Aviation Spline Research: History
View Latest Version
Please note this is an old version of this entry, which may differ significantly from the current revision.
Contributor:
Guang Zhao
,
Xiangyang Zhao
,
Liting Qian
,
Yunbo Yuan
,
Song Ma
,
Mei Guo

Splines are irreplaceable in high-speed aviation fields due to their simplicity, reliability, and high specific power. Aviation splines are not only subjected to severe operating mechanical loads, but also sometimes operate under grease-lubricated and non-lubricated environments. All of this results in aviation splines suffering widespread failures.

  • spline
  • wear
  • lubrication
  • misalignment

1. Introduction

Couplings are widely used in rotating machinery to transmit torque from driving machinery to driven machinery. There are various kinds of couplings. Among them, spline couplings make the structure simpler, more reliable and compact, and easier to install. Compared with other couplings, spline couplings have a larger contact area, higher bearing capacity, higher reliability, smaller stress concentration, and smaller strength weakening of shafts and hubs. Splines also perform well in terms of centering and guiding, which makes it simpler to correct installation errors and misalignments. As a result, splines are frequently utilized in transmission and connecting devices for rotating machinery [1].
In order to improve the safety, reliability, and power–weight ratio of transmissions, couplings are required to be rigorous in aerospace transmission devices. Splines are the only couplings that have been previously approved by military standards. A single-engine A-4 aircraft has 174 spline connections, not including splines internal to accessories and components [2].
Aviation splines bear complicated and severe torque loads during operation [3], including constant torque, periodic torque, additional cyclic torque, transient peak torque, and impact torque. In addition to these above torque loads, aviation splines also bear other mechanical loads, mainly including resonance load, misalignment load, and contact and friction loads. Furthermore, aviation splines often operate under conditions lacking lubrication and cooling. As a result, they often suffer conventional wear, fretting wear, corrosion, creep, fusion, and fatigue; moreover, they also sometimes suffer tooth and hub fractures.
According to a survey of the US Navy aircraft maintenance in the 1970s, 40% of fixed-wing aircraft and 70% of rotary-wing aircraft have spline problems. Aiming at the problem of misalignment contact wear and the failure of aviation splines, the US Navy maintenance warehouse has carried out systematic, comprehensive treatments of it, which has increased the mean time between failures of aviation splines from less than 500 h to more than 2000 h [2][4]. Since the 1970s, much research has been done on the design, contact, wear, fatigue, strength, and reliability of aviation splines.

2. Spline Type and Characteristics

2.1. Classification from Spline Shape

(1) Classification from tooth profile of spline
According to the tooth profile of the spline, splines can be divided into involute spline, rectangle spline, triangle spline, and circular arc spline. As shown in Figure 1a, the tooth profile of the involute spline has an involute curve. The tooth of the involute spline always experiences a radial force, which makes the involute spline automatically self-centering and further guarantees that every tooth bears the same load. The involute spline has a high load capacity and is widely applied for connection with high load and high centering accuracy requirements. As shown in Figure 1b, the centering accuracy of the rectangle spline can make sure by minor diameter centering; the rectangle spline is used for connections with static or light loads. As shown in Figure 1c, the internal spline tooth profile of the triangle spline is a triangular shape, and the external spline is an involute shape with a 45° pressure angle. Triangle splines are mostly used for light load and static connections with small diameters, especially for thin-walled parts [2]. As shown in Figure 1d, the tooth profile of the circular arc spline is circular. The contact area and tooth thickness of the circular arc spline are much bigger than those of the involute spline, which effectively reduces fretting wear and stress concentration and improves load capacity. The circular arc spline is mainly used for connection with large misalignments.
Lubricants 11 00006 g001
Figure 1. Profile diagram of (a) involute spline, (b) rectangle spline, (c) triangle spline, and (d) circular arc spline.
(2) Classification from body shape of spline
According to the body shape of the spline, splines can be divided into external splines with an open end (see Figure 2a) and an adjacent shoulder (see Figure 2b) and internal splines with an open end (see Figure 2c) and an adjacent shoulder (see Figure 2d). These different spline body shapes influence the selection of mechanical processing technology. In addition, the spline may also be designed with a taper along the axis direction, generally with a 0.54° taper. This design can reduce the maximum stress of the adjacent shaft by 15%. In other words, it can increase the fatigue load capacity of splines by 15% [3].
Lubricants 11 00006 g002
Figure 2. Shapes of spline body: (a) external spline with an open end, (b) external spline with an adjacent shoulder, (c) internal spline with an open end, and (d) internal spline with an adjacent shoulder.

