1. Introduction
Cucumber (
Cucumis sativus L.) is an important and popular vegetable of the Cucurbitaceae family. It is reported to be one of the earliest vegetables to be domesticated from wild Indian
C. s var.
Hardwickii [1] and its site of domestication by man could be dated back as far as 5000 years ago
[2][3]. Cucumber was first cultivated in India and then later spread eastwards to China and westwards to Europe about 2000 and between 700 and 1500 years ago, respectively. The Europeans eventually spread cucumber to North America and Africa in the 1400s
[3][4]. Cucumber is mostly grown for its soft fruits and is eaten in raw fresh form, cooked as a vegetable or pickled when immature
[5][6]. Consumed fresh or processed, cucumber is regarded for its special flavor and its high-water content (95% water). Its high-water content (about 95%) makes it ideal to promote hydration during hot sunny days. The nutrient availability per 100 g fresh weight of cucumber contains energy (12–15 cal), protein (0.6–0.65 g), total lipids (0.1–0.11 g), carbohydrates (2.2–3.63 g), calcium (14–16 mg), iron (0.28 mg–0.3), vitamin C (2.8–12 mg), and vitamin A (β-carotene, 1.125–5 μg), as well as other vitamins such as vitamin K, B6, B12, thiamine, niacin, flavonoids, and triterpenes, which provide antioxidants and anti-inflammatory substances
[7][8][9].
The semi-wild Xishuangbanna cultivar (
C. sativus var. xishuangbannesis, XIS hereafter) is unique based on their pedigree exhibiting orange-fleshed (endocarp) fruit at full seed maturity, signifying an abundance of β-carotenes just like melon, squash, and pumpkin
[10][11]. The XIS cucumber is highly outcrossing, and thus is readily intercrossed to the common cultivated cucumber, sharing the same chromosome number (2n = 2x = 14). Its fruits are eaten boiled or raw during different stages of maturity
[12][13]. β-carotene not only acts as a precursor to pro-vitamin A synthesis, which is essential for human health, but also contributes to the fruit flesh color. Flesh color is one of the most important traits of fruits and vegetables that impacts positively on consumer’s choice of food products. The flesh color type is attributed to different chlorophyll and carotenoid accumulations in fruits
[14]. Low uptake of carotenoid-rich food results in vitamin A deficiency. Vitamin A deficiency is one of the most serious health issues in many countries, resulting in irreversible blindness. It is among the key pillars in the fight against malnutrition, commonly referred to as ‘hidden hunger”, ravaging the ever-increasing world population
[15]. This situation has prompted researchers to attempt the biofortification of plant-derived foods including pro-vitamin A carotenoids (mainly β-carotene), which led to the birth of “golden” crops. Additionally, a variety of vegetables such as carrot and orange-fleshed sweet potato are naturally rich in β-carotene content and their improvement contributes to the pool of nutritional status. While high β-carotene cucumber may not contribute significantly to the vitamin A status among the consumers globally owing to its limited growing localities, consumption of carotenoid-rich XIS cucumber in regions where it is grown and marketed can contribute to the reduction in vitamin A deficiency and provision of health benefits required in the human body system
[16].
2. Chronological Perspective of Orange-Fleshed XIS Cucumber Discovery and Development
XIS is a Chinese landrace, an accession from mountainous Xishuangbanna region of Yunnan Province in Southwest China, the area bordering Myanmar
[12]. XIS cucumber was first described in 1983
[17]; thereafter, it drew the attention of the researchers, especially those interested in cucurbitaceous crops owing to its unique characteristics. Growing in a tropical warm and humid climate above 1000 m altitude, this form of cucumber has long been cultivated by the Jinuo, Hani, and Aini ethnic groups of China, Laos, and Vietnam, who call it ‘Shihuo’
[10].
A preliminary investigation of the orange flesh trait of XIS cucumber in 1991showed that a dominant genetic factor influences the orange-flesh color
[18]. However, three years later (1994) Navazio
[19] used a recessive two gene model to explain segregation in F
2 progeny (
n = 46) resulting from a cross between ‘SMR18’ and XIS. In 1997, Simon and Navazio
[16] developed XIS derivatives in U.S. pickling backgrounds that express orange fruit flesh pigmentation at maturity. This consisted of the development of early orange mass (EOM) 400, 402, and late orange mass (LOM) 404 from crosses between U.S. pickling cucumber and orange fruited XIS cucumber. Internal (mature and immature) fruit color was orange in 70–90 percent of the EOM 400 and EOM 402 plants in 1994, with yellow in the remaining samples. Plants with dark orange mature fruit color were slightly more prevalent in EOM 402 (15%) than in EOM 400 (5%); however, yellow immature fruit color was also slightly more common in EOM 402 (30%) than in EOM 400 (5%). However, the molecular mechanisms linked to early β-carotene accumulation of orange mass in EOM 402 or EOM400 remains unknown.
