Table of Contents

    Topic review

    Seed Banking Effectiveness

    Subjects: Plant Sciences
    View times: 173


    Understanding seed viability under long-term storage conditions provides basic and useful information to investigate the effectiveness of seed banking. Besides the germination success, seedling establishment is also an important requirement, and a decisive step to ensure plant propagation. We used comparative data of germination, seedling growth, and survival percentage between fresh and 10-years-stored seeds of Senecio morisii, a narrow endemic and vulnerable species of Sardinia (Italy), in order to evaluate if differences exist in these traits. Stored seeds showed higher germination percentages than fresh ones, whereas seedling growth and survival did not present significant differences between them, except for seedling growth in plants produced from seeds germinated at 25 °C. This study allowed us to assess if seeds of S. morisii were able to germinate under controlled conditions, and if they maintained their viability and germination capacity for at least 10 years of long-term storage in the seed bank. In addition, the high seedling survival detected in both fresh and stored seeds suggests that stored seeds of S. morisii can be used to support reinforcement or reintroduction actions when fresh materials are not available.

    1. Introduction

    Senecio morisii J.Calvo & Bacch._Photo_G. Bacchetta 

    Seed banking, as an integral part of the ex situ conservation, has a pivotal role in safeguarding plant species for long times in order to avoid loss of genotypes from populations. Ex situ conservation is complementary to in situ methods, serves as a source of material for in situ conservation actions [1][2][3] and, for some species, it might be the only option for their preservation [4][5]. About 45% of Europe’s vascular plants are considered threatened, according to IUCN criteria [6]. Furthermore, Target 8 of the Global Strategy for Plant Conservation (GSPC) calls for “at least 75% of threatened plant species in ex situ collections, preferably in the country of origin, and at least 20% available for recovery and restoration programmes” [7][8]. Therefore, extra attention is necessary to ensure the ex situ conservation of endangered plants in seed banks and to develop effective germination and multiplication protocols for these species.

    Seed banking is a particularly important conservation strategy for species with orthodox seeds (desiccation-tolerant, sensu [9]). These seeds can be gradually dried at 15 °C and 15% of relative humidity (RH), in order to reach ca. 3%–5% of internal seed moisture content, and then stored safely at temperature near to −18 and −25 °C [10]. Seed storage conditions maintain germplasm viability for several years, but even under suitable conditions, viability might decline over time [11]. Seeds of some species can remain viable for hundreds of years, while seeds from other species can only survive for few years [12][13]. For this reason, it is necessary to assess periodically the viability of seeds stored in seed banks. International guidelines and standards indicate that the viability of stored collections should be tested every five or 10 years [12][14][15][16][17]. Loss of seed viability and seed dormancy due to seed ageing have been found in many species [13][18][19][20], and are caused by metabolic changes and DNA deterioration [21].

    2. Development

    Seed germination studies have also been suggested to be performed in order to evaluate the effective viability of stored seeds [22]. For instance, seedling establishment and survival are vital to guarantee the persistence and multiplication of plant populations, and the successive effectiveness of restoration strategies [23]. Consequently, knowledge of the germination process, seedling establishment, and survival of threatened species are important for conservation practitioners, enabling them to produce plants and to increase the chance for establishment of self-sustaining populations [24][25].

    We studied the germination capacity of a threatened and narrow endemic species of Sardinia (Italy), Senecio morisii J.Calvo & Bacch. Existing within the genus Senecio L. (Asteraceae), one of the largest genera of flowering plants, almost cosmopolitan and occurring in all the five regions with a Mediterranean climate [26], this species forms part of the Senecio doria L. group, a species complex of perennial herbs from Europe, western and central Asia, and northwestern Africa [27]S. morisii was recently described from central-eastern Sardinia; it is a hygrophilous species which grows on water meadows or watersides with calcareous soils (limestones, travertines, and conglomerates) [27]. In particular, it lives along the edges of streams in woods of Ostrya carpinifolia Scop. accompanied by Taxus baccata L. and Ilex aquifolium L., between elevations of 700–1200 m a.s.l. [27]S. morisii flowers from late May to July; the ligulate florets produce achenes, subcylindrical and glabrous, at the end of July, and no information about its germination traits is currently available. Only six populations are currently known [27][28] and it was assessed as Vulnerable (VU) in the IUCN Italian Red List [29].

