To completely solve the problem of hydrolysis of NF membranes dominated by polyamide-based materials in the extremely acidic environment, researchers have developed a series of acid-resistant membranes, such as polysulfonamide, triazine polyamine, and polyurea membranes, and so on. Such acid-resistant membranes showed high stability in strong acidic environments and could treat acidic feed liquids as well. Unfortunately, the separation performance of acid-resistant membranes was often unsatisfied [70]. The majority of them still stay in laboratory stage, and further manipulation is needed to be carried out in order to improve the separation performance.

The aforementioned PSA-based TFC NF membranes are relatively stable compared to PA-based membranes. The separation layer formed by interfacial polymerization of amine monomers with sulfonyl chloride also has good acid resistance and thereby inhibits hydrolysis and keeps a high stability due to the stable sulfonamide groups. If rigid conjugated phenyl PSA chains are integrated into the structure of the separation layer, PSA-based TFC NF membranes will become more stable in the extreme acidic environment. In addition, hydrolysis of the sulfonamide group occurs only at extremely low pH and high temperatures. However, the present acid-resistant polysulfonamide membranes generally exhibited unsatisfied separation performance. The main reason is that the organic monomers containing sulfonyl chloride group tend to have relatively higher molecular weight, lower diffusion coefficient, and reactivity than that bearing acyl chloride groups [99], which are easy to form a relatively loose separation layer with larger pore size [100]. To improve the selectivity of the membrane, the thickness of separation layer is increased. As a result, the permeability significantly decreased, exhibiting the typical trade-off effect. For example, Eslami et al. prepared polysulfonamide membranes by interfacial polymerization of PEI, PIP, MPD, and BDSC [101]. For such a membrane, the highest flux was only 4.4 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹, while the rejection for salt solution was almost zero. This means that the separation performance of the membrane is necessary to be improved by changing the structure and composition of the membrane.

Using amine-rich macromolecular polymers, such as polyallylamine (PAH) or polyethyleneimine (PEI) as the aqueous monomers, will be useful to improve membrane permselectivity. In fact, the interfacial polymerization is regulated by the diffusion of organic phase into the aqueous phase. The monomer with higher molecular weight would lead to greater steric hindrance and lower diffusion rate, resulting in the fact that the interfacial polymerization just occurs on the side closest to the aqueous phase [102]. The reaction on the side of aqueous phase usually results in an increased membrane thickness. Therefore, it is necessary to use an appropriate concentration of aqueous phase monomer to reduce the diffusion rate of aqueous phase and improve the dispersion uniformity of aqueous phase, while the diffusion process of the organic phase is used to modify defects and reduce thickness. Moreover, the rich amine groups in the polymer chain can improve the positively charge capacity of the membrane surface and increase the selectivity of the NF membrane for metal ions. Wang et al. prepared positively charged and acid-resistant PSA TFC NF membrane by interfacial polymerization of macromolecular PAH and BDSC on the PES support layer [99]. By properly adjusting the concentration, the prepared membrane had more positive charges and a denser structure compared to the conventional PSA membranes. The water flux of the membrane was 6.82 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹, and the rejection rate was 88.3% for MgCl₂ after being soaked in 20% (wt/v) H₂SO₄ aqueous solution for 30 days.

To improve the crosslinking degree of interfacial polymerization reaction, 1,3,6-naphthalenetrisulphonyl chloride (NTSC) was used to replace BDSC. NTSC containing more sulfonyl chloride groups showed higher reactivity, which could increase the crosslinking degree of the separation layer and make it much dense. The dense interfacial layer can also reduce thickness and improve the separation performance of the acid-resistant membrane. Liu et al. synthesized the NTSC monomer by the reaction of sodium 1,3,6-naphthalene trisulfonate and thionyl chloride in N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) [103]. The interfacial polymerization reaction of NTSC and PIP on PSf support layer afforded an acid-resistant PIP-NTSC TFC NF membrane [103]. Such a NF membrane showed a water flux of 5.8 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹, with more than 86.5% of rejection for Na₂SO₄. Note that the separation performance did not show any significant decline after being soaked in 20% (wt/v) H₂SO₄ aqueous solution for two months or consecutively run in 4.9% (wt/v) H₂SO₄ aqueous solution for 60 days, indicating a good permselectivity and long-term stability, implying a promising application in treating acidic effluents from metal industries.