2.2. Spline Classification from Function and Positioning Mode

Splines can be divided into single-stage and multi-stage spline coupling, depending on their functions. The multi-stage spline can reduce torque fluctuation to a certain level and compensate for significant misalignment. Figure 3 shows two representative multi-stage splines (i.e., multi-stage splines with friction plates or a spline sleeve). As shown in Figure 3a, when applying an axial force on the multi-stage spline with friction plates, contact and friction would generate between the internal and external splines, which further transmit torques between the spline shaft and the spline sleeve [5]. As shown in Figure 3b, this type of multi-stage spline inserts a spline sleeve (ring) between the internal and external spline. Such a spline sleeve can be made of various materials, such as metal and nylon [6].
Lubricants 11 00006 g003
Figure 3. Multi-stage splines: (a) with friction plates and (b) nylon spline sleeve.
Splines can be divided into fixed and flexible splines according to Dudley’s method for calculating the bearing capacity of involute splines [7]. The fixed spline can be shrink-fitted or loosely fitted, but both ends have piloted rings to keep the spline from rocking. The rocking would result in a small amount of axial movement, which further leads to spline wear. A typical fixed spline is shown in Figure 4 [8].
Lubricants 11 00006 g004
Figure 4. Fixed spline in helicopter tail drive shafts. 1—Output shaft of the main reducer; 2—O-ring; 3—Spline; 4—Tail drive shaft.
Fixed splines are commonly used in the low-pressure rotors of aero engines to achieve stable and reliable torque transmission between low-pressure turbine rotors and fan rotors. The fixed splines used in aero engines are also called sleeve–tooth connection structures, as shown in Figure 5. The spline shown in Figure 5 is centered by cylindrical surfaces, and its axial direction is locked by an axial main locking nut [9].
Lubricants 11 00006 g005
Figure 5. Typical multifunction spline in aero engines.
When a flexible spline is not perfectly aligned, some rocking motion can occur, resulting in spline wear. Flexible splines are widely used in aero engine accessories, such as floating/semi-floating central driving shaft splines and fuel pump splines, as shown in Figure 6 [6]. These floating splines are typical flexible splines with two ends fixed to different boxes. Straight-tooth flexible splines can accommodate only a minor angle misalignment before wear becomes a significant issue. Splines such as crowned splines are advised for large misalignments to reduce stress concentration and spline wear.
Lubricants 11 00006 g006
Figure 6. Flexible spline of fuel pump in aero engine accessories [6].

