Current Aviation Fuel Production: Comparison
Please note this is a comparison between Version 1 by Vikas and technical activities Sharma and Version 2 by Wendy Huang.

For jet fuel, the aviation industry primarily uses two types of fuel: aviation gasoline and aviation kerosene. Aviation gasoline, also known as AVGAS, is derived from the distillation of crude oil in the range between 30 and 170 °C. AVGAS is normally used in small aircraft, such as private aviation, agricultural, and pilot training. Aviation kerosene is also a petroleum distillation product obtained in the range between 150 and 300 °C. This fuel is more suitable in aircraft engines for energy generation through combustion, used in many commercial and military aircraft.

  • aviation
  • fuel
  • aviation gasoline
  • aviation kerosene
  • distillation
  • specification
  • standards

1. Introduction

The rapid growth of the aviation industry, in recent decades, as well as airport expansions, has exacerbated aviation’s role in climate change and environmental protection [1]. Annually, about 3.1 billion people and 51.7 million tonnes of cargo are operated by 1000 commercial airlines, using approximately 15,000 aircrafts [2]. This has led to an annual 3.5–4.5% increase in hydrocarbon fuel consumption [3]. To meet the 2050 carbon reduction targets, improving aircraft fuel carbon-neutrality and emissions are critical [4].
Aircraft engine exhaust comprises up to 8% CO2 (approximately 900 Mt CO2) water vapour, NOx (0.03%), UHC, CO, and SO2 [5]. In 2010, the share of total global GHG emissions from the air transport sector was 4% and 6%, respectively, for domestic and international flights [6]. Although these numbers seem relatively low because the emissions are at high altitude, the NOx generated in the upper atmosphere leads to ozone production and is, therefore, likely to be more damaging than these figures initially suggest. Hence, to reduce the aviation carbon emission with sustainable energy efficiency, sustainable aviation fuel (SAF), such as algal-based biofuel, will be the key for this industry [7]. Such an alternative could potentially reduce the life cycle of CO2 emissions by up to 80% by 2050, compared to 2005 [6]. Fuel sustainability criteria must include: (1) suitability for existing aircraft engines, (2) no modifications in infrastructure, (3) must produce low life cycle carbon emissions, as compared to fossil-based jet fuel, (4) food and ecology should not be affected by energy crops, and (5) deforestation should not be the reason [8]. The SAF should be produced from biological feedstocks, such as non-edible oil crops (e.g., Jatropha, Palm, and Camelina), algae, municipal sewage and agricultural wastes [7][8][7,8]. The demand for jet fuel is 5–6 million barrels/day and is expected to increase by 15% by 2030 and account for 3.4% of the global CO2 emissions. Of the required global fuel supply of 6–7 billion litres/year, 30% is expected to be from bio-sources by 2030 according to the International Air Transport Association (IATA) [9][10][9,10]. In this context, offsetting CO2 emissions using microalgae is attractive since 1 tonne of microalgae can absorb 1.8 tonnes of CO2 from the 29 gigatons of CO2 that is released into the atmosphere annually from burning fossil fuels [9][10][9,10]. Improvements in other areas, such as lighter materials, improved engine design, and aerodynamics, have resulted in a 70% reduction in aircraft traveller/kilometre and tonne/kilometre consumption [11].
For jet fuel, the aviation industry primarily uses two types of fuel: aviation gasoline and aviation kerosene [12][22]. Aviation gasoline, also known as AVGAS, is derived from the distillation of crude oil in the range between 30 and 170 °C [13][14][23,24]. This fuel mainly consists of isoparaffins with C5 to C9 carbon and a small amount of aromatic carbon. Alkylates are a mix of high-octane, low-vapour-pressure, branched paraffinic hydrocarbons used for blending into gasoline [13][15][23,25]. AVGAS is normally used in small aircraft, such as private aviation, agricultural, and pilot training. Aviation kerosene is also a petroleum distillation product obtained in the range between 150 and 300 °C [13][15][23,25]. This fuel is more suitable in aircraft engines for energy generation through combustion, used in many commercial and military aircraft [16][26]. Many developed countries are following the jet fuel specifications, which are compatible with the Aviation Fuel Requirement for Operated System (AFQRJOS) (Table 1).
Table 1. Regulatory agency and standards of aviation fuel around the world [15].
Regulatory agency and standards of aviation fuel around the world [25].
Regulating Agency Country Standards/Resolution Commercial Name
Methods Description
Agência Nacional do Petróleo, Gás Natural Biocombustíveis Brazil Resolution No. 37 Jet A-1
FT-SPK Fischer-Tropsch synthetic paraffinic kerosene (FT-SPK). Biomass is converted into syngas and then biofuels via the FT process. ASTM approved the approach in 2009, and the UK MOD Def-Stan (91-91) approved it in 2010. FT-SPK aviation biofuel can be blended up to 50% with fossil jet fuel.
Federal Aviation Administration USA ASTM D1655/ASTM 6615 Jet A, Jet A1/Jet B
Transport Canada Civil Aviation
HEFA Hydro-processed fatty acid esters and free fatty acid (HEFA). Hydrogen is used to transform liquid feedstock, including vegetable oils, cooking oil, and tallow, into green diesel, which can then be isomerised and separated to produce a jet fraction. In 2011, the route was certified for a 50% blend with fossil jet fuel. Canada CAN/CGSB-3.23 CAN/CGSB-3.22 Jet A/A1/Jet B
Civil Aviation Authority UK DefStan 91–91 Jet A1
European Aviation Safety Agency EU AFQRJOS Jet A1
Federal Air Transport Agency Russia GOST 10,227/GOST R 52,050 TS-1/Jet A1
Civil Aviation Administration of China China GB 6537 No. 3

