2 | 1 mg/L by PS, PS-COOH and PS-NH2; ↓ cyp1a, multifunction gene (ATPase) by PS-NH2 and PS-COOH, respectively. No impairment of oxidative stress genes in all the treatments | 14 d[ | Haemolymph54 | Adult | 47 proteins ↓, including those belonging to extracellular, plasma membrane and lysosomal localization, and related to T cell receptor signaling pathway, epithelial cell signaling in Helicobacter pylori infection, and phospholipase D signaling pathway][57] | ||||
LC-MS/MS | Sebastes Schlegelii (marine jacopever) | 5 μm and 100 nm | 0.23 mg/L | 15 d | Liver | Juvenile | Changes in 345 metabolites. Disorders in essential amino acids, omega-3 fatty acids, intermediate products of glucose metabolism and TCA intermediates. ↓ gluconic acid, cis-aconitate, malic acid, tyrosine, targinine, glycerol phospholipid | [83][95] | |||||||||||||||||
[ | 109 | ] | [ | 121 | ] | RNA-seq and qRT-PCR | Oryzias melastigma (marine medaka) |
0.05, 0.50, and 6.00 μm | 0.1; 1 × 103; 1 × 106 particles/mL |
19 d | Whole organism | Nano HPLC MS/MS | Paracentrotus lividus (sea urchin)Larvae |
45 μm | 10, 50, 103, 104 particles/L↓ inflammatory and immune-related signaling pathways (Hippo, B cell receptor, RIG-I-like receptor, and inflammatory mediator regulation of the TRP-channels-signaling pathway); heart development (↓ gata4 and nkx2.5 | 72 h, and ↑ bmp4) hatching enzyme (hce and | Coelomocyteslce) | Adult | ↑ proteins involved in endosome transport via multivesicular body sorting pathway and in establishment of protein localisation, and proteins involved in catabolic processes | ||||||
LC-MS | Xiphophorus helleri (swordtail fish) |
1 μm | 1 × 106 microspheres/L (B) and 1 × 107 microspheres/L (C) | [ | 55 | ] | [ | 58] | |||||||||||||||||
[ | 72 h | 34 | Liver | ] | |||||||||||||||||||||
Adult | (3 months) | Changes in 37 (B) and 103 (C) metabolites. ↑ 3-hydroxyanthranilic acid, histidine, citrulline, linoleic acid, pantothenate, xanthine. | AQUATIC INVERTEBRATES | ||||||||||||||||||||||
WB | Paracyclopina nana (marine copepod) |
0.05 μm | 10 µg/mL | 24 h | Whole organism | Neonates | Oxidative stress induction (↑ ROS level) and ↑ phosphorilation of the proteins p38 Mapk, ERK and Nrf2 | [84][96] | qRT-PCR | Artemia franciscana (brine shrimp) |
50 nm PS-NH2 | 1 μg/mL | 14 d | Whole organism | Adult | ↑ clap and cstb genes | [56][59] | ||||||||
LC-MS/MS | Tigriopus japonicus (marine copepod) |
6 μm | 0.23 mg/L | Two generations (F1 and F2) | Whole organism | Adult | ↑ proteins involved in several cellular biosynthesis and ↓ cellular energy storage in F1 generation. Transgenerational proteome plasticity in F2 generation with elevated energy metabolism and stress related defense | [85][97] | RNA-seq | Artemia franciscana (brine shrimp) |
5 µm | 1 mg/L | 14 d | Whole organism | Adult |
[ | |||||||||||||||||
110 | |||||||||||||||||
] | |||||||||||||||||
[ | |||||||||||||||||
122 | |||||||||||||||||
] | |||||||||||||||||
AQUATIC INVERTEBRATES | |||||||||||||||||
LC-MS/MS | |||||||||||||||||
Crassostrea gigas | (Pacific oyster) |