2.3. Spline Classification from Modification

Tooth modifications along the axial orientation are often used to improve the contact properties of misaligned splines. These tooth modifications can prevent stress concentration. In general, tooth modifications are performed on the external spline, and the internal spline remains unchanged. Splines with tooth tip centering are usually modified in the top axial direction, while splines with tooth side centering are usually modified in the tooth axial direction and maintain an involute profile. Splines with the second type of tooth modification are called involute crowned splines, abbreviated as crowned splines [10]. As shown in Figure 7 and Figure 8, the crowned tooth surface of crowned splines enhances the friction and wear condition of the tooth surface and reduces noise compared to common splines. It also prevents edge extrusion and stress concentration misuse in a misaligned state. In addition, the internal and external splines are conveniently disassembled and assembled due to the flared shape of the external tooth end.
Lubricants 11 00006 g007
Figure 7. Common spline and its misaligned engagement state.
Lubricants 11 00006 g008
Figure 8. Crowned spline and its misaligned engagement state.
Crowned splines are very useful for angular misalignments. However, the crowned splines are not suitable for aligned conditions. Under aligned conditions, splines with extensive crowned modifications would suffer high stress concentration and potential tooth breaking. For aligned conditions, as shown in the second diagram of Figure 7 and Figure 8, crowned splines have smaller contact areas compared with straight splines. Straight splines have larger contact areas to decrease contact stress.
There are several classifications of aircraft splines from differing perspectives. Aviation splines can also be divided into spray-lubricated, oil-mist-lubricated, grease-lubricated, and non-lubricated splines, as well as continuous-lubricated and clearance-lubricated splines.

3. Aviation Spline Wear

Tooth wear is the main problem of aviation splines. Early studies on spline wear were primarily conducted between 1970 and 1985. After receiving thorough treatments, the life of American aviation splines was significantly extended. Spline wear studies have ushered in another upsurge since 2010. China Aviation Engine Group has done a lot of research on improving the anti-wear performance of aviation splines.
According to the statistics of AVIC Shenyang Engine Design Institute [11], splines and accessories should be inspected gradually every 100 h. Twelve accessories and twelve splines were inspected during one inspection. As shown in Figure 9, five internal splines and eleven external spline shafts of fuel booster pumps were found to have worn severely, and they all needed to be replaced. The troubleshooting experience showed that the main problems of aviation splines are inadequate surface hardness, excessive axial movement value, excessive misalignment, and insufficient lubrication. However, the spline wear problem has not been effectively solved, and the root cause of spline wear and the mechanism of rapid spline wear are still unclear. Thus, it is urgent to carry out in-depth theoretical and experimental research.
Lubricants 11 00006 g012
Figure 9. Spline wear examples of aero engine accessories. (a) Drive gear shaft internal spline of the fuel booster pump, (b) spline shaft of the fuel booster pump, (c) spline shaft of the fuel booster pump connected to flying attachment end, and (d) spline shaft of the fuel booster pump connected to pump end.
Most damage of tooth-side centering splines is caused by wear. Spline wear can be generally divided into three stages, as shown in Figure 10 [12]. The first stage is a short running-in process, the second stage has an approximate constant wear rate, and the third stage has a strong damage effect. The results of the spline wear test showed that three wear stages do not always exist simultaneously, shown as Curves A and C in Figure 10. In addition to friction and wear parameters, the working state also plays an important role in the wear process. Splines with large torques wear more severely than those with large transverse forces [12].
Lubricants 11 00006 g013
Figure 10. Qualitative characteristic curve of spline wear.