2. Aviation Fuel Specification

Aviation fuel properties and compositions should meet the fuel specifications standards [17][27]. They should have the lowest energy density by mass, the highest permitted freeze point, the highest allowable viscosity, the highest allowable sulfuret and aromatic content, the highest allowable acidity, and the lowest allowable flash point [18][19][20][28,29,30]. Parameters for the certified international standards for aviation jet fuel are presented in Table 2 and agree closely with one another in many respects.
Table 2. International standards for aviation jet fuel [18][19][20].
International standards for aviation jet fuel [28,29,30].
Properties Unit ASTM 1655-4a Def Stan 91-91 ANPn°37
Density g/mL 0.775–0.840 0.775–0.840 0.771–0.836 (20 °C)
Viscosity at 20 °C mm2/s 8.0 max 8.0 max 8.0 max
Acid value mgKOH/g 0.100 0.0012 0.015
HFS-SIP Hydro-processing of fermented sugars–synthetic isoparaffinic kerosene (HFS-SIP). Sugars can be transformed to hydrocarbons using modified yeasts. The current permitted technique creates a C15 hydrocarbon terpenoid, farnesene. ASTM authorised this technology in 2014, and it can be combined with fossil jet fuel up to 10%. Flash point °C 38 min 38 min 38–40 min
FT-SPK/AHeat of combustion MJ/kg 42.8 min 42.8 min 42.8 min
Freezing point °C −47 −47 −47
Sulphur % 0.3 0.3 0.3
Aromatics % 25 25 25
This is a modified FT-SPK process. Light aromatics are alkylated to yield a hydrocarbon mix with an aromatic component. This method was authorised in 2015 and can blend up to 50%.
ATJ-SPK Alcohol-to-jet-synthetic paraffinic kerosene (ATJ-SPK). Hydro-processing, dehydration, and oligomerisation are used to convert alcohols (iso-butanol) into hydrocarbon. A certified process allows a maximum 50% blending.
Co-processing Biological liquid feedstock, such as fats, oil, and other residues, can be blended with fossil crude oil by 5% (v/v) to carry out the refining process. This process was approved in April 2018 by ASTM and certified with ASTM D1655.
CCS-APR Catalytic conversion of sugars by aqueous phase reforming.
CH Catalytic hydrotreating of liquid to jet fuels. Smoke point Mm 25 min 25 min 25 min
JFTOT Delta P (260 °C) mmHg 25 25 25
Conductivity pS/m 50–450 50–600 50–600
Maximum boiling point °C 300 max 300 max 300 max

The chemical composition of Jet A and A1 fuels is presented in Table 3. Straight-chain hydrocarbons, C8 (octanes), and cyclic derivatives, both aromatic and non-aromatic, are major components.

