Bio-Based Polyurethane Elastomers: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Manuel Burelo and Version 2 by Camila Xu.

Elastomers, a category of polymers characterized by high elasticity and viscoelasticity, possess the ability to revert to their initial form after undergoing stretching or deformation and are known for their outstanding resistance to abrasion, tearing, and impact.

  • bio-based elastomer
  • rubbers
  • polyurethane
  • polyester
  • polyether
  • elastomeric properties

1. Introduction

According to PlasticsEurope AISBL©, the global plastics production data in 2021 was 390.7 Mt, and in 2022, it was 400.3 Mt; where Africa produced 9%, Europe 14%, America 21%, and Asia 56%, with China being the country with the highest plastic production, with about 32%. These include conventional plastics and thermoplastics such as PET, PE, PP, PVC, PS, and PU, as well as some thermoset plastics [1][2][1,2]. The production and consumption of conventional plastics and polymers show an increase year after year.
Elastomers, a category of polymers characterized by high elasticity and viscoelasticity, possess the ability to revert to their initial form after undergoing stretching or deformation and are known for their outstanding resistance to abrasion, tearing, and impact. Elastomers find applicability across various industries, including automotive, aerospace, construction, electronics, healthcare, and biomedicine [3][4][5][3,4,5]. There are two types of elastomers: thermoplastic elastomers (TPEs) (e.g., thermoplastic polyester elastomers, thermoplastic polyether elastomers, thermoplastic polyurethane elastomer, thermoplastic polyamide elastomers) and thermosets (e.g., vulcanized natural or industrial rubber, epoxidized natural rubber, cross-linked polyester elastomers, cross-linked polyurethane elastomers). Thermoset elastomers predominate in production and consumption. The elastomer industry encompasses three primary kinds: rubber, plastic, and gel. Rubber elastomers, crafted from natural or synthetic polymers, are renowned for their remarkable elasticity and durability. In contrast, plastic elastomers or TPE represent a fusion of rubber and plastic, delivering a harmonious combination of flexibility and rigidity [3][4][3,4]. Currently, polymers, including elastomers, are non-recyclable and come from non-renewable sources [5]. Due to this, the synthesis of elastomers from natural and renewable resources has attracted the attention of researchers and industries.
By the definition provided by the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry (IUPAC), the term “bio-based” refers to “materials that are either entirely or partially composed of biological products originating from biomass. This encompasses materials derived from plant, animal, marine, or forestry sources” [6]. In environmental terms, bio-based polymers possess the capacity to mitigate greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, particularly carbon dioxide (CO2). This reduction occurs because, during the synthesis process using natural resources as raw materials, plants absorb atmospheric CO2 for their growth. As a result, bio-based polymers contribute to a net reduction in atmospheric CO2 levels [7].
A bio-based polymer originates from natural and/or renewable sources, typically derived from biomass, and is recognized for its environmentally friendly characteristics. It exhibits a shorter environmental decomposition time, influenced by both abiotic and biotic factors [8]. This polymer or elastomer may consist partially or entirely of bio-based components, such as a mixture, composite, copolymer, graft, additive, or by employing natural monomers in the synthesis (biopolymer). A higher percentage of bio-based content indicates a more sustainable material, often associated with biodegradable and compostable behavior [9].