    Senecio morisii is a vulnerable plant species endemic to Sardinia, for which ex situ conservation has become a necessary strategy. Knowing and understanding the complex elements that control seed longevity and germination are therefore of major ecological and conservational importance [30]. This is the first attempt, to our knowledge, to investigate the seed germination of fresh and stored seeds of S. morisii. The results show that both fresh and stored seeds are able to germinate under controlled conditions. In addition, the high viability detected in seeds stored for 10 years under seed banking conditions at −25 °C allows us to suggest their use in the absence of fresh material for management actions, like translocations and/or population reinforcements. Especially in the case of endemic and/or threatened plants, which may present problems related to the poor availability of material for plant propagation, seed banks can be decisive sources of material for translocations [31].

    Seeds of S. morisii, collected in 2007 and then stored at −25 °C for 10 years, showed a broader germination temperature and higher germination rates, when compared with the fresh ones collected in 2017. Stored seeds presented a germination of approximately 70%, while the germination of fresh seeds of S. morisii was less than 42%. Compared with other species of the genus Senecio, this species presented similar requirements for the germination. For example, S. malacitanus Huter, that is native to the southwestern Mediterranean Basin, also germinated with high percentages in a wide range of temperatures, from 5 to 30 °C [32]. Furthermore, studies of S. vulgaris L. show that germination was also favored at 20 °C and higher temperatures [33][34]. The highest germination percentage of fresh seeds of S. morisii was found at 30 °C. This could be an adaptation derived from the dry conditions that occur in natural habitats of Mediterranean hygrophilous species. Usually, these species germinate during the driest season in order to avoid that seedling development would coincide with the occurrence of flooding, usually during cool seasons (i.e., autumn and winter). Specifically, after dispersal in early summer, S. morisii seeds experience a dry period (from July to September), characterized by high temperatures and low flow of the rivers or springs where this species grows.

    To better understand the reason for the lower germination detected (less than 50%) in fresh seeds, we used seed viability percentage and DI as indexes. Firstly, the viability did not present statistical differences between stored and fresh seeds (except at 5 °C). Therefore, seed viability related to idiosyncratic causes influenced by the particular conditions of each year had not caused differences on germination, despite several studies that proved the interannual germination plasticity related to interannual climatic fluctuations [35][36]. Moreover, according to [2] and [13], high DI values (>0.4) of fresh seeds indicated the presence of some kind of dormancy. Thus, our results allow us to hypothesize that S. morisii fresh seeds may be partially dormant. Further studies are needed to evaluate this and define the type of dormancy [37]. Unfortunately, the extreme ability of the achenes to disperse by wind, the limited population size, and other threats of this species, such as the low number of flowering individuals due to overgrazing, were a limit for ensuring the availability of material for these experiments.

    Even if seed germination was high at a wide range of temperatures, we detected that seedlings showed better growth performance and survival percentages when coming from germinated seeds at the incubation temperatures of 20 and 25 °C. This is in accordance with [38], who demonstrated that plant developmental processes are complex, but strongly dependent on incubation conditions.

    Seed storage under gene bank conditions for 10 years had not affected seedling growth and survival percentage in the first stage of plant development. Indeed, seed viability and seedling establishment (survived after an experimental period of 120 days) were similar across the stored and fresh seeds. Interestingly, percentages of seedling survival were higher than 50% in all conditions.

    These results provide information on seed germination and seedling establishment of this narrow endemic species, offering basic but useful information for the conservation efforts of S. morisii, where translocation actions are recommended due to its restricted distribution range (limited to six populations) and the intensive grazing that affects the conservation status of this vulnerable species.