6 and 50/60 μm | 1 × 104 particles/L | 14 d | Gills | Adult | Changes in 22 metabolites. ↑ asparagine, phenylalanine, glutathione, glucose-6-phosphate, carbohydrates, lactose, mannose; ↓ N-palmitoyl taurine, fatty acids. | [111][123] | |||||||||
1H NMR | Daphnia magna (water flea) |
53 nm (PS-NH2), 62 nm (PS-COOH) | 3.2 μg/L | 37 d | Whole organism | Adult | KEGG enrichment analysis mapped into arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy, viral myocarditis, hypertrophic cardiomyopathy, phagosome, fluid shear stress, atherosclerosis and regulations of actin cytoskeleton, with most of the DEGs correlated with ROS activity and apoptosis activity | [57][ | Changes in 15 metabolites. ↑ alanine, asparagine, glutamate, glutamine, isoleucine, leucine, lysine, phenyl alanine, tyrosine, valine, lactate, methionine sulfoxide; ↓ glucose, glycogen, nucleic acids, isopropanol.60] | ||||||||
[ | 112 | ] | [ | 124 | ] | qRT-PCR | Artemia franciscana | ||||||||||
LC-MS/MS | (brine shrimp) | Litopenaeus vannamei 50 nm PS-NH2 |
1 μg/mL | 48 h and 14 d | (whiteleg shrimp)Whole organism | Neonates and adult | Time-dependent ↑ clap and cstb genes and hsp60 and hsp70 | [58] | 2 μm[ | 0.02 to 1 mg/L | 72 h61 | Hepatopancreas] | |||||
Post-larvae | Changes in 119 metabolites. ↑ amino acids and dipeptides, e.g., taurine, aspartic acid and alanine; ↓ glyceraldehyde and fatty acids, e.g., 3-methyladipic acid and leucinic acid. | [ | 113 | ] | [ | 125 | ] | RNA-seq | Ciona robusta (ascidian) |
50 nm PS-NH2 | 10 and 15 μg/mL | 22 hpf | Whole organism | Embryos | ↓ genes involved in glutathione metabolism (glutamate--cysteine ligase catalytic subunit-like transcript variant X1 and X2; glutathione S-transferase omega-1-like), immune defense (integumentary mucin C.1-like transcript variant; mucin-5AC transcript variant; interferon-induced protein 44-like; plasminogen-like), nervous system (acetylcholinesterase-like; sco-spondin), transport by aquaporins (aquaporin-like) and energy metabolism (succinate--CoA ligase [ADP/GDP-forming] subunit alpha mitochondrial-like; 6-phosphofructo-2-kinase/fructose-26-bisphosphatase 1 transcript variant; glycoside hydrolase transcript variant) | [24] | |
1H NMR | Mytilus galloprovincialis (Mediterranean mussel) |
3 μm | 50 particles/mL | 72 h | Gills and hepatopancreas |
Changes in 10 (in gills) and 18 (in hepotopancreas) metabolites. Gills: ↑acetoacetate, ATP/ADP, mytilitol, betaine, taurine, homarine; ↓ alanine, glycine, succinate, acetylcholine. Hepatopancreas: ↑ isoleucine, leucine, valine, alanine, dimethylglycine, tyrosine, lactate, glycogen, glucose, betaine, taurine, homarine, glutathione; ↓ glycine, acetoacetate, succinate, malonate, hypotaurine. |
[32][36][32,36] | qRT-PCR | Daphnia magna (water flea) |
50 nm | 0.05, 0.5 μg/L | 21 d | Whole organism | Adult | ↓ cat after exposure of 21 d to 0.5 μg/mL | [59][62] | |
qRT-PCR | Daphnia pulex (water flea) |
75 nm | 0.1, 0.5, 1, 2 mg/L | 21 d | Whole organism | Adult | Sod, gst, gpx and cat initially ↑ and then inhibited. ↑ hsp in all the treatment groups | [60][63] | |||||||||
RNA-seq | Daphnia pulex (water flea) |
~70 nm | 1 mg/L (5.32 × 108 particles/mL) |