3.1. Influence of Lubrication on Spline Wear

Mating external and internal spline teeth slip with each other when the spline runs at high rotating speeds. The slips may occur in the following three directions, namely axial, radial, and torsional directions. Friction and heating issues are very prominent when considering variables like misalignment and vibration, so splines require reliable lubrication [13]. Splines are often lubricated using grease, oil/oil mist, or no lubrication. Grease-lubricated splines are simple to operate, easy to maintain, and highly reliable. They also have a unique property of sealing teeth from the environment. Grease-lubricated splines have drawbacks in that they are greatly affected by working temperature and have poor grease continuity and retention. When the grease is thrown out or completely squeezed out due to centrifugal force, the friction coefficient between the mating spline teeth increases as a result of no lubrication. In addition, the oxide coating cannot be produced because grease prevents air from entering the spline tooth surface at the initial stage. In small misalignment states, the aviation spline generates very little heat, and its temperature rise mainly comes from the heat transfer from the attached shaft. Currently, few lubricating greases can work at temperatures above 121 °C. Grease lubrication is therefore inappropriate for the enclosed area because its heat is difficult to dissipate. Continuous oil/oil mist lubrication makes the heat output from the spline increase rapidly, so splines running at high speed with oil lubrication would still have greater continuous service performance. The disadvantages of oil lubrication include its high cost and the needs of additional pipelines, oil stations, and other auxiliary systems. What is more, the spline wear will be accelerated once impurities enter the working environment through the lubricating oil. The non-lubricated spline is often used in conditions with compact structure, low running speed, light torque, and high working temperature. Additionally, the spline can use intermittent or discontinuous lubrication, or the radial hole can be employed to direct lubricating oil toward the spline engagement point, and the lubrication can be achieved through capillary actions [14]. Although the lubrication mode has the above rules to follow, it also needs to be determined according to the actual structure and working environment.
Spline wear is a complicated process that can be either mechanical, chemical, or both. Mechanical wear can be significantly alleviated by selecting the correct lubricant. If the lubricant is unable to reduce the creation of wear debris, wear propagation will dominate the wear process. The hardness of oxides is often higher than that of the spline matrix. That is, if wear debris remains in the lubricant, it will instead aggravate spline wear and even lead to connection failure. Essentially, grease lubrication cannot play a positive role if the aim is to improve the service life of splines. According to laboratory tests [15], splines need to be cleaned and relubricated at least every 50 h of operation. For aviation splines, the downtime is unbearable, to say nothing of the high maintenance costs. Only oil lubrication can achieve a significant improvement because, in addition to friction characteristics, lubricating oil can wash away the wear debris and further achieve complete lubrication. A summary of the influence of lubrication mode on spline wear is shown in Figure 11 [12].
Lubricants 11 00006 g014
Figure 11. Influence of lubrication method on spline wear.
In-depth experimental studies on the spline wear process were conducted by Weatherford and Valtierra [16]. They studied the effects of crowned amount, misalignment, lubrication, materials, working temperature, and surface treatment on spline wear. The qualitative effect of lubrication on spline wear in the dry air environment is shown in Figure 12. They found that a suitable lubricant will create an induction phase at the initial operating stage, which considerably delayed spline wear. Rapid wear with a consistent wear rate will happen when the lubrication runs out or the spline surface is damaged. They also found that the wear rates are different when the lubricants are different. Mura et al. [17] added graphene to standard grease to produce a high-performance lubricant effect. The friction force of different grease graphene compounds was measured through experiments. The results showed that grease mixed with graphene could reduce the friction coefficient.
Lubricants 11 00006 g015
Figure 12. Qualitative influence of lubricant on spline wear characteristics in dry air.
To sum up, the lubrication modes, lubricant parameters, and temperature have an important impact on spline wear. The individual operating environment and spline state must be taken into consideration while choosing a proper lubrication method and determining an acceptable cleaning and relubrication cycle.