In 2009, a genetic study involving two genetic linkage maps constructed with the markers of random amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD), sequenced characterized amplified region (SCAR), simple sequence repeats (SSR), Expressed sequence tag (EST), single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP), amplified fragment length polymorphism (AFLP), and (sequence specific amplification polymorphism (SSAP) was reported
[20].These genetic linkage maps defined a common collinear region containing four molecular markers (3 dominant and 1 codominant) on linkage group (LG) LG6 in Map 1 and LG3 in Map 2. The regions contained QTL associated with orange mesocarp (mc6.1/ec6.1) and endocarp (mc3.1/ec3.1) in Map1 and Map2, respectively. Two pairs of allelic genes were found to be responsible for the yellow mesocarp, while a single recessive gene controls β-carotene in the endocarp as reported in 2010
[21] However, there are limited findings on cucumber flesh color at the molecular level. Through the United States department of Agriculture, a high β-carotene (7.5 μg/g) cucumber line EOM 402-10, was released in 2011 but it was still maintained for research purposes only
[22].
In 2012, an inheritance and mapping of the gene controlling quantity of β-carotene at mature fruit stage was reported
[23]. To identify the genetic locus controlling β-carotene content in XIS cucumber, bulk segregant analysis (of 124 RIL-F
7 population was applied and orange endocarp (Ore) gene controlling quantity of β-carotene identified to be located between SSR07706 and SSR23231 in the short arm of chromosome 3. Further investigation in 2013 revealed that the Ore locus is defined by the putative β-carotene hydroxylase 1; CsaBCH1 (Csa3G183920) gene. The Ore mutant contains a SNP in the conserved fatty acid hydroxylase domain of CsaBCH1 that disrupts β-carotene turnover, which is a substitution of alanine to asparagine at position 257 of the
BCH1 gene, encoding a β-carotene hydroxylase, and causes an accumulation of β-carotene in the Xishuangbanna group. This mutation results in a non-functional carotene hydroxylase, which is unable to convert carotene to zeaxanthin, resulting in a build-up of carotene
[1][24].
Many other attempts have been made to study the regulations of β-carotene in orange-fleshed cucumber cultivars. Other variants of cucumber with yellow flesh significantly contribute to β-carotene content. In 2015, an investigation of the yellow flesh color of cucumbers (line PI200815) discovered that the yellow mesocarp flesh color is controlled by a single recessive gene, yf, which is located on cucumber chromosome 7
[25]. A total of 12 SSR primers and 5 Indel markers were used to build a molecular marker linkage group and the closest flanking markers linked to yf were yf SSR108 and yf Indel29 with genetic distances of 0.6 and 0.3 cM, respectively. The physical distance between
yf and the area containing 21 projected candidate genes was 149.0 kb. The latest study of XIS cucumber in 2019 on β-carotene content reported an identification of SNP in the homolog of the cauliflower Ore gene. This study however concluded that the Ore gene is not the only factor affecting β-carotene accumulation in orange flesh cucumber
[26]. Other than β-carotene content, the QTL of the flowering and fruit physical qualitative traits have recently have also been reported
[27][28]. A study involving a combination of genomics and transcriptomic further gave insights into photoperiod regulation of flowering in XIS cucumber
[29].
4. Future Prospects in Molecular Breeding of β-Carotene Content in Cucumber
Based on the foregoing review, it is apparent that previous research on β-carotene accumulation in orange-fleshed cucumber has been explored through introgression of XIS with other cultivated cucumber species for the identification of QTL and related markers. However, more approaches for further insights into XIS cucumber could be tested, as summarized in this section (
Figure 2). Rajasree and Pugalendhi
[54] highlighted the modern nutritional breeding techniques with wider application in vegetable crops, and these include the following: mutation breeding
[55], polyploidy breeding
[56], biotechnological approaches, advanced backcross QTL analysis, and transgenic approaches
[57]. Each approach has distinct or shared objectives in XIS cucumber. Given the relatively few QTL associated with XIS traits and their comparatively high allied LOD values, backcross MAS could be advantageous in the development of orange-colored, high β-carotene containing cucumber germplasm and other associated traits
[20].