Furthermore, manipulation on interface polymerization process can also be used to improve the membrane separation performance. For example, cross-linking agents or surfactants were pre-coated on the support membrane or added into the aqueous phase [104,105]. This could not only improve the distribution of monomers on the support layer, but also regulate the diffusion process of monomers, thereby improving the separation performance [103,106]. Pre-preparing porous interlayer polymers, such as covalent organic frameworks (COF) and sulfonated poly(ether-ether-ketone) (SPEEK) on the surface of the support layer, can improve monomer distribution and provide water flow channels, thereby improving permeability and selectivity [107,108]. Adding COF or other nanoporous materials to the separation layer can increase the membrane flux and the surface charge [109,110,111], thereby significantly improving the separation performance [112]. It is also possible to use a technique, which is similar to the LBL assembly method [113] or multilayer interfacial polymerization, to reduce the separation layer defects and increase the membrane density, leading to the significantly improved permeability [114,115].

Cyanuric chloride is regarded as a good monomer with high acid stability. It reacted with amine monomer to form triazine polyamine membrane, which showed a high acid-resistant ability. The reasons are attributed to (1) the absence of carbonyl group in amine group of the separation layer structure that is prone to protonation and nucleophilic attack compared to the amide group [116] and (2) the single and double bonds of the carbon and nitrogen atoms of the triazine ring are arranged alternately to form a stable acid-resistant conjugated structure [90], which makes the separation layer have good acid resistance. However, the separation performance of the triazine polyamine-based membrane is also not well satisfied, mainly because the three chlorines from cyanuric chloride of the triazine ring have different reactivities [117]. The first chlorine has a high reactivity [118], while the substitution of the second and third chlorine in CC gradually becomes difficult. Such stage reactivity of chlorine substitution makes it less possible for diamine monomers with smaller molecules, such as PIP and MPD, to react with CC to form continuous and compact polymers with higher molecular weight. Other monomers, such as diethylene triamine (DETA), tetraethylene pentamine (TEPA), or PEI, which contain three or more amine groups, were used to react with CC via interfacial polymerization to obtain the membrane with good selectivity [69]. Note that the reaction of CC and aqueous monomer often occurs under a high concentration, high temperature, and long time, thereby usually leading to a relatively thick separation layer. Because PEI with high concentration is prone to permeate into the pore of the support layer, this results in a serious pore blockage or reduction of pore diameter, thus reducing the permeability of membrane. The interfacial polymerization of PEI and CC on the hydrophilic PES UF membranes afforded acid-resistant polyamine membranes with the NaCl rejection of about 65% and a pure water flux of only 2.7 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹ [116]. Therefore, it is necessary to use some strategies to prevent the aqueous phase monomer from penetrating too deeply into the support layer, which include fine-tuning the concentration of reactants, regulating the reaction time, or introducing interlayer layer.

By finely regulating the concentration of the organic phase or decreasing temperature to alleviate the reaction rate, the separation performance of the polyamine membrane can be improved [119]. Yu et al. prepared a Janus acid-resistant nanofiltration membrane with opposite surface charge separation layer by using interfacial polymerization of PEI and low concentration of CC on PES UF substrate, and curing treatment was used to enhance crosslinking degree [120]. This approach, named the low concentration and curing treatment (LC-CT) method, resulted in a looser selective layer with more unreacted amine groups on the flip side of the membrane, as well as the formation of a less defective layer. The resultant TFC NF membrane showed the flux of 5.2 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹, along with 92.3% of rejection for MgCl₂ and 71.7% for Na₂SO₄, suggesting that such a Janus NF membrane prepared via the LC-CT method can effectively improve the separation performance and acid stability compared to the commercial PA membrane NFM-1 and the commercial acid-resistant membranes NFM-1 and NFM-2.

Ionic liquids (ILs) have been used in the membrane post-treatment process to improve membrane performance [121,122]. The regulation of the interfacial diffusion process is performed mainly by utilizing the orderly directional arrangement of ILs at the water–oil interface, controlling the orderly diffusion of water-phase monomers to the interface and effectively manipulating the interfacial polymerization process. This approach can efficiently construct a highly ordered separation layer and improve the permeance of the acid-resistance membrane. Bai et al. [123] employed ILs, 1-aminopropyl-3-methylimidazolium chloride, and 1-aminopropyl-3-methylimidazolium bis((trifluoromethyl)sulfonylimide to regulate the interfacial polymerization reaction of PEI and CC on the PSf UF support membrane for preparing a polyamine acid-resistant NF membrane with a highly ordered separation layer. Such a membrane showed a high selectivity, with 98.2% of rejection for Y³⁺ and good acid stability. Meanwhile, the permeability was significantly improved, reaching 71.2 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹.