3.2. Effect of Misalignment on Spline Wear

Although the good alignment of connected rotors is required by spline assembly standards, in practice, manufacturing and assembly errors, component tolerances, dirty assembly surfaces, wear, and cold and hot deformations together would lead to large misalignment. Misalignments can cause a number of problems, such as vibrations in the spline rotor [18], spline teeth breakage, scratches, cold deformation, wear, and pitting. Misalignment also generates considerable axial force. According to ARINC measurements, the axial force generated by significant misalignment is large enough to disengage the coupling. The axial force generated by a misaligned spline greater than 2 degrees can be as much as 900 N [2].
Curà et al. [19] established a theoretical method based on a non-finite element method to determine the exact number of engaging teeth and shared forces in involute spline couplings with parallel offset errors. Elkholy and Alfres [20] addressed that misalignment leads to a redistribution of the load on each spline tooth, which increases the maximum contact and bending stresses of the tooth. The uneven load on the tooth also generates tilting and friction moments, which will further transfer to bearings. Test investigations show that misalignment has a significant effect on spline reliability, wear, and life [4]. As shown in Figure 13, misalignment significantly increases spline wear, and a small increase in misalignment results in a sharp increase in wear and a sharp decrease in wear life. The most efficient way to extend wear life and decrease wear on splines, as well as the most efficient way to simplify spline design and lower lubrication and maintenance pressure, is strict control of misalignment. In view of the inevitability and severity of spline misalignment, Ref. [21] gives the requirements for misalignment control of couplings in rotating machinery.
Lubricants 11 00006 g016
Figure 13. Influence of misalignment on spline wear.
In general, the magnitude of fretting between internal and external splines is far greater than that of the rotor connected by splines. Splines are often regarded as the representative of the fretting damage of complex components. Spline wear is inseparable from the vibration of splines. Many researchers have studied fretting wear, fretting fatigue, and plain fatigue caused by splines under actual load conditions [22]. The main mechanisms of micro-damage are fretting wear and fretting fatigue, which coexist in the same contact and can cause damage wear and contact-related crack initiation [23]. Jason [24] proposed a method for predicting the fretting fatigue life of a system that takes into consideration the material removed as a result of fretting wear. This method can predict some critical experimental phenomena, such as crack occurrence. Leen et al. [25] and Sum et al. [26] simulated the operating conditions of aero engine splines and analyzed the wear problems caused by fretting motion using computational contact mechanics and finite element methods, considering complex asymmetric loads and variable loads. Liu [27] found that wear can be reduced by improving the machining accuracy of the spline, reducing the spline fit clearance, and improving strength by heat treatment. Houghton et al. [28] proposed a method to predict the fretting fatigue life of aero engine splines and obtained the wear of splines under complex loads due to friction coefficient and speed. Curà and Mura [29] identified the fretting wear damage in actual working conditions by experiment using crowned splines. They found that the fretting wear is mainly caused by the relative motions between teeth with angular misalignments. The influence of torque and misalignment on spline wear is shown in Figure 14.
Lubricants 11 00006 g017
Figure 14. Spline wear of crowned splines vs. torque and misalignment.