Figure 2. A summary of the proposed approaches to unravel the genetic basis of β-carotene accumulation in orange-/yellow-fleshed cucumber. The boxes highlighted in blue are the proposed main objectives, while the arrow points to the applicable methodology. Advanced backcross
[21]; MAS
[21][22][25]; OR SNP genetic markers
[26]; Triploid induction
[56]; cucumber-melon synteny
[58][59]; parthenocarpy
[60]; colchicine treatment
[61]; polyploidy hy-bridization
[62].
4.1. Combined Omics and Gene Editing Technology for Carotenoid Improvement
Combined ‘omics’ presents a powerful tool for molecular diagnosis of important qualitative and quantitative traits. Whereas the cucumber genome has been sequenced and released for the emergence of next generation sequencing technologies
[63], genomics alone may not meet the demand of the researchers. With the rapid development of sequencing technology, many omics technologies, such as transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics, have been developed
[64] and applied in cucumber research. A large amount of data generated from these studies provides a potential reference for mining cucumber functional genes controlling carotenoid accumulation. The combination of genomics and classical genetics has become a highly strong technique for identifying candidate genes influencing essential features such as carotenoid accumulation.
Combined ‘omics’ involving transcriptomics, proteomics, and metabolomics has been used to further clarify the complex signal conversion mechanism of key regulatory genes in carotenoid accumulations
[65]. Combining metabolite profiling with high-throughput RNA-sequencing analysis as well as proteomics established a correlation network between metabolites and genes involved in a number of important traits such as fruit flavor, fruit pigments, and other sensory characteristics in a number of crops. However, such studies are still lacking in dissecting the molecular mechanism of carotenoid biosynthesis in XIS cucumber. A number of regulators may be involved in those processes. Future studies should address the identification of key regulatory factors controlling the carotenoid metabolic pathway and chromoplast biogenesis. Genome editing research is currently being employed for plant research and crop improvement program
[66]. By analyzing the differences between mutant and control plants, CRISPR/CAS9-mediated deletion and siRNA-mediated knockdown technologies can be utilized to identify the function of candidate genes
[67]. Targeting of regulatory regions has been shown to alter gene expression without complete knockout of genes, leading to the development of useful traits. This is a current trend application for nutritional molecular breeding. For example, a comparison of the effects of mutations in the coding region to that of the 5′ untranslated region of CRTISO gene in tomato demonstrated that fruit quality changes can be achieved by CRISPR-Cas9-based editing of CRTISO coding region
[68] Further, a controlled knockdown of genes can be achieved by targeting the regulatory regions. In a similar study it was reported that color-related chlorophyll and carotenoid concentrations of Chinese kale can be altered through CRISPR/Cas9-targeted editing of the carotenoid isomerase gene, BoaCRTISO
[69]. More specific and accurate modifications could be created at specific regulatory elements that are part of the untranslated sections or promoter regions of genes using modern technologies like “prime-editing”, resulting in desired phenotypic features. These precise approaches could be used in cucumber improvement initiatives to increase β-carotene content.
4.2. Candidate Gene Approach and Association Mapping Applications in Carotenoid Nutritional Improvement
The candidate gene approach can systematically examine the relationship between structural genes in carotenoid biosynthetic pathway genes (PSY, PDS, ZDS, LCYB/LCYE, CHYB, VDE, ZEP, and NSY) and related phenotypic variability by using a comparative genetic system
[70][71]. Comparative genetic maps, non-overlapping sets of mutants generated across plant species, could be more informative about the function and evolution of that locus than the allelic variability available in one species, which can be used to extend the candidate gene method to these features
[72]. Furthermore, candidate genes for phenotypically defined quantitative and qualitative loci may be readily apparent for a wide range of species, providing new insights into cucumber β-carotene accumulation.
Association mapping targeting candidate genes has proven successful in many instances
[73]. Therefore, this approach might bring new insights into carotenoid biosynthesis as the genetic pathway has already been dissected through forward and reverse genetics in many organisms. It addresses the relationship between marker-based polymorphism and phenotypic variation in a diversified population. In a diverse population, it examines the link between marker-based polymorphism and phenotypic variation. Using a diverse population and all ancestral recombination events may improve the resolution of such a study. In comparison with bi-parental cross, one of the key advantages of association mapping population is the ability to examine a large number of alleles
[73].