96 h | Whole organism | Neonates | Alterations in oxidative stress (arachidonic acid metabolism, glutathione metabolism, and porphyrin and chlorophyll metabolism), immune response (drug metabolism–cyp450 and other enzymes, metabolism of xenobiotics by cyp450, glutathione metabolism, hippo signaling pathway, and adherens junction) and energy metabolism pathways (starch and sucrose metabolism, pentose and glucuronate interconversions, galactose metabolism, fructose and mannose metabolism, carbohydrate digestion and absorption, and glycolysis/gluconeogenesis) | [61][64] | |||||||||
RNA-seq | Daphnia pulex (water flea) |
75 nm | 1 mg/L | 21 d | Whole organism | Adult | Alteration in genes involved in chitin metabolism, trehalose transport and metabolism, growth-related genes, long-chain fatty acids metabolism, defense mechanisms, and sex differentiation | [62][65] | |||||||||
qRT-PCR | Litopenaeus vannamei (whiteleg shrimp) |
100 nm | 200 and 2000 mg/kg | 14 and 28 d | Hepatopancreas | Adult | ↑ Beta-glucan binding protein, LPS/β-glucan binding protein, and hsp90 genes. ↑ TLR gene | [63][66] | |||||||||
RNA-seq | Meretrix meretrix (marine clam) |
100 nm PS-NH2 200 nm PS-COOH |
2 mg/L | 7 d | Digestive gland |
Adult | ↑ energy homeostasis imbalance (e.g., lipid metabolism, PPAR signaling pathway, protein digestion and absorption, pyruvate metabolism, and glycolysis; Impairment of immune system (e.g., NLRs, NF-κB signaling pathway, TLR signaling pathway, phagosome, lysosome, and apoptosis) | [64][67] | |||||||||
qRT-PCR | Mytilus galloprovincialis (Mediterranean mussel) |
50 nm PS-NH2 | 0.150 mg/L | 24 and 48 hpf | Whole organism | Embryos | ↓ cs, ca, and ep genes | [25] | |||||||||
qRT-PCR | Mytilus galloprovincialis (Mediterranean mussel) |
3 µm | 50–500 particles/mL | 24 and 48 hpf | Whole organism | Embryos | ↑ ep, ca, and cs genes; ↑ mytc and mytb genes; ↓ gusb, hex, ctsl genes |
[65][68] | |||||||||
qRT-PCR | Mytilus galloprovincialis (Mediterranean mussel) |
50 nm PS-NH2 | 10 μg/L | First exposure 24 h, rest period 72 h, second exposure 24 h | Hemocytes | Adult | ↑ epp, lyso, amps, mytb, mytc, frep | [66][69] | |||||||||
qRT-PCR | Paracentrotus lividus (sea urchin) |
50 nm PS-NH2 | 3 μg/mL | 24 and 48 hpf | Whole organism | Embryos | ↑ cas8 | [19] | |||||||||
qRT-PCR | Paracentrotus lividus (sea urchin) |
50 nm PS-NH2 | 3 and 4 μg/mL | 24 and 48 hpf | Whole organism | Embryos | ↑ hsp70, p38 Mapk, univin and cas8 | [20] | |||||||||
RNA-seq | Pinctada margaritifera (black-lip pearl oyster) |
6 and 10 µm | 0.25–2.5–25 μg/L | 2 months | Mantle | Adult | Alteration in energy, stress, and immune-related genes. ↓ cyp2d11, gst1, sult1c4 and abcb1, cel and actin gene | [67][70] | |||||||||
RNA-seq | Procambarus clarkia (red swamp crayfish) |
0.10 μm | 1.4 × 1011 particles/L | 72 h | Hemocytes and hepatopancreas |
Adult | In hemocytes, ↑ 8 DEGs involved in gene transcription and translation. In hepatopancreas, differential expression of only 3 genes (cyp49a1 and two unknown genes) | [68][71] | |||||||||
qRT-PCR | Sterechinus neumayeri (Antarctic sea urchin) |
40 nm PS-COOH 50 nm PS-NH2 |
1 and 5 μg/mL | 6 and 24 h | Coelomocytes |