This entry is adapted from the peer-reviewed paper 10.3390/lubricants11010006

References

  1. Wang, Y.L.; Zhao, G.; Sun, X.C.; Shengxiang, L.I. Review on Research of Aviation Spline. Aeronaut. Manuf. Technol. 2017, 60, 91–100.
  2. Coss, R.A.; Gantschnigg, G.K. Aircraft Electric System and System Component Study (F-4 Type Aircraft); Interim Report; ARINC Research Corporation: Annapolis, MD, USA, 1967.
  3. Endoy, R. Gear Hobbing, Shaping, and Shaving: A Guide to Cycle Time Estimating and Process Planning; Society of Manufacturing Engineers: Dearborn, MI, USA, 1990; pp. 63–74.
  4. Ku, P.M.; Valtierra, M.L. Spline wear-effects of design and lubrication. J. Eng. Ind. 1975, 97, 1257–1263.
  5. Chase, K.W.; Sorensen, C.D.; De Caires, B. Variation Analysis of Tooth Engagement and Load Sharing in Involute Splines. Gear Technol. 2010, 7, 54–62.
  6. Brown, H.W. A Reliable Spline Coupling. J. Eng. Ind. 1979, 101, 421.
  7. Dudley, D.W. When Splines Need Stress Control. Prod. Eng. 1957, 28, 56–61.
  8. Kang, L.X.; Cao, Y.H.; Mei, Q. Dynamic Instability of Helicopter Transmission Rotating Shafts with Spline Coupling. J. Beijing Univ. Aeronaut. Astronaut. 2010, 36, 645–649.
  9. Fu, C.G.; Zheng, D.P.; Ou, Y.X.; Zhou, S.J.; Zhao, X.M. Aeroengine Design Manual (Volume 19); Aviation Industry Press: Beijing, China, 2000; pp. 34–78.
  10. Zhao, G.; Wang, M.R.; Feng, Z.F.; Wang, Y.Q.; Guo, M.; Su, C.Q. Design method and its misaligned contact characteristic of aviation crowned spline. J. Aerosp. Power 2022, 37, 694–703.
  11. Chen, C.H. The Common Failures of Aero-engine Mechanical System; Aviation industry Press: Beijing, China, 2013; pp. 72–78.
  12. Dietz, P.; Schafer, G.; Wesolowski, K. Strength and Abrasion Wear of Involute Splines. Chin. J. Eng. Des. 1996, 1, 31–38+46.
  13. Liu, W.M.; Xia, Y.Q.; Fu, X.G. Gear Drive Lubricating Materials; Chemical Industry Press: Beijing, China, 2005; pp. 14–73.
  14. Calistrat, M.M. Gear Coupling Lubrication; American Society of Lubrication Engineers: Chicago, IL, USA, 1974.
  15. Waterhouse, R.B. Fretting Fatigue; Applied Science Publishers: London, UK, 1981.
  16. Weatherford, W.D.; Valtierra, J.R.M.L. Mechanisms of Wear in Misaligned Splines. J. Lubr. Technol. 1968, 90, 42–48.
  17. Mura, A.; Curà, F.; Adamo, F. Evaluation of graphene grease compound as lubricant for spline couplings. Tribol. Int. 2018, 117, 162–167.
  18. Zhao, G.; Guo, J.N.; Wang, X.F.; Liu, Z.S. Dynamics of Rotor-Gear Coupling-Bearing System with Misalignment. J. Dalian Univ. Technol. 2011, 51, 338–345.
  19. Curà, F.; Mura, A.; Gravina, M. Load Distribution in Spline Coupling Teeth with Parallel Offset Misalignment. J. Mech. Eng. Sci. 2012, 227, 1–11.
  20. Elkholy, A.H.; Alfares, M.A. Misalignment Loads in Splined Gear Coupling. Int. J. Comput. Appl. Technol. 2002, 15, 128–137.
  21. Boyce, M.P. Shaft Alignment in The Gas Turbine Engineering Handbook, 3rd ed.; Gulf Professional Publishing: Boston, MA, USA, 2006; pp. 654–663.
  22. Leen, S.B.; McColl, I.R.; Ratsimba, C.H.H.; Williams, E.J. Fatigue Life Prediction for A Barrelled Spline Coupling Under Torque Overload. J. Aerosp. Eng. 2003, 217, 123–142.
  23. Waterhouse, R.B. Fretting Wear, in ASM Handbook, Friction, Lubrication and Wear Technology. Am. Soc. Met. 1992, 18, 242–256.
  24. Jason, J.M. Numerical Modelling of the Effect of Fretting Wear on Fretting Fatigue. Ph.D. thesis, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK, 2009.
  25. Leen, S.B.; Richardson, I.J.; McColl, I.R.; Williams, E.J.; Hyde, T.R. Macroscopic Fretting Variables in A Splined Coupling Under Combined Torque and Axial Load. J. Strain Anal. Eng. Des. 2001, 36, 481–497.
  26. Sum, W.S.; Leen, S.B.; Williams, E.J.; Sabesan, R.; McColl, I.R. Efficient Finite Element Modelling for Complex Shaft Couplings Under Non-Symmetric Loading. J. Strain Anal. Eng. Des. 2005, 40, 655–675.
  27. Liu, H.Y. Influence of Spline Matching Clearance on Spline Coupling Failure. Journal of Changchun University 2008, 18, 41–43.
  28. Houghton, D.; Wavish, P.M.; Williams, E.J. Multiaxial Fretting Fatigue Testing and Prediction for Splined Couplings. Int. J. Fatigue 2009, 31, 1805–1815.
  29. Curà, F.; Mura, A. Evaluation of the Fretting Wear Damage on Crowned Splined Couplings. Procedia Struct. Integr. 2016, 5, 1393–1400.
More
© Text is available under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license; additional terms may apply. By using this site, you agree to the Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy.
This entry is offline, you can click here to edit this entry!
Video Production Service
Feedback