4.3. Manipulation of Hormonal and Environmental Cues Involved in the Regulation of Carotenoid Biosynthesis
Molecular diagnosis and manipulation of hormonal and environmental factors might bring new insights into the mechanisms of carotenoid biosynthesis. Hormonal and environmental factors have been shown to influence carotenoid accumulation either directly on carotenoid synthesis genes or indirectly by acting on transcription factors involved in carotenoid biosynthesis
[74][75]. Light and temperature are the key environmental factors regulating carotenoid biosynthesis
[76]. The effects of plant hormones on carotenoid accumulation are well studied in tomato fruits. In addition, ethylene is an important hormone that plays a key role in regulating ripening-associated processes including carotenoid accumulation. Ripening inhibitor a master regulator of ethylene regulated fruit ripening, enhances lycopene accumulation during fruit ripening by positively regulating expression of PSY, PDS, ZDS, and CRTISO, and negatively regulating expression of LCYB and LCYE
[77]. Therefore, studies elucidating the impact of these environmental factors on carotenoid accumulation in cucumber, particularly XIS cucumber, need future investigations.
Structurally, fruits of XIS cucumber develop hollowness at the center of the endocarp, and this further limits the quantity of β-carotene derived from it by consumers. Moreover, it is the mesocarp that constitutes the greater percentage of the edible portion. Thus, developing a uniformly distributed orange-fleshed (mesocarp and endocarp) cucumber variety would be a greater milestone in carotenoid improvement. Such a novel cucumber variety would translate into the formation of a seedless cucumber similar to seedless watermelon. The known techniques of forming a seedless fruit comprise establishment of a parthenocarpic fruit or triploid development, as proposed herein, and hormonal or chemical treatments such auxins, ethylene, gibberellins or colchicine, among others
[60][61][62][78].
4.4. Application of Marker-Assisted Selection for β-Carotene Improvement and Development of Immature Orange-Fleshed Cucumber Variety
Previously, the diallel analysis of immature fruit sizes demonstrated significant positive genetic combining ability for P101 (derived from XIS ‘Addis’). Because orange color in immature cucumbers has not previously been detected in the most generally consumed stage of cucumbers, P101’s capacity to express fruit pigmentation in size 2 (27–38 mm) fruit was a fortuitous and unexpected breakthrough in the breeding for carotenoid pigmentation
[11]. The diallel study revealed that the parents had a high fruit carotene level. However, most diallel hybrids had a lower carotenoid content than their parents, indicating both low carotenoid content and a lack of genetic complementation among parents to improve fruit color. The genetic regulation of pigmentation in fruit with a diameter of 27–38 mm appeared to be separate from that of fruits with a diameter of 51–54 mm. Although the carotene concentration in immature fruit was not quantified, the accumulation of β-carotene at this stage is regulated by many genes that have additive effects
[11]. This allows for increased carotene content (orange color) through family selection. EOM 402-10 could be used to generate high-carotene pickled cucumbers with an orange endocarp/mesocarp that are appealing to customers thanks to their nutritional content. However, until now, no studies have further explored the genetic mechanism of orange coloration in immature EOM402-10 cucumber.
Genomics and marker assisted selection (MAS) technology has unlocked new pathways for improvement of complex quality traits
[59][79]. Therefore, fully defined high-carotene BC
2S
3 IBL produced by MAS and phenotypic selection could be used directly in epistatic interaction detection
[62]. Additionally, the identification of XIS progeny line segregating for both ore and fft1.1 loci (‘OreFt’), being β-carotene donor, can be used to foster β-carotene breeding initiatives. The β-carotene donor can then be instituted in the MAS by back crossing with inbred line segregating for fft1.1 locus (FFT), as outlined in
Figure 3. One NIL study might look into the differences in fruit color orange hue and its dispersion observed in fruit developing in the field and greenhouse under long-day and short-day growth settings
[10].

Figure 3. Marker assisted selection (MAS) strategy for utilization of ore recessive genes for development of an early flowering cucumber with enhanced β-carotene content. The phenotype description of above genes is based on the previous studies. OreFt, orange endocarp and early female flowering; fft, first female flowering time; P1, parent 1; P2, parent 2, Selfing, ⨂.