Table 3. Chemical composition of Jet A and Jet A1 fuels [18][19][20].
Chemical composition of Jet A and Jet A1 fuels [28,29,30].
CATJ-SKA
Catalytic upgrading of alcohol intermediate-catalytic ATJ-synthetic kerosene with aromatics.
ATJ-SPK


expansion
Catalytic upgrading of ethanol.
HEFA

expansion
Direct use of a wider cut of HEFA with renewable diesel.
HDCJ

UOP-Eco-refining™
Pyrolysis-hydrotreated de-polymerised cellulose.

Blending vegetable biodiesels with petroleum-based fuels.
Compound Formula Type Chemical Structure
n-octane C8H18 n-paraffin Fermentation 09 00907 i001
2-Methylheptane C8H18 Isoparaffin Fermentation 09 00907 i002
1-Methyl-1-ethylcyclopentane C8H14 Cycloparaffin Fermentation 09 00907 i003
Ethyl-cyclohexane C8H16 Cycloparaffin Fermentation 09 00907 i004
o-Xylene C8H10 Aromatic Fermentation 09 00907 i005
p-Xylene C8H10 Aromatic Fermentation 09 00907 i006
Cis-Decalin C10H18 Cycloparaffin Fermentation 09 00907 i007
Tetralin C10H12 Aromatic Fermentation 09 00907 i008
Naphthalene C10H8 Aromatic Fermentation 09 00907 i009
n-Dodecane C12H26 n-paraffin Fermentation 09 00907 i010
2-Methylundecane C12H26 Isoparaffin Fermentation 09 00907 i011
1-Ethylnaftalene C12H12 Aromatic Fermentation 09 00907 i012
n-Hexylbenzene C12H18 Aromatic Fermentation 09 00907 i013
n-Hexadecane C16H34 n-paraffin Fermentation 09 00907 i014
2-Methylpentadecane C16H34 Isoparaffin Fermentation 09 00907 i015
n-Decylbenzene C16H26 Aromatic Fermentation 09 00907 i016

3. Kerosene

Kerosene is a clear hydrocarbon-rich liquid obtained from petroleum distillation over a temperature range of 150 to 300 °C [21][14]. It is less viscous than biodiesel with a density of 0.78–0.81 g/mL and is composed of hydrocarbons predominantly from C10 to C16, although the range can extend to C6–C20. The main constituents are branched and straight-chain alkanes, as well as cycloalkanes, which account for at least 70% of the total volume [19][29]. Studies on synthetic alternative jet fuels with predominantly linear and lightly branched alkane content provide stronger low-temperature ignition characteristics, while other types of synthetic alternative jet fuels with a high content of highly branched alkanes exhibit weaker, low-temperature ignition characteristics, when compared to conventional jet fuels [22][31]. Aromatic hydrocarbons such as alkyl benzenes and alkyl naphthalene are rarely seen in concentrations greater than 25% by volume. Alkene content is low and typically makes up less than 5% of the total volume. Kerosene has a flash point of 37 to 65 °C and an autoignition temperature of 220 °C. Kerosene has a freezing point of −47 °C; however, this varies depending on the quality of the aviation fuel requirements [23][32]. Kerosene has a lower heating value of around 43 MJ/kg and a higher heating value of around 46 MJ/kg, similar to fossil diesel. The ASTM D-3699-78 recognises two grades of kerosene: 1-K (less than 0.04% sulphur by weight) and 2-K (0.3% sulphur by weight). The 1-K grade is better than the 2-K grade, providing cleaner combustion and fewer toxic emissions [23][32].

4. Routes to SAF Production

Several conversion routes have been developed to convert biomass into aviation fuel, and some key features are highlighted in Table 4, which include hydro-processing of esters and fatty acids (HEFA), Fischer-Tropsch (FT), and alcohol-to-jet (ATJ) [24][33]. In this regard, the only commercially demonstrated process for 100% SAF is the UOP-Eco-refining™ technology developed by Honeywell (USA).
Table 4. Sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) pathways [24].
Sustainable aviation fuel (SAF) pathways [33].
Video Production Service