2. Bio-Based Elastomers from Natural and Industrial Rubbers

Synthetic elastomers used in tires are derived mainly from petrochemicals, which are not sustainable. Recently, renewable resources have been used to produce several bio-based elastomers. For example, itaconic acid is a renewable resource from fermentations produced by microorganisms, especially Aspergillus terreus; it is used as a bio-based building block. Lei et al. have manufactured silica/poly(di-n-butyl itaconate-co-butadiene) (20–80% butadiene) nanocomposite-based green tires that are prepared by redox-initiated copolymerization of di-n-butyl itaconate and butadiene. These bio-based elastomers have excellent wet skid and low roll resistances, respectively [10]. It is essential to say that not all bio-based polymers are biodegradable (capability of being degraded by biological activity); for example, bio-based plastics such as the bio-polyethylene (Bio-PE) and Bio-poly(ethylene terephthalate) (Bio-PET) that use bioethanol from sugarcane (by the fermentation of glucose) [8][11][12][8,11,12], starch-based crops produced by wet-mill processing as raw material [13][14][13,14], the chemical modification of natural rubbers (NR) that have been modified to improve their properties and application, as well as the epoxidized NR under strain-induced crystallization (SIC) [15], are all non-biodegradable polymers. In particular, natural rubber (NR) is a polymer composed of isoprene units linked to form double bonds with a cis configuration (99.9%, cis-1,4-polyisoprene) when extracted from the latex of the Hevea brasiliensis trees and Parthenium argentatum woody shrub [16][17][18][16,17,18]; trans configuration extracted from the latex of the Palaquium gutta trees (trans-1,4-polyisoprene) [17][19][17,19]; and cis/trans isomer mixtures extracted from the latex of the Manilkara zapota trees [17][18][20][17,18,20]. NR (99.9%, cis-1,4-polyisoprene) is widely employed in the fabrication of tires, construction industries, and biomedical applications. NR possesses unique properties due to its low modulus and high elasticity and can rapidly recover its original state upon release of external stress [18]. Based on reprocessability, bio-based NR can introduce bio-based chemically crosslinked thermoplastics. The bio-based chemically crosslinked/cross-linkable elastomers (CCEs) from NR and synthetic elastomers derived from bio-based monomers have been reported. CCEs possess better resilience and higher operating temperatures due to covalent three-dimensional (3D) networks [4][21][22][23][24][4,21,22,23,24]. Several dicarboxylic acids are used as green crosslinkers to react with ENR (Figure 1).
Figure 1.
Crosslinked epoxidized natural rubber (ENR) with dicarboxylic acid.
Srirachya et al. investigated a crosslinking agent for ENR. They demonstrated that it was possible to crosslink ENR with maleic anhydride thermally; no additional catalysts were needed [21]. Riyajan et al. studied the influence on the physical properties, including the swelling behavior, tensile strength, and thermal stability of the vulcanization of ENR latex using a terephthalic acid crosslinker. It was observed that the ENR crosslinked with terephthalic acid depolymerized in natural soil compared to natural rubber vulcanized with sulfur [22]. Pire et al. crosslinked the epoxidized NR by dodecanedioic acid with 1,2-dimethylimidazole. The authors explain that 1,2-Dimethylimidazole accelerates crosslinking, and imidazolium dicarboxylate species are formed to reach the less substituted side of the epoxy site [23][24][23,24]. Generally, the ENR crosslinked with dicarboxylic acids improves mechanical properties compared to those vulcanized by sulfur because carbon–oxygen crosslinks possess higher bond energies than sulfur ones [25].