Yu et al. prepared a dual-charge polyamine acid resistant NF membrane (ARNFM) by interfacial polymerization of PEI with low concentration CC on the surface of PES UF membrane, followed by the post-treatment of citric acid (CA) to improve the permeation performance and acid resistance [124]. Treatment of dense nanofiltration membranes with weakly acidic or alkaline reagents, such as CA, removed small oligomers and readjusted the membrane pores by reacting with surface active groups, thereby significantly improving permeation performance while maintaining selectivity [125,126]. For example, the ARNFM flux after CA treatment was enhanced 7.1 times to 2.3 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹, and the rejection was 97.6% for MgCl₂ and 90.8% for MgSO₄ [124].

Moreover, the separation performance of the membrane can also be improved by controlling the interfacial polymerization process on the support layer. For example, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) adsorbed onto the surface of PES support layer can effectively change the electrostatic interaction between the aqueous phase and the support layer, further reduce the migration rate of the monomer, improve the uniformity of the distribution of the monomer, reduce the interfacial tension between the water and oil phases [127], reduce pore plugging and the defects of the separation layer defects, and thereby promote the separation performance [128]. This result also confirms that it is better to use SDS solution to activate the surface of PES support than adding it into the aqueous solution [128,129]. In addition, hydrophilic additives added to the aqueous phase can also improve the permeability by increasing the surface roughness and hydrophilicity of the separation layer [130,131].

Polyurea (PU) is an acid-resistant and mechanical strength material, which is often obtained through interfacial polymerization of amine monomers and isocyanate monomers. PU bonds with resonance structures have a higher degree of hydrogen bonding [132], which increases the energy barrier of C–N breakage in an acid environment. Hence, the urea linkages, being resistant to hydrolysis, bestow polyurea with excellent resistance to alkali and acid [133]. Polyurea membranes were first prepared as reverse osmosis membranes with a high density and poor permeability [134]. As a result, PU-based NF/UF membranes were almost neglected, especially in the field of NF separation of acid solution. Herein, a sample is showed. Zhang et al. used a series of isocyanate-based organic compound monomers, such as 1,4-phenylene diisocyanate (PDI), toluene diisocyanate (TDI), diphenylmethane diisocyanate (MDI), and hexamethylene diisocyanate (HDI), to react with PEI, PIP to form polyurea NF membranes via the interfacial polymerization on the PES support layer [135]. It indicated that PDI as the organic monomer exhibited a high reactivity. By optimizing the type and content of PDI monomer, the obtained PEI_−0.1/PDI_−0.2 TFC UF membrane indicated a rejection of 97.1% for MgSO₄ and a water flux of 0.65 L m⁻² h^−-1·bar⁻¹. Hydrogen bonds existing in urea groups in the PEI/PDI functional layer are beneficial for improving the permeation performance of the membranes. The results of static acid/alkali soaking tests corroborated that the increase in PDI content can not only enhance the degree of crosslinking, but also introduce more rigid and stable benzene rings in the PU layer, thereby promoting the stability of the TFC membrane in extreme pH conditions. Especially, after exposure to 20% (wt/v) HCl, 20% (wt/v) H₂SO₄, and 20% (wt/v) NaOH aqueous solution for one year, the PEI_-0.4/PDI_−0.25 membrane still preserved more than 90% of rejection for MgSO₄, revealing excellent acid/alkali-resistant ability and high stability for treating acidic and alkaline industrial wastewater.

Additionally, the integration of nanostructured materials is also used as an effective strategy to promote the permeation flux of NF because some two-dimensional layered nanofillers with ultra-high specific surface area and unique interlamellar spacing can provide more water channels [136,137,138]. Feng et al. dispersed molybdenum disulfide (MoS₂) nanosheets into aqueous solution of polyethyleneimine (PEI) by virtue of the adhesion effect of tannic acid (TA). Additionally, the positively charged polyurea NF membranes (TSPU) were prepared by interfacial polymerization of aqueous phase PEI/TA-MoS₂ and TDI organic phase on the polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) UF [139]. The optimized membrane TSPU-0.015 showed a better hydrophilicity performance and a retention performance of more than 99% for high-valence heavy metal ions, such as Fe³⁺ and Cu²⁺, and the permeation flux of TSPU-0.015 is 5.75 L·m⁻²·h⁻¹·bar⁻¹ for MgSO₄ aqueous solution, 2.88 times higher than that of undoped MoS₂ (TSPU-0), while a considerable the rejection rate of 93.18% for MgSO₄ is reached. Probably, such nanostructured material-integrated NF membranes should be further investigated in acid-stability and separation performance in acidic environments.

Hence, due to a high crosslinking degree and strong acid-/alkali resistance, as well as high mechanical strength in separation layer, PU membranes need to be widely investigated and probably provide a promising candidate for the application in the separation of extreme acid or alkali wastewater industry.