    The entry is from 10.3390/plants9050581


    1. Donald A. Falk; Endangered forest resources in the U.S.: Integrated strategies for conservation of rare species and genetic diversity. Forest Ecology and Management 1990, 35, 91-107, 10.1016/0378-1127(90)90234-3.
    2. C. A. Offord; M. L. McKensy; P. V. Cuneo; Critical review of threatened species collections in the New South Wales Seedbank: implications for ex situ conservation of biodiversity. Pacific Conservation Biology 2004, 10, 221, 10.1071/pc040221.
    3. Andrea Mondoni; Graziano Rossi; Simone Orsenigo; Robin J. Probert; Climate warming could shift the timing of seed germination in alpine plants. Annals of Botany 2012, 110, 155-164, 10.1093/aob/mcs097.
    4. Maunder, M.; Guerrant, E.O.; Havens, K.; Dixon, K.W.. Realizing the full potential of ex situ contributions to global plant conservation. In Ex Situ Plant Conservation: Supporting Species Survival in the Wild;; Guerrant, E.O., Havens, K., Maunder, M., Eds.; Island Press: Washington, DC, USA, 2004; pp. 389–418..
    5. J. A. Cochrane; Andrew Crawford; L. T. Monks; The significance of ex situ seed conservation to reintroduction of threatened plants. Australian Journal of Botany 2007, 55, 356-361, 10.1071/bt06173.
    6. Bilz, M.; Kell, S.P.; Maxted, N.; Lansdown, R.V.. European Red List of Vascular Plants; Publications Office of the European Union: Luxembourg, 2011; pp. 123–128.
    7. Giuseppe Fenu; Mauro Fois; Donatella Cogoni; Marco Porceddu; Maria Silvia Pinna; Alba Cuena-Lombraña; Anna Nebot; Elena Sulis; Rosangela Picciau; Andrea Santo; et al. The Aichi Biodiversity Target 12 at regional level: an achievable goal?. Biodiversity 2015, 16, 1-16, 10.1080/14888386.2015.1062423.
    8. S. Rivière; J. V. Müller; Contribution of seed banks across Europe towards the 2020 Global Strategy for Plant Conservation targets, assessed through the ENSCONET database. Oryx 2017, 52, 464-470, 10.1017/s0030605316001496.
    9. Roberts, E.H.; Predicting the storage life of seeds. Seed Sci. Technol. 1973, 1 , 499–514., .
    10. ISTA . International Rules for Seed Testing; The International Seed Testing Association (ISTA), Eds.; The International Seed Testing Association (ISTA): Bassersdorf, Germany, 2008; pp. 234–238.
    11. Robin J. Probert; John Adams; Julia Coneybeer; Andrew Crawford; Fiona R. Hay; Seed quality for conservation is critically affected by pre-storage factors. Australian Journal of Botany 2007, 55, 326-335, 10.1071/bt06046.
    12. Robin J. Probert; Matthew Daws; Fiona R. Hay; Ecological correlates of ex situ seed longevity: a comparative study on 195 species. Annals of Botany 2009, 104, 57-69, 10.1093/aob/mcp082.
    13. Sandrine Godefroid; Ann Van De Vyver; Julie Lebrun; Wilfried Masengo Kalenga; Guylain Handjila Minengo; Charles Rose; Michel Ngongo Luhembwe; Thierry VanderBorght; Grégory Mahy; Germination capacity and seed storage behaviour of threatened metallophytes from the Katanga copper belt (D.R.Congo): implications for ex situ conservation. Plant Ecology and Evolution 2013, 146, 183-192, 10.5091/plecevo.2013.745.
    14. Bacchetta, G.; Fenu, G.; Mattana, E.; Piotto, B.; Virevaire, M. . Manuale per la Raccolta, Studio, Conservazione e Gestione ex situ del Germoplasma;; Bacchetta, G.; Fenu, G.; Mattana, E.; Piotto, B.; Virevaire, M., Eds.; Manuali e Linee Guida (APAT): Roma, Italy, 2006; pp. 83–92.
    15. Bacchetta, G.; Bueno-Sánchez, A.; Fenu, G.; Jiménez-Alfaro, B.; Mattana, E.; Piotto, B.; Virevaire, M. . Conservación ex situ de Plantas Silvestres; La Caixa: Principado de Asturias, Spain, 2008; pp. 165–187.
    16. Porceddu, M.; Santo, A.; Orrù, M.; Meloni, F.; Ucchesu, M.; Picciau, R.; Sarigu, M.; Cuena-Lombraña, A.; Podda, L.; Sau, S.; et al. Seed conservation actions for the preservation of plant diversity: the case of the Sardinian Germplasm Bank (BG-SAR). Plant Sociol 2017, 54, 111–117, 10.7338/pls2017542S1/11.
    17. FAO. Genebank Standards for Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture; FAO: Rome, Italy, 2014; pp. 265–283.
    18. Sandrine Godefroid; Ann Van De Vyver; Thierry VanderBorght; Germination capacity and viability of threatened species collections in seed banks. Biodiversity and Conservation 2009, 19, 1365-1383, 10.1007/s10531-009-9767-3.
    19. Kun Liu; Jerry M. Baskin; Carol C. Baskin; Haiyan Bu; Mingxia Liu; Wei Liu; Guozhen Du; Effect of storage conditions on germination of seeds of 489 species from high elevation grasslands of the eastern Tibet Plateau and some implications for climate change. American Journal of Botany 2010, 98, 12-19, 10.3732/ajb.1000043.