Bio-Based Elastomers with Essential Oils

Citric fruits (Rutaceae family) are the most commonly cultivated and consumed fruits worldwide. According to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO), global overall citrus fruit production in 2020 was around 158.49 million metric tons [26]. The major citrus-producing countries include China, Brazil, and the United States of America. Approximately 40–60% of the fruit is discarded as waste upon consumption. In general, the industrial production of citrus fruits generates 110–120 million tons of citrus waste yearly, such as peels (flavedo and albedo), seeds, and pomace [27][28][29][27,28,29]. It is possible to extract limonoids, essential oils, phenols, flavonoids, carotenoids, and cellulose from these wastes. Significantly, essential oils can be obtained from the peels and seeds of citrus fruit waste, and they are considered potent bio-resource materials for various uses in the food and non-food sectors. Also, these substances are considered plant-based natural products consisting of volatile and aromatic compounds present at low concentrations. Essential oils are compounds made up of isoprene units attached to 10-carbon and 15-carbon structures known as monoterpenoids and sesquiterpenoids, respectively. These compounds are typically found in the oil sacs of citrus peels and cuticles, as shown in Figure 2 [29].
Figure 2.
Essential oils in the citrus peels and cuticle of the citrus fruit.
Essential oils or citrus oils have the characteristics of being low in toxicity, inexpensive, and can be obtained by several extraction techniques such as steam distillation and solvent extraction [30][31][30,31]. They are mainly used in the pharmaceutical industry to obtain active ingredients, the cosmetics industry in perfume production, food for flavoring preparation, and the chemical industry in packaging materials production, among others. In the bio-based elastomers elaboration, essential oils have significantly modified natural rubber and some industrial elastomers. Terpenes have emerged as viable candidates to serve as monomers in bio-based elastomer production. The most common type of bio-based elastomers from terpene is β-Myrcene, which is extracted by hops, bay, and thyme oils or can be obtained by pyrolysis from β-pinene [32]. β-Myrcene has two conjugated double bonds in its structure and can be polymerized similarly to its isoprene via anionic, free-radical, coordination, and cationic reactions. These polymerization reactions can have several possibilities for 1,2-; 3,4-; and 1,4-cis or trans myrcene isomerization to obtain elastomers with similar mechanical and thermal properties to NR (Hevea brasiliensis, Palaquium gutta, and Manilkara zapota trees). In 1960, Marvel studied the polymerization of myrcene by Ziegler-type catalysts (triisobutylaluminum, TiCl4, and vanadium trichloride) with a predominantly 1,4 arrangement of the diene unit in the polymer chain, with conversions of 80% of the polymyrcene [33]. It has been reported the stereoselective polymerization of β-myrcene and β-ocimene and their copolymerization with styrene using homogeneous titanium catalysts activated by MAO (methylaluminoxane) showing different stereoselectivity, for example, 1,4-trans-poly myrcene (92%) and its copolymerization with styrene using dichloro{1,4-dithiabutanediyl-2,2′-bis(4,6-di-tert-butyl-phenyl)}titanium complex, and 1,4-cis-poly myrcene (92%) in the presence of Ti(η5-C5H5)-(η2-2,2′-methylene bis(6-tert-butyl-4-methylphenoxo))Cl complexes were obtained. Also, these catalysts were used in the β-ocimene polymerization. Other terpenes are ocimene (which can be produced from the thermal cracking of β-pinene) and farnesene (which can be found in nature like α- and β-isomers); however, farnesene can be obtained through the fermentation of sugar feedstocks [34]. When using the last catalysts with ocimene and a high temperature (70 °C), the 1,4-trans polymer (70%) is formed, while at a lower temperature, an isotactic poly-1,2-ocimene (>99%) was obtained [35]. On the other hand, Lamparelli et al. have reported that the soluble heterocomplexes consisting of sodium hydride in combination with trialkylaluminium derivatives have been used as anionic initiating in the polymerization of myrcene and its copolymerization with styrene and isoprene [36][37][36,37]. It is well known that NR and industrial elastomers such as polybutadiene (PB) and poly(styrene-butadiene-styrene) (SBS) are materials used in the production of tires, adhesives, and rubber bands, among others. The properties of elastomers are amorphous polymers found above their glass transition (Tg), which explains their deformability. Authors have demonstrated that modified elastomers such as NR are proposed to expand the application [38]. It has been reported that d-limonene, β-pinene terpenes, some menthol, β-citronellol, and citral terpenoids, mainly extracted from turpentine, lemon, mandarin, orange, mint, citronella oils, citral, and other terpenes, contain in their structure carbon–carbon double bonds, and they are used in the natural rubber modification via metathesis reactions [39][40][41][42][39,40,41,42]. Some reports have shown that d-limonene, considered the most abundant component in mandarin (74%), lemon (87%), and orange (97%) essential oils, is used as a chain transfer agent (CTA) in the cross-metathesis reaction of NR in the presence of ruthenium carbene-alkylidene and vinylidene complex catalysts (Figure 3). These two classes of catalysts tolerate a wide range of functional groups (e.g., amino, carboxyl, acetoxy, ester, hydroxy, fluorine, and chlorine), and they are active with more sterically hindered substrates such as natural rubber [43][44][45][43,44,45].
Figure 3.
Synthesis of bio-based NR with d-limonene via
cross
-metathesis.
NR modification with limonene and mandarin oils via cross-metathesis allows the synthesis of mono-terminated or terpene-terminated oligomers (Table 1) with low molecular weight around Mn × 102 g × mol−1 and yields of 80% when the catalyst Grubbs-2 is used (entries 1 and 3). In contrast, with Grubbs-1 and vinylidene-II and -III catalysts [40], the molecular weights of terpene-terminated oligomers are around Mn × 104 g × mol−1 with yields ranging from 70–96% (entries 2, 7, and 8).
Table 1. Examples of terpene-terminated oligomers (bio-based elastomers) obtained by cross-metathesis reaction of NR and SBS with d-limonene and essential oils using Ru-carbene complexes.