    20. Orville C. Baldos; Joseph DeFrank; Matthew Kramer; Glenn S. Sakamoto; Storage Humidity and Temperature Affect Dormancy Loss and Viability of Tanglehead (Heteropogon contortus) Seeds. HortScience 2014, 49, 1328-1334, 10.21273/hortsci.49.10.1328.
    21. Yong-Bi Fu; Zaheer Ahmed; Axel Diederichsen; Towards a better monitoring of seed ageing underex situseed conservation. Conservation Physiology 2015, 3, cov026, 10.1093/conphys/cov026.
    22. Hannes Dempewolf; Ruth J. Eastwood; Luigi Guarino; Colin K. Khoury; Jonas V. Müller; Jane Toll; Adapting Agriculture to Climate Change: A Global Initiative to Collect, Conserve, and Use Crop Wild Relatives. Agroecology and Sustainable Food Systems 2014, 38, 369-377, 10.1080/21683565.2013.870629.
    23. Risolandia Bezerra De Melo; Augusto Cesar Franco; Clovis Oliveira Silva; Maria Teresa Fernandez Piedade; Cristiane Silva Ferreira; Seed germination and seedling development in response to submergence in tree species of the Central Amazonian floodplains.. AoB PLANTS 2015, 7, plv041, 10.1093/aobpla/plv041.
    24. David J. Merritt; Kingsley W. Dixon; Restoration Seed Banks--A Matter of Scale. Science 2011, 332, 424-425, 10.1126/science.1203083.
    25. A. Clemente; Jonas V. Müller; Erika Almeida; Catarina A. Costa; Sara Lobo Dias; Joana Magos Brehm; Rui Rebelo; Maria Amelia Martins-Loução; What can routine germination tests in seed banks tell us about the germination ecology of endemic and protected species?. Botany 2017, 95, 673-684, 10.1139/cjb-2017-0003.
    26. Pieter B. Pelser; Bertil Nordenstam; Joachim W. Kadereit; Linda E. Watson; An ITS phylogeny of tribe Senecioneae (Asteraceae) and a new delimitation of Senecio L.. TAXON 2007, 56, 1077-1104, 10.2307/25065905.
    27. Joel Calvo; Carlos Aedo; A Taxonomic Revision of the Eurasian/Northwestern African Senecio doria Group (Compositae). Systematic Botany 2015, 40, 900-913, 10.1600/036364415x689320.
    28. Mauro Fois; Alba Cuena-Lombraña; Giuseppe Fenu; Gianluigi Bacchetta; Using species distribution models at local scale to guide the search of poorly known species: Review, methodological issues and future directions. Ecological Modelling 2018, 385, 124-132, 10.1016/j.ecolmodel.2018.07.018.
    29. Simone Orsenigo; Chiara Montagnani; Giuseppe Fenu; Domenico Gargano; L. Peruzzi; Thomas Abeli; Alessandro Alessandrini; Gianluigi Bacchetta; F. Bartolucci; Maurizio Bovio; et al. Red Listing plants under full national responsibility: Extinction risk and threats in the vascular flora endemic to Italy. Biological Conservation 2018, 224, 213-222, 10.1016/j.biocon.2018.05.030.
    30. Sara Mira; M. Elena González-Benito; Ana M. Ibars; Elena Estrelles; Dormancy release and seed ageing in the endangered species Silene diclinis. Biodiversity and Conservation 2010, 20, 345-358, 10.1007/s10531-010-9833-x.
    31. Thomas Abeli; Kingsley W. Dixon; Translocation ecology: the role of ecological sciences in plant translocation. Plant Ecology 2016, 217, 123-125, 10.1007/s11258-016-0575-z.
    32. F.X. Sans; F. Xavier Sans Serra; Isabel Afán; Life-history traits of alien and native senecio species in the Mediterranean region. Acta Oecologica 2004, 26, 167-178, 10.1016/j.actao.2004.04.001.
    33. Janet R. Hilton; THE INFLUENCE OF LIGHT ON THE GERMINATION OF SENECIO VULGARIS L.. New Phytologist 1983, 94, 29-37, 10.1111/j.1469-8137.1983.tb02717.x.
    34. Z. Ren; Richard J. Abbott; Seed dormancy in Mediterranean Senecio vulgaris L.. New Phytologist 1991, 117, 673-678, 10.1111/j.1469-8137.1991.tb00972.x.
    35. M. Fenner; The effects of the parent environment on seed germinability. Seed Science Research 1991, 1, 75-84, 10.1017/s0960258500000696.
    36. Eduardo Fernández-Pascual; Borja Jímenez-Alfaro; Phenotypic plasticity in seed germination relates differentially to overwintering and flowering temperatures. Seed Science Research 2014, 24, 273-280, 10.1017/s0960258514000269.
    37. Jerry M. Baskin; Carol C. Baskin; A classification system for seed dormancy. Seed Science Research 2004, 14, 1-16, 10.1079/ssr2003150.
    38. S. Mira; Elena Estrelles; M. Elena González-Benito; Effect of water content and temperature on seed longevity of seven Brassicaceae species after 5 years of storage. Plant Biology 2014, 17, 153-162, 10.1111/plb.12183.